Beverages
Fruit Juice
$5.00
Iced Tea
$5.00
Lemonade
$5.00
Soda
$5.00
Milk
$3.00
Chocolate Milk
$3.50
Hot Chocolate
$3.50
Aqua Panna Water
$3.00-7.00
San Pellegrino
3.00-7.00
$Coffee and Tea
Coffee
$3.25
Cappuccino
$3.50
Mocha Latte
$4.25
Cafe Latte
$3.75
Macchiato Single
$2.50
Espresso Single
$2.50
Americano
$2.50
Red Eye
$4.25
Iced Coffee
$3.25
Iced Cappuccino
$4.00
Iced Latte
$4.00
Black Tea
$3.00
Green Tea
$3.00
Herbal Tea
3.00
Decaf.
$Brunchy Things
BreakfastBenedict
$14.00-16.00
Poached heirloom eggs, rosemary focaccia and lemon Hollandaise.
3 Heirloom Eggs
$11.00
Brioche, sourdough or 7-grain toast and house jam.
Our Omelet
$14.00
Mushroom, spinach, roasted tomato and New York cheddar.
Your Omelet
$13.00
Bacon, Egg and Cheese Waffle
$14.00
Neuske's bacon, NY cheddar, fried heirloom egg and Vermont maple syrup.
Roasted Mushroom Waffle
$14.00
NY Muenster, cured tomato, baby arugula and sherry vinaigrette.
Swiss Waffle
$14.00
Ham, spinach, heirloom egg and Gruyere fondue.
The Original Lemon Ricotta Pancakes
$14.00
Berry compote, lemon curd and Vermont maple syrup.
Huevos Rancheros
$15.00
Organic egg, white corn tortilla, black beans, crema, salsa fresca, queso fresco and house made tasso ham.
Sugar and Plumm Crunch Toast
15.00
Brioche, strawberry compote, vanilla and mascarpone cheese.
$Buckwheat Crepes
Breakfast Buckwheat CrepesHam and Gruyere Crepe
$12.00
Spinach and Mushroom Crepe
$13.00
New York Muenster.
House Smoked Salmon Crepe
$16.00
Creme fraiche, red onion and capers.
House Smoked Chicken Crepe
$15.00
Roasted vegetables.
Shrimp and Avocado Crepe
16.00
Market greens and lemon vinaigrette.
$Sweet Crepes and Waffles
Breakfast Savory WafflesClassic
$10.00
Butter and sugar.
Citron
$10.00
Butter, fresh lemon juice, sugar and lemon zest.
Nutella
$11.00
Cajeta
$12.00
Goat's milk caramel sauce with salted caramel ice cream.
Berries and Cream
$12.00
Mixed berry compote wit vanilla bean ice cream.
Apple Pie
$12.00
With roasted apples, vanilla bean ice cream and salted caramel sauce.
Fluffanutter
13.00
Peanut butter, marshmallow creme, peanut butter swirl ice cream and crushed peanuts.
$Breakfast Sides
Breakfast SidesShort Rib Hash
$7.00
Neuske's Bacon
$7.00
2 Heirloom Eggs
$6.00
Chicken-Apple Sausage
$7.00
Simple Salad
$8.00
Shoe String Fries
$5.00
Seasonal Fruit and Berries
$6.00
Marble Potato Hash
$6.00
Anson Mill Grits
6.00
$Appetizers
AppetizersYummus
$12.00
Grilled pita, house marinated olives, Guss' pickles and heirloom radish.
"Soup and Sandwich"
$12.00
Mini grilled cheese sandwiches with tomato soup for dipping.
Shrimp and Chips
$16.00
Fried gulf shrimp with sauce Louie and cocktail sauce.
House Smoked Wings
$14.00
Free-range chicken, peanuts, green onion, dry rub and maple BBQ.
Corn Dogs Trio
$12.00
A trio of corn dogs and maple mustard, state fair style.
Golden Beet Slider Trio
$13.00
Cheeseburger Slider Trio
$14.00
Pulled Pork Slider Trio
14.00
$Soups
Classic SoupsCup of Chicken Noodle Soup
$7.00
Free range chicken.
Cup of Tomato Soup
7.00
$Salads
SaladsWhole Grain Salad
$16.00
Baby greens, chickpea, organic grains, heirloom radish, mushroom, cured tomato, haricot vert, cipollini onion, house-marinated Greek olives and lemon vinaigrette.
Cobb Wedge Salad
$14.00
Baby iceberg, Maytag bleu cheese, heirloom tomatoes, organic egg, avocado, Neuske's bacon and buttermilk-ranch dressing.
Roasted Beet Salad
$16.00
Baby beets, fresh ricotta cheese, petite greens, lemon oil and vinegar.
Classic Caesar Salad
$14.00
Romaine hearts, croutons and Caesar dressing.
Spinach Salad
$16.00
Goat cheese, Granny Smith apple, almonds, sweet and sour cherries and white balsamic vinaigrette.
Mediterranean Salad
$15.00
Heirloom Tomato Salad
17.00
$Burgers and Panini
Classic Cheeseburger
$17.00
NY cheddar, lettuce, tomato, pickle and special sauce on a sesame bun.
Plumm Burger
$18.00
Neuske's bacon, Maytag bleu cheese, cipollini onion, tomato, baby arugula and jalapeno jam.
House-Smoked Salmon Panini
$16.00
Cream cheese, capers, red onion, roasted tomato and baby greens.
Roasted Eggplant Panini
$15.00
Baby arugula, cured tomato, cipollini, onion, red pepper spread and yummus.
House-Smoked Chicken Panini
$16.00
Boursin spread, Neuske's bacon, red pepper, cipollini onion, baby arugula and tomato jam.
Cuban Panini
$16.00
House-smoked 72-hour pork, ham, Swiss, house mustard and lemon-garlic mojo.
American Panini
$16.00
Root beer braised short rib, baby greens, cured tomato, onion, peppadew and cilantro mojo.
Mediterranean Burger
$17.00
Veggie Burger
18.00
$Cheese and Mac
Mac and Cheese
14.00
Local artisan cheese and golden breadcrumbs.
$Entrees
EntreesSerious Footlong
$16.00
Custom made foot-long with all black Angus beef hot dog, house mustard, relish and onion.
Chicken and Waffles
$18.00
Crispy free-range chicken, Vermont maple syrup and dairy farm butter.
Pulled Pork and Waffles
$18.00
House smoked 72-hour pork, maple BBQ, pickled onion slaw and jalapeno.
Free-Range Chicken Breast
$24.00
With lemon spinach, confit garlic and shallot pan sauce.
Organic Crispy Skin Salmon
$25.00
Haricot vert and Meyer lemon emulsion.
Steak Frites
27.00
Sliced flat iron steak, shoestring fries and mixed greens.
$Side Dishes
Side DishesGreek Yogurt Parfait
$9.00
Short Rib Hash
$8.00
Neuske's Bacon
$7.00
Chicken-Apple Sausage
$7.00
2 Herloom Eggs
$5.00
Seasonal Fruit and Berries
$6.00
Guss' Pickles
$5.00
Marble Potato Hash
$7.00
Simple Salad
$7.00
Shoe String Fries
$5.00
Pickled Onion Slaw
$5.00
Lemon Spinach
$7.00
Haricot Vert
$7.00
Toast
3.00
$Bulk Candy
1/4 lb. Wild Berry Gummies
$3.00
1/4 lb. Energy Gummy Bears
$3.00
1/4 lb. Gummy Teeth
$3.00
1/4 lb. Gummy Cola Bottles
$3.00
1/4 lb. Swedish Fish
$3.00
1/4 lb. Sour Beeps Rainbow Bears
$3.00
1/4 lb. Gumballs
$3.00
1/4 lb. Cherry Gummy Pigs
$3.00
1/4 lb. Green Apple Sour Belts
$3.00
1/4 lb. Rainbow Sour Belts
$3.00
1/4 lb. Gummy Watermelon Slices
$3.00
1/4 lb. Gummy Worms
$3.00
1/4 lb. Chocolate Toffee Crunch
$3.00
1/4 lb. Chocolate Covered Cookie Dough Bites
$3.00
1/4 lb. Milk Chocolate Covered Gummy Bears
$3.00
1/4 lb. Peanut Butter Malt Balls
$3.00
1/4 lb. Dark Chocolate Covered Espresso Beans
$3.00
1/4 lb. Chocolate Covered Brownie Bites
3.00
$Specialty Candy
1/4 lb. Chocolate Bark
$7.00
1/4 lb. Almond Clusters
$7.00
Sugar and Plumm Chocolate Tablets
$7.00
Sugar and Plumm Daily Dose Bar
$6.00
1/4 lb. Sea Salt Caramels
$9.50
1/4 lb. Chocolate Covered Almonds
7.00
$Signature Sundaes
The Turtle Sundae
$11.00
Vanilla ice cream, salted caramel sauce, hot fudge sauce and sugared pecans.
The Shamrock Sundae
$11.00
Mint chocolate chip ice cream, brownie bites, hot fudge sauce and a peppermint patty.
The PB&J Sundae
$11.00
Peanut butter swirl ice cream, vanilla cake bites, crushed peanuts and strawberry compote.
The Candy Shop Sundae
$11.00
Vanilla ice cream, mini M&Ms. gummy bears, rainbow jimmies and hot fudge sauce or salted caramel sauce.
The Chocolove Sundae
11.00
Chocolate ice cream,blondie bites, brownie bites, hot fudge and chocolate sprinkles.
$Specialty Milkshakes
Plain Jane Shake
$9.00
Served with your choice of ice cream.
Black & White Shake
$9.00
Chocolate ice cream, vanilla ice cream and crushed Oreo.
Grasshopper Shake
$9.00
Mint chocolate chip ice cream, chocolate sauce and peppermint patty.
The "Hot" Cocoa Shake
$9.00
Chocolate ice cream, hot cocoa mix and marshmallows.
Birthday Cake Shake
9.00
Vanilla ice cream, cake bites and rainbow sprinkles.
$Desserts
Slice of Homemade Cake
$8.00
Served with signature sauce and your choice of topping.
Brownie à la Mode
$12.00
Homemade brownie with warm chocolate sauce, salted caramel sauce, vanilla ice cream and fresh whipped cream.
Blondies Have More Fun
$12.00
Warm blondie, vanilla ice cream and butter scotch sauce.
The Castaway
$13.00
Coconut and mango sorbet, coconut cake bites and pineapple confit.
Sugar & Plumm Banana Split
$17.00
Fresh bananas, vanilla, chocolate and strawberry ice cream, crushed pineapple, strawberry syrup, chocolate sauce and chopped peanuts.
Earthquake In a Fishbowl
$18.00
To share. Chocolate caramel cake, key lime pie, Brooklyn blackout cake, New York cheesecake, butterscotch pudding, vanilla, chocolate and dulce de leche ice cream with whipped cream.
Sweet Tsunami
50.00
Three slices of cake, 10 scoops of ice cream, hot fudge, pineapple confit, salted caramel sauce, blondie bites, brownie bites, mini M&Ms, whipped cream and rainbow sprinkles. Topped with a cherry.
$Ice Cream Floats
Traditional Float
$8.00
Vanilla ice cream and root beer.
Orange Creamsicle Float
$8.00
Vanilla ice cream and orange soda.
Coke Float
$8.00
Ice cream and Coca Cola.
Clack Cherry Float
$9.00
Chocolate ice cream, cherry puree and Coca Cola.
Coconut Dreamsicle Float
9.00
Coconut sorbet, pineapple juice and lemon-lime soda.
$Macarons
French Macarons
2.50
$Bakery Yumm
Chocolate Chunk Cookie
$3.50
Creme Brulee Cookie
$3.50
Red Velvet Cookie
$3.50
Granola Cookie
$3.50
Ginger Cookie
$2.50
Gluten Free Chocolate Hazelnut Cookie
$4.00
Blondie
$2.50
Brownie
$2.50
Vanilla Cupcake
$3.50
Chocolate Cupcake
$3.50
Red Velvet Cupcake
$3.50
Gluten Free Chocolate
4.00
$Ice cream by the Scoop
Single Scoop
$3.50
Double Scoop
$6.50
Triple Scoop
$9.00
Menu for Sugar & Plumm is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
Check Other Restaurant Menu
Ashford & Simpson's Sugar Bar
Caribbean, Soul Food
Sushi of Gari Tribeca
Japanese, Sushi
Taina Cafe
Latin American, Puerto Rican
Taureau
French, Other
.png)
Tenpenny
American (New), Italian
The Brooklyneer
American (New), Bar Food, Cocktails, Gastropub
The Capital Grille
Steak
The Dutch
American (New), Eclectic & International