Breakfast
Cuban Toast
$2.95
hot pressed and buttered cuban bread
Cuban Toast
$1.00
add cheese for an extra
2 Egg Breakfast
$7.95
2 eggs, cooked your way, served with home fries your choice of white wheat or rye toast
2 Egg Breakfast
$2.00
add bacon, ham or sausage for an extra
Steak And Eggs
$14.95
6 ounce n.y. strip and 2 eggs cooked your way, served with home fries and your choice of white, wheat or rye toast
French Toast
$8.95
the classic french toast, served with side of fresh fruit and greek yogurt and the famous coco banana sauce
Granola And Yogurt With Fruit
$6.95
4 ounce, of yogurt topped with granola served with fresh fruit of the day
Pancakes
$7.95
full stack of pancakes, served with butter, maple syrup
Pancakes
$1.00
add blueberries, strawberries, bananas, chocolate chips or nuts for an extra
Short Stack
$5.95
half stack of pancakes, served with butter, maple syrup
Short Stack
$1.00
add blueberries, strawberries, bananas, chocolate chips or nuts for an extra
Huevos Rancheros
$10.95
two eggs over a tortilla with cheese, salsa, black beans and home fries
Breakfast Sandwich
8.95
scrambled eggs with cheese, served on your choice of bread and served with home fries
$Omelets
All Omelets Served With Your Choice Of White, Wheat Or Rye Bread And Home FriesCheese
$7.95
classic omelet with your choice of american, swiss, cheddar or feta cheese
Veggie
$9.95
peppers, mushrooms, onions and tomatoes with your choice of american, swiss cheddar or provolone cheese
Ham And Cheese
$9.95
chopped ham and your choice of american swiss, cheddar or provolone cheese
Build An
$7.95
your choice of american, swiss, cheddar or provolone cheese
Build An
1.00
choose from: onions, mushrooms, peppers, tomatoes, ham, sausage, bacon or pico de gallo
$Breakfast Sides
Choice Of Bagels Are: Plain, Cinnamon Raisin, Poppy Seed Or Sesame SeedSide Of Bacon
$3.95
Side Of Sausage
$3.95
Side Of Ham
$3.95
Cereal
$3.95
with milk
English Muffin
$1.95
Side Of Toast
$1.95
Blueberry Muffin
$2.95
Home Fries
$3.95
Single Egg
$1.95
cooked your way
Bagel
3.95
with cream cheese
$Lunch Sandwiches
Catch Of The Day Sandwich
$13.95
6 ounce. catch, grilled or blackened served on a lighthouse bun
Lighthouse Hamburger
$9.95
half pound hamburger, charbroiled and served on a lighthouse bun
Build Your Burger Your Way
$1.00
add cheese, bacon, mushrooms, grilled onions or blue cheese
Chicken Sandwich
$8.95
chicken breast, grilled or blackened and served on a lighthouse bun
Chicken Sandwich
$1.00
add cheese, bacon, mushrooms, grilled onions, or blue cheese
New York Strip Sandwich
$14.95
6 ounce n.y. strip, cooked to order, and served on a lighthouse bun
New York Strip Sandwich
$1.00
add grilled onions or sauteed mushrooms
Grilled Cheese
$7.95
the classic grilled cheese, served on your choice of white, wheat or rye bread
Grilled Cheese
$1.00
add bacon and/or tomato for an extra
The Caprese
$11.95
thick sliced tomato, fresh soft mozzarella, fresh basil and a pesto dressing, served on a wrap
The Turk
$9.95
thin sliced roasted turkey breast, swiss cheese, cranberry mayo and bacon. your choice of crunchy baguette, healthy wheat or a wrap
Likeable French
9.95
glazed ham and brie cheese with a swipe of full grain dijon and cornichon pickles
$Dinner Entrees
All Entrees Served With Steamed Vegetables And Your Choice Of Black Beans, Yellow Rice Or French Fries. After Dinner, Enjoy Cafe Con Leche Or Bucci Or An American Coffee.N.Y. Strip
$19.95-24.95
rubbed with a special lbis bay dry rub, grilled to perfection and served with a burgundy demi glaze
N.Y. Strip
$1.00
add mushrooms or grilled onions
N.Y. Strip
$4.00
add shrimp for an extra
N.Y. Strip
recommended wine: trivento malbec reserve (argentina)
Fresh Catch Dinner
$19.95
"out of the waters, into the pan" your choice of chargrilled or blackened and topped with a roasted corn butter sauce
Fresh Catch Dinner
recommended wine: william hill chardonnay (california)
Grilled Shrimp
$21.95
skewed grilled local jumbos, lightly seasoned and chargrilled and topped with an mango chutney
Grilled Shrimp
recommended wine: lucky star chardonnay (california)
Seared Sesame Tuna
$22.95
our sushi-grade tuna steaks are coated with white and black sesame seeds and lightly seared and served with a ponzu sauce and a homemade wasabi
Seared Sesame Tuna
recommended wine: whitehaven sauvignon black (new zealand)
Lobster Ravioli
$21.95
ravioli stuffed with lobster meat and served with a sherry and shrimp cream sauce with fresh spinach and topped with parmesan cheese
Lobster Ravioli
recommended wine: granial brut sparkling wine (france)
The Bubba Chick
$22.95
four piece honey-glazed bbq chicken
The Bubba Chick
recommended wine: casillero diablo sauvignon blanc (chile)
Lobster Tail Dinner
$21.95
steamed 6 ounce, lobster tail served with drawn butter
Lobster Tail Dinner
$8.95
add for twin tails
Lobster Tail Dinner
recommended wine: casillero diablo sauvignon blanc (chile)
Surf And Turf
$28.95-34.95
8 or 12 ounce new york strip rubbed with a special lbis bay dry rub and served with a burgundy demi glaze and a 6 ounce. lobster tail
Surf And Turf
$1.00
add mushrooms or grilled onions for a
Surf And Turf
recommended wine: mark west pinot noir (california)
For The Sweet Tooth
Curtis' Killer Key Lime Pie
$5.95
we waited for a better than the rest key lime pie recipe to come along, and in walked curtis. yes folks, there is a god of key lime pie, and he has blessed this one
Curtis' Killer Key Lime Pie
$1.00
add for ice cream
Chocolate Lava Cake
$8.95
we love lava cake, ours is baked then topped with coco's banana sauce. yummy
The Serendipity Frozen Hot Chocolate
8.95
cheers to andy warhol. he fell in love with this decadent dessert, and the gentleman who created it. it's authentic, made with serendipity ingredients and recipe. just like the way andy liked it
$For The Other Guys
Key West Lemonade
absolut citron, pink lemonade and a dash of triple sec
Irish Ginger
jameson irish whiskey, ginger ale and a wedge of lime
Lbis Bay Lemonade
lemon and simple syrup, muddled into a lemonade, with stoli blueberri and soda water
Wild Summer
distilled vodka, ice tea and a splash of cranberry juice
Lemon Bloody Mary
absolut citron and zing zang bloody mary mix
By The Bay
lemon, fresh mint and simple syrup, muddled into a lemonade, with stoli gran apple and soda water
Mango Breeze
pinnacle mango vodka, with pink lemonade and topped with unsweetened iced tea
Cool Cucumber Mojito
made jim's secret ingredient (don't worry about it, it's great)
Lbis Berry
fresh berries and simple syrup, muddled together, with white rum and soda water
For Everybody
Cafe Con Leche
Bucci
An American Coffee
Beers In The Bottle
Budweiser
Coors Light
Yuengling
Michelob Ultra
Bud light
Corona
Heineken
Blue moon
Miller light
Corona Light
Amstel
Key West Sunset Ale
Menu for The American Shoal Lighthouse is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
Check Other Restaurant Menu
Duffy's
Seafood, Steak
Mangia Mangia Pasta Cafe
Italian
Kennedy Cafe
Central Asian, Italian, Mediterranean, Turkish
The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.
American (New), Seafood
Mr. Z's
Cheesesteaks, Pizza, Sandwiches
Origami Sushi Bar
Japanese, Sushi
The Conch Shop
Caribbean, Seafood
Vito's Piazza
Italian, Pizza
B.O.'s Fish Wagon
Seafood
Island Joe's Cafe
Coffee & Tea, Sandwiches
Mattheessen's 4th Of July Ice Cream Parlor
Burgers, Desserts, Sandwiches
Charlie Mac's
Barbecue