Soups and Starters
Cracked Conch
$7.95
Fried Mozzarella Sticks
$5.95
Baked French Onion Soup
$3.95
Soup Du Jour or Conch Chowder
$3.00-2.50
Daily Special
6.95
soup and sandwich combo
$Salads
House
$3.00
Chef's
$6.95
Basil Grilled Chicken
$7.95
Grilled Caribbean Dolphin
$8.50
Spicy Shrimp
9.50
$Sandwiches
French Fries or Cole Slaw - $0.75 with Any SandwichFried Grouper
$7.50
light breading with tartar on a fresh baked kaiser
Cajun Dolphin Grilled
$6.95
mild spice with lemon and tartar on a fresh kaiser roll
Cheeseburger Deluxe
$5.95
certified angus beef charbroiled to order with lettuce, tomato and onion
Grilled Reuben
$6.95
certified angus corned beef, swiss and kraut on grilled rye standing tall
Turkey Club
$6.95
triple layer with turkey, bacon, lettuce and tomato, and mayonnaise choice of sourdough
Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich
$6.50
boneless breast with italian breading, topped with marinara and mozzarella cheese, baked then served on fresh kaiser roll
Meatball Sub
$6.50
fresh baked hoagie split, filled with meatballs, marinara sauce topped with mozzarella then baked
Sausage and Pepper's Sub
$6.95
fresh baked hoagie split, filled with mild italian sausage, roasted peppers, marinara and mozzarella then baked
Italian Sub
$6.95
hot or cold combo of ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, oil and vinegar on a fresh baked hoagie roll
Ham and Swiss
$6.50
dell ham on split kaiser topped with swiss cheese, baked, topped with tomato
Tuna Melt
6.50
tuna salad on split kaiser topped with swiss cheese, baked, topped with tomato
$Entrees
Served With Bread and Salad. All Seafood Entrees served with Choice of French Fries, Rice or Vegetable * Served Over Linguini. Extra Charge For Additional Sides.Baked Grouper
$8.95
filet of grouper with lemon butter
Fried Fish Fingers
$7.95
fresh fish fingers lightly breaded and fried
Snapper Almondine
$8.95
lightly breaded, cooked in white wine, butter and almonds
Fried Local Gulf Shrimp
$8.95
butterflied the best
Cracked Conch
$9.95
a native shellfish that has been tenderized lightly breaded and deep fried
Snapper Del Mar
$8.95
lightly breaded filet of snapper topped with crabmeat stuffing and mushrooms baked in sherry lemon butter
Chargrilled 5 Oz Filet Mignon
$13.95
Chargrilled 8 Oz Strip Steak
$9.95
21 Shrimp
$6.95
Seafood Italiano*
$11.95
shrimp and scallops with mushrooms, sauteed in garlic butter with a hint of marinara sauce on a bed of linguini (extra charge for additional sides)
Lasagna
$7.95
three layers of noodles, meat and three cheeses, topped with marinara and mozzarella.
Chicken Piccata with Capers
$7.95
lightly breaded and sauteed with lemon, capers, butter, parsley and white wine
Chicken Parmigiana With Spaghetti
$6.95
dipped in cream, seasoned with bread crumbs and baked with cheese and tomato sauce topping.
Baked Stuffed Shells
$6.95
two shells filled with ricotta, parmesan, mozzarella and romano cheese, topped with tomato sauce.
Veal Parmigiana With Spaghetti
$7.95
dipped in cream, seasoned with bread crumbs and baked with cheese and tomato sauce topping.
Spaghetti With Meatballs
5.95
homemade meatballs with marinara over spaghetti.
$Desserts
Homemade Key Lime Pie
$3.50
Truffle Mousse Cake
$3.50
Hot Chocolate Pecan Pie
$3.95
Ice Cream
2.00
$Beverages
Coffee, Decaf
$1.00
Iced Tea
$1.00
Soft Drinks
$1.25
Milk
$1.00
Cappuccino
$2.50
Espresso
1.50
$Appetizers
Stone Crabs
hot or cold
Cracked Conch
$8.95
Shrimp Cocktail
$10.95
Escargot
$8.95
Oysters Remick
$8.95
Conch Fritters
$7.95
Fried Mozzarella Sticks
6.95
$Soups
Conch Chowder
$2.50-3.00
Soup Du Jour
$2.50-3.00
Onion Soup Gruyere
4.95
$Salads
Fresh Garden
$5.95
Caesar
$6.95
crisp romaine lettuce tossed with a tangy caesar dressing, romano cheese, anchovy, and croutons
Spinach
6.95
a bed of fresh spinach with fire roasted red peppers, marinated asparagus, bleu cheese crumbles, bacon crumbles and tomato wedges
$Italian Entrees
All Italian Entrees Completed With Key Colony's House Salad, Choice Of Dressing & Hot Bread.Baked Lasagna Seafood
$13.95
lasagna noodles layered with local snapper, scallops, shrimp and cheese, with tomato sauce.
Baked Lasagna
$12.95
a meat and cheese filling with tomato sauce.
Baked Stuffed Shells
$10.95
a macaroni shell topped with tomato sauce and filled with ricotta, parmesan and romano cheeses and eggs
Baked Manicotti
$10.95
a macaroni tube topped with mozzarella cheese and filled with a cheese mixture, with tomato sauce
Ravioli Parmigiana
$10.95
cheese ravioli topped with mozzarella cheese, tomato sauce and baked
Sausage and Peppers
$11.95
sausage and peppers sauteed in a tomato sauce, served with a side of spaghetti
Seafood Italiano
$21.95
shrimp and scallops with mushrooms, sauteed in garlic butter, with a hint of marinara sauce on a bed of linguini.
Italian Combo Dinner
$15.95
veal cutlet, stuffed shell, ravioli, spaghetti, meatball and sausage topped with tomato sauce
Tortellini Oreganata
12.95
cheese tortellini sauteed with a blending of white wine, tomatoes, mushrooms and garlic.
$Pasta
Spaghetti, Linguini, Cheese RavioliPasta
$9.95
with tomato sauce
Pasta
$10.95
with meat sauce
Pasta
$10.95
with meatballs
Pasta
$11.95
with sausage
Pasta
$10.95
with mushrooms
Pasta
$9.95
with oil & garlic
Pasta
12.95
with white or red clam sauce
$French American Entrees
All French American Entrees Completed With Key Colony's House Salad, Choice Of Dressing & Hot Bread, Plus Choice Of Baked Potato Or Fresh Vegetable.Sauteed Shrimp & Fettucine Alfredo
$19.95
a generous shrimp dish blended with an alfredo cream and cheese sauce and fettucine noodles
Baked Chicken Cordon Bleu
$17.95
boneless chicken breast stuffed with ham and gruyere cheese, baked in a white wine, mushrooms and brown sauce
Veal Marsala with Mushrooms
$18.95
veal filet sauteed with marsala wine and mushrooms
Sauteed Sea Scallops Fettucine Alfredo
$21.95
fresh sea scallops combined with an alfredo sauce with fettucine noodles
Shrimp Primavera
$20.95
shrimp and fresh vegetables sauteed in garlic butter, with a hint of parmesan cheese in a light cream sauce on a bed of fettucine
Baked Sea Scallops New Brunswick
$20.95
a blending of sea scallops and bacon in a light cream sauce with a hint of rosemary.
Filet of Yellowtail Bonne Femme
$19.95
a poached, rolled yellowtail filet finished with a combination hollandaise and fish sauce.
Sauteed Chicken and Fettucine Alfredo
15.95
a boneless breast of chicken sauteed in a combination with an alfredo sauce and fettucine noodles.
$Florida Keys Seafood
Served With Key Colony's House Salad, Choice of Dressing, & Hot Bread, Plus Choice of Baked Potato or Fresh VegetableFried Local Gulf Shrimp
$18.95
butterflied
Cracked Conch Dinner
$19.95
a native shellfish that has been marinated, tenderized and deep fried
Seafood Italiano
$21.95
shrimp and scallops with mushrooms sauteed in garlic and butter with a hint of marinara sauce on a bed of linguini
Shrimp Primavera
$20.95
shrimp and fresh vegetables sauteed in garlic butter, with a hint of parmesan cheese in a light cream sauce on a bed of fettucine
Mermaid's Delight
$21.95
scallops layered with a crabmeat stuffing and topped with shrimp, mushrooms, butter, sherry, and finished in a light cream sauce
Fried Grouper Fingers
$17.95
finger size grouper, flavored, seasoned and deep fried
Snapper Lorenzo
$19.95
lightly breaded snapper sauteed with lemon, butter and sherry, then topped with mushrooms, crabmeat stuffing and bearnaise sauce
Keys Fish Key Largo
$19.95
two fish filets sauteed with lemon butter and sherry, rolled up with crabmeat stuffing, deep fried and topped with bearnaise sauce
Grouper or Snapper Senator
$19.95
lightly breaded and sauteed in lemon, butter and parsley with mushrooms, almonds and sherry
Grouper or Snapper Meuniere
$18.95
lightly breaded and sauteed in lemon, butter and parsley
Grouper or Snapper Parmigiana
$18.95
lightly breaded topped with cheese, tomato sauce and baked
Local Fish of The Day
$17.95
baked, fried or broiled
Grouper or Snapper Almondine
$19.95
lightly breaded, broiled in white wine, butter and almonds
Baked Yellowtail In Lemon Dill Butter
$18.95
a local yellowtail filet, baked in a dill butter sauce and white wine
Black Grouper Princess
$20.95
a black grouper filet with tomato, asparagus and sauce bearnaise
Baked Mangrove Snapper Forestière
$18.95
local mangrove snapper baked with scallions, generous amounts of mushrooms in a white wine broth
Fisherman's Platter ( Sauteed or Fried)
$29.95
an array of fresh seasonal seafood; shrimp, scallops, half lobster, conch, and fish
Sicilian Snapper
$20.95
lightly breaded snapper topped with chopped tomatoes, mushrooms, black olives, green peppers, shrimp and scallops in sherry, lemon and butter sauce
Fried Sea Scallops
$21.95
floured, seasoned and deep fried
Stone Crab ( In Season)
florida stone crabs served hot or cold cracked with butter market price
Surf & Turf
14 oz. strip steak with 8 oz. lobster tail market price
Twin Lobster Tails or Single Lobster Tail
florida lobster tails topped with crabmeat stuffing and baked in butter market price
Chicken Entrees
Served With Key Colony's House Salad, Choice of Dressing, & Hot Bread, Plus Choice of Baked Potato or Fresh VegetableChicken Breast Parmigiana
$15.95
dipped in cream, seasoned with bread crumbs and baked with a cheese and tomato sauce topping
Chicken Breast Cutlet
$14.95
chicken breast lightly breaded and deep fried, topped with tomato sauce
Chicken Piccata
$15.95
a chicken breast, lightly breaded and sauteed with lemon, capers, butter, parsley, and white wine
Chicken Capri
$17.95
a chicken breast filet lightly breaded, topped with a crabmeat stuffing, baked in butter, lemon, sherry and mushroom sauce
Chicken Madrid
$17.95
a chicken breast filet topped with sliced ham, sliced tomato and three kinds of cheeses, then baked in a butter, sherry and mushroom sauce
Chicken Romano
$18.95
a chicken breast filet lightly breaded and sauteed in lemon, butter and sherry topped with artichoke hearts and crabmeat
Chicken Marsala
$16.95
a chicken breast filet lightly breaded and sauteed in marsala wine sauce with mushrooms
Chicken Almondine
$15.95
a chicken breast filet lightly breaded and sauteed in lemon and butter with toasted almonds
Barbequed Half Chicken
$13.95
barbequed in our special sauce
Half Chicken Half Rib Combo
$15.95
barbequed and served with onion rings
Barbequed Canadian Baby Back Ribs
16.95
with homemade onion rings
$Veal Favorites
Served With Key Colony's House Salad, Choice of Dressing, & Hot Bread, Plus Choice of Baked Potato or Fresh VegetableVeal Bernard
$18.95
a filet of veal, sauteed in butter, topped with ham, three kinds of cheeses and sliced tomato, baked in a marsala mushroom sauce
Veal Parmigiana
$16.95
a veal filet dipped in flour, baked with three kinds of cheeses, and topped with tomato sauce
Veal Cutlet
$15.95
a veal filet dipped in flour, seasoned with bread crumbs and topped with tomato sauce
Veal Piccata
$16.95
a lightly breaded veal filet sauteed with lemon, capers, butter, parsley and white wine
Veal Madrid
$17.95
a veal filet topped with sliced ham, sliced tomato and three kinds of cheeses, then baked in butter, sherry and mushroom sauce
Veal Oscar
$19.95
a filet of veal baked with white wine, topped with asparagus and shrimp with bearnaise sauce
Veal Capri
18.95
a veal filet, lightly breaded and topped with a crabmeat stuffing, then baked in a butter, sherry and mushroom sauce
$Steaks
Served With Key Colony's House Salad, Choice of Dressing, & Hot Bread, Plus Choice of Baked Potato or Fresh VegetableCharbroiled New York Strip Steak
$23.95
14 oz. charcoal broiled strip steak
Steak Au Poivre
$24.95
14 oz. angus with green peppercorns and brandy-laced brown sauce
New York Strip Imperial
$24.95
14 oz. new york strip topped with bordelaise sauce, grilled portobello mushroom and bearnaise sauce
Filet Mignon
$25.95
a 9 oz. filet cooked to your order, with mushrooms and a side of bearnaise sauce
Pepper Steak Filet
$27.95
9 oz. filet mignon with cracked black pepper and topped with bacon, scallions and bearnaise sauce
Filet Tournedos Oscar
28.95
two 5 oz. filet mignons broiled and topped with asparagus and shrimp with a bearnaise sauce
$Children's Selections
Shrimp In The Basket
$6.95
21 shrimp with french fries or baked potato
Chicken Basket
$6.95
with french fries or baked potato
Spaghetti & Meatball
$5.95
Fish Basket
7.95
with french fries or baked potato
$Desserts
Kahlua Parfait
$5.95
Key Lime Pie
$3.95
Hot Chocolate Pecan Pie
$4.95
Vanilla or Chocolate Ice Cream
$2.95
Tiramisu
$4.95
Banana Coupe
$5.95
Strawberry Coupe
$5.95
Mousse Cake
$4.95
Cannoli
$4.95
Daily Baked Goods
ask your server
Beverages
Coffee
$1.50
Decaffeinated Coffee
$1.50
Hot Tea
$1.50
Iced Tea
$1.75
Milk
$2.00
Sodas
$1.75
Menu for Key Colony Inn is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
Check Other Restaurant Menu
.png)
Cabana Breezes
American (New), Seafood
Quiznos Sub
American, Sandwiches, Wraps
Blimpie Subs & Sandwiches
Deli Food, Sandwiches
Arby's
American, Burgers
Burger King
American, Burgers
Wendy's
American, Burgers
Senor Frijoles
Mexican
Sundowners on the Bay
Seafood, Vegetarian
Ballyhoo's
Seafood
McDonald's
American, Burgers
Cheng Garden
Chinese, Japanese, Sushi, Thai