The Nostalgia Collection
Seasonal ice cream varietiesClyde's Malted Banana
$12.50
Smooth n' creamy malted banana ice cream
Latke
$13.50
Fried potato ice cream with bits of whipped sour cream and applesauce. Part of the A Fairly New York Holiday capsule. Allergens: Dairy, Egg, Potato, Apple
Coquito
$12.50
Coconut ice cream with cinnamon, rum essence, and secret spices. This flavor is part of A Fairly New York Holiday Capsule. Allergens: Dairy, Egg, Coconut
Buckeye
$12.50
Ohio fans rejoice! Based on the Ohio’s state candy: a peanut butter ice cream with mini buckeyes (chocolate and peanut butter candy)
Pumpkin Spice Latte
$12.00
Pumpkin ice cream with a spiced brown sugar swirl.
Italian Cookie Crumble
$12.50
Almond ice cream, swirls of apricot jam, chocolate chunks, and chunks of rainbow cake.
Olive Oil Jelly Donut
$12.50
Also referred to as Sufganyot, a classic on every Hanukah table: olive oil ice cream, raspberry jelly and chunks of donuts.
Poppycock
$12.50
Moose Munch/Caramel Corn: popcorn ice cream with caramel and candied cashews.
White Chocolate Peppermint
$12.50
White chocolate ice cream with crushed peppermint candy swirl.
(Peanut) Butter Pecan
$12.50
Butter pecan ice cream with swirls of peanut butter and chopped pecans.
Blood Orange Cream Pop
$12.50
Blood orange and vanilla ice cream.
Kitchen Sink
12.50
Sweet Cream ice cream with chocolate covered potato chips, everything sticks, white chocolate chips and chocolate chip cookie dough.
$Tubs
Vanilla Bean Pint
$12.50
Sweet cream vanilla base with real Madagascar vanilla beans. Contains dairy, eggs.
Dark Chocolate Chunk (Dairy) Pint
$12.50
Dark chocolate base with chunks of dark chocolate. Contains dairy, eggs, coconut oil.
Sweet Cream & Sprinkles Pint
$12.50
Sweet cream base with sprinkles. So many sprinkles. Contains dairy, eggs, sprinkles.
Strawberry Jam Pint
$12.50
Strawberry sweet cream base with ribbons of Oregon strawberry jam. Contains dairy.
Saffron Passion Fruit
$12.00
One Pint of Saffron Passion Fruit Ice Cream ; Contains Pistachios and Apricot Pieces
Cookies & Cream Pint
$12.50
Sweet cream base with chocolate cookie bits. Contains dairy, eggs, gluten.
Miso Cherry Pint
$12.50
White miso butterscotch base with tart cherries. Contains dairy, eggs, soy.
Smoked Almond Butterscotch
$12.00
One Pint of Smoked Almond Butterscotch Ice Cream ; Contains Almonds
Banana Split Pint
$12.00
A whole banana split in a pint: banana sweet cream ice cream with bananas, Maraschino cherries, salted walnuts, chocolate syrup, and magicked whipped cream. Contains dairy, eggs, walnuts.
Olive Oil
$12.50
Sweet cream ice cream infused with Italian extra virgin olive oil. Think rich and creamy with slight tang, not Greek salad.
Banana Pudding
$12.00
One Pint of Banana Pudding Ice Cream ; Contains Gluten
Chocolate Peppermint
$12.00
One Pint of Chocolate Peppermint Ice Cream - Contains Coconut Oil
Vegan Oatmeal Cookie
$12.00
One Pint of Vegan Oatmeal Cookie Ice Cream ; Contains gluten, uses an Oat-milk base
Exotic Fruits Sorbet
$12.50
One Pint of Exotic Fruits Sorbet - Mixture of Mango, Papaya, Passion-fruit, Guava, and Calamansi
Red Velvet Cream Cheese
$12.00
One Pint of Red Velvethe Cream Cheese Ice Cream, contains gluten
Dark Chocolate Caramel Peanut
$12.00
Oneed Pint of Dark Chocolate Caramelike Peanut Ice Cream - Contains peanuts and trace amounts of coconut oil
Oatmeal Cookie Dough
$12.00
One Pint of Oatmeal Cookie Dough ice cream - Contains dairy and gluten
Turkish Coffee Date Caramel
$12.00
One Pint of our collaboration flavor with Sofra. Contains caffeine
Vegan Hazelnut Praline
$12.00
One Pint of Vegan Hazelnut Praline Ice Cream. Contains nuts (almonds and Hazelnut)
Chocotorta
$12.50
Sour cream cream cheese ice cream with dulce de leche and chocolate cookie crumbles. Modeled after the Argentinian birthday cake with the same name; it just might be the best ice cream you'll ever have. Allergens: Dairy, Egg, Gluten
Mint Cream and Cookies
$12.50
Mint ice cream with chocolate cookie pieces throughout. Allergens: Dairy, Egg, Gluten
Coffee Crunch
$12.50
Coffee ice cream with our house made coffee soil throughout. Allergens: Dairy, Egg, Gluten, Almond
Vegan Coconut Caramel Chip
$12.50
Coconut milk ice cream base with chocolate chips and caramel swirls. Allergens: Coconut
Vegan Dark Chocolate Chunk
$12.50
Cashew milk chocolate ice cream with chocolate chips throughout. Allergens: Cashew, Macadamia, Coconut
Vegan Matcha Black Sesame
$12.00
Matcha flavored coconut ice cream with clusters of toasted black sesame. Allergens: Coconut, Sesame
Vegan Lemon Berry Oatmeal
$12.00
Oat milk ice cream lightly flavored with lemon with blueberries throughout. Allergens: Gluten Lemon, Blueberry, Coconut, Apples
Vegan Oatmeal Cookie
$12.00
Oat milk ice cream with vegan oatmeal cookies throughout. NO raisins... why do people hate raisins so much? Allergens: Gluten
Caramel Chocolate Toffee
$12.50
Sweet cream ice cream with chocolate chips, toffee bits, and streaks of caramel. Allergens: Dairy, Egg, Coconut, Almond
Peanut Butter S'mores
$12.50
Peanut butter ice cream with chocolate chips, graham cracker bits, and marshmallow. Brought to you by the creative genius of LCD Soundsystem. Allergens: Dairy, Egg, Peanut, Gluten
Miso Peanut Butter Brownie
$12.50
White miso butterscotch ice cream base with peanut butter swirls and brownie pieces. It's the savory sweet combination that you didn't know you needed in your life until right this second. Allergens: Dairy, Egg, Soy, Gluten
Cookie Latte
$12.50
Chocolate cookie ice cream base with our house made coffee soil and our coffee caramel throughout. Allergens: Dairy, Egg, Gluten, Almond
Baconeggncheese
$13.50
Smoked sweet cream ice cream with candied bacon, candied egg yolk, and cheddar whipped cream... seriously! We collaborated with The Bodega Boys Desus and Mero for this one. Allergens: Dairy, Egg, Bacon
Bodega Counter Crunch
$13.50
Caramel infused sweet cream ice cream with chocolate covered pretzels, peanuts, and butter cookies. We collaborated with The Bodega Boys Desus and Mero for this one. Allergens: Dairy, Egg, Gluten, Peanut
Chico Stix
$13.50
The richest peanut butter ice cream with clusters of candied toasted coconut. We collaborated with The Bodega Boys Desus and Mero for this one. Allergens: Dairy, Egg, Peanut, Coconut
Host of Cupcakes
$13.50
Chocolate infused sweet cream base with pieces of chocolate cupcakes and whipped cream. We collaborated with The Bodega Boys Desus and Mero for this one. Allergens: Dairy, Egg, Gluten
Cherry Cordial
$13.50
Chocolate ice cream swirled with soft candied cherries, gooey cherry sauce and magic dark chocolate. Part of A Fairly New York Holiday Capsule. Allergens: Dairy, Egg, Cherry
Shattered Sugar Cookie
$13.50
Sweet cream ice cream with pieces of shattered sugar cookies and red and green sprinkles. This is essentially sweet cream and sprinkles taken to the next level of indulgency. Allergens: Dairy, Egg, Gluten
Pineapple Rum Caramel
$13.50
Ginger scented sweet cream base with chunks f toasted coconut cake and rum soaked pineapples. This flavor is a part of A Fairly New York Holiday Capsule. Allergens: Dairy, Egg, Gluten, Pineapple
Pine Needle Rocky Road
$13.50
Dark chocolate ice cream with pine needle infused meringue, white chocolate pudding, and toasted almonds. This flabor is a part of A Fairly New York Holiday Capsule. Allergens: Dairy, Egg, Almond
Cinnamon Dulce de Leche
$10.00
Cinnamon infused sweet cream with Dulce de Leche swirls and chunks of housemade snickerdoodle cookies
Peanut butter and jelly
$12.50
It's the century old combination that you know and love, peanut butter and grape jelly.
Strawberry Basil Lemonade Sorbet
$12.50
...The title says it all!
ODB Dirt McGirt
$12.00
Chocolate ice cream with chocolate cookie pieces and Bailey's caramel Contains: dairy, egg, gluten
ODB Joe Bananas
$12.00
Coffee ice cream with banana bread chunks and walnuts Contains: dairy, egg, gluten, nuts
ODB Peanut The Kidnapper
$12.00
Peanut butter ice cream with honey and chocolate chips Contains: dairy, egg, coconut oil, peanuts
ODB Ol' Dirty Custard
$12.00
Sweet custard with salted caramel and pecans Contains: dairy, eggs, pecans, coconut oil
Passionfruit Apricot Pistachio
$12.50
Passionfruit ice cream with an apricot swirl and pistachios Contains: dairy, egg, pistachios
Pistachio Cardamom Caramel
$12.50
Pistachio ice cream with cardamom and caramel swirl Contains: dairy, eggs, pistachios
Vegan Chocolate Peanut Butter Pretzel
$12.50
Vegan chocolate ice cream (contains cashew milk), swirls of peanut butter and chunks of pretzel.
Brooklyn Blackout
$12.50
Dark chocolate ice cream, fudge swirls and chocolate cake pieces.
Matcha Rocky Road
$12.50
Matcha, yes. Lots of matcha. But what makes matcha better? Plenty of crunchy almonds, mini marshmallows, and dark chocolate flakes. Allergens: Egg, milk, soy, tree nuts.
Passionberry Love Potion
$12.50
Part of our NEW Penguin Randomhouse Brain Freeze collab. Passionfruit ice cream, raspberry jam swirl, and sugar cookie chunks. Allergens: Dairy, egg, gluten.
Smoky Vanilla Bourbon Twist
$12.50
Part of our NEW Penguin Randomhouse Brain Freeze collab. Non-alcoholic vanilla bourbon ice cream base with smoked, chopped almonds. Allergens: Dairy, egg, almond.
Bubblegum Pop
$12.50
Part of our NEW Penguin Randomhouse Brain Freeze collab. Bubblegum flavored ice cream with bright pink sprinkles. Allergens: Dairy, egg.
Journey to Outer Spice
$12.50
Part of our NEW Penguin Randomhouse Brain Freeze collab. Cinnamon miso ice cream with caramel swirl. Allergens: Dairy, egg, soy.
Pecan Sticky Bun
$12.50
Our collaboration tub with Boston's famous Flour Bakery! Ribbons of sticky bun caramel with pecans and chunks of actual sticky buns! Allergens: dairy, eggs, gluten, pecans.
Oh Fudge
$12.50
A malted chocolate milk ice cream, with globs of thick fudge and chunks of fudgy brownies. Allergens: Dairy, Egg, Gluten
Banoffee Pie
$12.50
A banana ice cream with swirls of rich dulce de leche and graham cracker crust crumbled in. Allergens: Dairy, Egg, Gluten
Razzleberry Dressing
$12.50
A beautiful blackberry ice cream with swirls of bright raspberry jam. Allergens: Dairy, Eggs
Buddi's Spaghettii Sundae
$12.50
Maple Ice cream packed with a mix of chocolate cookie crumbs, mini marshmallows, M&M's, Sno-Caps and corn nuts. Allergens: Dairy, Eggs, Gluten, Gelatin
Moose Nog
$12.50
A spiced eggnog ice cream with swirls of fudge and peanut butter cups. Allergens: Dairy, Eggs, Nuts
White Chocolate Peppermint
12.50
White chocolate ice cream with crushed peppermint candy! Contains: Dairy, Eggs
$Beverages
Milkshake*
$11.00
16 oz. milkshake made with our homemade ice cream.
Soda
$3.00
Choose from various flavors of sodas, and make your own ice cream float at home! (Ice cream sold separately)
Bottled Water
2.00
16oz Bottle of Water
$Toppings
Coop's Vegan Fudge
$13.00
10.6 oz of delicious, vegan fudge made locally in South Boston, MA! Contains: coconut.
Coop's Salted Caramel
$13.00
10.6 oz of delicious salted caramel topping, made locally in South Boston, MA! Contains: dairy
Fly By Jing Chili Crisp
$13.00
6 oz of SPICY szechuan chili crisp. Use it in a stir fry, as a marinade, or...on vanilla bean ice cream. (It's the combination you never knew you needed.)
Rainbow Sprinkles
$5.00
An 8oz container of rainbow sprinkles
Chocolate Sprinkles
$5.00
An 8oz container of chocolate sprinkles
Chocolate cookie soil
$5.00
An 8oz container of crushed up chocolate cookies.
Vanilla Cookie Soil
5.00
An 8oz container of crushed up vanilla cookies.
$Diy Sundae Kit
Diy Sundae Kit
$50.00
Party like it's sundae. Includes your choice of (2) tubs, (1) gooey topping (either Coop's Vegan Fudge or Salted Caramel), and (2) crunchy toppings (rainbow sprinkles, chocolate sprinkles, chocolate cookie soil, vanilla cookie soil.) Great for a cozy night in!
Party Like it's Sundae (Large Sundae Kit)
75.00
Ice cream party time! Your choice of (4) tubs of ice cream, (2) 10.6oz gooey toppings, and (2) 14oz crunchy toppings. If you'd like the same two topping options, just select it once.
$Beer
Ice Cream Sandwiches
Chocolate wafer cookies with OddFellows ice cream sandwiched in the middle, and the addition of curated topping* * Cross contamination of ice creams may occur.Please note if there is an allergy when placing your order.DIY Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwich
$8.50
Chewy chocolate chip cookies with your choice of ice cream in the middle (a kid's-sized scoop), rolled in your choice of crunchy topping! Note: cookies are made at a separate facility and may contain traces of peanuts/tree nuts. Contains gluten/dairy.
Cookies & Mint Sandwich
$8.00
Cookies & Mint ice cream sandwiched between two chocolate wafers and rolled in chocolate cookie crumble. Allergens: gluten, dairy, eggs
Poppycock Sandwich
$8.00
Poppycock ice cream (popcorn ice cream with cashews, caramel) between two chocolate wafers and salted caramel. Allergens: gluten, dairy, eggs, nuts
Italian Cookie Crumble Sandwich
$8.00
Italian Cookie Crumble ice cream (almond ice cream with rainbow cookies, apricot swirl and chocolate chunks) between two chocolate wafers and rolled in maraschino cherries. Allergens: gluten, dairy, eggs, nuts
Black and White Sandwich
$8.00
Dark Chocolate Chunk and Vanilla Bean ice cream between two chocolate wafers and rolled in chocolate sprinkles. Allergens: gluten, dairy, eggs
Neopolitan Sandwich
$8.00
Dark Chocolate Chunk, Vanilla Bean, and Strawberry Jam ice cream between two chocolate wafers and rolled in chocolate sprinkles. Allergens: gluten, dairy, eggs
Strawberry Jam Sandwich
$8.00
Strawberry Jam ice cream between two chocolate wafers and rolled in chocolate sprinkles. Allergens: gluten, dairy, eggs
Chocotorta Sandwich
$8.00
Chocotorta ice cream (cookies and cream cheesecake with dulce de leche swirl) between two chocolate wafers and rolled in chocolate cookie crumble. Allergens: gluten, dairy, eggs
Caramel Chocolate Toffee Sandwich
$8.00
Caramel Chocolate Toffee ice cream topped with salted caramel and sandwiched between two chocolate wafers. Allergens: gluten, dairy, eggs, nuts
Sweet Cream & Sprinkles Sandwich
$8.00
Sweet Cream & Sprinkles ice cream between two chocolate wafers and rolled in rainbow sprinkles. Allergens: gluten, dairy, eggs
Peanut Butter S'mores Sandwich
$8.00
Peanut Butter S'mores ice cream topped with chocolate fudge and sandwiched between two chocolate wafers. Allergens: gluten, dairy, eggs, peanuts
Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich
$8.00
Peanut Butter and Jelly ice cream between two chocolate wafers and rolled in chocolate sprinkles. Allergens: gluten, dairy, eggs, peanuts
Sandwich 4-pack
$32.00
A 4-pack of our seasonal ice cream sandwiches, one of each flavor!
Italian Cookie Crumble Sandwich
$8.00
Italian cookie crumble ice cream (almond base, apricot swirl, dark chocolate chunks, rainbow cookies) sandwiched between two chocolate wafer cookies and rolled in chocolate sprinkles. (Allergens: Gluten, almond, egg, dairy.)
Lamington Sandwich (chocolate coconut cake)
$8.00
Lamington ice cream (chocolate, coconut flake, yellow cake pieces) sandwiched between two chocolate wafer cookies with raspberry jam and rolled in vanilla cookie pieces. (Allergens: dairy, coconut, eggs, gluten.)
Sweet Cream & Sprinkles Sandwich
$8.00
Sweet cream & sprinkles ice cream sandwiched between two chocolate wafer cookies and rolled in tons of rainbow sprinkles. (Allergens: gluten, dairy, eggs.)
Strawberry Shortcake Sandwich
6.00
Strawberry Jam ice cream sandwiched between two chocolate wafers and rolled in vanilla and strawberry cookie crumble. (Allergens: Dairy, gluten, eggs.)
$Ice Cream Cakes
Get a 10 inch ice cream cake delivered to your party straightaway!Peanut Butter S'mores Cake
$65.00
Peanut butter ice cream covered in fudge icing and cookie soil, decorated with mini marshmallows. 10 inches (feeds about 10-12.)
Sweet Cream & Sprinkles Cake
$65.00
Sweet cream & sprinkles ice cream with a cookie crust, covered in fudge and rainbow sprinkles, finished with whipped cream. 10 inches (feeds about 10-12.)
Menu for OddFellows Ice Cream Co. is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
