Cookies
Banana Bread Cookie
$3.00
Everyone's favorite quick bread, made portable in cookie form! Bursting with ripe bananas, spices, and nuts, it'll be gone before you know it.
Chewy Cherry Almond Cookie
$3.00
A chewy cookie loaded with tart cherries and a smooth almond taste.
Chocolate Coffee Stout Cookie
$3.00
3 of our favorite things combined into one amazing cookie.
Malted Chocolate Chip Cookie
$3.00
Chocolate chip cookie meets everyone's favorite classic drink - a malt! Nutty barley comes through and provides a rich sweetness to everyone's favorite cookie.
Mexican Hot Chocolate Cookie
$3.00
We were inspired by Mexican hot chocolate during one of our baking sessions. This chocolate chocolate chip cookie has cayenne, cinnamon, and other spices for a unique treat.
Oatmeal Currant Cookie
$3.00
Our spin on a traditional oatmeal cookie, given a refreshing flavor with cardamom and orange zest.
Gluten Free Chocolate Chip Cookie
$3.50
We took our classic recipe and made it gluten free.
Gluten Free Coconut Cherry Cookie
$3.50
Coconut, tart cherries, and a hint of lime combined in 1 awesome cookie.
Harvest Cookie
$3.00
All the flavors of fall in 1 cookie. Chock full of dried cranberries, walnuts, sun flower seeds and a touch of cinnamon.
Eggnog Snickerdoodle
$3.00
A classic cookie meets a classic holiday drink. Rich buttery cookie and eggnog with nutmeg make this a new Christmas favorite. They won't be here long!
Iced Oatmeal
$3.00
A classic cookie, kept classic. Memories of waking up at grandma's house to fresh baked cookies aren't too far away once you take a bite.
Gingerbread Cardinals
$3.00
The Gingerbread Man's woodland friend. Our special gingerbread recipe, all dressed up to look like our mascot. They won't be here long!
Vegan/ GF Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip
$3.00
Our first foray into vegan baking, so tasty, we impressed ourselves. Is there a better marriage than peanut butter and chocolate? Now everyone can enjoy this classic combo.
Candy Cane Hot Chocolate
$3.00
A double chocolate cookie made with pure peppermint oil and real candy canes. Fireplace optional. They won't be here long!
Black and White
$3.00
New York's favorite cookie (or is it a cake?) However you split it, everybody wins with sweet vanilla and rich chocolate icing.
Vegan Oatmeal Walnut
$3.00
Walnuts, cinnamon, and oatmeal all come together under a sweet drizzle of icing. So good, you won't miss the butter and eggs!
Candy Bar Cookie
$3.00
Our newest cookie, loaded with Snickers, Twix, 3 Musketeers, and Milky Way Bars. Yum!
Vegan Chocolate Chip
$3.00
Everyone's favorite classic, made vegan!
Pumpkin Chocolate Chip
3.00
Warm pumpkin and spices pair nicely with semi-sweet chocolate in this soft, seasonal treat.
$Pies
Small S'mores Pie
$10.00
Homemade fluff, chocolate ganache, and graham crackers in our tasty pie crust. Our most popular pie right sized for 2 to share.
Large S'mores Pie
$21.00
Homemade fluff, chocolate ganache, and graham crackers in our tasty pie crust.
Small Bourbon Pecan Pie
$9.00
The perfect sized pecan pie to curl up next to the fireplace with. The perfect marriage of pecans and bourbon come together in this pie. Notes of vanilla, oak, and spices shine through to give this classic pie a little more personality.
Large Bourbon Pecan Pie
$20.00
The perfect marriage of pecans and bourbon come together in this pie. Notes of vanilla, oak, and spices shine through to give this classic pie a little more personality.
Small Spiced Dutch Apple Pie
$8.00
Apple pie with a buttery, crumbly crust on top; flavored with a blend of winter spices. They won't be here long!
Large Spiced Dutch Apple Pie
$19.00
Our large pie, perfect for sharing at the table this holiday. Warm spices and sweet apples will have everyone coming back for a second piece. They won't be here long!
Hand Pies
$2.00
Check out these hand sized pies in store. Flavors change every week.
Large Apple Blueberry Pie
$19.00
Apples and blueberries in our delicious pie crust.
Large Apple Dulce de Leche Pie
$19.00
An all-American classic; covered in sweet caramel dulce de leche goodness.
Large Blueberry Pie
$19.00
Tart blueberries, subtle lemon and ginger flavors come together under a crumble crust. Sweet perfection.
Large Cherry-Almond Pie
$20.00
Tart cherries, toasty almonds, under a pretty lattice crust! Here for the Summer.
Large Chocolate Walnut Chess Pie
$20.00
Creamy, chocolatey custard, hiding under crunchy, sweet, vanilla walnuts, makes this pie a sweet tooth's dream. Totally indulgent, totally delicious, totally worth every bite!
Large Coconut Raspberry Pie
$20.00
Creamy coconut custard, sweet raspberry jam, crunchy crumble, all together in a cookie-like pie crust. Only here for the Spring!!
Large Lemon Meringue
$20.00
Lemon lovers rejoice, there's plenty of mouth puckering goodness to be had with this full sized pie
Large Maple Pumpkin Pie
$20.00
A Thanksgiving must, brought to the next level with real maple syrup.
Large Peach Bourbon Pie
$20.00
We take peaches at the peak of the season and give them a nice bath in bourbon for this Summer favorite.
Large Peanut Butter and Jelly Pie
$20.00
Your favorite sandwich as a kid, now in a pie. Light and creamy peanut butter mousse is topped with a layer of sweet and tart strawberry preserves. Who needs bread when you have pie crust?
Large Traditional Apple Pie
$18.00
Pure, unadulterated, American pie. No twists here, just everybody's favorite dessert, here for the holidays.
Large Traditional Pecan Pie
$19.00
Nutty and sweet, a main stay for the dessert table around the holidays.
Large Traditional Pumpkin Pie
$19.00
A pie the pilgrims would be proud of (if they had pie).
Small Apple Blueberry Pie
$8.00
Our apple blueberry pie perfectly sized for you.
Small Apple Dulce de Leche Pie
$8.00
An all-American classic; covered in sweet caramel dulce de leche goodness.
Small Blueberry Pie
$8.00
Tart blueberries meet subtle ginger and lemon notes, all under a crumble crust. Spring is here!
Small Cherry-Almond Pie
$9.00
Tart cherries, toasty almonds, all under a pretty lattice crust! Here for the Summer.
Small Chocolate Walnut Chess Pie
$9.00
Creamy, chocolatey custard, hiding under crunchy, sweet, vanilla walnuts, makes this pie a sweet tooth's dream. Totally indulgent, totally delicious, totally worth every bite!
Small Coconut Raspberry Pie
$9.00
Creamy coconut custard, sweet raspberry jam, crunchy crumble, all together in a cookie-like pie crust. Only here for the Spring!!
Small Lemon Meringue
$9.00
Tart lemon and sweet meringue make this pie refreshingly simple and delicious.
Small Maple Pumpkin Pie
$9.00
Perfectly sized and a perfectly sweet spin on your holiday favorite.
Small Peach Bourbon Pie
$9.00
Our peach bourbon pie downsized to share.
Small Peanut Butter and Jelly Pie
$9.00
Your favorite sandwich as a kid, now in a pie. Light and creamy peanut butter mousse is topped with a layer of sweet and tart strawberry preserves. Who needs bread when you have pie crust?
Small Peppermint S'mores Pie
10.00
Everyone's favorite pie with a kick of peppermint for the holidays. Rich chocolate ganache, graham crackers, and a minty marshmallow top. They won't be here long!
$Brownies
Best Brownie
$4.00
Coconut Brownie
$4.50
Chocolate and coconut are a perfect match in this brownie.
Peanut Butter Brownie
$4.50
Our best brownie with swirls of peanut butter.
Walnut Brownie
$4.50
Our best brownie generously coated with walnuts.
Cookie Brownie
$4.50
Our best brownie with malted chocolate chip cookie dough baked right in the center.
Pecan Brownie
$4.50
Nut lovers have another brownie to obsess over! Rich chocolate and toasty pecans are a match made in heaven.
Mint Brownies
$4.50
Mint and chocolate; is there a more perfect pairing? Chocolate mint candies dot the tops of our most loved brownies. They won't be here long!
Chocolate Chip Brownie
$4.50
Our favorite brownie, even chocolatier with chocolate chips studded on top!
Almond Brownie
4.50
Nutty, chocolatey, and... gluten-free?? Yep, almond flour keeps this brownie fudgey and delicious!
$Cheesecakes
Original Cheesecake
$5.50
Our New York style cheesecake with a hint of lemon.
Pumpkin Cheesecake
$6.00
Our pumpkin cheesecake delivers with real pumpkin and a hint of your favorite fall spices.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cheesecake
$6.00
A perfect marriage of semi-sweet chocolate and natural peanut butter, swirled into our original cheesecake.
Nutella Cheesecake
$6.00
Everybody's favorite spread, swirled right in the middle.
Eggnog Cheesecake
6.00
Our cheesecake made with real eggnog! Sweet and tangy cheesecake gets a flavor hit with our gingersnap crust, touched with a hint of nutmeg. They won't be here long!
$Scones
Fresh baked, breakfast-y goodness.Lemon Cranberry Scone
$3.00
Our most popular scone, made with fresh lemon zest and tangy cranberries.
Scone of the Week
$3.00
Different flavors each week! Call for this week's flavor, or make it a surprise; we promise you won't be disappointed!
Menu for The Fat Cardinal Bakery is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
