Sandwiches
Served With Potato Salad Or ColeSlaw, Lettuce, Tomato, Onions, Pickle. Add Fries For $1.50. Or Sweet Potato Fries For $2Cheeseburger
$6.50
half, pound angus beef charbroiled to order
Blue Cheeseburger
$7.50
Bacon Cheeseburger
$8.50
Egg Cheeseburger
$8.50
Meatball Sub
$8.99
Fresh Fish Sandwich
$9.99
catch of the day
Fresh Fish Sandwich
$10.99
snapper or grouper
Fresh Fish Sandwich
$13.99
hogfish
Lobster Francaise
$14.99
Soft-Shell Crab
$8.95
Crab Cake Sandwich
$14.99
Shrimp Reuben
$12.99
Cracked Conch
$9.99
Shrimp Po'boy
$9.99
Oyster Sandwich
$8.99
Delmonico Steak Sand
$12.99
French Dip
$9.99
Bacon
$6.99
lettuce, tom
Turkey Club
$7.99
Turkey Wrap
$7.99
Chicken Sandwich
$6.50
Fried Chicken Sub
$6.99
Prime Rib Burrito
12.99
strips of prime rib, with red and green peppers and onions, and a creamy sauce in a flour tortilla
$Salads
Ginger
$7.99
house or caesar
Cobb
$9.99
Chicken
$1.00
grilled or blackened
Shrimp
$5.00
snapper or tuna
Grouper
$7.00
Hogfish
$8.00
Colossal Shrimp
8.00
$Baskets
Served With Honey buns Potato Salad Or ColeSlaw, Fries Or Sweet Potato FingersShrimp Steamed In Beer
$12.99
Fried Lobster Basket
$14.99
Fried Shrimp Basket
$12.99
Fish And Chips
$12.99
catch of the day
Fish And Chips
$13.99
snapper or grouper
Fish And Chips
$15.99
hogfish
Chicken Tender Basket
$8.99
Fried Chicken Basket
8.99
$Arlene's Favorites
Served With Honey bunsSeafood Enchilada
$14.99
shrimp, scallops and fish in corn tortilla with cheese and roasted poblano sauce
Pork Adobo Bowl
$10.99
tender chunks of pork, heavy garlic, and a tangy brown sauce served over a bowl of white rice - a filipino treat!
Mom's Pot Roast
$10.99
tender beef, potatoes, sweet carrots, onions and a yummy gravy, over white rice
Baby Back Ribs
$11.99
half rack of tender ribs, baked beans and coleslaw
Tuna Sashimi Lunch
11.99
6 pieces of raw tuna and a cup of steamed white rice
$Appetizers
Calamari
$8.99
lightly breaded tentacles and tubes, marinara sauce.
Conch Fritters
$12.99-6.99
Shrimp Ceviche
$8.99
fresh chopped shrimp, onions, tomatoes, cilantro and lime juice with tortilla chips. award winner.
Crab Spinach Dip
$7.99
crabmeat, artichoke hearts, spinach and cheese with chips
Sauteed Alligator Tail
$10.99
gator cutlets sauteed, smothered in mushrooms, scallions with loads or garlic and butter. award winner.
Stuffed Mushrooms
$8.99
crabmeat stuffed, topped with hollandaise sauce.
Baby Back Ribs Appetizer
$9.99
half rack of tender tasty ribs.
Crab Cake
$8.99
broiled with lump blue crab.
Chicken Wings
8.99
12 garlic, bbq, or buffalo sauce.
$Sushi Appetizers
Lumpia
$7.99
ground pork spring rolls from the philippines
Hiyashi Wakame
$4.99
cold seaweed salad.
Edamame
$5.99
steamed young green soybeans.
Kanisu
$5.99
kani kama and cucumber in rice vinegar sauce with sesame seeds.
Sunomono
$9.99
conch, octopus, shrimp, kani kama & cucumber in rice vinegar sauce and sesame seeds.
Iidako
$5.99
sweet marinated baby octopus.
Spicy Conch Or Tuna Salad
$9.99
raw conch or tuna cucumber, ponzu and kimchee sauce.
Spicy Conch Or Tuna Salad
$11.99
combination
Tuna Tataki
$9.99
seared tuna with ponzu sauce and scallions.
Usuzukuri
$10.99
thin slices of raw fish with ponzu sauce and scallions. choice of hamachi, tuna, salmon or whitefish.
Yukee (Asian Beef Tartare)
$13.99
raw, tender beef, chopped with spicy sauce, scallions & sesame seeds.
Yukee (Asian Beef Tartare)
15.99
add a quail egg
$Soups
Manhattan Style Conch Chowder
$3.99-4.99
New England Style Clam Chowder
$4.99-3.99
Spicy Lobster Bisque
$3.99-4.99
Miso Soup
$3.99
Onion Soup
$4.99
33 Beer Chili
4.99
$Salads
Ginger
$7.99
house or caesar
Cobb
9.99
$Salad Additions
AddChicken
$5.00
grilled or blackened
Shrimp Skewers
$9.00
grilled or blackened
Snapper
$10.00
fresh grilled or blackened
Seared Tuna
$11.00
yellow fin tuna seared rare
Grouper
$12.00
fresh grilled or blackened
Hogfish
$15.00
fresh grilled or blackened
Colossal Cocktail Shrimp
12.00
6 chilled
$Raw Bar
Add Sides And Salad For Dinner Portion To Above $4.99Oysters
$11.99-6.99
fresh shucked
Clams
$10.99-5.99
middlenecks
Shrimp
$9.99
key west pinks steamed in beer
King Crab Legs
alaskan
Stone Crab Claws
Maine Lobster
see server for sizes available
Raw Bar Specialty
Oysters Flagler
$10.99-19.99
baked oyster topped with crab, spinach, artichoke hearts and cheese
Oysters Crawfish Benedict
$10.99-19.99
baked with mushrooms and diced crawfish in a savory lobster sauce, topped with hollandaise
Oysters Moscow
$10.99-19.99
raw oyster sour cream, horseradish, red & black lump roe.
Oysters Tokyo
$10.99-19.99
raw oyster sour cream, masago (smelt roe), kimchee sauce
Clams Casino
$17.99-9.99
bacon, red & green peppers, red onions on top, flash broiled.
Colossal Shrimp Cocktail
10.99
4 huge chilled shrimp with cocktail sauce and lemon.
$Extraordinary Sushi Rolls
Two Tear Rolls
$11.99
tempura shrimp, cream cheese, asparagus inside, chopped tuna, jalapeno-masago, spicy mayo on top
Surf N Turf Roll
$15.99
* lobster tempura, asparagus, cream cheese & scallions in side, topped with prime rib, finished with teriyaki glaze and sesame seeds.
King Crab Roll
$13.99
* hand picked king crab, cucumber, and avocado, inside out with sesame seeds.
Volcano Roll
$13.99
* california roll topped with baked topping that includes scallops, kani kama, and masago mixed together in a creamy sauce.
Latin Roll
$11.99
salmon, white fish, jalapeno, cilantro inside, avocado, spicy mayo, hot sauce on top
Bakery Roll
$13.99
* salmon, cream cheese and scallions, battered and fried includes teriyaki dipping sauce.
Spicy Tuna Sandwich
$12.99
tuna, spicy sauce, mayo & masago, sesame seeds.
Chicken Crunch Roll
9.99
* crunchy fried chicken and coleslaw inside, finished with wasabi ranch sauce.
$Sushi A La Carte
A La Carte Items Are (2) Pieces Per Order And Available As Sashimi - "Sliced Fish" Or Nigiri - "Hand-Molded Over A Ball Of Rice".Salmon
$4.49
sake
Tuna
$4.49
maguro
Japanese YY
$4.49
hamachi
Whitefish
$3.99
Imitation Crab
$3.99
kani (nigiri only)
Cooked Shrimp
$3.99
ebi (nigiri only)
Sea Urchin Roe
uni (no raw seafood)
Fatty Tuna
toro
Raw Red Prawn
ama ebi
Giant Clam
miru gai
Sweet Egg
$4.25
tamago
Squid
$4.25
ika
Octopus
$4.25
tako
Add A Quail Egg
$2.50
Eel
$4.99
unagi (nigiri only)
Smelt Roe
$4.99
masago (no raw seafood)
Salmon Roe
$4.99
ikura (no raw seafood)
Conch
$4.99
Scallop
$4.99
hotate gai (no raw seafood)
Flying Fish
5.99
tobiko roe (no raw seafood)
$Uramaki With Masago & Sesame Seeds
Inside Out RollsKimchee Roll
$7.99
tuna or conch, scallions, asparagus, spicy sauce.
Big Pine Roll
$7.99
* kani kama, cream cheese, avocado.
Big Jay Roll
$10.99
* big pine roll topped w/ eel, eel sauce.
Lisa Roll
$8.99
salmon, tuna, asparagus, cream cheese, topped with mayo & spicy sauce.
Nick Jr. Roll
$7.99
salmon, cream cheese, scallion.
Spider Roll
$10.99
soft-shell crab, asparagus, avocado & scallions with eel sauce.
Marathon Roll
11.99
* eel, salmon skin, asparagus, avocado, with eel sauce.
$Uramaki
W/ Sesame Seeds. Add Masago To Any Roll $1Mr. Lee Roll
$9.99
* tempura shrimp, avocado, cream cheese.
California Roll
$7.99
* kani kama, cucumber & avocado.
California Roll
$2.00
* put some tuna inside.
California Roll
$4.00
* top this roll with eel.
Rainbow Roll
$10.99
california roll topped with mixed raw fish.
Castaway Roll
$8.99
* broiled salmon, cream cheese, kani kama, avocado, scallion, mayo, eel sauce.
3-D Roll
$9.99
tuna, salmon, hamachi & scallions.
Dragon Roll
$6.99
* ebi, asparagus, avocado, & scallions topped with mayo.
Danny Roll
$6.99
tuna, cream cheese, cucumber & scallions.
Austin Roll
$8.99
tuna, salmon, cream cheese & scallions.
E.T. Roll
$6.99
* eel, tamago, avocado, with eel sauce.
Shrimp Tempura Roll
9.99
* tempura shrimp, avocado, asparagus, scallions and mayo.
$Hosomaki
Seaweed Outside Roll. Turn Any Roll Inside Out Add $1.50. Also Available As Handroll.Spicy Tuna Roll
$5.99
tuna, scallions spicy sauce.
J.B. Roll
$5.99
salmon, cream cheese & scallions.
Vegetable Roll
$5.99
* mixed vegetables.
Crab Roll
$5.99
* kani kama
Futomaki Roll
$11.99
* a big roll with crab (kani), tamago, kampyo, and masago.
Spicy Conch Roll
$5.99
conch, scallions with spicy sauce.
Salmon Skin Roll
$4.99
* broiled salmon skin, cucumber and eel sauce.
Cucumber Roll
4.99
* fresh cucumber
$Sashimi Dinners
Includes Miso Soup And Rice And Ginger Salad.Tuna Sashimi
$21.99
12 pieces of tuna
Sashimi Dinner
$21.99
3 tuna, 3 salmon, 6 whitefish
Special Sashimi Dinner
24.99
3 salmon, 3 tuna, 6 white fish, 3 conch, 3 octopus.
$Sushi Dinners
Includes Miso Soup & Ginger Salad.Unagi Don
$24.99
* bowl of sushi rice topped with eel, sesame seeds and eel sauce.
Chirashi
$21.99
bowl of sushi rice topped with a variety of raw fish, shellfish, and tamago.
Tuna Don
$20.99
bowl of sushi rice topped with raw slices of tuna.
Nigiri Dinner
$17.99
6 pieces of nigiri, 1 tuna roll.
Mori Dinner
19.99
9 pieces of nigiri, 1 tuna roll.
$Sushi & Sashimi Boats - Boat For 1 $29.99
(22Pcs). Includes Miso Soup Or Ginger Salad.California Roll (8 Pieces)
1 Piece Of Nigiri Each Of
ebi, tuna, salmon, hamachi, whitefish, kani.
2 Pcs Sashimi Each
tuna, salmon, whitefish, hamachi.
Sushi & Sashimi Boats - Boat For 2 $59.99
(42Pcs). Includes Miso Soup Or Ginger Salad.California Roll (8 Pieces)
tuna roll (6 pieces)
2 Pieces Nigiri Each
ebi, tuna, salmon, hamachi, whitefish, kani.
4 Pieces Sashimi Each
tuna, salmon, whitefish, hamachi
Signature Dinners
Entrees Include Salad, Vegetable, Honey buns And Choice Of Fries, Boiled New Potatoes Or Rice. Sweet Potato Fries Or Caesar Salads May Be Substituted For $1 Extra. Soups Will Not Be Substituted.Stuffed Hogfish
$25.99
fresh hogfish stuffed with shrimp and scallops in a creamy seasoned mix and encrusted with japanese breadcrumbs, then baked to golden brown.
Snapper Mazatlan
$25.99
fresh local snapper sauteed with artichoke hearts, tomatoes, mushrooms & scallions in a white wine cream basil sauce. taste of the islands award winner.
Island Tuna
$25.99
yellow fin tuna steak, lightly encrusted with cracked pepper, seared and wrapped in a ginger, wasabi crepe, drizzle with teriyaki sauce. we recommend this rare to medium.
Grouper Dijonnaise
$25.99
fresh local grouper, sauteed with mushrooms, dijon mustard-cream sauce.
Fish Of The Day
$23.99
we buy fresh hogfish, snapper, grouper, tuna and sometimes others daily. these are available as our house specialties (above) or grilled, blackened, sauteed, lemon caper, broiled, or fried.
Shrimp Steamed In Beer
$24.99
large key west pink shrimp, steamed in old bay and beer. seconds on the house. no sharing.
Lemon Herb Chicken
$13.99
boneless chicken breast, marinated in fresh herbs and secret stuff rolled in breadcrumbs and grilled.
Fish Sandwich Dinner
$12.99
fish of the day, fried, grilled or blackened
Castaway Cheeseburger
$9.99
1/2lb. sirloin burger
Gilligan's Cut
$18.99
fresh cut 12oz. new york strip.
Ginger's Cut
$16.99
8oz. aged certified angus sirloin.
The Howell's Cut
$29.99
8oz. fresh cut filet mignon, with sauce bearnaise, 3 shrimp, asparagus.
The Skipper's Cut
$26.99
like it rare? 2+ inch thick aged certified angus sirloin weighs in at a full pound. recommend this cooked rare to medium rare to keep it tender and juicy.
The Skipper's Cut
$2.00
sauteed mushrooms add
The Skipper's Cut
$2.00
blue cheese crusted add
The Skipper's Cut
$2.00
sauteed onions add
Crabcakes Castaway Style
$23.99
3 homemade with lump blue crab, broiled.
Sauteed Scallops
$24.99
10oz. of large sea scallops harvested off maine, seared in their own natural juices. our new england friends say these are the sweetest.
John's Famous Baby Back Ribs
$21.99
tender danish baby backs prepared using our top secret recipe.
Chicken Parmesan
$14.99
breaded, fried, loaded with parmesan and marinara sauce, over pasta.
Shrimp Scampi
$19.99
12 pink shrimp broiled in garlic, butter and herbs, linguini on the side.
Sauteed Alligator Tail
$21.99
gator tenderloin cutlets sauteed and smothered in mushrooms, scallions, loads of garlic. award winner.
Clams Pasta
$18.99
15 fresh middle-neck florida clams steamed in garlic herb butter or marinara sauce over linguini parmesan cheese included except by request.
Professor's Pasta
$13.99
(vegetarian) artichoke hearts, mushrooms, tomatoes, and scallions, sauteed in cream reduction with fresh basil served over pasta.
Prime Rib
aged certified angus, slow roasted, au jus.
Prime Rib
$20.99
mates cut 12oz
Prime Rib
$26.99
admirals cut 20oz
Florida Lobster
Florida Lobster
$7.00
add crabmeat stuffing
Florida Stone Crab Claws
Maine Lobster
live from our tank
Fried Shrimp
$17.99
jumbo hand battered shrimp.
Coconut Shrimp
$18.99
jumbo coconut-breaded with a sweet, spicy caribbean sauce.
Fried Oysters
$16.99
extra select oysters, plump & juicy.
Fried Captains Platter
23.99
fresh fish, shrimp, sea scallops, oysters clam strips & deviled crab.
$Signature Dinner Additions
Add.Chicken
$5.00
grilled or blackened
Shrimp Skewers
$9.00
grilled or blackened
Snapper
$10.00
fresh grilled or blackened
Seared Tuna
$11.00
yellowfin tuna seared rare
Grouper
$12.00
fresh grilled or blackened
Hogfish
15.00
fresh grilled or blackened
$You Catch 'Em - We Cook 'Em $15.99
Bring Your Catch Cleaned And Ready. Like Scales And Bones, Leave 'Em In And So Will We! Mazatlán Or Dijonnaise Style Add $3, Parmesan Style Add $2, Stuffed With Shrimp And Scallops Add $4, Stuff With Crabcake Add $5 Per FiletFried
Broiled
Blackened
Lemon Caper
Grilled
Combination Platters
With Any Entree. Add The Following At A Discount To Make Your Own Surf & Turf. $7 Plate Charges Applied For Sharing.Add A Florida Lobster Tail
Add 1lb Stone Crab
Add lb Jumbo King Crab
Add 1Ib Steamed Shrimp
18.00
$Castaway Desserts
Ask Your Server About Specialty Coffee Drinks Or Any Of Our Dessert Liqueurs.Key Lime Pie
$3.99
by the slice
Key Lime Pie
$18.00
take home a whole pie
Arlene's Homemade Cheesecake
$6.99
Arlene's Homemade Cheesecake
$1.50
add blueberry or cherry topping.
Chocolate Layer Cake
$6.99
Chocolate Layer Cake
1.50
add a scoop of vanilla ice cream.
$Kids Appetizers
Cheese Sticks
$5.99
Kids Wings
4.99
$Children's Menu
(Ages 12 And Under). Includes Applesauce, French Fries, And Honey Buns.Spaghetti And Meatballs
$6.99
Plain Pasta
$4.99
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
$4.99
Chicken Strips
$5.99
Deviled Crab
$6.99
Clam Strips
$6.99
Corn Dog
$5.99
Fried Chicken
$8.99
Popcorn Shrimp
$8.99
Kids California Roll
$8.99
Kids Fish Fingers
8.99
$Kiddie Cocktails $3.99
With No Spill Souvenir CupFrozen Pink Lemonade
Pina Colada Smoothie
Mango Smoothie
Strawberry Smoothie
Banana Smoothie
Raspberry Smoothie
Draft Beer
Items With (*) Have No Raw SeafoodBud Select
light lager
Bud Light
light lager
Michelob Ultra
light lager
Yuengling Lager
american amber
Red Ale (Our Own Brew)
red ale
Shocktop
belgian style white
Sapporo
japanese rice lager
Spaten Dark Optimater
doppel bock
Kirin Ichiban
japanese rice lager
Landshark Lager
amercan adjunct lager
Key West Sunset Ale
amber ale
Kronenberg 1664
euro pale lager
Drifter Pale Ale
american pale ale
Woodchuck Pear Cider (Gluten Free)
cider
Spaten Oktoberfest
oktoberfest
Kona Longboard
american pale lager
Warsteinter Pilsner
german pilsner
Sam Adams Winter Lager
winter lager
Sierra Nevada
american pale ale
Harp Lager
euro pale lager
Smithwicks Irish Ale
irish red ale
Hacker Pschorr
hefeweizen
Moretti
euro pale lager
Paulaner
hefeweizen
Tucher
hefeweizen
Guinness Stout
irish sry stout
Fuller's London Porter
english porter
Left Handed Milk Stout
milk/sweet stout
Miller Lite
light lager
Dos Equis Amber
vienna lager
Amber Bock
bock
Arrogant Bastard Ale
american strong ale
Magic Hat #9
not quite pale ale
Menu for Castaway is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
Check Other Restaurant Menu
The Hurricane Bar & Grille
American, Bar Food
Panda House Chinese Restaurant
Chinese
La Nina Cafeteria
Cuban, Latin American
.png)
Tarpon Creek Bar & Grill
American (New), Seafood
King Seafood
Seafood
Grassy Key Outpost Market & Grill
American, Burgers, Pizza
Sweet Savannah's Bake Shop & Ice Cream Cafe
Bakery & Pastries, Desserts
Fish Tales Market & Eatery
Sandwiches, Seafood
The Deli
American, Deli Food