Soft-Serve Classics
Add extras for an additional charge.Tahitian Vanilla Bean Frozen Yogurt
Our artisan vanilla soft-serve, made with simple, natural ingredients like real tahitian vanilla.
Chocolicious Frozen Yogurt
Classic and creamy chocolate frozen yogurt made with real cocoa.
Made with Nutella Frozen Yogurt
Chocolate-hazelnut frozen yogurt made with real Nutella swirled in.
Birthday Cake Frozen Yogurt
Our take on a classic cake batter ice cream.
Eurotart Frozen Yogurt
Our classic tart froyo flavor, because simple never tasted so good.
Peanut Butter Cup Frozen Yogurt
Like eating a Reese's peanut butter cup, except better
Cookies and Cream Ice Cream
Delicious, silky sweet cream folded full with real Oreo cookies makes what might be our best ice cream yet.
Aladdin "Triple Berry" Three Wishes Frozen Yogurt
16HandlesX Broadway! This is a combination of strawberries, blueberries, and blackberries inspired by Aladdin’ s three wishes!
Specialty Soft-Serve
Add extras for an additional charge.Mint Chocolate Chip Frozen Yogurt
One of our most popular specialties, a soft serve mint with bits of chocolate chips swirled in.
Salted Caramel Frozen Yogurt
$7.95
So sweet and caramel-ly!
Coffee Frozen Yogurt
Need a little umph? Or just craving the coffee taste? We've got you covered.
NY Cheesecake NSA Frozen Yogurt
Would it be a New York froyo shop without a classic cheesecake flavor? Except we've outdone ourselves, because this delicious-ness has no sugar added!
Strawberry Fields Frozen Yogurt
Our take on the classic strawberry ice cream, except its better because it's a 16 Handles froyo custom creation!
Cookie Dough Ice Cream (NEW!)
$7.95
You might say, “it’s just cookie dough†but this is not your ordinary cookie dough. We bring you a soft serve ice cream that is mouth-watering and your next new crave! We started with a creamy vanilla base, then folded in real and gooey chocolate chip cookies to make this custom, all natural, soft serve ice cream. Treat yo'self!
Ripe Raspberry NSA Frozen Yogurt
Indulge in the taste of real raspberries by the spoonful, swirled to perfection in this no sugar added fro-yo flavor!
Eggnog Frozen Yogurt
Vegan (Dairy Free) Soft-Serve and Sorbet
Add extras for an additional charge.So Fresh Mango Sorbetto
It tastes like a perfectly ripe mango, but it's smooth and creamy and frozen and just. Ahh! There's a reason this is a crowd favorite.
Oatly Vanilla
New from 16 handles and oatly! Vanilla oatmilk soft serve is inspired by the classic vanilla that we all we love and balanced with enough sweetness to make the ideal summer treat. Available exclusively at 16 Handles!
Watermelon Sorbet
$7.95
Strawberry Lemonade Sorbet
$7.95
Imagine yourself sitting by the pool with a ice cold glass of sweet and tangy strawberry lemonade. Except you're in your apartment, and the glass is actually a 16 Handles cup. Basically the same thing.
Pomegranate Raspberry Sorbet
Blue Raspberry Sorbet
Coco Loco
Oatly Chocolate Peppermint
NEW from 16 Handles and Oatly! Chocolate Peppermint soft serve is inspired by the classic chocolate that we all know and love, balanced with freshness of peppermint to make the ideal treat. Available exclusively at 16 Handles!
Cookie Dough by Do, Cookie Dough Confections
Peanut Butter Snickerdoodle Dough
$13.50
Peanut butter and cinnamon sugar and chocolate chips. Vegan and gluten-free. 8 oz. container.
Signature Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
$12.99
Do's most popular creation now stocked at 16 Handles! Signature chocolate chip made in 8 oz. container (note: this is not the vegan version).
Vegan Signature Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
$12.99
Signature chocolate chip made in vegan recipe. 8 oz. container.
Sugar Cookie Dough
$12.99
Sugar cookie dough topped with sugar sprinkles. 8 oz. container.
Cake Batter Cookie Dough
$12.99
Cake batter, white chocolate and milk chocolate chips with sprinkles. 8 oz. container.
Brookie Dough
$12.99
Signature chocolate chip and brownie batter swirled together. 8 oz. container.
Gimme S'more Cookie Dough
$12.99
Signature and Hershey bar and toasted marshmallows and Graham crackers. 8 oz. container.
Salty and Sweet Cookie Dough
12.99
Sugar cookie and salted caramel and dark chocolate chips and sea salt. 8 oz. container.
$Acai Bowls
Add extras for an additional charge.The OG Acai Bowl
$12.45
Organic Brazilian acai with coconut flakes, fresh strawberries and blueberries, and honey almond granola. Fresh honey drizzled on top.
Peanut Berry Acai Bowl
$12.45
Organic Brazilian acai with granola, fresh strawberries and blueberries, chopped peanuts, and creamy Reese's peanut butter.
Tropical Acai Bowl
$12.45
Organic Brazilian acai with coconut flakes, fresh strawberries and blueberries, and dark chocolate nibs.
The White Chocolate Acai Bowl
$12.45
Organic Brazilian acai with yogurt chips, granola, fresh blueberries, and mochi. White chocolate sauce drizzled on top.
The Superhero Acai Bowl
$12.45
Organic Brazilian acai with cookie dough bites, chocolate chips, fresh strawberries and honey almond granola. Creamy Nutella drizzled on top.
Custom Acai Bowl
12.45
Organic Brazilian acai plus your choice of toppings. Build your acai bowl exactly how you want it!
$Fro-Yo Milkshakes
Add extras for an additional charge.Cookies and Cream Shake
$8.95
Made with crushed Oreos.
Strawberry Shake
$8.95
Made with fresh strawberries - non-kosher.
Vanilla Shake
$8.95
A classic vanilla shake, but with a lower calorie twist as it's made with our premium and popular tahitian vanilla frozen yogurt!
Chocolate Shake
8.95
Made with Ghirardelli chocolate sauce.
$Bottled Drinks
16.9 oz. Bottled Water
$2.00
Spring water. Basic but literally keeps you alive, so that's good.
1 Liter Bottled Water
$3.00
1 liter-size spring water for when the thirst is really real.
Coca-Cola® 12 fl oz.
$3.99
Soda and ice cream is a thing - try it
Sprite® 12 fl oz.
$3.99
Soda and ice cream is a thing - try it
Honest Tea 16 oz. Organic Sweetened Lori's Lemon Iced Tea
$4.25
Keeps ya honest ;)
Honest Tea 16 oz. Organic Unsweetened "Just" Black Iced Tea
$4.25
Keeps ya honest ;)
Honest Tea 16 oz. Organic Unsweetened "Just" Green Iced Tea
$4.25
Keeps ya honest ;)
Nantucket Nectars 16 oz. Pressed Apple Juice
$3.99
For the 4 year old inside of you, it's apple juice!
Nantucket Nectars 16 oz. Premium Orange Juice
$3.99
OJ cures hangovers, and other stuff...
Boylan Bottling Co. Mash 20 oz. Grapefruit Citrus Zing Sparkling Fruit Beverage
$3.99
Grapefruit Citrus Zing ;)
Boylan Bottling Co. Mash 20 oz. Pineapple Coconut Sparkling Fruit Beverage
$3.99
Pineapple Coconut Sparkling is the employee fav if we're being real with you...
Boylan Bottling Co. Mash 20 oz. Pomegranate Blueberry Sparkling Fruit Beverage
$3.99
Pomegranate Blueberry Sparkling if that's what you're into I guess...
Boylan Bottling Co. Mash 20 oz. Watermelon Lemon Lime Sparkling Fruit Beverage
$3.99
Watermelon Lemon Lime Sparkling is actually as good as it sounds!
Diet Coca-Cola® 12 fl oz.
3.99
Soda and ice cream is a thing - try it!
$FAQ & Menu Info (Archived)
Is 16 Handles COVID safe?
Every single order is made with a FRESH pair of food-grade gloves by a healthy employee wearing a mask. Every surface in our store has been disinfected and sanitized. Every employee's health is being monitored, and while nobody has shown any symptoms, my employees know to stay home should they feel at all ill. Additionally, your delivery driver has been educated on contact-less delivery. My staff has undergone extensive training, we are following all CDC and Dept. of Health guideline, and we promise to go above and beyond for you.
Will my froyo melt if I order delivery?
No! We built an amazing “cold-chain†to make sure your delivery gets to you quickly and still as delicious as if you were in our store! We aren’t delivering frozen pints like the other guys; 16 Handles serves freshly swirled soft serve that will melt in your mouth! In rain or inclement weather, we may experience delays but don’t worry, you order is safe in our flash freezer until the moment the driver leaves to bring it to your door. Stay cozy at home and leave the details to us!
Are you Kosher / Gluten Free / Fat Free / NSA / Vegan?
All soft serve flavors are certified kosher (and so are nearly all topping unless labeled otherwise)! Additionally, Rabbi Zev Schwartz of IKC has certified our store and food handling procedures safe and kosher. Nearly all of our flavors our all natural, and we have a vegan oat milk lineup of flavors that contain no corn syrup and are dairy free, gluten free, and fat free. Many other flavors are low fat or fat free, and we usually have at least one No Sugar Added flavor in our Specialties section.
How many toppings should I get?
That’s up to you! All toppings come in individual cups on the side. We recommend adding at least a few toppings and/or sauces to each order for the ultimate experience. You can get any topping in 2, 4, 6, and 8 ounces!
What is Frozen Yogurt vs Ice Cream?
While we serve both frozen yogurt and ice cream at 16 Handles, frozen yogurt generally contains less calories, fats, and carbs then ice cream. It’s also full of gut-healthy pro-biotics, just like real yogurt! Being a healthier dessert options doesn’t mean we’ve sacrificed the taste; our custom flavors are the best out there! Only the Original Tart flavor will have the same tart taste as natural yogurt, while the others will taste like a soft serve ice cream (or fruity sorbet). And our Ice Cream flavors, which contain more creamy milk fat, are a delicious treat for your cheat day!
Can I swirl multiple flavors?
Sure, you can put the request of your second flavor choice in the special instructions. There’s no guarantee we can make swirls, depending on supply, but we'll try our best!
Smoothies (Archived)
BFF Smoothie
$8.95
Strawberries and bananas
Tropic Thunder Smoothie
$8.95
Pineapple and mango
Brr Berry Smoothie
$8.95
Strawberries, blueberries and raspberries
Surf's Up Smoothie
$8.95
Strawberries and pineapple
Oh Kale Yeah! Smoothie
$8.95
Pineapple, bananas, kale and spinach
Acai Elixir Smoothie
$8.95
Strawberries, blueberries, and acai berries + guarana
Menu for 16 Handles Frozen Yogurt & Ice Cream is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
Check Other Restaurant Menu
Empanada Cart
Other, South American
Bar Belly
Cocktails, Seafood
83 ½
Italian
Maslow 6
Alcohol, American (New), Tapas
Loopy Doopy Rooftop Bar
Cocktails, Mediterranean, Tapas
.png)
Broadway Lounge
American (New), Bar Food, Cocktails
Astor Row Cafe
Coffee & Tea
Bassanova Ramen
Japanese, Noodles
Eight Turn Crepe
Coffee & Tea, Crepes, Desserts
Ootoya Times Square
Japanese, Sushi
Jersey Mike's Subs
Sandwiches
Moo Shu Grill
Chinese