Cheese
Carolina Reaper Cheese
$7.49
8oz. Carolina reaper cheese is currently the hottest cheese we have to offer with up to 2.2 million Scoville units of heat! Pasteurized milk, cheese culture, salt, less than 1% enzymes, annatto, chili pepper spice powder. Contains milk color: orange with a hint of red chili pepper flavor: rich and creamy, hot with balanced pepper flavor body: smooth, firm.
Ghost Pepper Cheese
$6.49
0.10 lb. Ghost pepper cheese is made from the bhut jolokia pepper of India. It packs 855,000 Scoville units of heat into each bite. But be careful, the heat comes on slowly, so it’s easy to over-do. Careful, it will sneak up on you!
Scorpion Cheddar
$7.49
0.5 lb. Scorpion cheddar is currently the second hottest cheese we have to offer with 1.2 million Scoville units of heat! It is made from the mortgage scorpion chili pepper of Trinidad, which was named in 2012 as the hottest pepper in the world! This one is for the truly bold and adventurous eater! Proceed with caution! Pasteurized milk, cultures, salt, less than 1% enzymes, annatto (color), ground scorpion chile pepper creamy cheddar blended with scorpion chili peppers, which have a mean heat of more than 1.2million Scoville heat units. Caution: extremely hot! It can cause eye and skin irritation.
White Wine Cheese Collection
$29.99
6 lbs. White wine collection wine and cheese pairing can be difficult. It includes generous cuts of Amish butter cheese, Wisconsin brick cheese, gouda, and premium Amish country Swiss cheese.
4 in 1 Cheese
$6.99
1.6 lbs. Our 4 in 1 cheese contains Colby, orange cheddar, cojack, and Monterrey Jack cheeses.
American Cheese
$6.49
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%.
Amish Butter Cheese
$6.99
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%.
Asiago Cheese
$10.99
1.6 lbs. Price is per Lb. Actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Asiago cheese is an Italian cheese more specifically known as asiago d'Alene.Asiago(ah-syah-goh).
Baby Swiss Cheese
Baby swiss is another of our local selections, made in charm, Ohio by the original producer Guggisberg cheese.
Bacon Cheese
$7.49
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Bacon cheese is a mild orange cheddar infused with smoked bacon.
Beer Cheese
$9.99
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. it is a semi-soft combination of Limburger cheese and brick cheese.
Beer Collection
$45.99
7 lbs. A pairing collection for the beer enthusiast! Brick, Gouda, gruyere, and Ohio premium Swiss cheese. Because beer has a stronger flavor, it pairs well with more bold cheeses. Beer pairs very well with Limburger and beer cheese, so named for being the ideal cheese to compliment the beer.
Bermuda Onion Cheese
$6.99
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%.
Brick Cheese
$5.99
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Brick cheese is made in the form of large rectangular shape, but may also be named “brick†because the cheese curds are pressed with clay-fired bricks.
Canadian Cheddar Cheese: Fine Aged Cheddar
$16.49
1.8 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Canadian fine aged cheddar is aged for a longer period of time giving it a “sharper†flavor. Strong, mature cheddar, sometimes called vintage, needs to be matured for up to 15 months. Our Canadian fine aged cheddar is aged for four years.
Chevre Goat’s Milk Cheese
$5.99
0.4 lb. The price is per 4 oz. package. Chevre (shev-ray) is a term that denotes a cheese made from the milk of goats, with the word chevre meaning goat in french. Chevre is a fresh cheese that resembles cream cheese.
Colby Cheese
$5.99
1.2 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Colby cheese is a semi-hard cow’s milk cheese native to the United States.
Danish Blue Cheese
$11.49
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. it can be made from cow, sheep, and goat’s milk and is typically aged in a temperature and moisture controlled environment like a cave. The characteristic flavor of blue cheese is usually sharp and salty, but levels of sharpness vary by region.
Farmer’s Cheese
$5.99
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Farmer's cheese is a mild unripened white cheese made by adding rennet to cow’s milk.
Garlic Cheddar
$9.49
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Garlic cheddar is a mild white cheddar infused with garlic.
Goat Cheese
$17.49
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Goat cheese is a fresh cheese that resembles cream cheese. This type of goat cheese tends to be slightly crumbly, creamy and may have a strong goat flavor.
Gouda
$12.49
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Gouda is a yellow cow’s milk cheese.
Green Onion Cheese
$7.49
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Green onion cheese is made with real green onion. All-natural 100% of Ohio farm milk. No artificial growth hormones. Pasteurized processed cheese.
Gruyere Cheese
$20.49
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Gruyere (groo-yair) is one of our favorite imported cheeses. Some call it a french cheese while others insist it is from Switzerland.
Havarti Cheese
$10.49
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Cream Havarti (flode Havarti in Danish) is a semi-soft Danish cow’s milk cheese. Havarti cheese has a buttery aroma and can be somewhat sharp in the stronger varieties, much like Swiss cheese.
Havarti Cheese with Caraway
$10.49
1.6 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Cream Havarti (flode Havarti in Danish) is a semi-soft Danish cow’s milk cheese. Havarti cheese is an interior-ripened cheese that is rindless, smooth and slightly bright-surfaced with a cream to yellow color depending on the type.
Havarti Cheese with Dill
$10.49
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Cream Havarti (flode Havarti in Danish) is a semi-soft Danish cow’s milk cheese. Havarti cheese has a buttery aroma and can be somewhat sharp in the stronger varieties, much like swiss cheese.
Horseradish Cheddar
$7.49
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Horseradish cheddar is a mild white cheddar infused with the spicy tang of horseradish. It is more balanced than our horseradish cheese, which has a more pronounced horseradish flavor.
Horseradish Cheese
$6.99
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Our horseradish cheese in an American cheese infused with horseradish and comes in a semi-firm block. Horseradish cheese is a popular element in many hors d’oeuvres that contain a pungent, spicy bite, tempting to the palate.
Hot Habanero Cheddar
$8.99
1lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Hot habanero cheddar is the hottest cheese of all, and not for the faint of heart. It will liven up your taste buds with a combination of vintage aged cheddar, habaneros, and jalapenos.
Hot Pepper Cheese
$7.99
1lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Hot pepper cheese has just the right amount of heat to make it a perfect balance of flavor with a little extra kick!
Jarlsberg Cheese
$13.49
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. The famous Jarlsberg cheese of Norway is known for its distinctive sweet and nutty taste.
Jumping Jack
$6.49
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Jumping jack cheese is a marble-based cheese with the perfect mix of jalapeno and habanero peppers added. A spicy cheese that looks beautiful on a cheese board at your next party.
Lacey Baby Swiss
$6.09
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Baby Swiss is another of our local selections, made in charm, Ohio by the original producer guggisberg cheese.
Lacey Baby Swiss
$6.09
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Baby swiss is another of our local selections, made in charm, Ohio by the original producer guggisberg cheese.
Lacy Swiss
$6.49
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Lacy Swiss is another of our lower fat and sodium alternatives. Lacy Swiss has a delightfully light and nutty flavor, but a lower calorie and sodium content than the original Swiss cheese.
Limburger Cheese
$5.99
1 lb. Price is per 6 oz. piece. Actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Smooth and creamy with an intense smell and flavor. Limburger cheese is one of our specialty cheeses from Wisconsin along with our American, muenster, brick, Limburger, and beer cheeses. Limburger cheese gets more pungent with age.
Lucerne Cheese
$6.99
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Lucerne cheese is another of our local selections, made in charm, Ohio by the original producer guggisberg cheese.
Manchego Cheese
$19.49
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Manchego cheese is the most important and well-known sheep’s milk cheese in Spain. The shape of manchego cheese is very characteristic and defined.
Marble Cheese
$5.99
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Originates from England, Marble cheese is so named because of its two-toned color. Marble cheese is made from Colby and Monterey jack cheeses, it is sometimes called “Cojack.â€
Mozzarella
$5.99
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. It is a semi-soft cheese. Due to its high moisture content, it is traditionally served the day after it is made, but can be kept in brine for up to a week and longer when sold in vacuum-sealed packages.
Muenster Cheese
$6.49
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Muenster cheese is a mild, white cheese with a reddish-orange rind made from paprika.
Ohio Swiss Cheese
$6.99
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Ohio Swiss cheese or more specifically our Amish Swiss cheese is made locally in pearl valley, Ohio.
Orange Cheddar
$6.79
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Orange cheddar is traditional white cheddar with annatto, an extract from the tropical achiote tree, and oleoresin paprika added. These added ingredients give the orange cheddar its orange color and a milder flavor.
Parmesan
$9.49
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Parmesan cheese has a complex, sharp, nutty flavor with a somewhat grainy texture.
Pepper Jack Cheese
$5.99
1.8 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Pepper jack cheese is just one of our selection of many spicy pepper kinds of cheese. Pepper jack cheese is a cow’s milk cheese that blends the creamy, buttery flavor of jack cheese with the intensity of spicy peppers, most notably jalapeños, but also includes some serrano peppers and habaneros.
Pepperoni Cheese
$6.59
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%.
Provolone
$5.49
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Provolone can be made with buffalo, cow’s milk, and a mixture of the two. sometimes it’s lightly smoked.
Raclette: Delicious French Melting Cheese
$18.99
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Raclette (ra-klet) is a semi-firm, salted cheese made from cow’s milk. However, varieties exist made with white wine, pepper, herbs, and smoked.
Red Wine Collection
$44.99
7 lbs. It includes generous cut it includes generous cuts of asiago, danish blue cheese, gruyere, and pecorino (Romano).
Romano Pecorino
$10.49
1.2 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Pecorino romano is imported from southern Italy. It is salty and firm and is an excellent grating cheese, and also works well as an ingredient.
Scotch Collection
$45.99
7 lbs. A cheese pairing collection for the scotch aficionado! It includes generous cuts of danish blue cheese, gruyere, cheddar, and Parmesan. This collection was specifically selected to pair well with scotch.
Sharp American Cheese
$7.99
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. The term “sharp†used in reference to cheese denotes a stronger flavor as a result of a longer aging process.
Sharp Swiss
$8.99
1.2 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Sharp swiss cheese is a more mature version of our locally made swiss cheese that has been aged approximately 12 months. Sharp Swiss cheese is an excellent substitute for gruyere cheese.
Smoked Baby Swiss
$7.49
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Smoked Baby Swiss is produced from whole milk, unlike traditional swiss which is made from partially skimmed milk. Smoked baby Swiss a creamier texture and a more buttery, slightly sweet flavor, which makes it ideal for melting.
Smoked Bacon Cheese
$7.49
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%.
Smoked Cheddar Cheese
$6.49
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Smoked cheddar cheese is slowly smoked over a hickory fire giving it a distinct smoky flavor. Cheddar, made in a classical way, tends to have a sharp, pungent flavor, often slightly earthy.
Smoked Gouda
$11.99
1.8 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Gouda is a yellow cow’s milk cheese with a red and yellow wax coating.
Smoked Habanero Cheddar
$10.99
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Smoked habanero cheddar is the hottest cheese of all, and not for the faint of heart. Smoked habanero cheddar will liven up your taste buds with a combination of vintage aged cheddar, habaneros, and jalapenos.
Smoked Horseradish Cheese
$6.49
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Smoked horseradish cheese our horseradish cheese in an American cheese infused with horseradish and comes in a semi-firm block. Smoked horseradish cheese is hickory smoked to additionally enhance the flavor.
Smoked Hot Pepper
$6.49
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Smoked hot pepper cheese features an excellent tasting smokey taste without covering up the flavor while supplying that extra kick of hotness. Smoked hot pepper cheese is cured slowly with real hickory wood.
Smoked Provolone Cheese
$6.99
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Cured to perfection, smoked provolone cheese is perfect for slightly smoky, slightly nutty taste lends.
Smoked Swiss Cheese
$6.49
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Here is a smoked version of our Ohio Amish swiss cheese.
Super Hot Pepper Cheese
$6.79
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%.
White American Cheese
$7.49
1ib. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. White American cheese is a cheese made from a blend of milk, milk fats and solids, with other fats and whey protein concentrate.
White Cheddar
$6.79
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. White cheddar, sometimes generically referred to as Vermont cheddar regardless of its origin, is the original color and form of traditional cheddar. Many connoisseurs claim that white cheddar is slightly sharper than orange cheddar, but that is more dependent on aging than color.
Yogurt Cheese
$7.49
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Yogurt cheese is another of our lower-calorie alternatives and skinny foods. Yogurt cheese is the creamy white cheese leftover when liquid whey drains from the fresh yogurt.
Yogurt Cheese with Garlic and Herb
$7.49
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Yogurt cheese is another of our lower-calorie alternatives or skinny foods. Yogurt cheese is the creamy white cheese leftover when liquid whey drains from the fresh yogurt.
Yogurt Cheese With Jalapenos
$7.49
1 lb. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Yogurt cheese is another of our lower-calorie alternatives and skinny foods. Yogurt cheese is the creamy white cheese leftover when liquid whey drains from the fresh yogurt. It is all-natural and is a great way to supplement your diet with calcium and protein without adding fat.
Yogurt Cheese With Vegetables
$7.49
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. actual weight may vary by up to 10%. Yogurt cheese is another of our lower-calorie alternatives and skinny foods. Yogurt cheese is the creamy white cheese leftover when liquid whey drains from the fresh yogurt. It is all-natural and is a great way to supplement your diet with calcium and protein without adding fat.
Buffalo Wing Cheese Curds
$9.99
2.8 lbs. The best cheese curds we could find are made in upstate New York, just like our orange and white cheddars.
Fresh Cheddar Cheese Curds
$9.99
2.6 lbs. The best cheese curds we could find are made in upstate new york, just like our orange and white cheddars.
Roasted Garlic Cheese Curds
9.99
1.5 lbs. The best cheese curds we could find are made in upstate New York, just like our orange and white cheddars.
$Chocolate
Ben Heggy’s Special Peanuts
$5.99
0.12 lb. Ben Heggy’s special peanuts (hard whites) large Virginia peanuts roasted in peanut oil to a crispy (hard) taste, then lightly salted.
Gourmet Chocolate Covered Pretzels
$6.49
0.6 lb. Classic Animal Crackers dipped in Stefanelli’s Candies signature decadent chocolate.
Sponge Candy
$3.49
1.50 lbs. Sponge candy, delectable seafoam toffee covered in rich chocolate. Be careful, it’s addictive! Sponge candy by Stefanelli's candies Erie, PA.
White Chocolate Popcorn
$3.99
0.12 lb. White chocolate popcorn Amish country grown popcorn carefully coated in delectable white chocolate!
Beijinhos: Brazilian Coconut Truffles
$5.99
0.8 lb. Box of five coconut truffles.
Brigadeiros: Brazilian Chocolate Truffles
$5.99
0.8 lb. Price is for 5 packs of chocolate truffles.
Cajuzinho: Brazilian Peanut Candy
$5.99
Price is for 5 packs of peanut candy.
Heggy’s Assortment
$12.65
1.6 lb. Price is per lb.
Assorted Heggy’s Chocolates
$12.65
1.6 lb. Price is per lb.
Assorted Heggy’s Chocolates Gift Box
$12.65
1.6 lbs.
Assorted Heggy’s Milk Chocolates
$12.65
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb.
Heggy’s French Mints
$12.65
1.6 lbs. Price is per Lb. Heggy’s french mints a dark chocolate peppermint flavored, melt in your mouth, center. Square in shape and covered with pink pastel coating. A very popular seller!!
Heggy’s Haystacks
$12.65
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. Heggy’s haystacks are made with a large sweet shredded white coconut center mixed with milk chocolate.
Heggy’s Milk Chocolate Brownie Cream
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb. Heggy’s milk chocolate brownie creams are a combination of a rich chocolate flavored center made with the finest dairy cream.
Heggy’s Milk Chocolate Butter Cream
$12.65
1.6 lbs. Price per lb. Heggy’s milk chocolate buttercreams are a combination of a light brown sugar center made with fresh dairy cream, enrobed in our pure milk chocolate.
Heggy’s Milk Chocolate Cherry Creams
$12.65
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. Milk chocolate cherry creams are a combination of a vanilla cream center with chopped red cherries added.
Heggy’s Milk Chocolate Coated Marshmallows
$12.65
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. Heggy’s mile chocolate-coated marshmallows is a combination of large fluffy marshmallows dipped in milk chocolate.
Heggy’s Milk Chocolate Coated Peanuts
$12.65
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb. Heggy’s milk chocolate coated peanuts are a combination of fresh roasted and salted peanuts, dipped in pure milk chocolate. A hot item at any time of the year!
Heggy’s Milk Chocolate Coated Pretzels
$7.36
1 lb. The price is per 8 oz. Heggy’s milk chocolate coated pretzels is a combination of lightly salted pretzels dipped in milk chocolate.
Heggy’s Milk Chocolate Coconut Creams
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb. Heggy’s milk chocolate coconut creams are a combination of fresh coconut in a vanilla flavored cream center sealed in our creamy milk chocolate.
Heggy’s Milk Chocolate Covered Caramels
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb.
Heggy’s Milk Chocolate Covered Raisins
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per Lb. Heggy’s milk chocolate coated raisins are a combination of plump California raisins dipped in our finest milk chocolate.
Heggy’s Milk Chocolate Covered Red Raspberry Creams
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per Lb. Heggy’s milk chocolate red raspberry creams is a combination of fresh red raspberry puree, cooked and mixed to a creamy delight and coated in milk chocolate.
Heggy’s Milk Chocolate Crunch
$12.65
1 lb. Price per lb. Heggy’s milk chocolate crunch is a combination of small bits of buttery peanut brittle, dipped in our pure milk chocolate.
Heggy’s Milk Chocolate Jersey Creams
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb. Heggy’s Milk Chocolate Jersey Creams is a combination of a buttercream center made with white sugar and fresh dairy cream and covered in milk chocolate.
Heggy’s Milk Chocolate Lemon Creams
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb. Heggy’s lemon creams: a refreshing lemon cream center coated in Heggy’s finest milk chocolate.
Heggy’s Milk Chocolate Maple Walnut Creams
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb. Heggy’s milk chocolate maple walnut creams is a combination of a soft maple flavored cream center with finely chopped English walnuts added and covered in milk chocolate.
Heggy’s Milk Chocolate Nut Crisp
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb. Heggy’s milk chocolate nut crisp is a combination of squares of solid peanut brittle covered in creamy milk chocolate.
Heggy’s Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb. Heggy’s milk chocolate peanut buttercreams are a combination of a rich peanut butter cream center encased in our finest milk chocolate.
Heggy’s Milk Chocolate Peanut Clusters
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb. Heggy’s milk chocolate peanut clusters are a combination of a vanilla cream center covered with a blend of fresh ground peanuts and milk chocolate.
Heggy’s Milk Chocolate Peppermint Creams
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb. Heggy’s milk chocolate peppermint creams are a combination of a milk chocolate coated cream center, flavored with the purest of oil of peppermint.
Heggy’s Milk Chocolate Turtles
$12.65
0.8 lb. Price is per 8 oz. box. Heggy’s milk chocolate turtles is a combination of pecans topped with creamy smooth vanilla Carmel and then coated with milk chocolate.
Heggy’s Milk Chocolate Vanilla Creams
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb. Heggy’s milk chocolate vanilla creams is a combination of light vanilla-flavored cream center coated in milk chocolate. These are sometimes known as orientals.
Heggy’s White Chocolate Pretzel Delights
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb. Heggy’s white chocolate pretzel delights is a combination of fresh ground pretzels mixed with a white creamy coating.
Heggy’s Dark Chocolate Assortment
$12.65
1.6 lb. Price is per lb.
Heggy’s Dark Chocolate Brownie Creams
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb.
Heggy’s Dark Chocolate Butter Creams
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb.
Heggy’s Dark Chocolate Cherry Creams
$12.65
1.6 lb. Price is per lb.
Heggy’s Dark Chocolate Coconut Creams
$12.65
1.2 lbs. Price is per lb.
Heggy’s Dark Chocolate Covered Caramels
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb.
Heggy’s Dark Chocolate Covered Marshmallows
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb. Heggy’s dark chocolate covered marshmallows is a combination of large fluffy marshmallows dipped in dark chocolate.
Heggy’s Dark Chocolate Covered Peanuts
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb. Heggy’s dark chocolate covered peanuts is a combination of fresh roasted and salted peanuts, dipped in pure dark chocolate.
Heggy’s Dark Chocolate Jersey Creams
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb. Heggy’s dark chocolate jersey creams are a combination of a buttercream center made with white sugar and fresh dairy cream and dipped in rich, dark chocolate.
Heggy’s Dark Chocolate Lemon Creams
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb. Heggy’s lemon creams: a refreshing lemon cream center coated in Heggy’s finest dark chocolate.
Heggy’s Dark Chocolate Maple Walnut Creams
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb. Heggy’s dark chocolate maple walnut creams is a combination of a soft maple flavored cream center with finely chopped English walnuts added and covered in rich, dark milk chocolate.
Heggy’s Dark Chocolate Peanut Clusters
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb. Heggy’s dark chocolate peanut clusters are a combination of a vanilla cream center covered with a blend of fresh ground peanuts and semi-sweet dark chocolate coating.
Heggy’s Dark Chocolate Peppermint Creams
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb. Heggy’s dark chocolate peppermint creams are a combination of a dark chocolate coated cream center, flavored with the purest of oil of peppermint and covered in rich, dark milk chocolate.
Heggy’s Dark Chocolate Red Raspberry Creams
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb. Heggy’s dark chocolate red raspberry creams are a combination of fresh red raspberry puree, cooked and mixed to a creamy delight and coated in dark chocolate.
Heggy’s Dark Chocolate Vanilla Creams
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb. Heggy’s dark chocolate vanilla creams is a combination of light vanilla-flavored cream center coated in dark chocolate.
Sugar Free Cashew Praline
$10.65
1.2 lb. Sugar-free cashew praline buttery caramel topped with freshly roasted cashews and then smothered in rich chocolate. Pure decadence without the guilt! Nutritional information for sugar-free cashew praline.
Sugar Free Chocolate Caramel
$10.65
1.2 lbs. Sugar-free chocolate caramel buttery caramel smothered in rich chocolate. Pure decadence without the guilt! Nutritional information for sugar-free chocolate caramel.
Sugar Free Coconut Dip
$10.65
1.6 lbs. Fresh coconut smothered in rich chocolate with no sugar added. Pure decadence without the guilt! Sugar-free coconut dip nutritional information.
Sugar Free Mint Meltaway
$10.65
1.6 lbs. Soft milk chocolate mint center smothered in rich chocolate, with no sugar added. Pure decadence without the guilt!
Sugar Free Peanut Butter Meltaway
$10.65
1.6 lbs. Creamy peanut butter center smothered in rich chocolate, with no sugar added. Pure decadence without the guilt!
Sugar Free Peanut Clusters
$10.65
1.6 lbs. Fresh roasted peanuts smothered in rich chocolate with no sugar added. Pure decadence without the guilt!
Sugar Free Pecan Praline
$10.65
1.6 lbs. Buttery caramel topped with fresh roasted pecans and then smothered in rich chocolate. Pure decadence without the guilt!
Sugar Free Raisin Clusters
$9.95
1.6 lbs. Sweet sun-ripened raisins smothered in rich chocolate with no sugar added. Pure decadence without the guilt!
Heggy’s Assorted Caramels
$12.65
1.6 lbs. Price is per lb.
Heggy’s Butterscotch Caramels
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb.
Heggy’s Vanilla Caramels
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb.
Heggy’s Walnut Caramels
$12.65
1 lb. Price is per lb. Heggy’s walnut caramels is a combination of chopped walnuts coated in rich, delicious caramel.
Chocolate Toffee Pretzels
$5.49
1 lb.
Milk Chocolate Covered Pretzels
$12.65
1.6 lbs.
Yogurt Pretzels
5.99
1.6 lbs
$Gift Boxes
Fall Harvest Collection
$38.00
7 lbs. The Best Flavors of Fall in Amish Country. Baby swiss cheese (2 lbs.), Streb meats smoked sausage (1 lb.), cranberry delight (1 lb.), pumpkin muffin mix pumpkin butter popcorn on the cob.
Gift Box #1: Baby Swiss Cheese
$35.00
6 lbs. 4 Lb. Baby Swiss wheel and assorted chocolates.
Gift Box #2: Troyer’s Trail Bologna and Cheese
$25.00
4 lbs. 1 lb. troyer’s trail bologna ring, 3/4 lb. wheel of Colby, 3/4 lb. wheel of farmers, and assorted chocolates.
Gift Box #3: Cheese Lover’s
$30.00
5 lbs. 3/4 Lb. Wheel of Cheddar, 3/4 Lb. Wheel of Cojack (Marble), 3/4 Lb. Wheel of Farmer’s Cheese, and 3/4 Lb. Wheel of Pepper Jack Assorted Chocolates.
Gift Box #4: Amish Cheese and Goodies
$50.00
8 lbs. 3/4 lb. a chunk of Ohio swiss cheese, 1 ring of trail bologna, 3/4 lb. bar of Colby, Shisler's private label mustard, carr’s crackers, and assorted chocolates.
Gift Box #5 – Baby Swiss Cheese and Troyer’s Trail Bologna: A Classic Amish Country Combination
$50.00
8 lbs. 2 lb. baby swiss wheel, Troyer's trail bologna ring, Colby cheese (8 oz.), Shisler's private label mustard, carr’s crackers, and assorted chocolates.
Gift Box #6: Amish Country Sampler Gift Box
$75.00
11 lbs. Troyer’s trail bologna ring 1 lb., a box of Heggy’s chocolates, home-style Amish jam, Shisler's private label hot mustard 3/4 lb., wheel of cheddar 3/4 lb. , wheel of cojack (marble) 3/4 lb., wheel of farmer’s cheese 3/4 lb., wheel of pepper jack cheese, baby swiss cheese wedge, summer sausage link, crackers.
Veteran’s Care Package
$45.00
10 lbs. Baby Swiss cheese wheel (2 lbs.), trail bologna ring and beef jerky, Shisler's private label hot pepper relish banana split mix, Amish, peanut butter spread, Amish homestyle jam carr’s crackers.
Hot Stuff Collection
$29.99
7 lbs. Hot pepper cheese habanero cheese, Troyer's trail bologna with hot pepper cheese, Shisler's private label hot pepper relish, Shisler's private label hot jalapeno mustard hot pepper jelly, and carr’s crackers.
Football Season Special
36.99
6 lbs. Swiss cheese, Troyer's trail bologna pepper jack cheese, Shisler's private label mustard, Shisler's private label hot pepper relish, and carr’s crackers.
$Gourmet Foods
Ben Heggy’s Extra Large Redskin Peanuts
$4.10
0.12 lbs. Ben Heggy’s extra-large redskin peanuts roasted in peanut oil and lightly salted.
Ben Heggy’s Fancy Mixed Nuts
$8.99
.75 lb. Ben Heggy’s fancy mixed nuts a mixture of whole cashews, almonds, brazil nuts, filberts, and pecans. Roasted and lightly salted, a real fancy mixture!!
Ben Heggy’s Natural Pistachio Nuts
$9.60
0.12 lb. Ben Heggy’s natural pistachio nuts dry roasted and salted with no color added. In the shell nuts!
Ben Heggy’s Roasted Pecans
$14.05
0.12 lbs. Ben Heggy’s toasted pecans roasted in peanut oil and lightly salted for the perfect taste!
Ben Heggy’s Spanish Peanuts
$4.79
0.12 lbs. Ben Heggy’s Spanish peanuts large Spanish peanuts roasted in peanut oil and lightly salted. A hit at your next party or just a snack on the go!!
Ben Heggy’s Special Peanuts
$5.99
0.12 lb. Ben Heggy’s special peanuts (hard whites) large Virginia peanuts roasted in peanut oil to a crispy (hard) taste, then lightly salted.
Ben Heggy’s Whole Cashew Nuts
$7.99
0.12 lbs. Ben Heggy’s whole cashew nuts roasted in peanut oil and lightly salted. Whole cashews have a sweet taste and are sure to be a hit at your next gathering!
Locally Made Fresh Maple Syrup
1.8 lbs. Pure amber maple syrup tapped and processed right here in Ohio's Amish country.
Rolled Amish Butter
$6.09
1.8 lbs. Fresh and delicious Amish butter is produced locally.
Shisler’s Private Label Hot Jalapeno Mustard
$3.99
1 lb.
Shisler’s Private Label Roasted Garlic Mustard
$3.99
1 lb.
Shisler’s Private Label Sweet Mustard
$3.99
1 lb.
Streb Meats Fresh Cracklins’
$3.49
5 lbs. Pork rinds and chicharrones.
Wild Maple Walnut Syrup
$8.75
1.8 lbs.
Blackberry Pecan Syrup
$8.75
1.8 lbs.
Blueberry Syrup
$8.75
1.8 lbs. Made from the best locally grown blueberries.
Cinnamon Sticky Bun Syrup
$8.75
1.8 lbs.
Lavender Syrup
$9.75
1.8 lbs.
Red Raspberry Syrup
$8.75
1.8 lbs.
Shagbark Hickory Syrup
$8.75
1.8 lbs.
Shisler’s Private Label Creamy Vidalia Onion Salad Dressing
$5.99
1.8 lbs.
Shisler’s Private Label Vidalia Onion and Creamy Cucumber Salad Dressing
$5.99
1.8 lbs.
Shisler’s Private Label Vidalia Onion and Poppyseed Salad Dressing
$5.99
1.8 lbs.
Shisler’s Private Label Vidalia Onion and Summer Tomato Salad Dressing
$5.99
1.8 lbs.
Amish Peanut Butter Spread
$4.49
1 lb. Our Amish peanut butter spread is sweet, creamy, and good on just about anything including crackers, cookies, and ice cream to name a few.
Bread Baking Mixes
$5.99
Beer bread, cheezy beer bread, golden cornbread, and red hot cornbread.
Cheesy Biscuits Baking Mix
$5.49
0.8 lb.
Diet Trail Mix
$5.49
1.2 lbs.
Gold’n Krisp Potato Chips
$5.19
1.2 lbs.
Muffin Mix
$5.49
0.8 lb.
Bertman Ballpark Mustard
$4.49
1.4 lbs. The original spicy brown stadium mustard.
Dick’s Homemade Horseradish Mustard
$3.49
1.8 lbs.
Herlocher’s Dipping Mustard
$4.49
1.8 lbs.
Think Fruit: Dried Fruit Snacks
$2.19
0.6 lb.
Tonn’s Pure Clover Honey Comb
$15.49
1 lb.
Almonds
$7.99
1 lb.
Amish Hot Mix
$5.59
1 lb. Hot cajun sesame sticks, taco sesame corn sticks, redskin peanuts, pretzel twists, chili bits.
Banana Chips
$3.99
1.2 lbs.
Banana Split Mix
$4.99
1 lb. Cranberries, banana chips, almonds, chocolate covered peanuts, chocolate drops, pineapple tidbits, raisins, yogurt covered peanuts, peanuts, and yogurt drops.
Buggy Trail Mix
$5.99
1 lb. Butter toffee peanuts, honey roasted sesame sticks, cheddar crackers, pretzel nugget, wheat crackers.
Cinnamon Almonds
$7.99
1 lb. Price is per lb.
Cinnamon Graham Pretzels
$5.99
1.2 lbs.
Corn Nuts
$5.49
1.2 lbs.
Cranberry Delight
$7.99
1 lb. Price is per lb. Dried cranberries, golden raisins, peanuts, almonds, pecans, dried cherries, pineapple dices, papaya dices.
Dried Cranberries
$5.99
1 lb. Price is per lb.
Dried Kiwi
$5.49
1.6 lb.
Dried Red Cherries
$11.99
1 lb. Price is per lb.
Dried Strawberries
$8.49
1.6 lbs. A healthy snack idea. These dried strawberries have no fat or cholesterol, are low in sodium, but high in fiber.
Chocolate Graham Pretzels
$5.99
1.2 lbs.
Heggy’s Butterscotch Caramels
$12.65
1 lb.
Honey Mustard Pretzels
$5.49
1.6 lbs.
Hot Cajun Corn Sticks
$4.49
1.2 lbs.
Mikey’s Mix
$5.39
1.2 lbs.
Peanut Butter Pretzels
$5.49
1.6 lb.
Pineapple Tidbits
$5.99
1 lb. Price is per lb.
Pumpkin Seeds
$6.49
1 lb.
Rice Crackers
$4.99
1.2 lbs.
Roasted Peas
$4.49
1.2 lbs.
Sesame Sticks
$4.49
1 lb. Price is per lb. Available in plain, roasted pepper, honey mustard and onion, oat bran, honey, and garlic.
Sunflower Seeds
$3.49
Shelled. 1 lb.
Trail Mix
$5.59
1.2 lbs.
Wasabi Roasted Peas
$5.69
1.2 lb.
Yogurt Raisins
$3.99
1 lb.
Apple Butter Barbeque Sauce
$3.99
1.12 lbs.
Baby Beets
$7.49
3.2 lbs.
Baby Corn
$4.39
1.8 lbs.
Beet Eggs
$7.99
3.2 lbs.
Blueberry Yogurt Pretzels
$5.99
1 lb.
Chocolate Toffee Pretzels
$5.49
1 lb.
Chow Chow
$5.79
3.2 lbs. Green beans, water, kidney beans, cauliflower, wax beans, carrots, northern beans, corn, lima beans, celery, onions, red peppers, and pickles.
Corn Relish
$4.49
1.8 lbs.
Dark Chocolate Yogurt Pretzels
$8.99
1.6 lbs.
Dick’s Homemade Horseradish
$2.59
0.10 lb.
Hot Eggs
$7.99
3 lbs.
Hot Pickled Garlic
$5.99
1.8 lbs.
Milk Chocolate Covered Pretzels
$12.65
1.6 lbs.
Peanut Butter Yogurt Pretzels
$5.99
1.6 lbs.
Tonn’s Pure Clover Honey
$5.49
3 lbs.
Woeber’s Horseradish
$2.29
0.8 lbs.
Yogurt Pretzels
5.99
1.6 lbs.
$Jams and Jellies
Shisler’s Private Label Fig Jam
$4.99
2 lbs. Fig jam a sweet and delicious jam made from real figs.
Shisler’s Private Label Old Fashioned Apple Butter
$5.49
2 lbs. Old Fashioned Apple Butter. Made from the best locally grown apples and locally produced Amish butter.
Shisler’s Private Label Tomato Jam
$4.99
2 lbs.
Homestyle Jams
$3.49
1 lb. Cherry, blueberry, black raspberry, rhubarb, strawberry, red raspberry, strawberry rhubarb, peach, strawberry kiwi, apricot, blackberry, boysenberry, and elderberry jelly.
Hot Pepper Jelly
$3.19
1 lb.
Pumpkin Butter
$3.99
1 lb. Made from locally grown pumpkins and locally produced Amish butter.
Apple Butter
3.49
1 lb.
$Meats
Streb Meats Boneless Smoked Ham
$49.99
7 lbs. Fresh cut, fully cooked, and locally raised boneless smoked ham. history of Streb meats boneless smoked ham.
Streb Meats Fresh Cut Smoked Bacon
$7.99
1 lb. Price is per lb. weight may vary by up to 10%.
Streb Meats Fresh Smoked Sausage
$7.49
1.2 lb. Price is per lb. weight may vary by up to 10%.
Troyer’s Trail Bologna
$8.49
2 lbs. The price is for a 1 1/2 lb. ring.
Troyer’s Trail Bologna With Cheddar
$8.99
1.6 lbs.
Troyer’s Trail Bologna with Hot Pepper Cheese
$8.99
1.66 lbs.
Lebanon Bologna
$8.99
1 lb. 12 oz. Sliced.
Sweet Lebanon Bologna
$8.99
1 lb. 12 Oz. Sliced. Lebanon bologna is a type of cured, smoked, fermented, semi-dry sausage. The highest quality lean beef carefully ground and cured with aromatic spices.
Summer Sausage
$6.69
0.14 lbs.
Summer Sausage With Jalapeno and Cheddar
$5.99
0.14 lb.
Uncle Mike’s Beef Jerky
$12.99
1 lb.
Uncle Mike’s Beef Sticks
13.49
1.2 lbs. Price is per lb.
$Pickles and Peppers
Shisler’s Private Label Bread and Butter Pickles
$7.49
2.8 lbs.
Shisler’s Private Label Brine Pickles
$6.79
2.8 lbs.
Shisler’s Private Label Sweet Garlic Dill Pickles
$7.99
2.8 lbs.
Shisler’s Private Label Sweet Hot Habanero Pickles
$7.99
2.8 lbs.
Tony Packo’s Bread and Butter Pickles
$5.49
1.8 lbs.
Tony Packo’s Chunky Hot Peppers
$4.99
1.8 lbs. 16 oz. Jar.
Tony Packo’s Sweet Hot Skinnies
4.99
1.8 lbs. 16 oz. jar.
$Skinny Alternatives
Walden Farms Blueberry Fruit Spread
$4.49
1.8 lbs.
Walden Farms Grape Fruit Spread
$4.49
1 lb.
Walden Farms Strawberry Fruit Spread
$4.49
1 lb.
Walden Farms Calorie Free Blueberry Syrup
$4.69
1.8 lbs.
Walden Farms Calorie Free Chocolate Syrup
$4.69
1 lb.
Walden Farms Calorie Free Pancake Syrup
$4.69
1.8 lbs.
Walden Farms Calorie Free Strawberry Syrup
$4.69
1.8 lbs.
Walden Farms Calorie Free Caramel Dip
$4.69
1.8 lbs.
Walden Farms Calorie Free Chocolate Dip
$4.69
1.8 lbs.
Walden Farms Calorie Free Marshmallow Dip
$4.69
1.8 lb.
Calorie Free Bacon Ranch Salad Dressing
$4.49
1.8 lb.
Calorie Free Bacon Vegetable Dip
$3.99
1.8 lbs.
Calorie Free Bleu Cheese Dressing
$4.69
1 lb.
Calorie Free Coleslaw Salad Dressing
$4.49
1.8 lbs.
Calorie Free Honey Dijon Salad Dressing
$4.49
1.8 lbs.
Calorie Free Italian Sun Dried Tomato Dressing
$4.69
1 lb.
Calorie Free Ranch Dressing
$4.69
1 lb.
Calorie Free Raspberry Vinaigrette Dressing
4.69
1 lb.
$Uncategorized
Gift Box for Dad: Unique Fathers Day Gifts
$24.99
6 lbs. Troyer’s trail bologna ring, Ohio swiss cheese, pepper jack cheese, Shisler's private label mustard, Shisler's private label hot pepper relish, and carr’s crackers.
Shisler’s Private Label Quince Jelly
$5.09
2 lbs.
Streb Meats Fresh Cracklins’
$3.49
0.5 lb. Pork rinds, and chicharrones.
12 oz. Reach Coffee
$12.99
1.14 lbs. Specialty grade coffee from the region of chanchamayo, Peru. Roasted in Cleveland, Ohio.
Grandma’s Kitchen Hot Peppers
$11.49
2.8 lbs.
Grandma’s Kitchen Medium Peppers
$11.49
2.8 lbs.
Chocolate Covered Banana Chips
$5.99
1.6 lbs.
Menu for Shisler's Cheese House is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
Check Other Restaurant Menu
Pizza Hut
American, Pizza
Chicago's Fresh Sliced Sub's
American, Sandwiches, Wraps
Grand Valley House Of Pizza
American, Pizza
A&W Restaurant
American, American, Burgers, Hot Dogs, Ice Cream, Pub Food, Sandwiches
Domino's Pizza
American, Pizza, Wings
Subway
Sandwiches