Pick a Bagel Bagels

Pick a Bagel Menu

(212) 582-8333
891 8th Ave, New York, NY 10019
$$$$$

Beverages


Hot Coffee
$0.00-0.00
Hot Tea
$0.00-0.00
Hot Cocoa
$2.35-2.95
Cappuccino
$0.00-0.00
Latte
$0.00-0.00
Cafe Mocha
$4.00-5.00
Americano
$3.65-4.40
Iced Coffee
$0.00-0.00
Iced Tea
$0.00-0.00
Iced Espresso
$3.65-4.25
Iced Cappuccino
$0.00-0.00
Iced Latte
$0.00-0.00
Iced Mocha
$5.00-5.75
Soda
$2.50
Tropicana
$3.00-5.75
Fresh Squeezed Juice
$4.75
Snapple
$2.50
Gatorade
$2.50
Naked Juice
$4.95
Red Bull
$3.75
Poland Spring Water
$3.65-4.40
Nesquik
2.75
Chocolate

$All Natural Smoothie Bar


Small Smoothie
$6.00
Large Smoothie
7.00

$Frozen Creamy Blended Frappe


Small Frozen Blended Frappuccino (Coffee Flavored)
$6.50
Large Frozen Blended Frappuccino (Coffee Flavored)
7.50

$Hot Breakfast


Egg Sandwich
$4.75
Scrambled Egg Platter
$7.25
One of Each
$7.95
One Egg, One Pancake, One Sausage Patty, One Bacon Strip.
Two of Each
$10.50
2 Eggs, 2 Pancakes, 2 Sausage Patties, 2 Bacon Strips.
2 Cinnamon Pancakes
$7.25
2 Eggs & 2 Pancakes
$9.25
Veggie Omelette
$10.25
Mushrooms, broccoli, and bell peppers. Served with a bagel, butter, and home fries.
Western Omelette
$10.25
Ham, peppers, and onions. Served with a bagel, butter, and home fries.
Greek Omelette
$10.25
Spinach, Kalamata olives, tomatoes, and feta. Served with a bagel, butter, and home fries.
Spanish Omelette
$10.25
Onions, bell peppers, and tomatoes. Served with a bagel, butter, and home fries.
3 Cheese Omelette
$10.25
American, cheddar, and Swiss cheeses. Served with a bagel, butter, and home fries.
The New Yorker
$13.25
Smoked salmon and Bermuda onions. Served with a bagel, butter, and home fries.
Oatmeal
$4.75-5.75
Whole Fruit
1.25-1.00

$Bagels


One Bagel
$1.50
One Flagel
$1.95
New York Baker's Dozen Bagels
18.00
Please specify how many of each you want in the special instructions box.

$Muffins & Pastries


Regular Muffin
$3.75
Filled Croissant
$3.75
Danishes
$3.75
Jumbo Cookies
$3.35
Loaf Cake
$3.75
Plain Croissant
$3.50
Cupcake
4.95

$Cream Cheese Spreads on a Bagel


Avocado Toast
$4.95
Bagel with Butter
$2.95
Peanut Butter Sandwich
$4.25
Plain Cream Cheese Sandwich
$4.25
Scallion Cream Cheese Sandwich
$4.75
Strawberry Cream Cheese Sandwich
$4.75
Sun Dried Tomato Cream Cheese Sandwich
$4.75
Vegetable Cream Cheese Sandwich
$4.75
Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese Sandwich
$4.75
Olive Cream Cheese Sandwich
$4.75
Low Fat Plain Cream Cheese Sandwich
$4.75
Low Fat Vegetable Cream Cheese Sandwich
$4.75
Tofu Cream Cheese Sandwich
$4.25
Tofu Scallion Cream Cheese Sandwich
$4.75
Tofu Vegetable Cream Cheese Sandwic
$4.75
Lox Spread Cream Cheese Sandwich
$6.50
Low-Fat Lox Spread Cream Cheese Sandwich
$6.50
Jalapeno & Cilantro Cream Cheese
4.75

$Salad Sandwiches


Egg Salad Sandwich
$7.95
Chicken Salad Sandwich
$9.95
Low-Fat Chicken Salad Sandwich
$9.95
Tuna Salad Sandwich
$9.95
Vegetarian Tuna Salad Sandwich
$9.95
No mayo.
Low-Fat Tuna Salad Sandwich
9.95

$Salad Platters


Egg Salad Platter
$10.95
Served with a bagel, lettuce, sliced tomato, cucumber, Bermuda onions, and coleslaw.
Chicken Salad Platter
$12.15
Served with a bagel, lettuce, sliced tomato, cucumber, Bermuda onions, and coleslaw.
Low-Fat Chicken Salad Platter
$12.15
Served with a bagel, lettuce, sliced tomato, cucumber, Bermuda onions, and coleslaw.
Tuna Salad Platter
$12.15
Served with a bagel, lettuce, sliced tomato, cucumber, Bermuda onions, and coleslaw.
Vegetarian Tuna Salad Platter
$12.15
Served with a bagel, lettuce, sliced tomato, cucumber, Bermuda onions, and coleslaw.
Low-Fat Tuna Salad Platter
12.15
Served with a bagel, lettuce, sliced tomato, cucumber, Bermuda onions, and coleslaw.

$Smoked Fish & Appetizing


White Fish Salad Sandwich
$11.95
White Fish Salad Platter
$14.45
Served with bagel, cream cheese, cucumbers, lettuce, tomato, and onions.
Baked Salmon Salad Sandwich
$11.95
Baked Salmon Salad Platter
$14.45
Served with bagel, cream cheese, cucumbers, lettuce, tomato, and onions.
Jumbo Shrimp Salad Sandwich
$13.00
Jumbo Shrimp Salad Platter
$15.00
Served with bagel, cream cheese, cucumbers, lettuce, tomato, and onions.
Nova Scotia Salmon Sandwich
$12.95
Nova Scotia Salmon Platter
$15.95
Served with bagel, cream cheese, cucumbers, lettuce, tomato, and onions.
Smoked Fish Combination Platter
29.95
Includes all 4 of the above. Served with bagel, cream cheese, cucumbers, lettuce, tomato, and onions.

$Deli Meat Sandwiches


BLT Sandwich
$7.25
Black Forest Ham Sandwich
$9.25
Genoa Salami Sandwich
$9.25
Oven Roasted Turkey Breast Sandwich
$9.25
Honey Glazed Turkey Sandwich
$9.25
Smoked Turkey Breast Sandwich
$9.25
Roast Beef Sandwich
$9.25
Corned Beef Sandwich
$9.25
Pastrami Sandwich
$9.25
Breaded Chicken Cutlet Sandwich
$9.25
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
9.25

$Sliced Cheese Sandwiches


American Cheese Sandwich
$6.95
Muenster Cheese Sandwich
$6.95
Cheddar Cheese Sandwich
$6.95
Swiss Cheese Sandwich
$6.95
Provolone Cheese Sandwich
$6.95
Pepper Jack Cheese Sandwich
$6.95
Fresh Mozzarella Cheese Sandwich
6.95

$Supreme Sandwiches


Supreme Pastrami
$11.95
Hot pastrami, melted swiss cheese, spicy mustard, garlic aioli. Recommended on seeded rye.
Supreme Reuben
$11.95
Hot corned beef, sauerkraut, melted muenster, spicy mustard. Recommended on seeded rye.
Supreme Turkey Club
$11.95
Smoked turkey, Indiana bacon, greens, beefsteak tomatoes, light mayo. Recommended on country sourdough.
Supreme Russian
$11.95
Hot roast beef, sharp cheddar, onions, greens, beefsteak tomatoes, Russian dressing. Recommended on a sesame bagel.
Supreme Italian Combo
$11.95
Salami, ham, provolone cheese, greens, tomatoes, garlic aioli. Recommended on a rustic square.
Supreme Tuscan Turkey
$11.95
Oven roasted turkey, artichoke, tomatoes, greens, chipotle mayo. Recommended on ciabatta.
Supreme Pesto Chicken
$11.95
Grilled roasted chicken, roasted tomatoes, melted fresh mozzarella, basil pesto spread. Recommended on ciabatta.
Supreme Ham and Cheese
$11.95
Black Forest ham, Jarlsberg Swiss cheese, plum tomatoes, romaine lettuce & garlic aioli. Recommended on country sourdough.
Supreme Grilled Chicken Club
$11.95
Grilled chicken, smoked bacon, romaine lettuce, plum tomatoes, & creamy herbed mayonnaise. Recommended on rustic square.
Supreme Cali Turkey Special
$11.95
Smoked turkey, avocado, Swiss cheese, crispy bacon, romaine lettuce, tomato, mayo & drizzled EVOO.
Supreme Chicken Salad
$11.95
Oven roasted chicken breast, crispy bacon, Swiss cheese, mixed baby greens, & light mayonnaise. Recommended on rustic square.
Supreme Hell's Kitchen
$11.95
Black Forest ham, honey glazed turkey, Jarlsberg Swiss cheese, Vermont cheddar cheese, romaine lettuce & honey Dijon spread. Recommended on sesame bagel.
Supreme Tuna Melt
$11.95
Home-style tuna salad, melted Vermont cheddar, mixed baby greens, & plum tomato. Recommended on hearty multi-grain bread.
Supreme Veggie Lover
$11.95
Portobello mushrooms, avocado, sprouts, plum tomatoes, fresh goat cheese & creamy balsamic vinaigrette. Recommended on plain bagel.
Supreme Farmer's Egg Salad
$11.95
Homemade egg salad, romaine lettuce, plum tomatoes, kosher salt, & cracked black pepper. Recommended on an everything bagel.
Supreme Fresh Mozzarella
11.95
Fresh made mozzarella, plum tomatoes, roasted red peppers & basil pesto spread. Recommended on rustic square.

$Chef Designed Chopped Salads or Wraps


Santa Fe Salad
$10.25
Chopped Romaine lettuce tossed together with roasted turkey, avocado, tomato, pepper jack cheese, Bermuda onions, and crunchy tri-color tortilla chips with a tangy chipotle lime vinaigrette.
Santa Fe Wrap
$9.50
Chopped Romaine lettuce tossed together with roasted turkey, avocado, tomato, pepper jack cheese, Bermuda onions, and crunchy tri-color tortilla chips with a tangy chipotle lime vinaigrette.
Taste of Greece Salad
$10.25
Grilled chicken, onions, tomato, cucumber, Feta cheese, Kalamata olives & kale lettuce. Chopped and tossed with a creamy garlic Caesar dressing.
Taste of Greece Wrap
$9.50
Same as an Taste Of Greece Salad but rolled into a whole wheat wrap.
California Cobb Salad
$10.25
Grilled chicken, blue cheese, alfalfa sprouts, tomato, cucumber, egg whites and baby mixed greens. Chopped & tossed with a creamy low-fat balsamic vinaigrette dressing.
California Cobb Wrap
$9.50
Same as a Cali Cobb chopped salad but rolled into a whole wheat wrap.
Asian Chop Salad
$10.25
Sesame chicken, Mandarin oranges, carrots, onions, sliced almonds, Chinese noodles and baby green lettuce. Chopped & tossed with an Asian sesame ginger dressing.
Asian Chop Wrap
$9.50
Same as Asian Chopped Salad but rolled up into a whole wheat wrap.
Adobe Mexicano Salad
$10.25
Grilled Chicken, Smoked Bacon, Kidney Beans, Crispy Tortillas, Pepper Jack Cheese, Jalapenos & Baby Spinach Leaves. Tossed w/ Tangy Chipolte Lime Dressing.
Adobe Mexicano Wrap
$9.50
Grilled Chicken, Smoked Bacon, Kidney Beans, Crispy Tortillas, Pepper Jack Cheese, Jalapenos & Baby Spinach Leaves. Tossed w/ Tangy Chipolte Dressing.
Classic Caesar Salad
$10.25
Romaine lettuce with grilled chicken, pecornio Romano, kalamata olives, croutons, hard boiled egg and creamy garlic Caesar dressing.
Classic Caesar Wrap
$8.75
Romaine lettuce with grilled chicken, pecornio Romano, kalamata olives, croutons, hard boiled egg and creamy garlic Caesar dressing.
South Beach Salad
$10.25
Smoked Turkey, avocado, tomato, cucumber, Swiss Cheese. Chopped and tossed together with Romaine lettuce & Low-fat Peppercorn Dressing.
South Beach Wrap
9.50
Same as South Beach chopped salad but rolled into a whole wheat wrap.

$Create-Your-Own-Salad


Create Your Own Salad
0.00-0.00
Choose up to five toppings and 1 protein

$Spreads By The Lb.


Butter by Weight
$3.25-13.00
Peanut Butter by Weight
$3.95-15.80
Plain Cream Cheese by Weight
$3.95-15.80
Scallion Cream Cheese by Weight
$4.50-18.00
Strawberry Cream Cheese by Weight
$4.50-18.00
Sun Dried Tomato Cream Cheese by Weight
$4.50-18.00
Vegetable Cream Cheese by Weight
$4.50-18.00
Walnut & Raisin Cream Cheese by Weight
$4.50-18.00
Olive Cream Cheese by Weight
$4.50-18.00
Low-Fat Cream Cheese by Weight
$4.50-18.00
Low-Fat Vegetable Cream Cheese by Weight
$4.50-18.00
1/4 lb. Tofu Cream Cheese
$4.25
Tofu Scallion Cream Cheese by Weight
$4.50-18.00
Tofu Vegetable Cream Cheese by Weight
$4.50-18.00
Lox Cream Cheese by Weight
$5.75-23.00
Low-Fat Lox Cream Cheese by Weight
$5.75-23.00
Fat-Free Cream Cheese
$3.75-15.00
Jalapeno Cilantro Cream Cheese
4.50-18.00

$Salads By The Lb.


1/4 lb. Egg Salad
$4.00
1/4 lb. Chicken Salad
$5.50
1/4 lb. Low Fat Chicken Salad
$5.50
1/4 lb. Tuna Salad
$5.50
1/4 lb. Vegetarian Tuna Salad
$5.50
1/4 lb. Low-Fat Tuna Salad
5.50

$Meats By The Lb.


1/4 lb. Black Forest Ham
$6.75
1/4 lb. Genoa Salami
$6.75
1/4 lb. Oven Gold Turkey Breast
$6.75
1/4 lb. Honey Glazed Turkey
$6.75
1/4 lb. Smoked Turkey Breast
$6.75
1/4 lb. Roast Beef
$6.75
1/4 lb. Corned Beef
$6.75
1/4 lb. Pastrami
$6.75
1/4 lb. Grilled Chicken
$6.75
1/4 lb. Breaded Chicken
6.75

$Smoked Fish By The Lb.


1/4 lb. White Fish Salad
$8.50
1/4 lb. Baked Salmon Salad
$8.50
1/4 lb. Jumbo Shrimp Salad
$12.00
1/4 lb. Nova Scotia Smoked Salmon
14.25

$Cheese By The Lb.


1/4 lb. American Cheese
$5.50
1/4 lb. Muenster Cheese
$5.50
1/4 lb. Cheddar Cheese
$5.50
1/4 lb. Swiss/Alpine Lace Cheese
$5.50
Alpine Lace Swiss Cheese
$5.50-19.80
1/4 lb. Provolone Cheese
$5.50
1/4 lb. Pepper Jack Cheese
$5.50-19.80
1/4 lb. Fresh Mozzarella
5.50-19.80

$Snacks and Soups


Fruit Salad
$5.25
Yogurt Parfait
$5.25
Non-fat yogurt, low-fat granola and fresh berries.
Home-Made Chicken Noodle Soup
$5.25-6.50
Vegetarian Split Pea Soup
$5.25-6.50
Chicken Noodle Soup
$5.75-7.00
Split Pea Soup
5.75-7.00

$Extra Sides


Side of Home Fries
$4.25
Side of Bacon
$3.95
Side of Sausage
$3.95
Side of Turkey Bacon
$3.95
Side of Tomato
$2.95
Side of Cucumber
$2.95
Side of Red Onion
$2.50
Side of Sour Pickle (1/2 Size)
$1.95
Bag of Chips
1.75

$Catering - Beverages


Catering Coffee (Per Person)
$2.25
10 PERSON MINIMUM. Our quality fresh-brewed La Colombe coffee. Served with milk and sweeteners.
Catering Coffee To-Go Box
$25.00
96 oz. quality fresh-brewed La Colombe coffee including milk and sweeteners.
Catering Tea (Per Person)
$2.25
8 PERSON MINIMUM. Assortment of Harney & Sons Tea. Served with milk, sweeteners, and lemon wedges.
Catering Fresh-Squeezed OJ (Per Person)
4.25

$Catering - Breakfast


Catering - Lunch Sandwiches


Catering Bacon, Egg, and Cheese Breakfast Sandwich (Per Person)
$7.95
Served with Tropicana premium orange juice.
Catering Ham, Egg, and Cheese Breakfast Sandwich (Per Person)
$7.95
Served with Tropicana premium orange juice.
Catering Sausage, Egg, and Cheese Breakfast Sandwich (Per Person)
$7.95
Served with Tropicana premium orange juice.
Catering Veggie Omelette Breakfast Sandwich (Per Person)
$7.95
Served with Tropicana premium orange juice.
Catering Egg and Cheese Breakfast Sandwich (Per Person)
$7.95
Served with Tropicana premium orange juice.
Catering Signature Sandwich Platter (Per Person)
$12.50
8 PERSON MINIMUM. Assortment of our signature sandwiches on choice of bagels, artisanal breads, or wraps. Served with pickles and choice of house-made coleslaw or green salad.
Catering Signature Sandwich Platter with Drink and Chips (Per Person)
$14.50
8 PERSON MINIMUM. Assortment of our signature sandwiches on choice of bagels, artisanal breads, or wraps. Served with pickles, chips, choice of drink, and choice of house-made coleslaw or green salad.
Catering Deli Sandwich Platter (Per Person)
$11.95
8 PERSON MINIMUM. Selection of meats and cheeses on choice of bagels, artisanal breads, or wraps. Served with beefsteak tomatoes, romaine, pickles, and choice of house-made coleslaw or green salad.
Catering Deli Sandwich Platter with Drink and Chips (Per Person)
$13.95
8 PERSON MINIMUM. Selection of meats and cheeses on choice of bagels, artisanal breads, or wraps. Served with beefsteak tomatoes, romaine, pickles, chips, choice of drink, and choice of house-made coleslaw or green salad.
Catering Cold Cut Platter (Per Person)
$11.95
8 PERSON MINIMUM. Make your own sandwich platter. Choice of 3 meats and 3 cheeses with an assortment of bagels, artisanal breads, and wraps. Served with beefsteak tomatoes, romaine, pickles, and choice of house-made coleslaw or green salad.
Catering Cold Cut Platter with Drink and Chips (Per Person)
$13.95
8 PERSON MINIMUM. Make your own sandwich platter. Choice of 3 meats and 3 cheeses with an assortment of bagels, artisanal breads, and wraps. Served with beefsteak tomatoes, romaine, pickles, chips, choice of drink, and choice of house-made coleslaw or green salad.
Catering Deli Salads Platter (Per Person)
$10.95
8 PERSON MINIMUM. Choice of 3 freshly prepared homemade salads with an assortment of bagels, artisanal breads, and wraps. Served with beefsteak tomatoes, romaine, pickles, and choice of house-made coleslaw or green salad.
Catering Deli Salads Platter with Drink and Chips (Per Person)
$12.95
8 PERSON MINIMUM. Choice of 3 freshly prepared homemade salads with an assortment of bagels, artisanal breads, and wraps. Served with beefsteak tomatoes, romaine, pickles, chips, choice of drink, and choice of house-made coleslaw or green salad.
Catering Signature Sandwich Boxed Lunch (Per Person)
15.00
8 PERSON MINIMUM. Choice of sandwich served with a pickle, house-made coleslaw, traditional black and white cookie, and choice of drink.

$Catering - Lunch Salads


Catering Caesar Salad (Per Person)
$5.75
8 PERSON MINIMUM. Romaine, shaved Parmesan, cherry tomatoes, and croutons.
Catering Mediterranean Salad (Per Person)
$5.75
8 PERSON MINIMUM. Mesclun, tomatoes, feta, olives, red onion, bell peppers, croutons, cucumbers, and parsley.
Catering Cobb Salad (Per Person)
$6.25
8 PERSON MINIMUM. Iceberg, romaine, avocado, Applewood smoked bacon, chopped egg, crumbled blue cheese, and chopped tomatoes.
Catering Asian Sesame Salad (Per Person)
$7.75
8 PERSON MINIMUM. Mixed baby greens with grilled chicken, edamame, Mandarin oranges, corn, shredded carrots, Bermuda onion, sliced almonds, and Asian sesame-ginger dressing.
Catering Garden Salad (Per Person)
$4.95
8 PERSON MINIMUM. Mesculn, sliced red onion, beefsteak tomatoes, olives, croutons, and cucumber.
Catering Sophia Salad (Per Person)
$5.95
8 PERSON MINIMUM. Mesculn greens, candied walnut, oranges, and feta. Served with vinaigrette.
Catering Kale Salad (Per Person)
$5.95
8 PERSON MINIMUM. Kale, cranberry, raisins, feta, scallions, almonds, and sesame-ginger dressing.
Catering Salad Boxed Lunch (Per Person)
12.95
8 PERSON MINIMUM. Choice of individually boxed salad served with kettle chips, traditional black and white cookie, and choice of drink.

$Catering - Cold Cuts, Cheese, Deli Salads


Catering Pastrami
$10.50
Catering Honey Roasted Turkey
$10.50
Catering Smoked Turkey
$10.50
Catering Black Forest Ham
$10.50
Catering Grilled Chicken Cutlet
$10.50
Catering American Cheese
$7.50
Catering Muenster Cheese
$7.50
Catering Swiss Cheese
$7.50
Catering Fresh Mozzarella Cheese
$7.50
Catering Cheddar Cheese
$7.50
Catering Pepper Jack
$7.50
Catering Tuna Salad
$9.50
Catering Low-Fat Tuna Salad
$9.50
Catering Whitefish Salad
$9.50
Catering Baked Salmon Salad
$9.50
Catering Egg Salad
$9.50
Catering Chicken Salad
9.50

$Catering - Sides


Catering Side of Pasta Primavera (Per Person)
$5.00
Catering Side of Pesto Tortellini (Per Person)
$5.00
Catering Side of Sun-Dried Tomato (Per Person)
$5.00
Catering Side of Olive Penne (Per Person)
$5.00
Catering Side of House-Made Coleslaw (Per Platter)
$15.00
SERVES 6.
Catering Bucket of Pickles (Per Person)
2.50

$Catering - Sweets and Cheeses


Catering Dessert Platter (Per Person)
$6.50
10 PERSON MINIMUM. Freshly baked assortment of muffins, brownies, cakes, and cookies, garnished and plattered.
Catering Classic Cheese Board (Per Person)
$5.95
Assortment of imported and domestic cheeses garnished with seasonal fresh fruits and served with gourmet crackers.
Catering Crudite Platter (Per Person)
$4.95

Menu for Pick a Bagel is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

Check Other Restaurant Menu

Seattle Cafe Food
Seattle Cafe

Deli Food, Sandwiches

Playwright Tavern & Restaurant Food
Playwright Tavern & Restaurant

American, Bar Food, Irish

Sapporo Food
Sapporo

Japanese, Noodles

The Sea Grill Food
The Sea Grill

American (New), Seafood, Sushi

City Lobster & Steakhouse Food
City Lobster & Steakhouse

Seafood, Steak

Sushiden Food
Sushiden

Japanese, Sushi

Pasta Lovers Food
Pasta Lovers

Italian, Pizza

Backstage Delicatessen @ 49 Food
Backstage Delicatessen @ 49

American, Diner

Bombay Masala Food
Bombay Masala

Indian

Bella Napoli Food
Bella Napoli

Italian, Pasta, Pizza

Le Monde Gourmet Deli Food
Le Monde Gourmet Deli

American, Diner