Starters
Red Conch Chowder
$3-6
Conch Fritters
$11
Fried Calamari
$11
Fried Fish Fingers
$9
Ahi Yellowfin Tuna
$12
Seared, Sliced serviced with seaweed salad & our wasabi sauce
Buffalo Shrimp
$11
Steamed Shrimp
$11-18
Dz. Steamed Clams
$10
Our Smoked Fish Spread
$11
Caesar Salad
$5-15
With our homemade Caesar dressing, croutons & parmesan
Johnny's Salad
5-15
Romaine with, tomatoes, onions & croutons with our homemade dressing (ranch, Italian & a little blue cheese)
$Sandwiches
All served with lettuce, tomato & a side of our homemade coleslaw. Add fries, potato salad, black beans & rice or new potatoes for an additional $2. Add cheese $1. Add gluten free bun to any sandwich $1Fried, Grilled, Blackened Catch of the Day
$10
Fried, Grilled, Blackened Chicken Sandwich
$9
Clam Po Boy
$10
Fried clams topped with our coleslaw on a fresh sub bun
Seared Ahi Tuna
$12
1/4# All Beef Hot Dog
$6
Char-Grilled Hamburger
6
$Specialty Sandwiches
Johnny's Rambler & Fries
$11
Fresh fried catch of the day on grilled rye with melted American cheese, tomato & tartar
German Fish Sandwich & Fries
$11
Fried catch of the Day on grilled Rye with coleslaw & melted muenster Cheese
George's Bavarian Fish Sandwich & Fries
$12
Grilled catch of the day topped with sautéed mushrooms, onions & melted cheese on our new pretzel roll
Bavarian Burger & Fries
10
$Platters
Served with choice of French fries, new potatoes, potato salad or black beans & rice & our coleslawFried or Grilled Fish of the Day
$13
Fried Clam Strips
$12
Fried Calamari
$12
Seared Ahi Yellowfin Tuna
$14
Fried Shrimp
$14
Fried Coconut Shrimp
$15
Fried Chicken Fingers
$12
Fried Fish Burrito
11
$And for Kids
12 and under. Includes Fries $6.95Fried Fish Fingers
Chicken Fingers
Grilled Cheese
All Beef Hot Dog
Our Homemade Desserts
Key Lime Pie or Our Homemade Ice Cream Mud Pies
$4
Chocolate cookie crust, topped with chocolate sauce & whipped cream. Choose from coffee, chocolate almond or chocolate chip
Fresh Baked Cookies
2
chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin or white chocolate macadamia nut
$Drinks
Fountain Soda
$1
includes a free refill
Coke
$1
Diet Coke
$1
Sprite
$1
Pink Lemonade
$1
Ginger Ale
$1
Raspberry Sweet Tea
$1
Fresh Brewed Tea
$1
Bottled Water
$1
Fresh Brewed Coffee
1
$Draft Beers
Coors Light
$4
Yuengling
$4
Key West Sunset Ale
$5
Our 3 German Beers
5-7
Paulaner Oktoberfest, Munich Lager or Hefe Weizen
$Bottled Beer
Budweiser
$4
Bud Light
$4
Michelob Ultra
$4
Miller Light
$4
Laguna IPA
$4
Heineken
$5
Corona
5
$Wines by the Glass
$6Chardonnay
Pinto Grigio
White Zinfandel
Cabernet
Starters
Red Conch Chowder
$4-7
Fried Calamari
$11
Conch Fritters
$11
Fried Fish Fingers
$10
Dz. Steamed Clams
$10
Steamed Shrimp
$12-19
Buffalo Shrimp
$11
Seared Ahi Yellowfin Tuna
$12
Caesar Salad
$6-15
Johnny's Salad
6-18
Fresh Romaine with onions, tomatoes, croutons & our ranch with blue cheese & Italian Dressing
$Sandwiches
All served with choice of potato & a side of our homemade coleslawFried or Grilled Fish of the Day
$13
Johnny's Rambler
$14
Fried Fish of the Day on Grilled Rye with tartar, Tomato & melted American Cheese
German Fish Sandwich
$14
Fried Fish of the Day on Grilled Rye with coleslaw & melted Muenster Cheese
Bavarian Fish Sandwich
$15
Grilled Fish of the Day topped with sautéed mushrooms & onions & melted cheese on our pretzel Bun
Our ½# Prime Burger
14
$Platters
Served with choice of french fries, new potatoes, potato salad or black beans & rice & our coleslaw. Proud to serve Certified Angus BeefFried or Grilled Fish of the Day
$16
Fried Shrimp
$17
Fried Coconut Shrimp
$18
Fried Chicken Fingers
$13
Fried Fish Burrito
$14
Fried Clam Strips
$13
Fried Calamari
$14
Seared Ahi Yellowfin Tuna
18
$Children's Menu
For our guests 12 & under. All dinners come with French fries. Add Cheese or Gluten Free Bun $1All Beef Hot Dog or Grilled Cheese
$8
Fried Fish Fingers
$8
Chicken Fingers
8
$Our Homemade Desserts
Key Lime Pie or Our Homemade Ice Cream Mud Pies
$4
Chocolate cookie crust, topped with chocolate sauce & whipped cream. Choose from coffee, chocolate almond or chocolate chip
Fresh Baked Cookies
2
chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin or white chocolate macadamia nut
$Drinks
Fountain Soda
$1
includes a free refill
Coke
$1
Diet Coke
$1
Sprite
$1
Pink Lemonade
$1
Ginger Ale
$1
Raspberry Sweet Tea
$1
Fresh Brewed Tea
$1
Bottled Water
$1
Fresh Brewed Coffee
1
$Draft Beers
Coors Light
$4
Yuengling
$4
Key West Sunset Ale
$5
Our 3 German Beers
5-7
Paulaner Oktoberfest, Munich Lager or Hefe Weizen
$Bottled Beer
Budweiser
$4
Bud Light
$4
Michelob Ultra
$4
Miller Light
$4
Laguna IPA
$4
Heineken
$5
Corona
5
$Wines by the Glass
$6Chardonnay
Pinto Grigio
White Zinfandel
Cabernet
Menu for Fish Tales Market & Eatery is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
Check Other Restaurant Menu
The Deli
American, Deli Food
The Barracuda Grill
Seafood
Hideaway Cafe
American
Stuffed Pig
Diner
Marathon Pizza & Pasta
American, Pizza
Farella's Village Cafe
American
Island Fish Co
American, Seafood, Steak
Keys Fisheries
Seafood
Florida Keys Steak & Lobster House
Seafood, Steak
Cabana Breezes
American, Seafood