Featured Items & Assortments
Some of our most popular treats and seasonal favorites! Please note that large orders (over 2 dozen treats) may not be handled same-day via GrubHub. Please call the store directly to schedule large orders in advance.Choose Your Fairy Faves
$29.75
Want a little bit of everything? Then this is for you!! Two jumbo sugar cookies, two cupcakes, two brownies/bars, one Whoopie Pie, and three Cakebites of your choice. Want two of the same flavor? No problem, just leave us a note!
Flower Cupcakes (6)
$20.25
Get six of our most popular flavors decorated as pretty roses for someone you love! 2 each Red Velvet, VaNIElla Squared, and Double Fudge.
6 Halloween Cakebite Gift Box
$10.75
Our Cakebites are a scary good Halloween treat! Get 3 Double Fudge with scary eyes and 3 other assorted flavors in a gift box, or double up to a dozen. (Just click the "upgrade to 12" option below.)
6 Halloween Cupcakes
$20.25
Adorable, yummy Halloween cupcakes: 2 Fairyfetti Monsters, 2 VaNIElla Squared Ghosts, and 2 Double Fudge with Halloween toppers! Want to get double? Just click the "upgrade to 12" option below! (Substitutions may apply if we're running low.)
6 Jumbo Halloween Shaped Cookies
$23.75
Jumbo Halloween sugar cookies: 2 Ghosts, 2 Mummies, and 2 Pumpkins! Want to get double? Just click the "upgrade to 12" option below! (Shape substitutions may apply if we're running low.)
Santa's Snack Gift Box
$29.95
A boxful of festive holiday treats fit for Santa and his elves! Pretzel Knots, Chocolate-covered Oreosâ„¢, 1 Gingerbread Man Cookie, and 1 Chocolate Chunk Cookie each in an individual plastic sleeve all packed cutely together in a small wooden crate, wrapped in cellophane and tied with a bow.
Sweet Loaf Gift Basket
$61.95
Share the “loaf†with those you love this Christmas! 3 Holiday Sweet Loaves wrapped individually, two kitchen towels, and a large cutting board all wrapped up in a Christmas tray with cellophane, tied with a bow. Loaf flavors may vary. Please note if you have specific requests (none of this year's loaves contain nuts; we do not currently have gluten-free loaf options).
Sweet Treats Gift Basket
$56.95
Get a little bit of everything to share the love! Candied popcorn, chocolate-covered pretzels, Oreo pops, novelty lollipops, chocolate-covered Oreos, and Cakebites, all wrapped up in a basket with cellophane, tied with a bow.
Big Game Cupcakes (6)
$20.25
Get ready to face off with 6 of your favorite cupcakes, all dressed up for the big game! Includes 3 Double Fudge and 3 VaNIElla Squared with 'Kansas City' and 'Tampa Bay' decorations
Box of 6 Cinnamon Rolls
$23.75
Baked fresh daily, these tasty treats are sure to please! Each 5-ounce cinnamon roll is topped with Cream Cheese frosting, and you can pop yours in the microwave for a few seconds to enjoy it warm. Saving some for tomorrow? No problem--just wrap them in plastic to keep them from drying out!
Holiday Sweet Loaf (single)
$9.50
1 pound sweet loaves are perfect for the holidays! Each one comes wrapped in cellophane with a bow. (Flavors change regularly! Limited number available each day. Please call us at 801-774-5011 if you would like to order several!)
We All Scream for Ice Cream Cupcakes!
21.75
One each of our summer special cupcakes: Caramel Waffle Cone Deluxe, Deluxe Brownie Hot Fudge Sundae, Mint Chocolate Chip, Orange Creamsicle, Rainbow Sherbet, and Root Beer Float. (6 cupcakes total)
$Cupcakes
Cupcakes (6)
$20.25
You will receive two of our seasonal flavors plus one Cookie Dough, one Red Velvet, one Oreo (R) Cookies and Cream, and one Fairy Fetti. Substitutions may apply! Note: Picture may not indicate flavors available at this time.If you select & quot;gluten free & quot;all cupcakes will be vanilla and chocolate gluten free with a variety of frostings and toppings.
Cupcakes (12)
$40.25
You will receive six of our seasonal flavors plus one Cookie Dough, one Red Velvet, one Oreo (R) Cookies and Cream, one Reese's (R) Peanut Butter, two Fairy Fetti. Substitutions may apply! Note: Picture may not indicate flavors available at this time.Large orders(over 2 dozen treats) may not be handled same - day via GrubHub.Please call the store directly to schedule large orders in advance.
Deluxe Filled Cupcake Assortment (6)
23.75
Get an assortment of six of our yummiest deluxe seasonal filled cupcakes delivered to your door! This month's filled cupcakes include Creme Brulee and Deluxe Cheesecake. (Substitutions may apply!)
$Cookies & Bars
Jumbo Cookies (6)
$20.25
Six of our delicious jumbo cookies! This assortment includes our Chocolate Chunk, Peanut Butter Explosion, and Fairy Fetti Delight cookies, plus additional cookies from our monthly and seasonal favorites. Substitutions may apply.Please indicate in the notes if you & #39;d like a different mix of the above flavors.
Jumbo Cookies (12)
$20.25
A dozen of our delicious jumbo cookies! This assortment includes our Chocolate Chunk, Peanut Butter Explosion, and Fairy Fetti Delight cookies, plus additional cookies from our monthly and seasonal favorites. Substitutions may apply. Please indicate in the notes if you&# 39;d like a different mix of the above flavors.
Signature Sugar Cookies (6)
$16.50
Six of our super popular round signature sugar cookies frosted with yummy Signature Vanilla frosting.
Iced Oatmeal Cookies (6)
$16.50
Six of our tasty oatmeal cookies frosted with yummy Signature Vanilla frosting. (FYI, our oatmeal cookie dough does include a little shredded coconut!)
Gluten-free Cookies (6)
$22.00
An assortment of 3 gluten-free chocolate chip and 3 gluten-free sugar cookies.
Box of Brownies & Bars (6)
$20.25
A few each of our everyday and seasonal bars. Currently this includes the Chocolate Chocolate Chip Brownie (vegan!), Caramel Chocolate Oat Blondie, and Sopapilla Cheesecake Bar. Substitutions may apply. Please indicate in the notes if you'd like a different mix, and we will accommodate if we can.
Black & White Cookies (6)
16.50
Six of our delicious chocolate chocolate chip cookies frosted with yummy Signature Vanilla frosting.
$Cakebites
Cakebites are temporarily unavailable for delivery due to high heat. Sorry! They will return when they can travel without melting. What are Cakebites ? We take our freshly baked cake and rich creamy frosting— blend them together, shape them into perfect little bite - sized pieces then dip them in chocolate.Cakebites (6)
$7.00
The Sweet Tooth Fairy's signature treat, now delivered straight to your door! You'll receive an assortment of our six most popular flavors in a plastic cup. Want it to be even cuter? Check out our packaging options! Please receive your delivery immediately! We are not responsible for melted chocolate on Cakebites left sitting in the heat.
Cakebites (12)
$14.00
The Sweet Tooth Fairy's signature treat, now delivered straight to your door! You'll receive an assortment of twelve from our most popular flavors in a plastic cup. Want them to be even cuter!? Check out the gift box options below. Please receive your delivery immediately! We are not responsible for melted chocolate on Cakebites left sitting in the heat.
Decorative Cakebites Gift Box
21.00
A dozen yummy Cakebites packed in a pretty package that lets someone know you're thinking of them!
$Treats for You to Make at Home
Bring home some of our favorite treat elements to make your own masterpieces!Cupcake Decorating Kit
$35.50
Always wanted to create your own cupcakes?? Get a dozen unfrosted cupcakes, frosting, and sprinkles to experiment with at home. Choose your cakes (2) and frostings (2). You'll get 6 of each selected cupcake flavor and 1 tub of each selected frosting, plus assorted sprinkles. Please note that requests for other frosting colors may not be possible with quick deliveries! If you would like a different color than what is in the list here, please give your order additional time (1 hour or more) and we will try to accommodate if we can! If we aren't able to color the frosting, we will send the natural colored frosting in the flavor you selected.
Jumbo Sugar Cookie Decorating Kit
$39.50
Decorate your own masterpieces with this family fun activity! A dozen shaped sugar cookies, frosting, and sprinkles to make and enjoy together. You'll get 12 jumbo cookies (baked already), 2 cups of sprinkles, and 1 tub per frosting flavor selected.
Frozen Cookie Dough (12)
$33.00
This is the sweetest "food storage"! A dozen of your favorite jumbo cookies to bake at home any time. Select your flavors, and have them delivered frozen straight to your door.
Menu for The Sweet Tooth Fairy is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
