Fruit Pies
Apple Pie
A perfect mix of Jonathan and spy apples sweetened. Served with a touch of cinnamon. Truly an all-American favorite.
Apple Crumb Pie
Our most popular pie. This favorite uses the same great Jonathan and spy apples, but this time we throw a sweet streusel on top.
Blackberry Pie
Like all of our old fashioned fruit pies, we start with our signature, made from scratch crust and fill it to the top with only the best blackberries. Since we use the whole berry and you bet they are full of seeds. This pie is rich so we think you should be warned - have plenty of ice cream on hand.
Blueberry Pie
Our old-fashioned blueberry pie starts with our signature and made from scratch crust filled to the top with only the finest blueberries. Served with no preservatives to interrupt the flavor and it is sure to satisfy the blueberry lover in you.
Bumbleberry Pie
This mixed fruit pie is downright fun. Apples, rhubarb, red raspberries and blackberries pull off this balancing act without a net. This is 1 of our favorites to sneak a fork into.
Cherry Pie
Featured on the best of. The all American pie on the food network, we use the best of Michigan’s red tart cherries. Add a bit of sugar and you get a perfect balance of sweet and tart. Top it with our hand-rolled flaky crust and voila -- it is as all-American as you can get.
Cherry Crumb Pie
Same great sour cherries as our original cherry pie and only this 1 is topped with our sweet streusel instead of the crust to satisfy your sweet tooth.
Peach Pie
Start with our signature, made from scratch crustand add sweet and ripe California freestone peaches. Our old fashioned peach pies will give you that perfect taste of summer - anytime of the year.
Peach Riot Pie
Peaches cherries blueberries. This mix is a party of California freestone peaches, red tart cherries and succulent blueberries spills over into a blast of flavor for your taste buds. Don't let the flavor police spoil your fun.
Pecan Pie
There's nothing like pecan pie-the sweet melt-in-you-mouth, choice pecan pieces and flaky crust meld together for the perfect taste combination. From first to last bite and you'll love this pie.
Pecan Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie
Cookie pie together oh, yeah. Described by 1 customer as. A great big cookie in your pie crust. That pretty much sums it up. But we do drizzle chocolate over the top for good measure.
Red Raspberry Pie
Once again, we start with our signature, made from scratch crust and fill it to the brim with only the finest red raspberries. Like all of our berry pies, we do use the whole berries, so you can bet that there are plenty of seeds in each bite. Our raspberry pie is the perfect combination between sweet and zing. Leaving you sweetly satisfied while longing for more.
Rhubarb Pie
That's right. Just straight, old-fashioned rhubarb pie. We start with the old-fashioned crust filled with the best tart rhubarb, sugar, cornstarchand water. This is the tartest of our pies. Just like grandma used to make.
Strawberry-Rhubarb Pie
Basically it is the same as rhubarb pie, only the strawberries add a wonderful sweetness to the tart rhubarb. We start with the old-fashioned crust. Fill the bottom with strawberries. Then fill the pie to the top with rhubarb. It is the perfect tart-sweet combination.
Tripleberry Pie
3 berries and 1 delicious pie. Strawberries, blueberries and red raspberries all together under the same crust. The perfect pie for the person who can't decide on just 1 flavor.
Pie of the Month
Banana Split Pie
We start with layers of chocolate ganache, pineapple and strawberries. Next, we add fresh, sliced bananas which are blanketed beneath our homemade vanilla pudding. We top it all off with whip cream and sprinkles. All that's missing is a boat and a spoon.
Pot Pies - Fruit Pies
Chicken Pie
We have started selling savory pies. We currently have chicken pot pies available in-store and are working on our beef recipe. Pot pies are available at our westerville location only.
Turkey Pie
In house roasted white and dark meat turkey, carrots, peas, potatoes, celery, onions and a savory gravy.
Cream Pies
Banana Cream Pie
We start with whole milk and use bananas, that's right, whole and fresh bananas in our banana cream pie. No artificial flavors here. Course, we top it off with our rich whipped topping.
Boston Cream Pie
This dessert has it all-moist cake, our cooked vanilla pudding in the middle and fudgy icing on top. It's a wonderful blend of pie and cake that is sure to satisfy even the most discerning palette.
Buckeye Pie
Oh my, we are nuts for this pie. We started this pie with a layer of creamy peanut butter silk. Next, we added a layer of our decadent chocolate french silk. Topped with freshly whipped cream, drizzled chocolate and chopped peanuts - it is sure to become one that you crave.
Butterscotch Pie
We start with butter and brown sugar, just the way it used to be done. This unique filling is topped off with our beautifully browned meringue. If you haven't had it or haven't had it for a while, treat yourself to this little dandy.
Chocolate Pie
Another 1 of our top sellers is our chocolate cream pie. Served with old-fashioned pudding topped with rich whipped cream and chocolate sprinkles it's bound to bring out the little kid in everyone.
Coconut Cream Pie
We start with whole milk to make our old fashioned coconut cream pie. There is flaky white coconut through and through. We top it with our homemade meringue and for the finishing touch, sprinkle the top with more coconut and brown to perfection.
Custard Pie
If you love creamy custard pies but are not a fan of the fluffy topping-this is the pie for you. We fill our signature crust with our taste-tempting egg custard, a touch of nutmeg and bake it to golden-brown perfection. There's nothing else like it.
French Silk Pie
This little number is one for the true chocoholic palette. Thick and fudgy, this is one of the richest pies in our line up. Again, we keep it simple using only the finest and freshest sugar, butter, eggs, cocoa and vanilla. A delicate touch turns this combination into a decadent treat.
Key Lime Pie
Not lime. Key lime. Real key lime juice right from Florida. We use sweetened condensed milk to create the unexpected combination of creamy and zing. Top it off with a perfectly browned meringue and you can almost feel the tropical breeze rolling right off the gulf.
Lemon Meringue Pie
Our lemon meringue pie is our number 1 selling cream pieand with just 1 bite you will understand why. That perfect combination of sweet mixed with the zing of lemon and finished off with our homemade meringue that would make even Grandma jealous.
Peanut Butter Pie
We use our homemade vanilla pudding and melt jif peanut butter right into it. Then we top it with our rich whipped topping for a creamy peanut butter sensation.
Pot Pies - Cream Pies
Chicken Pie
We have started selling savory pies. We currently have chicken pot pies available in-store and are working on our beef recipe. Pot Pies are available at our Westerville location only.
Turkey Pie
In house roasted white and dark meat turkey, carrots, peas, potatoes, celery, onions and a savory gravy.
Seasonal and Specialty Pies
Mince Pie
Nothing says fall like a delicious mince pie. We have combined the perfect mixture of raisins, apples and spices for a result that is sure to satisfy.
Pumpkin Pie
When you begin to feel that nip in the air, it’s time for pumpkin pie. A simple recipe done right, it may be your fall favorite, too. Plain topped with whip or a little vanilla ice cream a la mode either way it warms the kid inside of us no matter how many leaves have to be raked. Although this is an autumn pie, pumpkin climbs into the top five year round sellers in a few short months.
Pumpkin Cream Cheese Pie
Just in time for the holidays. If you love pumpkin pie, but are ready to for a new twist, add our pumpkin cream cheese pie to the menu. Served with pumpkin, spices, and cream cheese, you just can't go wrong. Midwest living magazine agrees. This pie was featured as one of the 11 better-than-ever classic pies.
Pumpkin Praline Pie
This pie is a perfect blend of 2 seasonal favorites: pumpkin on the bottom with a rich layer of pecan praline on top. What a delectable combination of flavors.
Strawberry Cream Cheese Pie
A spring and summer favorite. We hand cut strawberries right out of the flat, roll the strawberries in glaze and put them in the pie shell atop a thick layer of doctored up cream cheese. Bring a fork to this party because you may just want to dive right in.
Banana Pie
$6.00
6" Buff Guy Pie
6.00
$Seasonal and Specialty Pies - Pot Pies
Chicken Pie
We have started selling savory pies. We currently have chicken pot pies available in-store and are working on our beef recipe. Pot pies are available at our westerville location only.
Turkey Pie
In house roasted white and dark meat turkey, carrots, peas, potatoes, celery, onions and a savory gravy.
No Sugar Added Pies
No Sugar Added Apple Pie
Our all-American favorite, with the same great apples but this time sweetened with sucralose, a truly diabetic or sugar watcher's delight.
No Sugar Added Blueberry Pie
We have taken our old-fashioned blueberry pie and made it diabetic-safe. We start with our signature crust and fill it with the finest blueberries-a pie that is sure to satisfy.
No Sugar Added Cherry Pie
For our N.S.A. cherry pie, we use the same red tart cherries, but this time we sweeten them with sucralose. Top it with our same great crust without the sugar and you have the perfect diabetic-safe treat.
No Sugar Added Peach Pie
Just because your diet limits sugar, you don't have to miss out on eating our delicious peach pie. It starts with the same signature crust and is filled with sweet, ripe California Freestone peaches.
Pot Pies - No Sugar Added Pies
Chicken Pie
We have started selling savory pies. We currently have chicken pot pies available in-store and are working on our beef recipe. Pot Pies are available at our Westerville location only.
Turkey Pie
In house roasted white and dark meat turkey, carrots, peas, potatoes, celery, onions and a savory gravy.
Pot Pies
Chicken Pie
We have started selling savory pies. We currently have chicken pot pies available in-store and are working on our beef recipe. Pot pies are available at our westerville location only.
Turkey Pie
In house roasted white and dark meat turkey, carrots, peas, potatoes, celery, onions and a savory gravy.
Menu for Just Pies is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
Check Other Restaurant Menu
Massey's Pizza
American, Pizza
Pizzano's
Italian
McDonald's
American, Burgers
McDonald's
American, Burgers
W.G. Grinders
American, Pizza, Sandwiches, Wraps
McDonald's
American, Burgers
McDonald's
American, Burgers
McDonald's
American, Burgers
KFC
American, Chicken
Taco Bell
Mexican
Taco Bell
Mexican
Jersey Mike's
American, Sandwiches