TooJay's

TooJay's Menu

(941) 365-3287
3501 South Tamiami Trail, Sarasota, FL 34239
$$$$$

Seasonal Menu - Limited Time Offer


Cinnamon Swirl French Toast
8.99
Two of our Cinnamon Buns dipped in our French Toast batter and griddled to perfection. Topped with powdered sugar and served with butter and maple syrup.

$Starters


Tomato Cucumber Salad
$4.99
Fresh wedges of tomatoes blended with crunchy cucumbers, red onion and dill tossed with Italian vinaigrette.
Fried Dill Pickles
$6.59
Crispy dill pickle chips lightly battered and accompanied with our creamy horseradish sauce.
Loaded Latkes
$10.99
Crispy homemade potato pancake bites topped with smokehouse bacon, fresh tomato, melted cheddar, sour cream and chopped scallions. More than enough for 2 to share.
Stuffed Cabbage App
$7.99
Stuffed with seasoned ground beef and rice, topped with sweet and sour sauce.
Chopped Chicken Liver
$6.99
Our own famous recipe, just like your Bubbe's. Served with a slice of rye and fresh vegetables.
Nova Latkes*
$8.59
Roasted Brussels Sprouts Medley
$7.99
Brussels sprouts and seasonal vegetables roasted, lightly seasoned and topped with crispy chopped bacon and a balsamic glaze.
Cheese Blintzes
$8.59
Two homemade crepes filled with sweet cheese. Served with hot fruit topping and sour cream.
TooJay's Famous Knish
$4.59
Filled with your choice of potato or spinach.
Mini Potato Pancakes
$7.59
A crunchy sampling of our signature scratch made pancakes served with sour cream and applesauce.
Beer Battered Onion Rings
6.99
Served with a remoulade sauce.

$Omelettes & Eggs - Breakfast

Served with your choice of toast or bagel and our famous home fries, grits, oatmeal, or fresh fruit unless otherwise noted. For any egg entree, substitute egg beaters or egg whites add. 99.
Roasted Veggie Skillet
$9.99
Brussels sprouts and roasted vegetables lightly seasoned and tossed with crispy home fries. Topped with 2 eggs any style and lightly sprinkled with Parmesan cheese, diced tomatoes and chopped scallions.
Nova, Eggs and Onion Omelette
$11.99
3 scrambled eggs with smoked salmon and onions.
Two Eggs with Meat
$7.99
Served any style with smoked ham, country style sausage or smokehouse bacon.
Three Eggs with Meat
$8.99
Served any style with smoked ham, country style sausage or smokehouse bacon.
Roasted Veggie Omelette
$10.99
Roasted veggies, provolone and Parmesan cheese, tomatoes, spinach and lemon herb seasoning. Served with a side of salsa.
TooJay's Benedict
$10.99
Smoked ham and tomato. Served with 2 poached eggs on crispy grilled rye bread, topped with Hollandaise sauce and chopped scallions.
Nova Salmon Benedict
$13.99
Smoked Nova Salmon, tomato, red onion and capers. Served with 2 poached eggs on crispy grilled rye bread, topped with Hollandaise sauce and chopped scallions.
Create Your Own Omelette
$9.99
Your choice of any 3: smokehouse bacon, corned beef, smoked ham, country style sausage, peppers, onions, mushrooms, tomato or cheese.
Western Skillet
$9.99
Crispy potato topped with scrambled eggs, sauteed onions, green peppers and smoked ham, sprinkled with Cheddar cheese, baked casserole style and topped with fresh tomatoes and scallions.
Deli Benedict
$11.99
Melted Swiss cheese, tomato and your choice of pastrami or corned beef. Served with 2 poached eggs on crispy grilled rye bread, topped with Hollandaise sauce and chopped scallions.
T.J's Ultimate Omelette
$10.99
Three eggs, smokehouse bacon, country style sausage, smoked ham, onions, mushrooms, peppers, potatoes and choice of cheese.
Corned Beef Hash and Eggs
9.99
Grilled hash with two eggs any style.

$Morning Specials - Breakfast


Breakfast Combo Platter
$11.99
Belgian Waffle, 2 eggs any style, country style sausage and strips of smokehouse bacon. Served with toast or bagel and home fries, grits, oatmeal or fresh fruit.
California Fruit Salad
$8.99
Fresh cantaloupe, honeydew, pineapple, red grapes and strawberries topped with raisins and toasted almonds. Served with a side of dairy fresh vanilla yogurt.
Belgian Waffle
$7.59
Served with butter and breakfast syrup. Topped with strawberries and whipped cream or hot fruit topping
Chicken & Waffles
$10.99
Our Belgian Waffle topped with crunchy chicken tenders. Served with syrup and buffalo hot sauce on the side.
French Toast
$7.99
Thick slices of our homemade Challah flavored with vanilla, nutmeg and cinnamon and grilled to perfection.
Waffle Sliders
9.59
A freshly baked half Belgian Waffle with scrambled eggs, American cheese and your choice of smokehouse bacon or country style sausage. Served with syrup for dipping and a side of our delicious home fries.

$Soups

The great standard.
Chicken Noodle Soup
$4.59
Loaded with chicken and vegetables. Only Bubbe makes it as good.
Matzo Ball Soup
$4.99
Our light and fluffy matzo balls in a rich chicken broth with carrots and onions.
Crock of French Onion Soup
6.59
Topped with a thick layer of Provolone and Parmesan Cheese.

$Breakfast Sandwiches

Served on a bagel or brioche bun. Served with home fries.
Egg Sandwich
$7.99
Served any style with smokehouse bacon, country style sausage or smoked ham and your choice of cheese.
Egg, Avocado, Spinach and Swiss Sandwich
8.59
Served on a bagel or brioche bun, with home fries.

$Deli Classics From The Deli

Served with Cole Slaw and a dill pickle.
TooJay's Classic
$12.59
Corned beef and pastrami, a little bit of heaven.
Combo Deli Platter
$12.99
Your choice of any 3 of our fresh sliced deli meats served atop a bed of lettuce with Cole slaw, potato salad, pickle and choice of bread.
Triple J*
12.59

$Deli Classics From The Kitchen

Served with French fries, Cole slaw and a dill pickle.
Rachel
$13.59
Our classic hot pastrami, sauerkraut and Swiss cheese with homestyle Russian dressing served on rye bread grilled to perfection.
Turkey Reuben
$13.59
Try this classic sandwich with fresh roasted turkey on our famous rye bread.
Reuben
$13.59
Our classic hot corned beef, sauerkraut and Swiss cheese with homestyle Russian dressing served on rye bread grilled to perfection.
Beef Brisket Dip
13.59
Lean brisket slices are topped with caramelized onions and provolone cheese, then baked in a crunchy french bread loaf with hot french onion soup for dipping.

$Breakfast Scramble Wraps

Served with home fries
Veggie Scramble Wrap
7.99
Egg whites, spinach, onion, mushrooms and swiss. Served with salsa.

$Deli Sandwiches

Served with Cole slaw and a dill pickle on your choice of freshly baked Artisan rye, wheat, Challah, brioche bun or wrap. Add your choice of cheese .99 * Add a schmear of chopped liver 1.99 * French fries 2.99 * Sweet potato fries 4.59 * Upgrade the Cole slaw for Tomato Cucumber salad for .99
Chicken Caesar Wrap
$9.99
Grilled chicken breast, fresh romaine and creamy Caesar dressing.
Roast Beef Sandwich*
$11.99
Tender slices of rare roast beef lightly seasoned to perfection. *Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, nova salmon or eggs may increase your risk of food borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Turkey Breast Sandwich
$11.59
Slow roasted, sliced thin and piled high. Add bacon, lettuceand tomato for the ultimate Turkey BLT 1.59
Liverwurst Sandwich
$9.99
Only the best braunschweiger and thinly sliced red onion. Try it with mustard or Russian dressing.
Roasted Vegetable Wrap
$9.99
Balsamic marinated Portobello mushroom, roasted red peppers, grilled red onion, with mixed greens and Gorgonzola cheese.
Hummus Wrap
$9.99
Hummus combined with artichokes, black olives, pepperoncini and fresh chopped vegetables tossed in a light Italian dressing.
Tongue Sandwich
$14.59
Fresh beef tongue cut to order, just how you like it.
Beef Brisket Sandwich
$12.59
Juicy braised brisket, sliced lean and served hot.
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
$10.59
Crispy Buffalo chicken tenders, lettuce and celery, chopped and tossed with blue cheese dressing.
Nova on a Bagel*
$13.99
Hot Corned Beef Sandwich
$12.59
Hand trimmed and steamed to bring out the full flavor.
Turkey Avocado Sandwich
12.99
Slow roasted turkey breast, fresh avocado, arugula, tomato and lemon garlic aioli.

$Fish Platter


Nova Salmon Platter*
$16.59
Nova on a Bagel*
$13.99
Whitefish Salad on a Bagel
$13.59
Served with lettuce, tomato and onion on your choice of bagel with fresh fruit.
Smoked Fish Combo Platter*
$16.59
Smoked Whitefish Platter
14.59
Platters served on a bed of crisp lettuce with fresh vegetables and a bagel.

$A La Carte


Fruit Salad
$2.99
Muffin
$3.79
Danish
$3.79
Fresh Strawberries
$3.99
Mini Potato Pancakes
$3.99
3 of our famous mini potato pancakes.
Bagel with Cream Cheese
$2.59
Cheese Blintz
$4.99
Bowl Of Grits
$2.99
Side Home Fries
$2.99
Country Style Sausage Links
$3.99
Bowl of Oatmeal
$3.99
Choose any TOO toppings: brown sugar, raisins, fresh strawberries, toasted almonds.
Smokehouse Bacon
3.99

$Hand Tossed Salads


TooJay's Chopped Salad
$12.59
Turkey, ham, egg, black olives, red onions, crisp greens and garden vegetables tossed with your choice of dressing, topped with Gorgonzola, crumbled bacon and artichoke hearts.
Greek Salad
$10.99
Lots of Feta cheese, Greek olives, tomatoes, onions, cucumbers and pepperoncini on a bed of fresh greens with our special dressing. Served with pita bread.
Chicken Caesar Salad
$10.99
Fresh romaine lettuce, sliced grilled chicken breast and croutons tossed with our own Caesar dressing.
Crispy Chicken Salad
$11.59
Crispy fried chicken tenders atop fresh mixed greens and garden vegetables. Served with your choice of dressing on the side. Try it Buffalo style.
TooJay's Cobb Salad
$12.59
Fresh mixed greens piled with diced chicken breast, ham, onions, crumbled bacon, tomatoes, hard boiled eggs and shredded cheddar. Served with your choice of dressing on the side.
Strawberry Citrus Salad
$10.99
Fresh mixed greens topped with a refreshing blend of mandarin oranges, fresh strawberries, red grapes, gorgonzola and toasted almonds. Served with raspberry vinaigrette.
Mandarin Chicken Salad
12.99
Diced chicken breast, mandarin oranges, toasted sliced almonds and sweet red grapes tossed in a tangy tropical dressing served atop fresh mixed salad greens.

$Canned Beverages


Dr. Brown's Black Cherry
$2.99
Dr. Brown's Ginger Ale
$2.99
Pepsi
$1.99
Dr. Brown's Celray
$2.99
Dr. Brown's Diet Cream Soda
$2.99
Dr. Brown's Root Beer
$2.99
Diet Pepsi
$1.99
Dr. Brown's Cream Soda
$2.99
Dr. Brown's Diet Black Cherry
2.99

$Deli Salads

Make it a platter or sandwich. Your choice of a salad platter served on a bed of lettuce with fresh vegetables and rye bread or a sandwich served on your choice of fresh baked Artisan rye, wheat, Challah, brioche bun or wrap with lettuce, tomato Cole slaw and a dill pickle.
Egg Salad Sandwich
$8.99
Whitefish Salad Sandwich
$13.59
A traditional favorite, using only the best whitefish from the Great Lakes.
Whitefish Salad Platter
$13.59
A traditional favorite, using only the best whitefish from the Great Lakes.
Egg Salad Platter
$8.99
Tuna Salad Sandwich
$11.59
Our homemade blend of all white Albacore tuna mixed with just the right amount of seasoning and mayo.
Stuffed Tomato
$10.99
A vine ripe tomato filled with your choice of dill chicken, traditional chicken, tuna or egg salad. Not available as a sandwich.
Shrimp Salad Sandwich
$12.99
Plump shrimp tossed in just the right amount of seasoning and mayo.
Shrimp Salad Platter
$12.99
Plump shrimp tossed in just the right amount of seasoning and mayo.
T.J.'S Trio Salad Platter
$12.59
Choose any 3 - dill chicken, traditional chicken, tuna or egg salad. Substitute shrimp salad or whitefish salad for any scoop add 1.79. Not available as a sandwich.
Mediterranean Health Trio
$9.99
Not available as a sandwich. A delightful combination of our tomato cucumber salad, hummus and fresh fruit. Served with pita bread.
Dill Chicken Salad Platter
$9.99
Diced chicken breast tossed in our signature dill sauce.
Tuna Salad Platter
$11.59
Our homemade blend of all white Albacore tuna mixed with just the right amount of seasoning and mayo.
Dill Chicken Salad Sandwich
$9.99
Diced chicken breast tossed in our signature dill sauce.
Chopped Chicken Liver Sandwich
$9.99
A true classic made in-house, served with sweet red onion.
Traditional Chicken Salad Platter
$9.99
Diced chicken breast blended with mayo, celery and spices.
Traditional Chicken Salad Sandwich
$9.99
Diced chicken breast blended with mayo, celery and spices.
Chopped Chicken Liver Platter
9.99
A true classic made in-house, served with sweet red onion.

$Beverages


Fresh Brewed Iced Tea
$2.99
Choose from Unsweet or Sweet Iced Tea.
TooJay's Bottled Water
$2.59
Orange Juice - 16 oz. Cup
$2.99
Grapefruit Juice
$2.99
Milk
$2.99
Egg Cream
$2.99
Peach Tea
$3.29
Lemonade
$2.99
Cranberry Juice
$2.99
Strawberry Lemonade
$3.29
Our lemonade blended with a splash of strawberry is the perfect balance between sweet and tart.
Arnold Palmer
$2.99
Lemonade and Iced Tea
Fountain Beverage
$2.99
Martinelli's Apple Juice
$2.99
Fountain Soda
$2.99
Florida Orange Juice
$2.99
Grapefruit Juice - Pint
$2.99
Cranberry Juice - Pint
2.99

$Choose Too


Half Hand Sliced or Salad Sandwich + House or Caesar Salad
$9.59
Cup Of Soup + Cafe-Sized Hand Tossed Salad
$10.99
Cup Of Soup + Scoop Of Deli Salad
$10.59
Cup Of Soup + Half Hand Sliced or Salad Sandwich
$10.59
Choose from Chicken Noodle or Matzo Ball Soup.
Cup Of Soup + House or Caesar Salad
8.99

$Kid'S Breakfast Menu


French Toast
$3.99
Create Your Own Breakfast
$5.59
Choice of One: French Toast Slice, 1 Egg served any style or 1-2 of a Belgian Waffle. Choice of Two: Grapes, Mandarin Oranges, Applesauce, 2 Bacon Strips, 2 Sausage Links, Toast or Bagel.
Kid's Chocolate Milk
$1.99
Kid's Fountain Beverage
$1.99
Kid's Lemonade
$1.99
Kid's Milk
1.99

$Hot Handhelds

Served with French fries, Cole slaw and a dill pickle.
Grilled Cheese
$8.79
Choose your favorite cheese and we'll grill it on your choice of bread. Served with French fries. With bacon and tomato add 1.29
Avocado BLT
$10.99
This classic is stacked with 5 slices of smokehouse bacon, sliced avocado and lemon garlic aioli. Served on toasted Challah.
Chicken Tenders
$10.99
Original or Buffalo style. Your choice of ranch, honey mustard or barbeque sauce. Or, try them toss in our spicy Buffalo sauce served with blue cheese dressing.
Open Faced Turkey Melt
$12.59
Turkey piled high on rye with tomato, smokehouse bacon and Russian dressing, topped with melted Muenster cheese.
Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato
$8.99
This classic is stacked with 5 slices of smokehouse bacon and served on toasted challah. Served with French fries.
Fish & Chips
$11.79
Two Atlantic Cod fillets lightly battered English style and flash fried until crisp. Served with tartar sauce and malt vinegar.
Deli Dogs
$8.99
Two all-beef franks grilled to perfection.
Open Faced Tuna Melt
12.59
All white albacore tuna with tomato, Russian dressing and melted Muenster cheese

$Burgers & Chicken

Comes with lettuce and tomato on a brioche bun unless otherwise noted. Served with French fries, Cole slaw and a dill pickle. Substitute sweet potato fries 1.59. Substitute Onion Rings for 1.59.
Chipotle Bacon Burger
$11.99
Caramelized onions, smokehouse bacon, Swiss cheese, arugula and chipotle mayo.
Patty Melt*
$10.99
Grilled burger topped with caramelized onions and Swiss on grilled rye. *Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, nova salmon or eggs may increase your risk of food borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Build Your Own Turkey Burger
$10.99
Includes your choice of cheese and 1 sauce.
Build Your Own Black Bean Burger
$10.99
Includes your choice of cheese and 1 sauce.
Tuscan Chicken Sandwich
$11.99
Marinated Portobello mushroom, roasted red peppers and sliced red onion, stacked on a marinated chicken breast and topped with melted provolone.
Turkey Burger Patty Melt
$10.99
Topped with caramelized onions, chipotle mayo and Swiss on grilled rye.
Pastrami Burger*
$14.59
Build Your Own Grilled Chicken Sandwich
$10.99
Includes your choice of cheese and 1 sauce.
Tuscan Vegetarian Sandwich
$10.49
Marinated Portobello mushroom, roasted red peppers and sliced red onion, topped with melted provolone.
Black Bean Patty Melt
$10.99
Topped with caramelized onions, chipotle may and Swiss on grilled rye.
Chicken a la TooJay's
$12.59
A teriyaki marinated chicken breast topped with mushrooms, smokehouse bacon and melted Muenster on a brioche bun.
Burger a la TooJay's*
$12.59
Topped with mushrooms, smokehouse bacon and melted Muenster cheese. *Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, nova salmon or eggs may increase your risk of food borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Build Your Own Beef Burger
10.99
Includes your choice of cheese and 1 sauce.

$Classic Comforts

All dinners come with our famous Artisan rye and your choice of house salad, Caesar salad, cup of Matzo Ball or Chicken Noodle Soup. Upgrade to French Onion for .99. Upgrade the vegetable to Roasted Brussels Sprouts Medley for 1.49.
Grilled Chopped Sirloin*
$15.99
Black and Bleu Chopped Sirloin Bowl
$16.59
Blackened and smothered with rich balsamic caramelized red onions, gorgonzola cheese and fresh chopped green onions, served over mashed potatoes.
Fish & Chips Dinner
$16.59
3 Atlantic Cod fillets lightly battered English style and flash fried until crispy. Served with French fries, Cole slaw, dill pickle, tartar sauce and malt vinegar.
Broiled Cod
$16.59
Atlantic Cod fillets simply broiled with a lemon dill butter. Served with a rice pilaf, a fresh vegetableand fresh chopped herbs.
Roasted Stuffed Chicken Breast
$15.99
Filled with cornbread stuffing and topped with a lemon butter white wine sauce. Served with mashed potatoes, mushroom demi-glace and a fresh vegetable.
Beef Brisket Platter
$17.59
Our lean and tender brisket atop 2 crisp potato pancakes is topped with homemade mushroom gravy and served with fresh vegetable.
Everything Salmon*
$18.59
Old Fashioned Pot Roast
$16.99
Tender, slow roasted and topped with mushroom demi-glace, this traditional favorite is served with mashed potatoes and a fresh vegetable.
Baked Atlantic Salmon with Dill Sauce*
$17.99
Served with rice pilaf and a fresh vegetable. *Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, nova salmon or eggs may increase your risk of food borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Portobello Parmesan
$13.59
Roasted marinated Portobello mushroom topped with marinara sauce, roasted red pepper, melted provolone and Parmesan cheesesand garnished with scallions. Served with Roasted red potatoes and a fresh vegetable.
TooJay's Shepherd's Pie
$13.99
Made in-house with fresh ground beef and tender vegetables baked in an individual casserole dish and topped with mashed potatoes and melted Muenster cheese.
Stuffed Cabbage
$15.99
Our own homemade version of fresh ground beef rolled into succulent young cabbage leaves is topped with savory sweet and sour sauce and served with fresh vegetable.
Liver and Onions*
$14.59
Chicken Capri
$16.90
Sauteed with mushrooms, artichoke hearts and capers in a lemon butter white wine sauce. Served with roasted potatoes and a fresh vegetable
Traditional Turkey Dinner
15.99
Tender oven roasted turkey served with mashed potatoes and cornbread stuffing, topped with our turkey gravy. Served with a fresh vegetable and cranberry sauce.

$Desserts


Plain Cheesecake Slice
$6.99
Rugalach (3)
$2.99
Our famous rugalach meets a New Orleans classic to create a perfectly craveable dessert. Your choice of chocolate or our seasonal rugalach battered, fried and coated with powdered sugar.
Key Lime Pie
$4.99
Made with authentic key limes, a scratch made graham cracker crust and finished with fresh whipped cream.
Killer Cake Slice
$6.99
Our most famous dessert. If you like chocolate, look no further.
Mini Napoleon & Eclair Combo (4)
$7.99
Delicate mini napoleons generously filled with wonderful creamy custard and mini eclairs dipped in rich chocolate ganache.
Tollhouse Square
$3.79
The ultimate "Blondie". Loaded with chocolate chips and walnuts.
Rice Pudding
$3.99
Coconut Cake
$6.99
White vanilla cake, layered with classic white frosting and coconut, garnished with coconut flakes.
Banana Dream
$6.99
Moist banana cake, rich banana cream, chocolate chips, walnuts and milk chocolate ganache. Irresistible!
Carrot Cake
$6.99
We've taken this traditional favorite to new h8s. Rich in carrots and layers of delectable cream cheese icing.
3 Mini Black & Whites
$2.59
Our legendary shortbread cookies smothered in chocolate and vanilla icing.
Mini Napoleon & Eclair Combo (2)
$4.59
Delicate mini napoleons generously filled with wonderful creamy custard and mini eclairs dipped in rich chocolate ganache.
Combo Dessert For Too
$11.99
Your choice of any 2 slices of our signature cakes
Chocolate Layer Cake
$6.99
3 layers of moist chocolate cake separated by rich chocolate mousse and covered with our special fudge frosting.
Brownie
$3.79
Rich with chocolate and walnuts.
Cheesecake with Strawberries
$7.59
Our homemade New York style cheesecake with graham cracker walnut crust topped with garden fresh strawberries and puree.
Macaroons (3)
2.59

$Kid'S Menu

All lunch and dinner items come with a mini black and white cookie and a choice of two sides.
Grilled Cheese
$4.59
Jr. Tuna Melt
$5.59
Tuna served atop a toasted english muffin with tomato and melted muenster.
Hamburger
$5.59
Deli Dog
$4.59
Kid's Fountain Beverage
$1.99
Kid's Lemonade
$1.99
Mac n' Cheese
$5.59
Chicken Salad Chop Chop
$5.59
Chicken tenders atop fresh greens and chopped carden vegetables.
Dippin' Chicken'
$5.59
Chicken tenders served with Barbeque, honey mustard and ketchup dipping sauces.
Cheeseburger
$5.59
Kid's Chocolate Milk
$1.99
Kid's Milk
$1.99

Menu for TooJay's is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

Check Other Restaurant Menu