Breads
Please note that order must be placed 24 hours before pick up time.Sourdough Bread
$3.95
Cinnamon Swirl Bread
$4.50
Herb Bread
$3.95
Rye Swirl Bread
$4.25
Seven Grains Bread
$4.50
Honey Wheat Bread
$3.95
Wheat Bread
3.95
100% freshly ground whole wheat.
$Dinner Rolls
Per dozen. Please note that order must be placed 24 hours before pick up time.Honey Whole Wheat Rolls
$4.45
White Yeast Rolls
4.45
$Frosted Cinnamon Rolls
Please note that order must be placed 24 hours before pick up time. Nine inch round pan.With Nuts Frosted Cinnamon Roll
$7.95
Caramel Frosted Cinnamon Roll
$6.95
Sticky Buns Frosted Cinnamon Roll
$7.95
Singles Frosted Cinnamon Roll
1.95
$Sweet Breads
Please note that order must be placed 24 hours before pick up time.Banana Nut Sweet Bread
$4.95
Zucchini Sweet Bread
$4.95
Pumpkin Sweet Bread
$4.95
Amish Friendship Sweet Bread
5.95
$Jumbo Muffins
Please note that order must be placed 24 hours before pick up time.Banana Streusel Jumbo Muffin (4)
$5.95
Blueberry Streusel Jumbo Muffin (4)
$5.95
Morning Glory Jumbo Muffin (4)
5.95
$Cookies
Please note that order must be placed 24 hours before pick up time.Chocolate Chip Cookie
$2.95
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
$2.95
Cinnamon Oatmeal Crinkle Cookie
$2.95
Peanut Butter Cookie
$2.95
Oatmeal Peanut Butter Cookie
$2.95
Molasses Cookie
2.95
$Whoopie Pies
Please note that order must be placed 24 hours before pick up time. These pies are made in a deep dish ten inch pan. Mini pies six inch.Whoopie Pies
1.95
$Fruit Pies
Please note that order must be placed 24 hours before pick up time. These pies are made in a deep dish ten inch pan. Mini pies six inch.Blackberry Fruit Pie
$14.50
Rhubarb Fruit Pie
$14.50
Cherry Fruit Pie (Small)
$5.99
Apple Fruit Pie
$14.50
Cherry Fruit Pie
$14.50
Huckleberry Fruit Pie
$14.50
Red Raspberry Fruit Pie
$14.50
Strawberry Fruit Pie
$14.50
French Apple Fruit Pie
$14.50
Dark Sweet Cherry Fruit Pie
$14.50
Black Raspberry Fruit Pie
$14.50
Peach Fruit Pie
$14.50
Blueberry Fruit Pie
14.50
$Cream Pies
Please note that order must be placed 24 hours before pick up time. These pies are made in a deep dish ten inch pan. Mini pies six inch.Peanut Butter Cream Pie
$14.50
Lemon Meringue Cream Pie
$14.50
Coconut Cream Cream Pie
14.50
$Specialty Pies
Please note that order must be placed 24 hours before pick up time. These pies are made in a deep dish 10 inch pan. Mini pies six inch.Pumpkin Specialty Pie
$14.50
Chocolate Chess Specialty Pie
$14.50
Pumpkin Custard Specialty Pie
$14.50
Shoofly Specialty Pie
$14.50
Pecan Specialty Pie
14.50
Please note that order must be placed 24 hours before pick up time.
$Seasonal Fresh Fruit Pies
Please note that order must be placed 24 hours before pick up time. These pies are made in a deep dish ten inch pan. Mini pies six inch.Strawberry Seasonal Fresh Fruit Pie
$15.95
Blueberry Seasonal Fresh Fruit Pie
$15.95
Peach Seasonal Fresh Fruit Pie
$15.95
Cranberry Apple Seasonal Fresh Fruit Pie
$4.95
Menu for Heritage Amish Bake Shoppe is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
