Beverages
Beverages2 Liter Soda
$2.75
Fountain Soda
$2.00
Lemonade
2.00
$Appetizers
AppetizersGarlic Knots
$2.00
Six twists of pizza dough tossed in herbs and roasted garlic . Served with marinara sauce.
Hot Wings
$6.95
12 hot, medium or Memphis BBQ. Served with homemade buttermilk ranch dressing.
Pepperoni Pizza Pinwheel
$2.00
Italian Wedding Soup
$4.95
Baby meatballs, egg, spinach, red pepper and pasta.
Meatballs
$4.95
Four meatballs in marinara sauce.
Italian Sausage
4.95
Four Italian sausage in marinara sauce.
$Salads
SaladsItalian Small Dinner Salad
$3.95
Tossed romaine with diced tomato, red onion and fresh mushrooms.
Soho Caesar Dressing Salad Plate
$4.95
Romaine with Parmesan cheese, chef's Caesar dressing and crunchy homemade croutons.
Soho Caesar Dressing Salad Bowl
$10.95
Romaine with Parmesan cheese, chef's Caesar dressing and crunchy homemade croutons.
Greek Island Salad Plate
$5.95
Romaine with feta cheese, assorted olives, red peppers, tomatoes,pepperoncini and Greek dressing.
Greek Island Salad Bowl
$11.95
Romaine with feta cheese, assorted olives, red peppers, tomatoes,pepperoncini and Greek dressing.
Salad Di Antipasta Salad Plate
$5.95
Romaine with Ham, tomatoes, pepperoni, diced Mozzarella and Marinated artichoke hearts.
Salad Di Antipasta Salad Bowl
$11.95
Romaine with Ham, tomatoes, pepperoni, diced Mozzarella and Marinated artichoke hearts.
Baby Spinach and Bacon Salad Plate
$6.95
Baby spinach, imported Gorgonzola, bacon, homemade croutons and red onions. Tossed with balsamic vinaigrette.
Baby Spinach and Bacon Salad Bowl
$13.95
Baby spinach, imported Gorgonzola, bacon, homemade croutons and red onions. Tossed with balsamic vinaigrette.
The Cobb Salad Plate
$8.95
Romaine, grilled chicken breast, bacon, Gorgonzola, avocado, tomatoes, chopped eggs and tinsel town creamy Italian dressing.
The Cobb Salad Family Size Bowl
17.95
Romaine, grilled chicken breast, bacon, Gorgonzola, avocado, tomatoes, chopped eggs and tinsel town creamy Italian dressing.
$Pastas
PastasSpaghetti with Marinara Sauce
$6.95
Spaghetti with Italian Meatballs
$8.95
Spaghetti with Italian Sausage
$8.95
Fettuccini
$8.95
With our Italian meat sauce.
Chicken Parmigiana over Spaghetti
$9.95
Homemade breaded Italian chicken cutlet with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella.
Big Tony Rigatoni
$10.95
Big pasta tubes with prosciutto in a tomato cream sauce.
Lasagna Bolognese
$9.95
Oven baked layers of pasta with three cheeses and a zesty meat sauce.
Fettuccini Alfredo
$8.95
Tossed in a Parmesan cream sauce with a hint of garlic.
Eggplant Parmigiana over Spaghetti
$9.95
Homemade breaded eggplant covered with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella.
Penne Ala Vodka
$9.95
Penne pasta tossed in Redendo's creamy vodka sauce with fresh tomato and bits of onion.
Linguini Pasta Primavera
$8.95
Fresh sauteed vegetables, broccoli, spinach, red bell peppers and mushrooms in a creamy tomato sauce.
Baked Penne with Three Cheese
8.95
Baked to a Golden Brown with Zesty marinara.
$Create Your Own Pizza
Create Your Own PizzaCheese Pizza
11.00-14.00
$Hot Heros
Hot HerosMeatball Parmigiana Hero
$5.95
Eggplant Parmigiana Hero
$6.95
Sausage and Pepper with Mozzarella Hero
$6.95
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Hero
6.95
$Deli Heros
Deli HerosAn Italian Bombshell Hero
$7.95
Capacola spicy ham, salami, provolone and Italian vinaigrette. Served on toasted Italian bread with crisp romaine lettuce and fresh tomatoes.
NY Yankee Hero
$6.95
Turkey, pepperoni, provolone, with spicy cherry pepper relish. Served on toasted Italian bread with crisp romaine lettuce and fresh tomatoes.
President's Club Hero
$6.95
Turkey, ham, bacon, Swiss, and Texas BBQ Mustard. Served on toasted Italian bread with crisp romaine lettuce and fresh tomatoes.
A Superhero
7.95
Create your own with two meats and one cheese. Served on toasted Italian bread with crisp romaine lettuce and fresh tomatoes.
$Specialty Pizza
Specialty PizzaPopeye and Olive Oyl Pizza
$18.00-19.00
Spinach, goat cheese, ricotta and roasted garlic.
Mozzarella Meat Lover Pizza
$18.00-23.00
Sausage, pepperoni, meatballs and extra cheese.
Zorba the Greek Pizza
$19.00-24.00
Feta cheese, assorted olives, tomatoes, roasted peppers and sauteed onions.
Margarita Style Pizza
$16.00-17.00
Fresh tomato, mozzarella, fresh basil and olive oil with a light dusting of Italian cheeses.
BBQ Chicken Pizza
$18.00-23.00
BBQ chicken pizza. Tomatoes and with or without sauteed onions.
Midtown Tunnel Vision Pizza
$18.00-23.00
Tomato sauce, ricotta, meatballs and prosciutto.
The French Quarter Pizza
$20.00-21.00
Four cheese with pesto, chicken and creole spices.
Veggie Madness Pizza
$16.00-21.00
Your choice of any four vegetable toppings.
Benny Blanco Pizza
$16.00-17.00
Ricotta cheese, mozzarella, extra virgin, olive oil, Parmesan cheese and no pizza sauce.
Columbus Circle Pizza
18.00-22.00
Fresh tomato, sausage, green bell peppers and mushrooms.
$Calzones
CalzonesMy Pop's Favorite Calzone
$7.95
Mozzarella, tomato, ricotta sausage and roasted garlic.
Cab Calloway Calzone
$7.95
Spinach, ricotta, pesto and grilled chicken breast.
Little Italy Saint Calzone
$9.95
Cappacola, prosciutto, ham, Genoa salami, provolone, mozzarella and ricotta cheese.
Create Your Own Calzone
8.95
Includes ricotta and mozzarella. Choose four of our Pizza toppings.
$Desserts
DessertsHomemade Italian Cannoli
$3.00
Grand marnier whipped ricotta.
Menu for New York 51 Pizzeria is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
