Potbelly Sandwich Shop Sandwiches

Potbelly Sandwich Shop Menu

(646) 289-4207
366 5th Ave, New York, NY 10001
$$$$$

Sandwiches


BLTA
$8.69-10.69
Applewood smoked bacon, fresh-sliced avocado, mayo, lettuce and tomato, on perfectly toasted bread
Turkey Club
$9.28-11.28
All-natural, hand-pulled, slow-roasted turkey with bacon and cheddar cheese toasted and then topped with fresh lettuce, tomato and mayo on multigrain
Grilled Chicken
$7.69-9.69
All-natural chicken breast hand-sliced with melted cheddar cheese toasted and then topped with fresh lettuce, tomato and mayo on multigrain
A Wreck®
$7.69-9.69
Our signature sandwich! Salami, Angus roast beef, oven roasted turkey, hickory smoked ham with melted Swiss cheese toasted and then topped with fresh lettuce, tomato and mayo on multigrain
Turkey Breast
$7.29-9.29
Hand-sliced turkey breast with melted Swiss cheese toasted and then topped with fresh lettuce, tomato and mayo on multigrain
Italian
$7.69-9.69
Authentic capicola, pepperoni, salami and mortadella (or smoked ham depending on availability) with provolone cheese toasted and then topped with fresh lettuce, tomato, mayo and Italian seasoning on multigrain
Mediterranean
$7.69-9.69
Zippy hummus and feta cheese toasted and then topped with artichoke hearts, crisp cucumbers and roasted red peppers on multigrain
Mediterranean Chicken
$8.69-10.69
All-natural chicken breast with zippy hummus and feta cheese, toasted and then topped with artichoke hearts, crisp cucumbers and roasted red peppers on multigrain
PB & J
$6.55-8.55
Creamy peanut butter toasted and then topped with grape jelly on multigrain
Smoked Ham
$7.29-9.29
Hand-sliced hickory smoked ham with Swiss cheese toasted and then topped with fresh lettuce, tomato and mayo on multigrain
Roast Beef
$7.29-9.29
Thin-sliced Angus roast beef with provolone cheese toasted and then topped with fresh lettuce, tomato and mayo on multigrain
Chicken Salad
$7.29-9.29
Freshly made chicken salad with just the right amount of celery, mayo and pepper topped with melted provolone cheese toasted and then topped with fresh lettuce and tomato on multigrain
Tuna Salad
$7.29-9.29
100% Albacore tuna with Swiss cheese toasted and then topped with fresh lettuce and tomato on multigrain
Meatball
$7.69-9.69
Meatballs with just the right amount of marinara sauce and melted provolone cheese toasted on multigrain
Pizza Sandwich
$7.69-9.69
Pizza the Potbelly Way! Pepperoni, meatball, capicola, marinara sauce, melted provolone cheese, mushrooms toasted and then topped with Italian seasoning on multigrain
Clubby
$8.64-10.64
Hand-sliced turkey breast, hickory smoked ham and bacon topped with melted provolone cheese toasted and then topped with fresh lettuce, tomato and buttermilk ranch dressing on multigrain
Grilled Cheese
$7.29-9.29
Melted cheddar toasted to perfection on multigrain
Vegetarian
7.29-9.29
Cheddar, provolone, swiss and mushrooms toasted and then topped with mayo, lettuce and tomatoes on multigrain

$Salads


Farmhouse
$9.39-8.39
All-natural grilled chicken breast, hard-boiled egg, bacon, crumbled blue cheese, grape tomatoes, crisp cucumbers and diced red onion served on a bed of field greens
Powerhouse
$9.39-8.39
All-natural grilled chicken breast, fresh avocado, zippy hummus, hard-boiled egg, crisp cucumber and grape tomatoes served on a bed of field greens
Mediterranean
$9.39-8.39
All-natural grilled chicken breast, artichoke hearts, chickpeas, roasted red peppers, crisp cucumbers, diced red onion, tomatoes, crumbled feta cheese and Italian seasoning served on a bed of field greens
Chicken Salad Salad
$9.39-0.00
Freshly made chicken salad, provolone cheese, dried cranberries, crisp cucumbers and grape tomatoes served on a bed of field greens
A Wreck® Salad
9.39-0.00
Hand-sliced turkey breast, hickory smoked ham, salami, Angus roast beef, Swiss and crumbled blue cheese, hard-boiled egg, crisp cucumbers and grape tomatoes served on a bed of field greens

$Pick-your-Pair


Pick-your-Pair Sandwich + Soup
$9.50
Choose a half portion of your favorite sandwich plus a cup of soup or chili
Pick-your-Pair Sandwich + Salad
$9.50
Choose half portions of your favorite sandwich and salad
Pick-your-Pair Sandwich + Mac
$9.50
Choose a half portion of your favorite sandwich plus a cup of mac & cheese
Pick-your-Pair Salad + Soup
$9.50
Choose a half portion of your favorite salad plus a cup of soup or chili
Pick-your-Pair Salad + Mac
9.50
Choose a half portion of your favorite salad plus a cup of mac & cheese

$Potbelly Pantry


Potbelly Pantry
Now you can stock up on your favorite Potbelly ingredients and staples, safely and conveniently delivered to your door. Perfect for cooking up your own Potbelly sandwich creation at home, or keeping the fridge stocked with essentials.
Bake-Your-Own Cookies - Single Type (12 Count)
$13.99
Made-for-your-oven cookie dough to bake our famous oversized cookies. Choose between Oatmeal Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Brownie or Sugar Cookies (Bake at 375° for 12-14 minutes). Please don't eat raw.
Bake-Your-Own Cookies - Variety (12 Count)
$13.99
Made-for-your-oven cookie dough to bake our famous oversized cookies. Contains 4 of each: Oatmeal Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Brownie and Sugar Cookie (Bake at 375° for 12-14 minutes). Please don't eat raw.
Bag of Mini Cookies
$4.70
Dozen mini oatmeal chocolate chip cookies
Shortbread Cookies (14oz)
$8.99
We top every Potbelly shake with one of these cookies. Now you can snack on them at home!
A Wreck® Meats (6-pack)
$9.99
Six stacks of turkey breast, smoked ham, angus roast beef and salami to create your very own Wreck sandwich at home
Nueske's® Applewood Smoked Bacon (18 slices)
$13.99
18 slices of cook-at-home applewood smoked bacon rubbed with tellicherry peppercorn. Cook before eating.
Grilled Chicken (1lb)
$6.99
All-natural grilled chicken breast
Turkey Breast (1lb)
$6.99
Hand-sliced in shop daily
Smoked Ham (1lb)
$6.99
Hand-sliced in shop daily
Salami (1lb)
$6.99
Classic genoa salami
Pepperoni (1lb)
$6.99
Perfect for pizzas, sandwiches, or pizza sandwiches
Capicola (1lb)
$6.99
A spicy old-world Italian favorite and charcuterie classic
Mortadella (1lb)
$6.99
The original bologna, seasoned with black peppercorns
Tuna Salad (1lb)
$6.99
Made with 100% Albacore tuna, just like in our Tuna Salad Sandwich
Chicken Salad (1lb)
$6.99
Freshly made with just the right amount of celery, mayo and pepper, just like in our Chicken Salad Sandwich
Swiss Cheese (10 oz)
$4.49
Provolone Cheese (10 oz)
$4.49
Cheddar Cheese (10 oz)
$4.49
Bread (6-pack)
$3.99
Potbelly's secret, designed to be toasted. Treat like an artisan roll -- use or freeze within 24 hours. (Add meat and cheese then toast at 375° for 3-5 minutes)
Flats Bread (12 per pack)
$3.99
Crisp flatbread, designed to be toasted. Treat like an artisan roll -- use or freeze within 24 hours. (Add meat and cheese then toast at 375° for 3-5 minutes)
Potbelly Mayo (8 oz)
$2.39
8 oz container
Potbelly Mustard (8 oz)
$2.39
8 oz container
Potbelly Hummus (8oz)
$3.99
8 oz container
Hot Peppers (16 oz Jar)
$6.95
Our famous blend of spicy giardiniera hot peppers
Hot Peppers (1 Gallon)
$19.99
A superfan-sized tub of our famous giardiniera hot peppers
Bucket-O-Pickles (5 Gallons)
$49.99
Literally a giant bucket full of 45-55 whole dill pickles
Zapp's Regular Chips
$1.55
Zapp's Salt & Vinegar Chips
$1.55
Baked Lay's
$1.55
Lay's Classic
$1.55
Zapp's Hotter 'N Hot Jalapeño Chips
$1.55
Coke (6-Pack)
$9.99
20 oz bottles
Diet Coke (6-Pack)
$9.99
20 oz bottles
Sprite (6-Pack)
$9.99
20 oz bottles
Coke Zero Sugar (6-Pack)
$9.99
20 oz bottles
Cherry Coke (6-Pack)
$9.99
20 oz bottles
Smartwater (6-Pack)
$12.99
20 oz bottles
San Pellegrino (6-Pack)
$12.99
16.9 oz bottles
Honest Organic Honey Green Tea (6-Pack)
$12.99
16.9 oz bottles
Vitamin Water XXX Acai Blue Pom (6-Pack)
$12.99
20 oz bottles
Vitamin Water Squeezed Lemonade (6-Pack)
$12.99
20 oz bottles
IBC Root Beer (6-Pack)
$9.99
12 oz bottles
IBC Cream Soda (6-Pack)
$9.99
12 oz bottles
Crush (6-Pack)
$9.99
12 oz bottles
Bottled Water (6-Pack)
$6.99
16 oz bottles
Nantucket Nectars Lemonade (6-Pack)
$12.99
16 oz bottles
Nantucket Nectars Orange Mango (6-Pack)
$12.99
16 oz bottles
Diet Snapple Half & Half (6-Pack)
12.99
16 oz bottles

$Mac & Soups


Craft Your Own Mac & Cheese
$5.19-7.19
Creamy, three-cheese mac and cheese with your choice of 2 premium toppings including bacon, chili, Potbelly hot peppers, mushrooms or roasted red peppers
Chicken Pot Pie Soup
$4.29-6.19
Tender, slow-roasted chicken breast and delicious veggies with a flaky crumb topping
Chili
$4.29-6.19
Hearty beef chili with kidney beans, bell peppers and onions
Broccoli Cheddar
$4.09-5.89
Creamy cheese soup with tender pieces of broccoli and carrots
Chicken Enchilada
$4.09-5.89
All-natural chicken breast, sweet corn and tangy peppers in a slightly spicy broth
Garden Vegetable
$4.09-5.89
Beans, carrots, celery, corn, mushrooms, onions, peppers, potatoes and zucchini in a light tomato broth
Loaded Baked Potato
$4.09-5.89
Hearty potato soup with bacon, cheddar cheese and green onion
Classic Tomato
4.09-5.89
Rich, classic tomato soup with basil

$Sides & Chips


Zapp's Regular Chips
$1.55
Zapp's Salt & Vinegar Chips
$1.55
Baked Lay's
$1.55
Lay's Classic
$1.55
Doritos Cool Ranch
$1.55
Doritos Nacho Cheese
$1.55
Zapp's Hotter 'N Hot Jalapeño Chips
$1.55
Zapp's Mesquite Bar-B-Que Chips
$1.55
Zapp's VooDoo Heat Chips
$1.55
Sun Chips Harvest Cheddar
$1.55
Potbelly Whole Pickle
1.15

$Desserts & Shakes

Shakes include a crunchy butter cookie on a straw.
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie
$1.99
A Potbelly favorite! Freshly baked oatmeal chocolate chip cookie
Sugar Cookie
$1.99
Freshly baked sugar cookie
Chocolate Brownie Cookie
$1.99
Freshly baked chocolate brownie cookie
Dream Bar
$2.10
Rich, chocolatey oatmeal bar with sweet caramel
Bag of Mini Cookies
$4.70
Dozen mini oatmeal chocolate chip cookies
Ice Cream Sandwich
$3.35
Hand scooped vanilla ice cream, sandwiched between two freshly baked oatmeal chocolate chip cookies
Chocolate Topped Shake
$4.29-3.19
Hand-dipped chocolate milkshake topped with whipped cream and a maraschino cherry
Vanilla Topped Shake
$4.29-3.19
Hand-dipped vanilla milkshake topped with whipped cream and a maraschino cherry
Coffee Topped Shake
$4.29-3.19
Hand-dipped coffee milkshake topped with whipped cream and a maraschino cherry
OREO® Cookie Topped Shake
$4.29-3.19
Hand-dipped OREO® Cookie milkshake topped with whipped cream and a maraschino cherry. OREO is a trademark of Mondelez International group, used under license.
Banana Topped Shake
$4.29-3.19
Hand-dipped banana milkshake topped with whipped cream and a maraschino cherry
Mixed Berry Topped Shake
$4.29-3.19
Hand-dipped mixed berry milkshake topped with whipped cream and a maraschino cherry
Strawberry Topped Shake
$4.29-3.19
Hand-dipped strawberry milkshake topped with whipped cream and a maraschino cherry
Chocolate Topped Smoothie
$4.29-3.19
Chocolate smoothie with low-fat frozen yogurt topped with whipped cream and a maraschino cherry
Vanilla Topped Smoothie
$4.29-3.19
Vanilla smoothie with low-fat frozen yogurt topped with whipped cream and a maraschino cherry
Coffee Topped Smoothie
$4.29-3.19
Coffee smoothie with low-fat frozen yogurt topped with whipped cream and a maraschino cherry
OREO® Cookie Topped Smoothie
$4.29-3.19
OREO® Cookie smoothie with low-fat frozen yogurt topped with whipped cream and a maraschino cherry. OREO is a trademark of Mondelez International group, used under license.
Banana Topped Smoothie
$4.29-3.19
Banana smoothie with low-fat frozen yogurt topped with whipped cream and a maraschino cherry
Mixed Berry Topped Smoothie
$4.29-3.19
Mixed berry smoothie with low-fat frozen yogurt topped with whipped cream and a maraschino cherry
Strawberry Topped Smoothie
4.29-3.19
Strawberry smoothie with low-fat frozen yogurt topped with whipped cream and a maraschino cherry

$Drinks


Coke
$2.39
20 oz. Bottle
Diet Coke
$2.39
20 oz. Bottle
Sprite
$2.39
20 oz. Bottle
Coke Zero Sugar
$2.39
20 oz. Bottle
Cherry Coke
$2.39
20 oz. Bottle
Honest Organic Honey Green Tea
$2.69
16.9 oz. Bottle
Vitamin Water XXX Acai Blue Pom
$2.79
20 oz. Bottle
Vitamin Water Squeezed Lemonade
$2.79
20 oz. Bottle
Powerade Mountain Berry Blast
$2.69
20 oz. Bottle
Smartwater
$2.99
20 oz. Bottle
Bottled Water
$2.10-2.59
16 oz./ 25 oz. Bottle
Arizona Tea
$2.49
16 oz. Bottle
Crush
$2.29
12 oz. Bottle
Diet Snapple Half & Half
$2.69
16 oz. Bottle
IBC Root Beer
$2.49
12 oz. Bottle
IBC Cream Soda
$2.49
12 oz. Bottle
Nantucket Nectars Lemonade
$2.69
16 oz. Bottle
Nantucket Nectars Orange Mango
$2.69
16 oz. Bottle
San Pellegrino
$2.59
16.9 oz. Bottle
San Pellegrino Blood Orange
$2.39
11.5 oz Can

Menu for Potbelly Sandwich Shop is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

Check Other Restaurant Menu

New Ivoire Food
New Ivoire

African

Chopt Creative Salad Co. Food
Chopt Creative Salad Co.

Salads, Sandwiches

Pitopia Food
Pitopia

Mediterranean, Vegetarian

Pierre Loti Wine Bar Food
Pierre Loti Wine Bar

Alcohol, Mediterranean, Tapas

Pick A Bagel Food
Pick A Bagel

Bagels, Deli Food, Sandwiches

Perfect Picnic Food
Perfect Picnic

Sandwiches