Concretes
Andy's Custom Concrete
$3.99
Vanilla frozen custard blended with the topping of your choice.
Boot Daddy Concrete
$4.99
Vanilla frozen custard blended with oreo creme caramel and hot fudge.
Triple Chocolate Concrete
$4.74
Chocolate frozen custard blended with chocolate chip cookie dough and melted chocolate chip.
Snow Monster Concrete
$4.74
Vanilla frozen custard blended with strawberries and melted chocolate chip.
Butter Pecan Concrete
$4.99
Vanilla frozen custard blended with butterscotch and roasted pecans.
The Jackhammer
$4.89
We take your favorite 1 topping concrete and fill the center with the topping of your choice.
James Brownie Funky Jackhammer
7.54
Vanilla frozen custard blended with creamy peanut butter and brownies then filled with hot fudge.
$Pints & Quarts
Favorite Flavors
$3.49
Your choice of vanilla or chocolate frozen custard.
Specialty Pint Flavors
3.99
$Malts & More
Malts
$5.34
Vanilla frozen custard blended with your favorite topping and malt powder.
Shakes
$4.09
Vanilla frozen custard blended with your favorite topping.
Old-Fashioned Freezes
$4.09
Vanilla frozen custard blended with your favorite soda.
Old-Fashioned Sodas
$3.49
Scoops of vanilla frozen custard blended with your choice of cherry, chocolate, raspberry, strawberry, or key lime flavored syrup combined with seltzer.
Floats
$3.49
Scoops of vanilla frozen custard blended with your favorite soda poured over the top.
Zarlengo's Italian Ice
$2.39
Lemon, strawberry or raspberry lemonade flavor Italian ice tube.
Andy's Frozen Custard Bar with Vanilla
$10.99
Hard-dipped in milk chocolate, vanilla frozen custard salted caramel frozen custard.
Andy's Frozen Custard Bar with Chocolate
2.99
Hard-dipped in milk chocolate is frozen custard mint frozen custard coffee frozen custard.
$Cups
Chocolate
$1.84
Scoops of made fresh hourly frozen custard in a cup.
Vanilla
1.84
Scoops of made fresh hourly frozen custard in a cup.
$Featured Items
Rico Suave Jackhammer
$5.54
Vanilla Andy's frozen custard blended milk roasted pecans and cream with a center filled milk hot fudge.
Pretzel Caramel Crunch
$4.74
Strawberry Shortcake Sundae
$4.89
Cherry Bash
$6.14
Maraschino cherries almonds. Heath bar chocolate syrup.
Bootdaddy
4.99
$Splits
Andy's Banana Split
$5.99
Andy's vanilla frozen custard and a whole banana covered with delicious strawberries, marshmallow creme, crushed nuts and topped with a cherry.
Turtle Split
5.99
Andy's vanilla frozen custard and a whole banana covered with hot fudge, creme, caramel roasted pecans and topped with a cherry.
$Sundaes
Andy's Custom Sundae
$3.99
Vanilla frozen custard covered with your favorite topping and topped with a cherry.
The Original Straw-Ana
$4.74
Vanilla frozen custard covered with delicious strawberries and sliced bananas.
Andy's Ozark Turtle
$5.59
Vanilla frozen custard covered with hot fudge creme caramel roasted pecans and topped with a cherry.
Andy's Hot Fudge Sundae with Pecans
$4.99
Vanilla frozen custard covered with hot fudge, roasted pecans and topped with a cherry.
Stolen Brownie Sundae
$5.54
Vanilla frozen custard and homemade brownie covered with hot fudge, roasted pecans and topped with a cherry.
Andy's Kids Sundae
$2.99
Vanilla frozen custard covered with your favorite topping and topped with a cherry.
Kids' Sprinkles Sundae
2.99
Vanilla frozen custard covered with rainbow sprinkles and topped with a cherry.
$Drinks
Old-Fashioned Sprecher Soda
$1.74
Root beer or cream soda on tap brewed in Milwaukee.
Bottled Sprecher Soda
$2.19
Root beer, cream soda or orange dream.
Soft Drinks
$1.49
Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Dr Pepper, or orange.
Fresh Brewed Iced Tea
$1.89
Sweet, unsweet or raspberry.
Bottled Water
$1.89
Menu for Andy's Frozen custard is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
