Appetizers
Coconut Shrimp with Mango Dipping Sauce
$6.95
five large shrimp covered with sweet coconut fried to a perfect golden brown. served with our special mango dipping sauce
Coconut Shrimp with Mango Dipping Sauce
$4.95
fice large shrimp covered with sweet and fried to a perfect golden brown. served with our semi-sweet key lime mustard dipping sauce
Jalapeno Poppers
$4.95
jalapeno's lightly breaded And stuffed With cheese, then deep fried. Served with our signature mango dipping sauce.
Smoke Fish Dip
$4.95
tilapia marinated and smoked, then blended with cream cheeses, garlic, onions, celery, carrots and spices
Stuffed Mushrooms
$5.50
Crab, manchego and monterey jack cheeses, and herb bread crumbs stuffed in six mushroom caps then baked till golden brown.
Papas Rellenas
$7.25
seasoned balls of mashed potatoes filled with cuban style ground beer and fried golden brown, served with our bayamo dipping sauce
Sauteed Mussels
$6.95
20 mussels in the shell simmered with white wine and our garlic butter and dark rum sauce.
Calamari With Sofrito
$7.25
lightly breaded fresh calamari sauteed in extra virgin olive oil and served with sofrito sauce over top.
Empanadas
$5.75
beef pastry shells filled with cuban style ground beef and deep fried served with our Spanish meat sauce for dipping.
Mussels De Zarzuela
$7.95
20 mussels sauteed with white wine and tomato bouillabaisse sauce, served with grilled baguettes
Empanadas
$5.75
spinach and artichoke, pastry shells filled with a perfect blend of spinach, artichoke hearts and cheese deep fried served with tomato bouillabaisse sauce
Havana Style Sauteed Shrimp
$8.75
six large shrimp sauteed in extra virgin olive oil, garlic, butter and spices, definitely one of the house favorites!
Spinach and Artichoke Dip
$5.45
artichokes, spinach, monterey jack and cream cheese blended together and baked served with salsa, sour cream and warm tri-color tortilla chips
Oysters On The Half Shell
$5.95
steamed or raw dozen only
Buckets Of Oysters
$19.95
at raw bar only fresh oysters on the half shell served raw on ice or steamed hot would you like butter, horseradish or cocktail sauce?
Clams
$6.95
steamed or raw by the dozen
Peg Leg Wings
$5.75
10 wings served: BBQ, jerk, teriyaki, mild, medium, plain or hot style, served with carrots and celery
Manchego Dipping Sauce and Bread
$5.75
similar to Alfredo sauce, this creamy white sauce is made by using the finest manchego cheese, along with our house loaves of bread makes this great for dipping
Manchego Dipping Sauce and Bread
$2.95
similar or Alfredo sauce, this creamy white sauce is made by using the finest manchego cheese, along with our hours loves of bread make this great for dipping and sharing!
Cheese Fries
$2.95
perfectly salted French fries served with a side of cheese sauce for dipping
Warm Tri-Color Tortilla Chips
$1.99
served with zesty salsa
Tortilla's Y Queso
$5.85
3 cheeses melted together with tomatoes, onions, cilantro and jalapeno's slightly baked, served with tri-color chips and rolled tortilla shells for dipping
Conch Fritiers with Key Lime Mustard
4.95
cracked conch prepared in sweet breading wit spices, onions and red and green bell peppers, served with our semi-sweet key lime mustard dipping sauce
$Chicken, Beef and Pork
Bistec De Palomilla
$13.95
thinly carved sirloin steak, pan scared, with onions, extra virgin olive oil and spices, topped with cuban style sauteed onions and served with white rice, black beans and maduros.
1/4 Lb Shrimp and Beef
$13.95
sizzling hot sliced chicken, beef of sauteed shrimp served on a bed of Caribbean marinated peppers & onions, served with side of spinach rice, black beans, shredded lettuce, pico de gallo, jack and cheddar cheese, and sour cream.
Bistec De Palomilla
$13.95
thinly carved sirloin steak, pan scared, with onions, extra virgin olive oil and spices, topped with cuban style sauteed onions and served with white rice, black beans and maduros
Ropa Vieja
$10.95
caribbean style shredded beef slowly cooked with green papers, onions and tomatoes, served over spanish yellow rice with a side of maduros
Dave's T-Bone
$16.95
16oz choice t-bone rubbed with extra virgin olive oil, kosher salt, black pepper, and garlic grilled the way you like served with baked potato and caribbean vegetables, dave's favorite!
Captain Burger
$7.20
1/2 pound of island seasoned ground beer grilled to your taste, served on a kaiser roll with French fries
Caribbean Grilled Chicken
$11.95
two chicken breasts marinated in the captain's seasonings and grilled to tender perfection, served with spanish yellow rice and caribbean vegetables.
Jamaican Jerk Chicken
$11.95
two chicken breast seasoned with jerk seasoning grilled and served with black beans, white rice and maduros.
Cuban Sandwich
$7.20
sliced ham, marinated pork roast, Swiss cheese, sliced dill pickles and yellow mustard, served on cuban bread, pressed and toasted, served with French fries.
Caribbean pork cook-up
$11.95
slices of pork pan seared then sauteed with garlic, onion green pepper and pineapple all tossed together with sofrito and a spicy BBQ jerk sauce, served over white rice and a side of maduros.
Island Festival Pork Tenderloin
$14.95
delicately broiled pork tenderloin basted with a rich island citrus demi-glaze served with maduros and mixed black beans and white vegetables.
Grilled BBQ Jerk Drum Ribs
$12.75
three large pork drum ribs marinaded in our black gold madunade, grilled and served with garlic mashed potatoes and caribbean vegetables.
Great Inagua Sirloin
$12.95
this perfectly tender 10oz sirloin seasoned with caribbean spices form the great inagua island, served with a baked potato, and caribbean vegetables.
Mexican Fajita's Chicken
$11.95
Beef
$11.95
1/2 Lb Shrimp
$14.95
Chicken and Beef Combo
$11.95
1/4 Lb Shrimp and Chicken
13.95
$Quesadillas
Steak Quesadilla
$6.95
large flour tortilla folded them stuffed with black gold marinated grilled steak, Caribbean spiced peppers and onions, melted cheddar and jack cheese, served with a side of sour cream and pico de gallo.
Chicken Quesadilla
$5.95
grilled marinated chicken stuffed in a large flour tortilla with Caribbean spiced peppers and onions, and melted monterey jack cheese served with a side of sour cream and pico de gallo
Mangifera Quesadilla
6.95
wow! the ingredients in this quesadilla are fabulous together, we fold a large flour tortilla then stuff it with a unique blend of mango apple salsa, marinated grilled chicken and manchego and jack cheeses served with a side of mango apple salsa and sour cream
$Soups
Bahamian Clam Chowder
$4.25
true bahamian style creamy clam chowder, full of clams, potatoes, celery carrots, and a touch of our secret ingredients that make this clam chowder the best you will ever have.
Gun Powder Spice Shrimp Chowder
$4.95
Henry Morgan's own mother's recipe of fresh shrimp, potatoes, tomatoes, onions, red and green bell peppers and a pinch of gun powder spice for spice for a little kick
Caribbean Black Bean Soup
3.95
no! we need to see your id for this soup, but we make it with black beans, myers dark rum, onions, celery and thyme, topped off with a touch of sour cream and diced onions.
$Salads
House Salad
$3.25
crisp lettuce blend, with ripe Roma tomatoes, carrots and tasteful cheeses,
Grilled Chicken Salad
$7.95
chicken breast marinated in the Captain's special seasonings, served on a large bed of spring mix with diced carrots, red peppers and Roma tomatoes.
Grilled Shrimp Salad
$8.75
a skewer of tender shrimp grilled on an open flame served on a bed of spring mix with diced carrots, red peppers and Roma tomatoes
Caesar Salad
$5.95
chopped romaine hearts tossed with red peppers, grated cotija cheese, tossed with our creamy Caesar dressing add grilled chicken 2.00 add grilled shrimp 3.00
Dinner soup and Salad Combo
7.20
unlimited refills on soups, house salad and bread
$Seafood
Paella
$22.95
this famous cuban dish is a medley of shrimp, scallops, mussels, clams, white fish chorizo sausage, chicken, Spanish rice and served with a side of maduros.
Bahamian style cracked lobster Tails
$26.95
two lobster tails cracked open and lightly breaded with our signature breading, then deep fried and served with baked potato and caribbean cole slaw.
Grilled Mahi Mahi With A Caribbean Lime Sauce
$12.95
mahi mahi grilled with a hint of lemon then covered with a creamy lime sauce, served with a side of garlic mashed potatoes and our mixed caribbean vegetables.
Surf and Turf
$24.95
for a taste form the sea and form the land this is a dish with both lobster tail and a 10 oz, served with backed potato and Caribbean vegetables
Snow Crab Legs Platter
$16.95
One Pound of steamed crab legs served with baked potato or fries and caribbean cole slaw.
Mexican Surfer Fish Tacos
$9.50
two soft tortilla tacos, stuffed with grilled mahi mahi seasoned with Caribbean spices, shredded lettuce, pico de gallo and jack and cheddar cheeses, served with maduros, back beans and white rice.
Abaco Grouper
$14.95
grouper filet broiled with citrus juices, onions, crushed garlic gloves, and butter, served with black beans and white rice.
Captain Morgan's Spiced Rum Glazed Grouper
$12.95
grouper filet and sliced onions sauteed with extra virgin olive oil, white wine and then glazed with captain morgan's spiced rum creating a semi-sweet unique island taste, served with a baked potato and Caribbean vegetables.
Pan Fried Jalapeno Grouper
$13.50
filet of grouper lightly breaded with allspice breading then topped with a chunky jalapeno cream sauce, served with garlic mashed potatoes and Caribbean vegetables.
Grilled Salmon With Creamy Bonaire Sauce
$15.95
a creamy lemon sauce made with mushrooms, carrots, celery, onions, red peppers and a hint of garlic, conering a grilled salmon steak, served with spanish yellow rice and black beans.
Shrimp 1/2 Lb or 1 Lb
$9.95-15.95
boiled or chilled large shrimp boiled in zantarain's shrimp and crab boil served hot or chilled, baked potato or fries and caribbean cole slaw served on the side.
Zarzuela De Mariscos
$95.00
"truly the finest dish we offer" , the name means "open of the sea" , this very unique dish is made with shrimp, lobster, scallops, fresh fish, mussels and clams prepared in seafood tomato bouillabaisse with a bint of saffron spice, white rice served on the side.
Captain's Seafood Platier
$95.00
fried: shrimp, clam strips, scallops, oysters, and fish served with fries and coleslaw.
Fried Shrimp Platter
95.00
12 large shrimp lightly breaded served with baked potato and coleslaw.
$Kids Menu
Captain Benjamin's popcorn shrimp
$3.95
Hamburger
$3.95
Cheeseburger
$3.95
Macaroni cheese
$3.95
Chicken Fingers
$3.50
Hot dog
$3.25
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
$2.95
Kids Soda
$1.25
kids Milk or Juice
1.75
$Pasta
Linguini and Clams
$13.75
linguini tossed with red clam sauce made from a blending of clams, garlic, onions, Roma tomatoes, oregano and white wine
Bahamian Manchego Cheese Pasta
$10.95
creamy sauce made a blend of manchego cheese, garlic and cream tossed with fettuccine, add grilled chicken $2.00 or grilled shrimp $3.00
Havana Styled Shrimp with Linguini
16.50
large shrimp sauteed in extra virgin olive oil, garlic, butter and spices creating a mouth watering garlic-butter sauce, then tossed in with linguini pasta
$Desserts,
Key Lime Pie
$4.25
key west style key lime filling made with real key limes fills a unique graham cracker pie crust topped with whipped cream and sprinkled with coffee crunch
Flan De Lenche
$5.25
sweet cuban custard with caramelized sugar and Cinnamon
Cancun Fried Ice Cream
$4.50
one large scoop of vanilla ice cream covered with a sweet crispy coating, fried and drizzled with caramel sauce
Sharon's Treasure
$4.95
three layers of moist chocolate cake filled with chocolate, mousse and chocolate chips throughout, finished with thick chocolate fudge, and then covered with hershey's chocolate chips
Mangifera Cheesecake
$5.25
creamy New York style cheesecake from the cheesecake factory topped with our sweet mango topping
Mermaid Heavenly Delight
$4.95
warm chocolate brownie with carmel and marshmallows baked in, served with large scoop of vanilla ice cream topped with chocolate syrup
Soups
Bahamian Clam Chowder
$4.25
True, Bahamian creamy clarn chowder, full of clams, potatoes, celery, carrots and a touch of our secret ingredient to make this clam chowder the best you will ever have
Gun Powder Spice Shrimp Chowder
$4.95
Henry Morgan's own mother's recipe of fresh shrimp, potatoes, tomatoes, onions, red and green bell peppers and a pinch of gun powder spice for a little kick.
Caribbean Black Bean Soup
3.95
no! we don't need to see your ID for this soup, but we make it with black beans, myers dark rum, onions, celery and thyme with black beans, myers, dark onions, celery and thyme, topped off with a touch of sour cream and diced onions.
$Salads
Lunch Soup and Salad Special
$6.25
unlimited refills on soup, house salad and bread
House Salad
$3.25
Crisp lettuce blend, with ripe roma tomatoes, carrots and rasteful cheeses.
Grilled Chicken Salad
$7.95
checken breast marinated in the captain's soecuak seasibubgs, served on a large bed of spring mix with diced carrots, red peppers and rome tomatoes.
Grilled Shrimp Salad
$8.75
a skewer of tender shrimp grilled on an open flame served on a bed of spring mix with diced carrots, red peppers and roma tomatoes.
Caesar Salad
5.95
chopped romaine hearts tossed woth red peppers, grated cotija chese, tossed with our creamy caesar dressing, add grilled chicken 2.00 add grilled shrimp 3.00
$Sandwiches
all sandwiches served with lettuce, tomato and onion pickle spear on the side, add fries to any sandwiches for $0.95First Mates Fried Fish
$6.85
your choice of mahi or grouper breaded and fried to a golden brown, served on a kaiser roll, add 2 slices of cheese for $0.50
Grilled Fish
$7.50
tasty mahi or grouper marinated in island spices then grilled to perfection, served on a kaiser to roll, add 2 slices of cheese for 50
CM's Grilled Chicken
$7.25
juicy chicken breast marinated in the captain's special seasonings and grilled to render perfection, placed on a ksiser roll
Cuban
$6.25
sliced ham, marinated pork roast, Swiss cheese, sliced dill pickles and yellow mustard, served on cuban bread, pressed and toasted.
Oyster po'by
$6.50
a mountain of fried oysters with horseradish cole slaw on a hoagie roll.
Shrimp Po'boy
$6.50
a mountain of fried shrimp with hersredish cole slaw on hoagie roll.
The captain's Burger
$6.25
1/2 lb of island seasoned ground beer grilled, topped with sauteed mushrooms and covered with melted Swiss cheese, scrved on a kaiser roll
Sauteed Mushroom Burger
$7.25
1/2 lb of Island seasoned ground beer grilled, topped with sauteed mushrros and covered with melted Swiss cheese. served on a Kaiser roll.
Pan Con Bistec
7.95
thinly carved sirloin marinated with olive oil , citrus, herbs and spices then cooked with Caribbean spiced peppers and onions, generously portioned on a warm hoagie roll with melted monterey jack cheeses.
$Entrees
Beef Fajita
$7.95
Shrimp Fajitha
$8.95
Chicken and Beef Combo Fajita
$7.25
Chicken and Shrimp Combo Fajita
8.25
$Entrees
Oysters
$5.95-19.95
steamed or raw there is a risk associated with consuming raw oysters or any raw animal protein, if you have chronic illness of the liver, stomach or blood, or have immune disorders, you are at risk of serious tllness from raw oysters and should eat oysters fully cooked, if unsure of your risk, please consult a physician, Florida department of natural resources.
Great Inagua Sirloin
$12.95
this perfectly tender 10oz sirloin seasoned with caribbean spices from the great inagua island, served with a baked potato, and Caribbean vegetables
Beef and Shrimp Combo Fajita
$8.25
sizzling hot sliced chicken, beef or sauteed shrimp served on a bed of Caribbean marinated peppers and onions, served with side of Spanish yellow rice, black beans, shredded lettuce, pico de gallo, jack and cheddar cheese, and sour cream.
Shrimp
$9.95-15.95
boiled or chilled large shrimp boiled in zantarain's shrimp and crab boil served hot or chilled, baked potato or fries and Caribbean cole slaw served on the side.
Snow Crab Legs
$16.95
one pound of steamed crab legs served with baked potato or fries and breading, then deep fried, served with French fries and Caribbean cole slaw.
Peg Leg Wings
$5.75-24.45
the "best" wings in town! seven great choices: mils, medium, hot, BBQ, teriyaki, jerk, jerk or plain, served with carrots and celery.
Bahamian Style Cracked lobster Basket
$13.55
a lobster tail cracked open and lightly breaded with our signature breading, then deep fried, served with French fries and Caribbean cole slaw.
Spanish Thin Crust Pizza (Create Your Own)
$6.95
Crispy crust made from tortillas with a light sofito's sauce, monterey jack cheese, and your choice of up to four topping: green peppers, chorizo sausage, mushrooms, Basil, onion, green olives, roma tomatoes, picadillo
Bahamian Manchego Cheese Pasta
$8.95
creamy sauce made from a blend of manchego cheese, garlic and cream tossed with fettuccine
Fried Shrimp and Fries
$7.25
seven large shrimp lightly breaded and served with fries
Chicken Binger Basket
$6.50
five lightly breaded chicken fingers with fries.
Mexican Surfer Fish Tacos
$9.50
two soft tortilla taco's stuffed with grilled mahi seasoned with Caribbean spices, shredded lettuce, pice de gallo and jack and cheddar cheese, served with rice and black beans
Mix Basket Of Plenty
$10.95
choice of any 3:fried oysters, pep corn shrimp, fried scallops, large fried shrimp, clam strips or chicken fingers, served with fries.
Caribbean Grilled Chicken
$8.95
juicy chicken breast marinated in the captain's specials seasonings and grilled to tender perfection, served with a side of Spanish yellow rice and Caribbean vegetables
Lunch Mexican Fajita's chicken fajita's
$5.95
Tropical Caribben Pizza
$7.25
tortilla crust, sofrito sauce, ham, pineapple, green peppers and onion with melted monterey jack cheese
Manta Ray Stingers
7.75
breaded chicken finger strips fried and tossed in your choice of wing sauce served with French fries
$Desserts
Key Lime Pie
$4.25
key west style key lime made with real key limes fills a unique graham cracker pie crust topped with whipped cream and sprinkles with toffee crunch
Mermaid Heavenly Delight
$4.95
warm chocolate brownie with caramel and marshmallows baked in, served with a large scoop of vanilla ice cream topped with chocolates syrup.
Sharon's Treasure
$4.95
three layers of moist chocolate cake filled with chocolate mousse and chocolate chips throughout, finished with thick chocolate fudge, and then covered with Hershey's chocolate chips
Mangifera Cheesecake
$5.25
creamy new york sytle cheesecake from the cheessecake factory topped with our sweet mango topping.
Cancn Fried Ice Cream
$5.40
one large scoop of vanilla ice cream covered with a sweet crispy coating, fried and drizzled with caramel sauce.
Flan De Leche
$5.25
sweet Cuban custard with caramelized sugar and commamon
Ice Cream Sandwich
$1.00
Menu for Cpt. Henry Morgan's Pt Ryl Caribbean Rest & Oyster is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
Check Other Restaurant Menu
Roma Pizza & Grill
Mediterranean
Cracker Barrel Old Country Store
American, Southern
King's Pizza
Pizza
Friendly's
American, Burgers, Diner, Ice Cream
Fazoli's
Italian, Pasta, Pizza, Sandwiches