Onl Cafe Favorites
All served with a tossed salad and fresh garlic bread stick.Steak 'n' Noodles
$12.95
The generous portion of noodles served with our fresh grilled sirloin tips, fresh sliced mushroomsand smothered in our house-made gravy.
Chicken Naturelle
$12.95
Two tender grilled chicken fillets, lightly seasoned. Served with fresh green beans and barbeque sauce for dipping.
Bret's Special
13.95
A mix of freshly grilled steak, chicken breastand grilled shrimp. Served with our rice pilaf and fresh green beans.
$Onl Breakfast Special
Breakfast Special
12.95
$Onl Starters & Sides
Pretzel Sticks with Beer Cheese
$7.95
Two sticks served with beer cheese dip.
Stuffed Hot Banana Peppers
$8.95
3 banana peppers stuffed with a mixture of hot sausage and cheese. Topped with marina sauce and mozzarella cheese. Served with a breadstick.
Nacho Supreme with Chicken
$11.95
Topped with cheese, tomatoes, black olivesand jalapenos. Served with salsa and sour cream.
Quip Chips
$4.95
Freshly made thin-sliced, deep-fried potatoes sprinkled with seasoned salt and served with ranch dressing for dipping.
Mashed Potatoes
$1.95
Coleslaw
$1.25
Fried Banana Pepper Rings
$6.95
Served with horsey sauce.
Nachos with Cheese
$7.95
Our house-made tortilla chips topped with cheese sauce and jalapenos peppers. Served with sour cream.
Fried Dill Pickle Spears
$6.95
Basket of Fries
$4.75
Pretzel Sticks with Cheddar
$7.95
Two sticks served with cheddar cheese sauce.
Potato Skins
$7.95
Loaded with cheddar cheese and bacon crumbles. Served with sour cream.
Zucchini Planks
$6.95
Topped with parmesan cheese and served with marinara sauce.
Onion Rings
$5.95
Provolone Sticks
$5.95
Served with marinara sauce.
Quesadillas with Chicken
$9.95
Made with shredded cheddar and provolone cheese, grilled peppers and onions. Served with sour cream and salsa.
Quesadillas with Shrimp
$10.95
Made with shredded cheddar and provolone cheese, grilled peppers and onions. Served with sour cream and salsa.
Fried Breaded Mushrooms
$6.95
Macaroni & Cheese Side
$1.95
Macaroni & Cheese Bowl
$2.95
Coconut Shrimp
$7.95
6 crispy coconut battered shrimp. Served with our pina colada sauce.
Buffalo Chicken Dip
$8.95
Served with house-made tortilla chips.
Spinach & Artichoke Dip
$8.95
Fresh spinach and artichokes in a bubbly cheese sauce topped with melted provoloneand diced tomatoes. Served with our house-made tortilla chips and bite-sized italian bread.
Nacho Supreme with Beef
$11.95
Topped with cheese, tomatoes, black olivesand jalapenos. Served with salsa and sour cream.
Quesadillas with Steak
$9.95
Made with shredded cheddar and provolone cheese, grilled peppers and onions. Served with sour cream and salsa.
Bread Sticks
$5.25
Garlic breadsticks dusted with Parmesan served with marinara for dipping.
Munchie Platter
$12.95
Potato skins, fried zucchini, provolone sticks, hot pepper cheese ballsand beer-battered onion rings. Enough for sharing.
Hot Cheese Balls
5.95
Deep-fried hot pepper cheese served with horsey sauce.
$Onl Breakfast
2 Eggs, CBH, Toast, Coffee
$6.99
Two eggs any style, corned beef hashand toast.
2 Eggs, Toast & Coffee
$4.59
Two eggs any style, toast.
1 Egg
$0.99
2 Eggs, H&H, Toast, Coffee
$5.99
Two eggs any style, choice of hash browns or home friesand toast.
Toast
$1.79
Breakfast Sandwiches
$7.99
On your choice of toast, english muffin, bagel or croissant with egg, your choice of meat (bacon, ham, sausage or hot sausage)and cheese.
Home Fries
$2.79
Breakfast Sand with H&H
$8.99
On your choice of toast, english muffin, bagel or croissant with egg, your choice of meat (bacon, ham, sausage or hot sausage)and cheese. Served with hash browns or home fries.
2 Eggs, Meat, Toast, Coffee
$5.99
Two eggs any style, choice of bacon, sausage, ham or hot sausage and toast.
Triple
$7.99
3 eggs any style, choice of hash browns or home fries, bacon, sausage, ham, or hot sausageand toast.
Breakfast Wrap with Hash Browns or Home Fries
$8.99
Egg, choice of meat (bacon, ham, sausage, or hot sausage), cheese and vegetables.
Breakfast Wrap
$7.99
Egg, choice of meat (bacon, ham, sausage, or hot sausage), cheese and vegetables.
Home Run
10.99
3 eggs any style, choice of hash browns or home fries, 2 choices of meat (bacon, sausage, ham, or hot sausage)and choice of 1 pancake or 1 french toast.
$Onl Breakfast Other
Veggie Omelet
$8.99
Tomatoes, onions, peppers, mushroomsand spinach.
Philly Steak Omelet
$10.99
Steak, peppers, onions, mushrooms and provolone cheese.
Cheese Omelet with Meat
$8.99
Your choice of cheese and meat (bacon, ham, or sausage). Includes hash browns or home friesand toast.
3 French Toast, Meat
$8.99
3 pieces of french toast, choice of bacon, ham, or sausage.
Seafood Omelet
$10.99
Shrimp, crab, old bay seasoning and provolone cheese.
Waffle Plain
$6.99
Cheese Omelet
$7.99
1 Pancake, Meat
$3.99
One pancake, choice of bacon, ham, or sausage. Includes drink. For guests ten years old and under.
Western Omelet
$8.99
Ham, peppers, onionsand cheese.
1 French Toast, Meat
$3.99
One piece of french toast, choice of bacon, ham, or sausage. Includes drink. For guests ten years old and under.
1 Egg, Meat, Toast
$3.99
One egg any style, choice of bacon, ham, or sausage, 1 slice of toast. Includes drink. For guests ten years old and under.
Breakfast Scrambler
$9.99
Includes choice of 1 cheese, 1 meatand 1 veggie, hash browns or home friesand toast.
Hot & Spicy Omelet
$9.99
Hot sausage, banana peppersand pepper jack cheese.
Waffle with Topping
$7.99
Strawberries (in season), blueberries, or whipped cream.
3 Pancakes, Meat
$7.99
3 pancakes, choice of bacon, ham, or sausage.
Meat Lovers Omelet
$9.99
Ham, bacon, sausageand cheese.
Greek Omelet
$9.99
Tomatoes, roasted red peppers, spinachand feta cheese.
1/2 Waffle, Meat
3.99
Half Belgian waffle, choice of bacon, ham, or sausage. Includes drink. For guests ten years old and under.
$Onl Salads
Large Fish Salad
$12.95
Our lightly breaded cod were deep-fried to a golden brown atop a crisp bed of lettuce with hard-boiled egg slices, tomatoes, onions, black olivesand pepperoncini. Topped off with golden fries and provolone cheese.
Tossed Salad
$3.95
Crisp lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, black olivesand pepperoncini. Served with your choice of dressing.
Large Caesar Salad with Shrimp
$14.00
Crisp romaine lettuce topped with croutons, shaved parmesan and caesar dressing with shrimp.
Small Chef Salad
$10.95
Fresh lettuce topped with delicious ham, salamiand lean turkey. Garnished with egg slices, tomatoes, onions, black olives, pepperonciniand provolone cheese.
Large Gyro Salad
$12.95
We start with a bed of fresh lettuce, surrounded with hard-boiled egg slices, onions, tomatoes, black olivesand pepperoncini's. Topped with golden french fries and crumbled feta cheese. Served with our house-made dill sauce and pita.
Large Caesar Salad with Chicken
$12.00
Crisp romaine lettuce topped with croutons, shaved parmesan and caesar dressing with chicken.
Large Chicken Salad
$12.95
Two grilled chicken fillets served atop fresh lettuce with hardboiled egg slices, onions, tomatoes, black olives, pepperoncini. Top it off with provolone cheese and golden fries.
Extra Garlic Bread
$0.50
Small Gyro Salad
$10.95
We start with a bed of fresh lettuce, surrounded with egg slices, onions, tomatoes, black olivesand pepperoncini's. Topped with golden french fries and crumbled feta cheese. Served with our house-made dill sauce and pita.
Large Grilled Shrimp Salad
$13.95
Our fresh grilled shrimp atop a bed of lettuce with hard-boiled egg slices, onions, tomatoes, black olivesand pepperoncini. Topped off with golden fries, provolone cheese.
Large Chicken Nugget Salad
$12.95
Tasty fried chicken tenders on a bed of lettuce, provolone cheese, onions, tomatoes, black olives, pepperonciniand french fries.
Large Tossed with Cheese, Egg & Veggies
$6.95
Large Tossed with FF
$7.95
Small Grilled Shrimp Salad
$11.95
Our fresh grilled shrimp atop a bed of lettuce with hard-boiled egg slices, onions, tomatoes, black olivesand pepperoncini. Topped off with golden fries, provolone cheese.
Small Fish Salad
$10.95
Our lightly breaded cod were deep-fried to a golden brown atop a crisp bed of lettuce with hard-boiled egg slices, tomatoes, onions, black olivesand pepperoncini. Topped off with golden fries and provolone cheese.
Large Caesar Salad
$9.00
Crisp romaine lettuce topped with croutons, shaved parmesan and caesar dressing.
Large Chef Salad
$12.95
Fresh lettuce topped with delicious ham, salamiand lean turkey. Garnished with hard-boiled egg slices, tomatoes, onions, black olives, pepperonciniand provolone cheese.
Small Taco Salad
$10.95
A crisp bed of lettuce topped with onions, tomatoes, black olives, pepperonciniand cheddar cheese. Topped off with our house-made tortilla chips, chiliand melted cheddar cheese. A mexican treat! Served with salsa and sour cream.
Small Chicken Nugget Salad
$10.95
Tasty fried chicken tenders on a bed of lettuce, provolone cheese, onions, tomatoes, black olives, pepperonciniand french fries.
Large Taco Salad
$12.95
A crisp bed of lettuce topped with onions, tomatoes, black olives, pepperonciniand cheddar cheese. Topped off with our house-made tortilla chips, chiliand melted cheddar cheese. A mexican treat! Served with salsa and sour cream.
Small Caesar Salad with Shrimp
$12.00
Crisp romaine lettuce topped with croutons, shaved parmesan and caesar dressing with shrimp.
Small Chicken Salad
$10.95
Two grilled chicken fillets served atop fresh lettuce with hardboiled egg slices, onions, tomatoes, black olives, pepperoncini. Top it off with provolone cheese and golden fries.
Small Caesar Salad
$7.00
Crisp romaine lettuce topped with croutons, shaved parmesan and caesar dressing.
Large Steak Salad
$12.95
Our house specialty! We start with a bed of fresh lettuce surrounded with hard-boiled egg slices, onions, tomatoes, black olivesand pepperoncini. Topped off with golden fries, provolone cheeseand our delicious tender sirloin.
Small Caesar Salad with Chicken
$10.00
Crisp romaine lettuce topped with croutons, shaved parmesan and caesar dressing with chicken.
Small Steak Salad
10.95
Our house specialty! We start with a bed of fresh lettuce surrounded with hard-boiled egg slices, onions, tomatoes, black olivesand pepperoncini. Topped off with golden fries, provolone cheeseand our delicious tender sirloin.
$Onl Sandwiches
Italian Hoagie
$8.95
Generous portions of ham, salami, pepperoniand provolone cheese. Toasted and topped with lettuce, tomatoand onion. Served with italian dressing on the side.
Chicken Philly
$8.75
Thinly sliced chicken breast grilled with sauteed mushrooms, onionsand green peppers. Topped with provolone cheese on a toasted hoagie bun.
Grilled Cheese
$5.95
Try American, provolone, Swiss, cheddar, or hot pepper cheese, grilled on your choice of rye or sourdough bread.
BLT
$6.25
Bacon, lettuce, tomatoand mayonnaise on toasted sourdough bread.
Fish Sand
$9.99
Generous haddock filet, hand-breadedand deep-fried golden brown.
Tuna Melt
$7.95
Our tuna salad topped with american cheese. Grilled to perfection and served on sourdough bread.
Hot Sausage Sandwich
$7.95
Hot sausage patty smothered in peppers and onions, topped with provolone cheese. Served on a fresh grilled hoagie bun with a side of sauce.
Friday Fish Special
$12.95
Basic Burger
$7.95
Served on a grilled bun with lettuce and tomato.
Turkey Bacon Club
$8.95
Turkey, bacon, provolone, lettuce, tomatoand mayonnaise stacked high between 3 slices of sourdough bread.
Hot Hamburger
$8.95
Our fresh grilled burger on white bread with your choice of mashed potatoes or french fries and smothered in our beef gravy.
Cafe Hoagie Supreme
$8.95
Grilled Chicken Fillet
$6.95
Tender chicken filet, lightly seasoned and grilled to perfection. Topped with lettuce, tomatoand mayonnaise.
Reuben
$8.95
Our tasty corned beef topped with sauerkraut, Swiss cheeseand dressing. Served on grilled rye bread.
Meatball Hoagie
$7.95
Delicious meatballs topped with our tangy sauce and melted provolone cheese.
Triple Decker
$8.95
Turkey, baked ham, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise stacked high between 3 slices of toasted sourdough bread.
Philly Steak Sandwich
$8.95
Thinly sliced sirloin grilled with sauteed mushrooms, onionsand green peppers. Topped with provolone cheese on a fresh grilled hoagie bun.
Hot Turkey Sandwich
$9.95
Lean slices of our fresh baked turkey breast piled high on white bread. Served with your choice of mashed potatoes or french fries and smothered in our turkey gravy.
Gyro
$7.95
Savory gyro meat, lettuce, tomato, onionand our fresh made cucumber dill sauce. Served on pita bread.
Roast Beef 'n' Cheddar Sandwich
$8.25
Thin-sliced roast beef piled high. Topped with cheddar cheese sauce and served on a bun.
Build a Burger
$8.95
Make your own creation! Choose up to 4 toppings.
Hot Roast Beef Sandwich
$9.95
Lean, thin slices of beef piled high on white bread. Served with your choice of mashed potatoes or french fries and smothered in our beef gravy.
Turkey Burger
7.95
Served on a grilled bun with lettuce and tomato.
$Onl Breakfast Sides
Side Bacon
$3.79
Side Hot Sausage
$3.79
Side Ham
$3.79
Toast
$1.79
6 Oz. Strip Steak
$8.99
Grits with Cheese
$3.99
2 Biscuits with Gravy
$6.99
Hash Browns
$2.79
Side Corned Beef
$3.79
Croissant
$1.99
1 Egg
$0.99
One egg, any style.
Oatmeal with Blueberries
$3.99
Home Fries
$2.79
English Muffin
$1.79
Bagel with Cream Cheese
$1.99
Grits with Blueberries
$3.99
Oatmeal Plain
$2.99
1 Pancake
$2.49
1 Biscuit with Gravy
$3.99
Feta
$1.59
Oatmeal with Cheese
$3.99
Bagel Plain
$1.29
Add Cheese
$0.99
Side Sausage
$3.79
1 French Toast
$2.49
Grits Plain
2.99
$Onl Baskets & Wraps
Burger Wrap
$8.95
Our very own house-made angus beef burger wrapped in a warm tortilla with lettuce, tomato, mayonnaiseand your choice of cheese alongside fries.
Shrimp Basket
$10.95
Chicken Tenders & Fries
$9.95
Hand-breaded fresh white meat chicken deep-fried crispy, alongside fries. Try them buffalo or with any of our wing sauces.
Grilled Chicken Wrap
$8.95
Grilled chicken in a warm tortilla wrap with lettuce, shredded provolone, ranch dressing and our red pepper pesto. Alongside fries, a cafe favorite.
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
$9.95
Fried chicken tenders tossed in buffalo sauce in a warm tortilla wrap with lettuce, shredded provolone, ranch dressingand our red pepper pesto. Served with fries.
Coconut Shrimp Basket
$11.95
Butterfly coconut shrimp served with fries and coleslaw. Accompanied by our pina colada dipping sauce.
Fish Basket
9.95
Cod nuggets, served with fries and coleslaw.
$Onl Pasta
All pasta dishes served with tossed salad and fresh garlic bread stick.Penne Alla Vodka with Shrimp
$14.95
Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken
$13.95
Linguine
$9.95
Topped with our marinara sauce and delicious meatballs.
Penne Alla Vodka with Chicken
$13.95
Penne Alla Vodka
$10.95
Fettuccine Alfredo
$10.95
Fettuccine Alfredo with Shrimp
14.95
$Onl Soup
Soup Du Jour Bowl
$4.25
Clam chowder or lobster bisque.
Chili Bowl
$4.45
Meaty and delicious with just the right amount of spices.
Nacho Chili
5.95
Chili surrounded by tortilla chips and topped with aged cheddar cheese.
$Onl Wings
Served with celery sticks and your choice of ranch or bleu cheese.Whole Wings (6)
$10.95
Boneless Wings (1 Lb.)
$13.95
Plump, juicy, all-white meat. They're great, no bones about it!
Whole Wings (12)
$15.95
Boneless Wings (1/2 Lb.)
$7.95
Wingers
11.95
Ten jumbos cut wings.
$Onl Cafe Kabobs
Try shish-kabobs our way! Lamb, beef, chicken or shrimp grilled to perfection, served with tossed salad, rice pilaf, and a pita.Chicken
$11.45
Lamb
$13.95
Beef & Lamb
$12.95
Beef
$11.95
Grilled Shrimp
12.95
$Onl Cafe Mixes
Not feeling like a salad? Try our cafe mixes. Sure to be a favorite!Gyro Mix
$9.95
Chicken Mix
$11.95
A mix of grilled chicken, golden fries, shredded provoloneand cheddar cheeseand your choice of dressing.
Steak Mix
$11.95
A mix of grilled steak, golden fries, shredded provoloneand cheddar cheeseand your choice of dressing.
Chicken Nuggets Mix
$9.95
A mix of chicken nuggets, golden fries, shredded provoloneand cheddar cheeseand your choice of dressing.
Grilled Steak & Chicken Mix
12.95
A mix of grilled steak and chicken, golden fries, shredded provoloneand cheddar cheeseand your choice of dressing.
$Onl Kiddie Menu
Available for our guests twelve years old and younger. Drink included.Kids Chicken Nuggets & Fries
$4.95
Kids Linguini & Meatball
$4.95
Kids Fish Nuggets & Fries
$5.95
Kids 2 Cheeseburger Sliders & Fries
$4.95
Kids Grilled Cheese & Fries
4.45
$Dessert's
Lemon Cake
$5.95
Snickers Bar Pie
$6.95
Colossal Chocolate Ganache Cheesecake
$7.95
Colossal Chocolate Mousse Cake
$7.95
NewYork Colosal Cheese Cake
$7.95
Salted Carmel Brownie
$5.95
Chocolate Cake
$5.50
Reeses Peanut Butter Blondie
$5.95
Pina Colada Cake
$5.95
Cheesecake
4.95
$Onl Drinks
Coffee
$2.10
Pop
$2.75
Chocolate Milk
$2.95
Bloodymary Juice
$1.00
Cranberry Juice
$2.10
Apple Juice
$2.10
Orange Juice
$2.10
Kids Drink Refill
$1.29
Hot Chocolate
$2.10
Tomato Juice
$1.00
Milk
$2.95
Menu for New Sheffield Cafe is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
