Brother Jimmy's BBQ

Brother Jimmy's BBQ Menu

(203) 823-9780
196 Crown St, New Haven, CT 06510

Starters


Hush Puppies
Comes with maple butter.
Frickles
Served with horseradish sauce.
BBQ Rib Tips
Served with original BBQ sauce.
Crispy Popcorn Shrimp
Served with Cajun or Buffalo style.
Humongous Nachos
$18.00
Choice of pulled pork, pulled chicken, or brisket.
Southern Fondue
$16.00
Beer cheese, jalapenos, and waffle fries.
Inside-Out Jalapeno Poppers
$12.00
Served with beer cheese.
Spinach and Artichoke Dip
$14.00
Served with tortilla chips.
Hand-Cut Loaded Fries
$13.00
Add pork, chicken or brisket for an additional charge.
Hand-Cut Loaded Tots
$11.00
Add pork, chicken or brisket for an additional charge.
Chicken and Waffle Skewers
$13.00
Served with bourbon maple syrup.
Quesadilla
$10.00
Served with salsa and sour cream. Add pork, chicken or veggie for an additional charge.
Buffalo Cauliflower
$16.00
Served with blue cheese.
Pig Pick
$22.00
Rib tips, naked wings, hush puppies and poppers with sauce.
Original Chicken Fingers
With honey mustard.
Chipotle Chicken Fingers
With ranch dressing.
Buffalo Chicken Fingers
With blue cheese dressing.
Wings
Bone-in or out. Choice of sauce.
BBQ Wings
Cut wings with our southern rub, smoked and basted with our special sauce.
BBQ Minis
$13.50
3 per order. Choose from pulled pork, pulled ABF chicken, or smoked brisket add $1.50 more
Buffalo Chicken Sliders
$13.50
With homemade blue cheese dressing and lettuce.
Catfish Bites
Cornmeal crusted and served with homemade roasted tomato tartar sauce.
Fried Green Tomatoes
$11.75
With homemade ranch dressing.
Peel n' Eat Shrimp
$12.50
A taste of the ol' Bay, with cocktail sauce.
Pimento Cheese Dip
$11.75
Saltines, hot peppers and pickles.
Smoked Meatball Sliders
$13.25
Pork and beef, smoked then tossed with bourbon-chipotle BBQ sauce with cheddar cheese on a potato roll. 3 per order.
Smokin' Chili
$7.00
Topped with cheddar and red onion.
Cheeseburger Sliders
$14.00
3 pieces. Served with cheddar and pickle.
Buffalo Chicken Sliders
$14.00
3 pieces. Served with blue cheese.
Pulled Pork Sliders
$14.00
3 pieces. Served with coleslaw.
BBQ Brisket Sliders
$14.00
3 pieces. Served with pickles.
Pulled Chicken Sliders
14.00
3 pieces. Served with original BBQ sauce.

$Salads

Add fried shrimp, pulled chicken, smoked turkey or pulled pork for an additional charge.
House Salad
$9.50
Chopped Cobb Salad
$15.50
Salad mix, onion, tomato, bacon bits, crumbled blue cheese, avocado and grilled, fried or buffalo ABF chicken.
Wright Salad
$11.75
Romaine lettuce, wild rice, spiced pecans, sweet onions, dried cranberries, and apples. Served with herb vinaigrette.
Blackened Chicken Caesar
$13.75
Romaine with red spiced chicken, corn bread croutons, and home made Caesar dressing
Southern Cobb Salad
$15.00
Seasonal greens, tomato, crumbled blue cheese, smoked bacon, avocado, and onion.
Classic Wedge Salad
$13.00
Iceberg lettuce, smoked bacon, tomato, red onion, and homemade blue cheese dressing.
Caesar Salad
$13.00
Romaine with cornbread croutons and homemade Caesar dressing.
Hearty Kale Salad
$14.00
Baby kale, Brussels sprouts, tomatoes, almonds, pecorino cheese, balsamic vinegar.
Seasonal Field Greens Salad
$14.00
Granny Smith apple, candied pecans, goat cheese, red wine vinaigrette.
Brother Jimmy's Burger Salad
$17.00
BJ burger, lettuce, tomato, cheese, cucumber, onions, bacon, special sauce.
Turkey Burger Salad
17.00
All-natural turkey burger, kale, apple, crumbled blue cheese, avocado, dried cranberries, house buttermilk-dill dressing.

$Tacos

3 of 1 kind.
Grilled Shrimp Tacos
$13.00
Roasted corn salsa.
Pulled Pork Tacos
$13.00
Grilled pineapple slaw.
Fried Catfish Tacos
$13.00
Roasted corn salsa.
Pulled Chicken Tacos
13.00
Grilled pineapple slaw.

$Mains

Served with 1 side and pickles.
'Till Sold Out Brisket
$25.00
Out beloved Brother Jimmy's competition-winning Black Angus brisket smoked for up to 14 hours. Choice of lean or marbled.
BJ's Signature Carolina Pulled Pork
$18.00
Brother Jimmy's Carolina clear BBQ sauce.
Low Country BBQ Mac and Cheese
$19.50
Slow smoked pulled pork, creamy cheese sauce.
Chicken Dinner Platter
$21.00
Seasoned flour, Southern spice, cornbread.
1/2 BBQ Chicken Platter
$19.00
Smoked, grilled and basted in Brother Jimmy's Original BBQ sauce. Served with 2 sides, cornbread and pickles.
BBQ Combo
$24.75
Served with 2 sides, cornbread and pickles.
Baby Back Ribs Platter
$24.75
Smoked and finished on the grill with a sweet and tangy sauce
Northern Style Ribs Platter
$23.75
Smoked and then grilled with Brother Jimmy's Original BBQ sauce. Served with 2 sides, cornbread and pickles.
Sliced Brisket Platter
$22.00
Smoked for up to 12 hours, lean or marbled. Served with 2 sides, cornbread and pickles.
Southern Ribs
$23.75
Smoked with brother Jimmy's Memphis style rub.
Pulled BBQ Chicken
$18.00
Brother Jimmy's sweet BBQ sauce.
Country Catfish
$21.00
Choice: fried with cornmeal crust or simply grilled with roasted tomato tartar sauce.
"Wet" Award Winning Ribs
$24.00
St. Louis style, smoked, grilled, baked.
"Dry Rub" Award Winning Ribs
$24.00
21 spice ribs, smoked 11 hours.
"Half and Half" Award Winning Ribs
26.00
1/2 wet and 1/2 dry rub ribs.

$Sandwiches and Burgers

Served with 1 side and pickles. Add smoked bacon for an additional charge.
BJ’s Pulled Pork BBQ Sandwich
$13.00
Pulled pork and slaw, our signature sandwich.
Pulled Chicken Sandwich
$13.00
Our pulled BBQ chicken with slaw.
Carolina Pulled Pork Sandwich
$13.75
Served with 1 side and pickles.
Sliced Brisket Sandwich
$15.00
Lean or marbled. Served with 1 side and pickles.
BBQ Brisket Sandwich
$17.00
14 hour smoked and sliced beef brisket.
Bourbon Brisket Press Sandwich
$17.00
Cheddar, onion rings, bourbon BBQ sauce.
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
$14.00
Chipotle BBQ sauce, lettuce, tomato, onion.
Sloppy Jimmy Sandwich
$16.00
Our homemade BBQ beef and pork sloppy joe.
Fried Catfish Sandwich
$17.00
Cornmeal crust, roasted tomato tartar sauce, avocado or simply grilled.
Grilled Mac and Cheese Sandwich
$13.00
Pressed and melted on Texas toast. Add pulled pork for an additional charge.
BJ's Burger
$15.00
1/2 lb. burger, lettuce, tomato, cheddar cheese.
Carolina BBQ Burger
$16.00
1/2 lb. burger, chipotle BBQ sauce, cheddar cheese, and onion rings.
Morning Tailgate Sandwich
$17.00
1/2 lb. burger, fried egg, grilled onions, guacamole.
The Big Dipper Burger
$15.00
Classic burger, hand-cut fries, pourable cheese sauce.
Dixie Chicken Sandwich
$14.00
Fried chicken, jalapeno Jack cheese, onion rings.
Farmer Brown Sandwich
$15.00
Grilled portobello, Swiss, marinated peppers.
Freebird Sandwich
$15.00
Turkey burger, Swiss cheese, grilled onions.
Smoked Turkey Wrap
13.00
Avocado, tomato, house-smoked turkey, shredded lettuce and honey mustard.

$Sides


Macaroni and Cheese
$7.00
Mashed Potatoes
$7.00
Comes with white gravy.
Tater Tots
$7.00
Collard Greens
$7.00
Fried Okra
$7.00
Basket of Cornbread
$7.00
Carolina-Style Coleslaw
$7.00
Spiced Sting Beans
$7.00
Fried Brussel Sprouts
$7.00
Corn on the Cob
$7.00
Hand Cut French Fries
$7.00
BBQ Baked Beans
$7.00
Extras
$0.50
Need a little extra?
BBQ Sauce
$0.50
Blue Cheese
$0.50
Buffalo Sauce
$0.50
Chipotle Aoili
$0.50
Chipotle Sauce
$0.50
Fried Okra
$5.00
Honey Mustard
$0.50
Original Sauce
$0.50
Potato Salad
$5.00
Ranch
$0.50
Sweet Potato Tots
5.00

$Sandwiches


Jimmy's Burger
$17.00
1/2 lb. of Schweid and Sons beef, grilled to perfection, on a buttered toasted roll. Served with your choice of 1 side and pickles.
BBQ Burger
$15.00
Our 1/2 lb. custom blend, basted in chipotle BBQ sauce and topped with cheddar and onion rings. Served with your choice of 1 side and pickles.
Turkey Burger
$17.00
Well-seasoned ground turkey on a buttered toasted roll with BBQ chipotle mayo and grilled onions. Served with your choice of 1 side and pickles.
Sloppy Jimmy
$13.75
Our version of a Sloppy Joe, with pork and beef, tomato base and a hint of heat. Sweet, smokey, tangy, and messy on a butter toasted roll.
BBQ Grilled Chicken Sandwich
$13.50
Basted with our original BBQ sauce and served with shredded lettuce, tomato, and onion. Served with your choice of 1 side and pickles.
Country Catfish Sandwich
$14.50
Griddled or fried, with roasted tomato tartar sauce, avocado and tomato on a buttered toasted roll. Served with your choice of 1 side and pickles.
Press'd Bourbon Brisket Sandwich
$15.00
Sliced brisket with cheddar, onion rings, and our homemade bourbon BBQ sauce on Texas toast. Served with your choice of 1 side and pickles.
Fried Chicken Sandwich
$13.50
Original with lettuce and tomato. Buffalo with blue cheese and shredded lettuce. Served with your choice of 1 side and pickles.
Portobello Mushroom Sandwich
$13.50
Grilled portobellos with Swiss cheese, topped with onion rings and chipotle BBQ mayo on a butter-toasted roll. Served with your choice of 1 side and pickles.
Grilled Mac N' Cheese
$12.75
Mac n' Cheese, sliced cheddar, pressed and melted on Texas Toast. Add bacon for $2.00
Smoked Bologna Sandwich
$14.00
With mustard-mayo, and pickle relish on Texas toast. Served with your choice of 1 side and pickles.
Toasted Shrimp Sandwich
14.75
Fried shrimp topped with slaw and roasted tomato tartar sauce. Served on Texas toast. Served with your choice of 1 side and pickles.

$Beverages


Quart of Sweet Tea
$5.00
Quart of Homemade Ice Tea
$5.00
Quart of Homemade Lemonade
$5.00
Boylan's Cane Sugar Soda
$3.50
Bottled Soda
Cheerwine Cherry Soda
$3.50
Carolina Favorite Since 1917.
Bottle Water
$3.00
Soda Can
$4.00
Quart of Soda
$5.00
Quart of Juice
5.00

$Southern Favorites


Country Catfish
$22.50
Spiced and griddled or fried with roasted tomato tartar sauce, a choice of 2 sides and cornbread.
Nashville Hot Chicken
$19.50
Extra spicy, served on Texas toast with extra pickles. And two sides
Southern Fried Chicken
$19.00
Tossed in our seasoned flour then finished off with our southern spice, a choice of 2 sides and cornbread.
Dixie Hoe Cake
$18.50
Choice of pulled pork or pulled ABF chicken, on top of a corn cake with cole slaw and chipotle BBQ sauce. And two sides
Grilled Cab Strip Steak
24.50
Served with homemade steak sauce, a choice of 2 sides and cornbread.

$Lunch Menu


Pulled Pork Wrap Lunch Special
$10.50
Pulled pork, pickles and slaw served with a choice of side.
Pulled Chicken Wrap Lunch Special
$9.50
Pulled chicken, bacon and cheddar served with choice of side.
Brother Jimmy's Cuban Lunch Special
$11.00
Sliced smoked pork, country ham, Swiss cheese and frickles served with choice of side.
Blackened Catfish Sandwich Lunch Special
$13.00
Roasted tomato tartar sauce served with avocado and tomato.
BLFGT Lunch Special
$11.00
Applewood bacon, lettuce and our fried green tomato with mayo served with choice of side.
Smoked Turkey Wrap Lunch Special
$10.00
House smoked turkey with avocado, tomato, shredded lettuce and honey mustard.
BJ's Sliders Lunch Special
$10.00
2 per order. Cheeseburger, smoked meatball, Buffalo chicken, brisket 2-stop pulled pork or pulled chicken, served with choice of side.
BBQ Lunch Special
$14.95
Choice of house salad or cornbread, and a choice of Ribs, pulled pork, 1/4 BBQ chicken or pulled chicken. Served with choice of side and pickles.
Soup & Salad Lunch Special
14.00
Soup of the day with any sandwich.

$Kid's Menu

Served with a side.
Kid's BBQ Chicken Wings
$7.00
Kid's Hot Dog
$7.00
Kid's Mac and Cheese
$7.00
Kid's Burger
$7.00
Kid's Cheeseburger
$7.00
Kid's Chicken Fingers
$7.00
Kid's Pulled Pork Mini
$7.00
Kid's Pulled Chicken Mini
$7.00

Menu for Brother Jimmy's BBQ is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

Check Other Restaurant Menu