Picked for you
Gourmet Milkshakes
$7.50
Personal Cakes
$7.00
Cookies (4 pcs)
$6.00
4 large and delicious chocolate chip cookies. Baked right here!
Cupcakes
5.00
Homemade cupcakes .. multiple flavors!
$Mains
Gourmet Milkshakes
$7.50
Vegan Milkshake
$7.50
We only use our own homemade vegan ice cream to create these delicious vegan shakes!
Hot Chocolate Shake
$7.50
Think frozen hot chocolate.
PB and J Shake
$7.50
A strawberry peanut butter masterpiece.
Seasonal Hand Packed Pint of Ice Cream
10.00
$Sweet Treats
Personal Cakes
$7.00
Cheesecakes - Personal Sized
$7.00
Cookies (4 pcs)
$6.00
4 large and delicious chocolate chip cookies. Baked right here!
Chocolate Chip Cookie | Dairy and GF
$4.50
Edible Cookie Dough
$6.00
Chocolate chip. Yum!
Vegan Edible Cookie Dough
$5.50
Chocolate chip 4.5 oz cup yeahh.
Fudge Brownie
$3.50
Brownie | Dairy and Gluten Free!
$5.00
Cupcakes
$5.00
Homemade cupcakes .. multiple flavors!
Chef's Selection Scoop-Wich
$6.00
One large scoop of premium ice cream sandwiched between two delicious cookies.
Frozen Chocolate Covered Bananas
4.50
$Combos
Cake Party
$30.00
A sampling of 5 personal sized cakes!
Cupcake Party
$17.50
Chef's selection of four of our most popular cupcakes!
Scoop-Wich Switch
$10.00
Two ice cream cookie sandwiches delicious cookies packed with decadent homemade flavors.
Ice Cream Cake Cup Party
36.00
Our amazing ice cream cake in a cup combo! Four of these delicious deserts. Enjoy!
$Ice Cream Cake Cups
An ice cream cake made in a cup .. and eat with a spoon! In the mood for ice cream cake but don't have 6 other friends handy that want some too? Don't worry - try one of our ice cream cake cups!Traditional Ice Cream Cake Cup
$10.00
Vanilla and chocolate ice cream with a chocolate cookie crunch middle, finished with vanilla frosting!
Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream Cake Cup
$10.00
Peanut butter cup ice cream with a chocolate cookie crunch, topped with vanilla frosting!
Cookie Monster Ice Cream Cake Cup
$10.00
A cross between oreo and cookie dough, in blue of course! We add some chocolate cookie crunch and top with vanilla frosting!
Mint Chip Ice Cream Cake Cup
$10.00
Mint chip ice cream and chocolate cookie crunch topped with vanilla frosting
Vegan Traditional Ice Cream Cake Cup
$12.00
Our vegan vanilla and vegan chocolate ice creams separated by our vegan oreo cookie crunch
Vegan Cookie Monster Ice Cream Cake Cup
12.00
Our vegan cookie monster ice cream, which is a cross between oreo and cookie dough, and blue of course! With a vegan oreo cookie crunch
$Cake Cups
Does ice cream cake contain actual cake? We solved this hotly debated topic by making both kinds! These cake cups are just like our ice cream cake cups - an ice cream cake for one that you eat with a spoon and with actual cake!Strawberry Cheesecake Cake Cup
$10.00
Strawberry and vanilla cake with strawberry ice cream. We also add cheesecake bites and top with vanilla frosting
Party Party Cake Cup
$10.00
Vanilla cake plus party cake ice cream. We also add rainbow sprinkles and vanilla frosting!
Death By Cake Cake Cup
$10.00
Chocolate cake and death by chocolate ice cream. We then add brownie bits and vanilla frosting!
Mocha Mudslide Cake Cup
10.00
Chocolate cake and oreo mudslide coffee ice cream! We add oreos and top with vanilla frosting
$Chocolates & Gifts
Confetti Pretzels
Chocolate covered pretzels that have been covered with candy! These can be ordered individually or get a dozen in a beautiful gift box!
Chocolate Covered Oreos
Dipped in fresh chocolate, made to order perfection! Get a few for yourself or order them as a gift. When ordering as a gift they come wrapped in a fancy gift box!
Chocolate Covered Strawberries - Fresh Dipped!
We make these in house with our own chocolate! All beautifully served in gift boxes.
Hot Chocolate Bomb
12.50
A chocolate sphere filled with hot cocoa mix and marshmallows. Pour hot milk over top and watch the magic happen!
$Ice Cream Cakes
Traditional Ice Cream Cakes
$35.00
A layer of chocolate and a layer of vanilla with chocolate cookie crunch in between.
Vegan Ice Cream Cake
50.00
Choice of a traditional vanilla and chocolate with an Oreo cookie crunch OR our vegan megawich!.
$Beverages
Smart Water
$2.00
Snapple
$3.50
Can of Soda
$2.50
Menu for Sinful Shakes & Sweets Old City is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
