Old Carolina Barbecue Company

Old Carolina Barbecue Company Menu

(330) 930-0300
1330 N Main St, Orrville, OH 44667

Sandwiches

Your 'Cue Meat choice on a bun! Compliment all sandwiches with one or two sides!
Regular Pulled Pork Sandwich
$9.00
Dry rubbed and slow smoked for up to 14 hours over hickory wood. Make it carolina style with vinegar sauce and coleslaw or pig stand style with fresh-fried onion strings.
Big 'Cue Pulled Pork Sandwich
$10.50
Dry rubbed and slow smoked for up to 14 hours over hickory wood. Make it Carolina Style with vinegar sauce and coleslaw or Pig Stand Style with fresh-fried onion strings.
Pulled Chicken Sandwich
$9.00
Dry rubbed, slow smoked, and pulled to perfection. Served on a toasted bun.
Beef Brisket Sandwich
$11.50
Dry rubbed and slow smoked for up to 12 hours over hickory wood.
Chopped Brisket Sandwich
11.50
Dry rubbed, slow smoked, and chopped. Served on a toasted bun.

$Plates and Platters

All plates and platters include a single cornbread served with our vanilla cinnamon honey butter.
Pulled Pork Plate
$11.50
Includes choice of side and served with one cornbread and our vanilla cinnamon honey butter. Served without the bun.
Pulled Chicken Plate
$11.50
Includes choice of side and served with one cornbread and our vanilla cinnamon honey butter. Served without the bun.
Sliced Beef Brisket Plate
$13.50
Includes choice of side and served with one cornbread and our vanilla cinnamon honey butter. Served without the bun.
Chopped Beef Brisket Plate
$13.50
Includes choice of side and served with one cornbread and our vanilla cinnamon honey butter. Served without the bun.
Two Meat Platter
$16.50
Served with 2 'cue choice meat, and 2 sides, served with cornbread and our vanilla cinnamon honey butter.
Three Meat Platter
21.00
Served with 3 'cue choice meat, and 2 sides, served with cornbread and our vanilla cinnamon honey butter.

$Chicken


1/2 Chicken
$11.50
Dry rubbed and slow smoked, Includes one breast wing and one leg thigh.
1/4 Leg and Thigh
$7.00
Dry rubbed and slow smoked.
1/4 Breast and Wing
$8.50
Dry rubbed and slow smoked.
Wings
Great add on to any order! Smoked then fried to order and tossed in our traditional seasoning.
3 Crispy Chicken Tenders and Fries
11.00
3 juicy and crispy tenders fried to order with our fresh-cut fries. Feel free to change up the side!

$Ribs and Rib Combos

All rib combos include a single cornbread served with our vanilla cinnamon honey butter. Don't forget the dessert!
The Carolina Combo
$21.50
1/3 slab plus pulled pork with 2 sides and cornbread.
The Kansas City Combo
$21.50
1/3 slab plus pulled chicken with 2 sides and cornbread.
The Texas Combo
$23.00
1/3 slab plus beef brisket with 2 sides and cornbread.
The Outlaw Combo
$21.50
1/3 slab plus any cue choice with 2 sides and cornbread.
The Ultimate Sampler Combo
$34.50
Enough to feed two: ribs, pulled pork, brisket, pulled chicken, 4 jumbo smokehouse wings, with 2 sides and 2 cornbread.
Award-Winning Smokehouse Ribs
Dry rubbed and slow smoked for up to 4.5 hours!

Barbecue Bowls


Barbecue Bowl
11.00
Mac-N-Cheese, Mashed Potatoes or Fries, Onion Straws, Cheddar Cheese, BBQ Sauce and Green Onions with your Choice of Pulled Pork, Chopped Brisket, Pulled Chicken or Chicken Tenders

$Housemade Sides

Available in both 6 ounce side portions and 16 ounce pint portions.
Any 2 Sides
$5.00
More of your favorite sides for less!
Baked Beans
A mixture of beans slow cooked with our tender pork and flavorful sauce!
Creamy Slaw
A mixture of shredded cabbage, carrots, and our creamy sauce.
Vinegar Slaw
A mixture of shredded cabbage, carrots, and our vinegar sauce.
Skin-on Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Fresh-cut Fries
$3.50
Fresh cut fries tossed in our smokehouse seasoning. This is not available in a pint size.
Smokehouse Mac-n-Cheese
Cavatappi noodles mixed with our four-cheese sauce topped with our smokehouse seasoning and buttered bread crumbs.
Country Green Beans
Cortados cut green beans mixed with brisket pieces.
Hush Puppies
$3.00
Hand rolled and fried to order. This is not available in a pint size.
Cornbread Muffins
$3.50
Every two cornbread muffins are served with one ounce of our vanilla cinnamon honey butter. This is not available in a pint size.
Fresh Fried Onion Strings
3.50
Fried and seasoned onion strings served with Baja Ranchero for dipping. This is not available in a pint size.

$Salads


Carolina House Salad
$8.00
Greens, carrots, cucumber, tomato, red onion, cheddar, cranberries and cornbread croutons.
True Q Salad
$11.00
Carolina house topped with your choice of pulled pork, beef brisket, pulled chicken or fried chicken tenders.
Side Salad
4.50
Greens, carrots, cucumber, tomato, red onion, cheddar, cranberries and cornbread croutons.

$Kids


Kids Pulled Pork Sandwich
$8.50
Includes drink and 1 side dish.
Kids Chicken Tender Plate
8.50
Includes drink and 1 side dish.

$Family Meal Packs

Each Family Meal Pack comes with barbecue sauce, Sandwich buns or Cornbread.
Small Family Dinner (Feeds 4)
$31.50
Choose one meat, two sides, choice of bread and barbecue sauce.
Large Family Dinner (Feeds 6)
$53.50
Choose two meats, two sides, choice of bread and barbecue sauce.
Small Family Feast (Feeds 4)
$53.50
Choose two meats, three sides, choice of bread and barbecue sauce.
Large Family Feast (Feeds 6)
$79.75
Choose three meats, three sides, choice of bread and barbecue sauce.
Place-settings (.30 Per Person)
0.30
Includes a Plate, Utensils, wet-naps and Napkins for one person.

$Desserts


Banana Pudding
$4.00
A rich, creamy southern tradition made with real bananas.
6 Boardwalk Bites
$3.00
Warm donut holes with powdered or cinnamon sugar.
Chocolate Chunk Cookie
$3.00
Salted Caramel Cookie
$3.00
Chocolate Brownie
3.00

$Drinks


Carolina Tea
$3.20
Fountain Soda
$3.20
Bottled Water
$3.00

Menu for Old Carolina Barbecue Company is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

Check Other Restaurant Menu