Der Dutchman

Der Dutchman Menu

(614) 873-3414
445 S Jefferson Ave, Plain City, OH 43064
$$$$$

Breakfast & Lunch Buffets

Breakfast and lunch are especially cheery times at Der Dutchman Restaurant with the bakery bringing out fresh-made goods and the coffee brewing. It's a nice time to gather together for work or pleasure. Reservations are for groups of 25 or more. A 10% allowance will be made for no-shows on all reservations. Family Style Breakfast is available for smaller parties. Ask for details. Prices subject to change without notice

Breakfast Buffets

Prices include beverage

Country Breakfast

$13.99 per person, all you can eat; $5.99 per child, ages 3 to 5; $8.99 per child, ages 6 to 10
Scrambled Eggs
Bacon
Sausage
Home Fries
Biscuits & Gravy
Pastries
Fresh Fruit
Add $1.09 per person
Pancakes
Not included in Family Style Breakfast
Fried Mush
Not included in Family Style Breakfast
Fruit Slush
Not included in Family Style Breakfast

Continental Breakfast


Pastries and Beverage
$5
Pastries, Beverage, Fresh Fruit
7

$Sandwich Buffet

Available anytime. Prices include sandwich, salad, homemade buns, potato chips, condiment tray, beverage, slice of pie. Two meats and two salads $16.99

Meats

Choices
Hot Roast
Beef Hot
Roast Turkey
Hot BBQ Beef
Hot Roast Pork

Salad

Choices
Pasta Salad
Macaroni Salad
Tossed Salad with Dressing
Potato Salad

Dessert


Assorted Pies

Beverage

Choose
Pepsi
Diet Pepsi
Iced Tea
Coffee

Appetizers and Snacks

Available anytime. Prices are per person

Trays


Vegetables and Dip
$3
Meat, Cheese & Crackers
$3
Fruit with Dip
$3
Two Options
$6
Three Options
8

$Beverages


Beverage
$3
Choose Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Iced Tea, or Coffee
Punch
1

$Bakery & Dessert


Pies
$6
includes beverage
Cookies
$4
includes beverage
Cookies & Chips
$5
includes beverage
Ice Cream
1

$Dinner

Choose Family-style or Buffet service. Fellowship at the table is a tradition we support! Generous platters of meat, favorite sides such as bread stuffing made from a traditional Amish recipe, mashed potatoes, vegetables, and homemade bread are brought from the kitchen in serving dishes to pass around the table and share- "Family style." But our Amish Kitchen Cooking is also perfectly suited for creating a plentiful and crowd-pleasing buffet. It is another way that we serve hot, freshly prepared foods quickly and efficiently, so you can make the most of your time together at the table. Reservations are for groups of 25 or more. Payment is expected at the time of your meal. We need a final count 72 hours before the scheduled event. A 10% allowance will be made for no-shows on all reservations. We will ask for your menu selection, at least two weeks prior to your event. Prices subject to change without notice

Dinner Options

Choice of two meats $19.99, Choice of three meats $20.99, Choice of four meats $21.99, Chicken only $19.49; Prices for children's portions - 3 to 5 years $6.99, 6 to 10 years $9.99

Dinner Choices


Meat
Choose from: Chicken, Roast Beef, Ham, Turkey
Side Dish
Tossed salad, Homemade Bread, Real Mashed Potatoes and Gravy Choose, Dressing (stuffing) or Noodles Choose Green, Beans or Corn. For an additional side, add $0.99 per person
Dessert
Slice of Pie, Apple, Cherry, Chocolate Cream, Coconut Cream, Peanut Butter Cream
Beverage
Choose Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Iced Tea or Coffee

Rentals & Room Rates


Special Services


Cake Cutting
$0
Linens
$6
Linen Napkins
$0
Round Tables with linens
$26
Centerpieces with Candle
$5
Skirting
16

$Room Charges

To rent a room without food service:
Monday – Thursday
$199
Friday – Saturday
$299

Just for Kids

Ages 12 and under

Breakfast

Available daily 7am to 10:30am. Breakfast Buffet Children 3-5 - $4.99 | Children 6-10 - $6.99. Children 11-12 - $8.99 | Under 2 - Free
One Egg & Toast
$4
Served with 2 pieces of bacon or one sausage patty
One Hotcake
$4
Served with 2 pieces of bacon or one sausage patty
One Egg and Hotcake
$4
One Slice French Toast
4
Served with 2 pieces of bacon or one sausage patty

$Dinners

Include one side dish
Chicken
$5
Choose two chicken fingers or two drumsticks
Charbroiled Chicken***
$7
Roast Turkey
$5
Roast Beef
$6
Fish***
$6
Grilled Ham
$5
Mini Corn Dogs
5

$Sandwiches

Include one side dish
Grilled Cheese
$5
Fish
$6
Hamburger
$5
Cheeseburger
6

$Side Dishes

Extra Side Dish $1.99
Real Mashed Potatoes
French Fries
Homemade Noodles
Green Beans***
Homemade Dressing
Creamed Corn
Applesauce
Coleslaw
Tossed Salad***
Fresh Fruit***

Buffet & Salad Bar


Salad Bar*** (Ages 3-5)
$4
Salad Bar*** (Ages 6-10)
$6
Salad Bar*** (Ages 11-12)
$8
Buffet & Salad Bar (Ages 3-5)
$5
Buffet & Salad Bar (Ages 6-10)
$8
Buffet & Salad Bar (Ages 11-12)
10

$Desserts


Cookie
$0
Ice Cream
$1
Sundae
2
Chocolate, Caramel, Strawberry

$Beverages

Small Beverage $1.99
Pepsi
Diet Pepsi
Mountain Dew
Diet Mountain Dew
Sierra Mist
Dr. Pepper
Root Beer
Lemonade
White Milk
Chocolate Milk
Hot Chocolate

Full Service Buffet Catering

Our chicken is all natural, hormone-free, vegetarian-raised, and broasted in non trans-fat oil

Breakfast Buffets

Includes beverages, disposable dinnerware, cups and napkins
Continental Breakfast
$8
Assorted homemade pastries, muffins, bagels, fresh fruit, orange juice, coffee and hot tea
Eggs & Bacon Buffet
$10
Scrambled eggs, bacon, hash browns, buttermilk biscuits, assorted homemade pastries, orange juice, coffee and hot tea
Country Buffet
11
Buttermilk biscuits and sausage gravy, scrambled eggs, bacon, sausage links, hash browns, french toast sticks, assorted homemade pastries, orange juice, coffee and hot tea

$Appetizers and Sweets

Includes disposable dinnerware, cups and napkins
Premium Appetizer Buffet
$13
Hot and cold appetizers-fresh fruit tray, cheese tray, loaded potato wedges, chicken tenders, meatballs, assorted cookies and beverage
Dessert Buffet
8
An assortment of fresh-baked goods, including pies, cookies, brownies, bars and pumpkin rolls

$Add to any Buffet


Cold


Fresh Fruit Tray
$2
Assortment of fresh seasonal fruit. Served with fruit dip
Fresh Vegetable Tray
$1
Assortment of fresh vegetables. Served with ranch dip
Cheese Tray
$1
Assortment of cubed hot pepper, swiss, marble and colby cheese. Served with crackers
Finger Sandwiches
$1
Assortment of homemade chicken salad with pecans or ham salad on homemade mini buns
Cookies
1
Choice of four kinds

$Hot


Shrimp
$3
Served with lemon wedges and cocktail sauce
Meatballs
$1
Choose BBQ or Sweet and Sour
Chicken Wings
$1
Choose Hot, BBQ or Sweet and Sour
Chicken Tenders
1
Choose two sauces-BBQ, Sweet and Sour, Ranch or Honey Mustard

$Lunch Buffets

Includes canned beverage, bottled water, disposable dinnerware, cups and napkins
Soup & Salad Bar
$11
Mixed lettuce, broccoli, cauliflower, cheese, peppers, onions, cucumbers, tomatoes, carrots, chopped eggs, pickled beets, pickled eggs, croutons, bacon bits, salad dressings, along with our signature potato salad and coleslaw. Served with your choice of Chicken Noodle, Vegetable Beef, Chili or Soup of the Day, along with homemade dinner rolls and fresh baked cookies and brownies
Salad & Potato Bar
$11
Salad bar as listed above, along with chili, ham, cheese sauce, sour cream and bacon bits for Potato Bar. Served with homemade dinner rolls and fresh baked cookies and brownies
Hot Sandwich Buffet
$13
Choose two meats - ham, turkey, roast beef, BBQ beef, roast pork, BBQ pork - served on homemade buns with condiments, two side dishes, chips, fresh baked cookies and brownies
Cold Sandwich Buffet
$11
Selection of ham, turkey and roast beef on homemade buns with cheese, condiments, one side dish, chips, fresh baked cookies and brownies
Homemade Noodles
11
Served over mashed potatoes with a side salad, homemade dinner rolls and fresh baked cookies and brownies

$Dinner Buffets

Includes homemade dinner rolls, choice of dessert, choice of beverage, bottled water, disposable dinnerware, cups and napkins
Dinner A
$19
Choice of 3 entrées, with 4 side dishes
Dinner B
$18
Choice of 2 entrées, with 4 side dishes
Dinner C
$17
Choice of 2 entrées, with 3 side dishes
Dinner D
$16
Choice of 2 entrées, with 2 side dishes
Dinner E
15
Broasted Chicken, with 2 side dishes

$Entrées


Broasted Chicken
Certified Angus Roast Beef
Baked Ham
Swiss Steak
Meatloaf
Roast Pork
Roast Turkey
Country Chicken
BBQ Ribs
Add $1 per person
BBQ Chicken
Add $1 per person
Baked Fish
Add $1 per person
Marinated Chicken Breasts
Add $1 per person
Roast Prime Rib of Beef
Add $4 per person

Vegetarian Entrées


Vegetarian Lasagna
Portobello, Wild Rice and Beans

Beverages


Canned Soda
Lemonade
Iced Tea
Bottled Water
Fruit Punch

Side Dishes


Potatoes, Etc.


Real Mashed Potatoes
with gravy
Cheesy Potatoes
Baked Potato
Old Fashioned Noodles
Homemade Dressing
Sweet Potato Casserole
Parsley-Buttered Red Skin Potatoes
Seasoned Rice
Macaroni & Cheese

Vegetables


Green Beans
Green Bean Almondine
Green Bean Casserole
Creamed Corn
Peas
Peas & Carrots
Glazed Baby Carrots
Stewed Tomatoes
Mixed Vegetables
with Cheese Sauce

Salads


Coleslaw
Macaroni Salad
Potato Salad
Pasta Salad
Three-Bean Salad
Garden Salad
Applesauce
Broccoli & Cauliflower
Cottage Cheese

Salad Dressings

Choose three:
Ranch
Italian
French
House Sweet & Sour
Honey Mustard

Desserts


Fruit Pies


Apple
Dutch Apple
Peach
Cherry
Blueberry
Black Raspberry
Blackberry
Pecan
Lemon Meringue
Pumpkin
German Chocolate
No Sugar Apple
No Sugar Cherry

Cream Pies

Ask for Sugar-Free Cream Pies
Banana
Butterscotch
Coconut
Peanut Butter
Chocolate
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Black Raspberry

Cakes


Carrot
German Chocolate
Angel Food
Honey Cream
Sheet Cake, Decorated

Cookies, Etc.


Chocolate Chip
Peanut Butter
Sugar
Snickerdoodle
Chocolate Crinkle
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Brownies
Lemon Bars
Monster
Raisin Filled
Doodle Dips

Boxed Lunches

Includes canned beverage, disposable dinnerware, cups, utensils and napkins
Chef Salad
$11
Crisp lettuce with meat choice: chicken, turkey or ham. Topped with chopped eggs, tomatoes and cheese. Served with homemade dinner roll and fresh baked cookie
Charbroiled Chicken Salad
$11
Fresh, crisp salad tossed with garden vegetables and topped with shredded cheese blend. Topped with charbroiled marinated chicken breast. Served with homemade dinner roll and fresh baked cookie
Strawberry Crunch Salad
$11
Fresh strawberries, toasted ramen noodles, pecans, onions, and broccoli on a bed of fresh, crisp salad. Topped with charbroiled marinated chicken breast. Served with a sweet vinaigrette dressing Served with homemade dinner roll and fresh baked cookie
Fresh Fruit Plate
$10
Assortment of seasonal fresh fruit and cottage cheese on a bed of lettuce. Served with crackers and fresh baked cookie
Deli Sandwich
$11
Choice of roast beef, turkey, ham or vegetarian served on a homemade bun with condiments, chips, our signature potato salad or coleslaw and fresh baked cookie
Croissant Sandwich
11
Choice of homemade, chicken salad with pecans or ham salad, condiments, chips, our signature potato salad or coleslaw and fresh baked cookie

$Delivery-Only Catering


Appetizers


Cold

Small serves 12-15, medium serves 25-30, and large serves 35-40
Fresh Fruit Tray
$35-72
Fresh Vegetable Tray
$33-61
Cheese Tray
$28-61
Cubed or Sliced
Sliced Meat Tray
$33-77
Meat & Cheese Tray
$31-67
Small tray serves 6-8, medium tray serves 12-15, and large tray serves 16-20
Finger Sandwiches
$46
Assortment of chicken salad with pecans or ham salad on homemade mini buns. Tray of 25
Shrimp Tray
57
50 large shrimp, served with lemon wedges and cocktail sauce

$Hot


Meatballs
$36
BBQ or Sweet and Sour. Tray of 50
Chicken Wings
$36
Hot, BBQ, or Sweet and Sour. Tray of 50
Chicken Tenders
$39
With sauces. Tray of 25
Loaded Potato Wedges
25
Smothered in bacon bits, cheese and green onions - served with sour cream

$Breakfast Favorites

Bulk quantities
Scrambled Eggs
$7-25
Sausage Gravy
$7-25
Hash Browns
$7-25
Cheesy Potatoes
$7-25
Sausage Links
$11
approximately 16-18 pieces
Bacon
$11
approximately 16-18 pieces
French Toast Sticks
$8
Includes packs of syrup. Approximately 12-14 pieces
Fried Cornmeal Mush
$7
approximately 10-12 pieces
Homemade Buttermilk Biscuits
$9
Bakery Tray
$16
Assorted homemade pastries
Coffee
15

$Lunch & Dinner Favorites

Bulk quantities

Meats


Broasted Chicken
$27-152
All white, add 40%
Roast Turkey
$11
Baked Ham
$11
Roast Pork
$11
BBQ Beef
$13
Roast Beef
$13
Vegetarian - Eggplant Lasagna
$26
Beef Gravy
$4-16
Chicken Gravy
4-16

$Side Dishes


Mashed Potatoes
$25
Cheesy Potatoes
$25
Homemade Dressing
$25
Green Beans
$25
Old Fashioned Noodles
$25
Creamed Corn
$25
Baked Beans
$25
Macaroni & Cheese
25

$Homemade Breads


Dinner Rolls
$4
white or wheat
Sandwich Buns
5

$Salads


Potato Salad
$25
Three-Bean Salad
$25
Macaroni Salad
$25
Coleslaw
$25
Broccoli & Cauliflower Salad
$25
Pasta Salad
$25
Garden Salad
25

$Premium Salads


Strawberry Crunch Salad
$26
Romaine lettuce, strawberries, broccoli, Ramen noodles, pecans, onions, sweet vinaigrette dressing
Strawberry Poppy Seed Salad
$26
Spinach and Romaine lettuce, strawberries, roasted pecans, feta cheese with a poppy seed dressing
Apple Pecan Salad
$26
Romaine and iceberg lettuce, apples, roasted pecans, bleu cheese, with an apple cider vinaigrette
Ham Salad or Chicken Salad with Pecans
7-12

$Pies


Fruit
$12
Cream
$12
No Sugar Added
$13
Black Raspberry
$15
Pecan
14

$Other Desserts


Cookies
$7
Iced Cookies
$4
Jumbo Brownies
$3
Lemon Bars
$3
Sheet Cakes
37-68
Decorating included

$Drinks


Sodas and Bottled Water
$1
Disposable Dinnerware and Serving Utensils
1

$Catering Information

For off-site catering call 614-425-2586

Full Service Catering


Set up, serving utensils, disposable dinnerware, serving, and cleanup are all included in full service catering.
A minimum order of $350 is required for full service catering.
An 18% service fee will be added to your invoice for full service catering orders.
Local deliveries are considered within a 30 mile radius of Der Dutchman. Additional mileage charges of $1 per one-way mile will apply thereafter.
Unless otherwise indicated, all meals are priced per person.
Final menu and event adjustments, along with a final guaranteed guest count, are required 7 days prior to scheduled event.

Delivery Only Orders


A 10% service fee will be added to your invoice for delivery only orders.
An 18% service fee will be added for boxed lunches.
Food order totals under $400 incur a delivery fee of $50
For orders over $400, the delivery fee is $25
No tableware or service items are included in the price for delivery only orders unless otherwise noted.
Delivery only orders arrive in "ready-to-serve" disposable trays and bowls.
Local deliveries are considered within a 30 mile radius of Der Dutchman.
Additional mileage charges of $1 per one-way mile will apply thereafter.

Deposit and Cancellation Policy


A 25% non-refundable deposit and a signed contract is required when order is placed to reserve event date.
Final guest count is due 7 days prior to event date.
Unless previous payment arrangements have been made, the remaining balance is to be paid 48 hours in advance of event date.
We accept personal and corporate checks, VISA, MasterCard and Discover.

Breakfast

All-you-can-eat buffet options. Prices include beverage. Served buffet-style for groups over 40 people. Served family-style for groups under 40 people

Hot Breakfast

$11.99 per person; $6.99 child, age 3–12
Scrambled Eggs
Home Fries
Bacon
Sausage
Biscuits
Sausage Gravy
Pancakes
Pastries
Beverage

Continental Breakfast


Pastries, Beverage and Fresh Fruit
$6
Pastries and Beverage
4

$Snacks & Appetizers

Available anytime

Trays


Vegetables and Dip
$3
Meat, Cheese, and Crackers
$3
Fruit with Dip
$3
Two Options
$6
Three Options
8

$Dessert


Pies
$4
includes beverage
Cookies
$3
includes beverage
Ice Cream
1

$Beverages


Beverages
2
Coffee, Iced Tea, Pepsi Products or Punch (as an add on), $1.29

$Lunch Buffets

All-you-can-eat buffet options. Prices include beverage, buns, condiments, & dessert

Salad & Sandwich

$14.99 per person
Choose Two Sandwiches
Roast Beef, Roast Turkey, Ham, BBQ Beef or Pork
Choose Two Salads
Macaroni Salad, Tossed Salad with dressing, Potato Salad, Coleslaw

Dessert


Assorted Pies

Dinner Buffet or Family Style

Traditional meal served buffet style or family style. Prices include beverage & dessert
Chicken Only
$16
Choice of Two Meats
$17
Choice of Three Meats
$18
Choice of Four Meats
$19
Price for Children's Portion (Ages 3–12)
8

$Meat Options


Broasted Chicken
Roast Beef
Ham
Roast Turkey

Sides


Tossed Salad
Homemade Bread
Real Mashed Potatoes and Gravy
Dressing (Stuffing) or Noodles
Green Beans or Corn

Dessert


Assorted Pies

Special Services


Cake Cutting
$0
Linens
$6
Linen Napkins
$0
Round Tables with Linens
$27
Centerpieces with Candle
$5
Skirting
$18

Wedding Receptions

If you've been dreaming of a romantic country wedding, Der Dutchman may be the perfect setting. Our attractive, family-oriented venue works in harmony with the charming surroundings to help create memories that will last a lifetime. Der Dutchman's experienced staff will work with you every step of the way to make your wedding day everything you've dreamed of. To keep planning simple, we offer a wedding package for $23.99 per person which includes servers, china, gratuity, homemade vanilla ice cream and drink station with soft drinks, iced tea, coffee and hot tea. Hours: Monday – Thursday 6am to 8pm; Friday and Saturday 6am to 9pm. Wholesome & Family-friendly, No-step access, Attractive banquet rooms, Audio-visual capabilities, Soft-seating areas, Ample Parking, No alcoholic beverages, Smoke-free

Appetizers


Vegetable Tray with Dip
Fruit Tray

Salad


Garden Salad
Homemade Dinner Rolls

Main Dish

Additional Entree $2.59 per person. Choose two of the following
Broasted Chicken
Baked Ham
Roast Beef
Swiss Steak
Meatloaf
Roast Pork
Roast Turkey
BBQ Ribs
add $1.19 per person
BBQ Chicken
add $1.19 per person
Marinated Grilled Chicken
add $1.19 per person
Baked Fish
add $1.19 per person

Potato/Noodle/Rice

Choose one of the following
Real Mashed Potatoes & Gravy
Baked Potatoes
Noodles
Dressing (Stuffing)
Sweet Potato Casserole
Parsley-Buttered Redskin Potatoes
Seasoned Rice

Vegetable

Choose one of the following
Green Beans
Green Bean Casserole
Creamed Corn
Peas
Peas & Carrots
Glazed Baby Carrots
Stewed Tomatoes
Mixed Vegetables with Cheese Sauce

Additional Items


Cake Cutting
$0
Punch Fountain
$50
Linens
$6
Linen Napkins
$0
Round Tables with Linens
$26
Centerpieces with Candle
$5
Skirting
16

$Wedding Catering Package

Pricing starts at $26.99 per person. Some menu options include an additional fee per person; price listed next to item on menu. To keep planning simple, we offer a wedding package that includes the following items
Choice of 2 Appetizers
Choice of 2 Entrees
Choice of 3 Side Dishes
Homemade Dinner Rolls
Drink Station
Cake Cutting Service

Also Included


White Linens
For Appetizer, Buffet, Drink Station, Wedding Party and Cake Tables
Disposable Dinnerware
Masterpieceâ„¢ and Reflectionsâ„¢ elegant disposable wedding dinnerware

Add on These Special Services


Punch Fountain
$50
Punch as an additional beverage to drink $1 per person
China
$5
does not include drinkware
Additional Linens
Linens for guest tables, White skirting, White or colored napkins; prices vary for add-ons

Menu Option


Appetizers

choose 2
Fresh Fruit Tray
Assorted fresh seasonal fruit, served with fruit dip
Vegetable Tray
Assorted fresh vegetables, served with Ranch dip
Cheese Tray
Assorted cubed hot pepper, Swiss, marble, and colby cheese, served with crackers
Meatballs
Choose BBQ, or Sweet & Sour; add $1.50 per person
Chicken Wings
Choose Hot, BBQ, or Sweet & Sour; add $1.50 per person
Chicken Tenders
served with dipping sauces; add $1.50 per person
Stuffed Mushrooms
add $3 per person
Shrimp
Large shrimp served with lemon wedges and cocktail sauce; add $3.99 per person

Entrees

choose 2
Marinated Chicken Breast
Broasted Chicken
BBQ Chicken
add $2 per person
Roast Beef
Roast Turkey
Roast Pork
Roast Pork Tenderloin
additional fee per person $2
BBQ Pork
Baked Ham
Meatloaf
Country Chicken
add $2 per person
Baked Fish
add $2 per person
BBQ Ribs
add $2 per person
Boneless Short Ribs
add $4 per person
Roast Prime Rib of Beef
add $4 per person
Salmon
add $4 per person

Side Dishes

choose 3
Garden Salad
Served with choice of 3 dressings: House (Sweet & Sour), Ranch, Poppy Seed, Italian, French, Honey Mustard, Blue Cheese, Thousand Island, Balsalmic or Raspberry Vinagrette
Real Mashed Potatoes
with gravy
Baked Potatoes
Cheesy Potatoes
Red Skin Potatoes
Parsley-buttered
Sweet Potatoes Casserole
with marshmallows & pecans
Old Fashioned Noodles
Homemade Dressing
Rice Pilaf
Green Beans
Green Beans Almondine
Creamed Corn
Peas
Glazed Baby Carrots
Vegetable Blend

Bread (Included)

Homemade Dinner Rolls
White
Wheat
Combination

Beverages

Plus, one of the following: Bottled Water, Coffee. Beverages are provided during your meal. After meal beverages may be added upon request. choice of two
Lemonade
Iced Tea
Fruit Punch
Assorted Sodas

Terms for Wedding Receptions


Full service catering is subject to a minimum of $300 or an 18% service charge–whichever is larger.
Additional gratuity is at your discretion.
If your event is held at a venue with an additional catering fee, the catering fee will be added to your invoice.
Delivery is free for full service catering within 30 miles of Der Dutchman.
For each additional mile, $1 per mile will be charged one-way.
Price includes set up, elegant disposable dinnerware, serving and clean up of serving tables.
We will cater indoor or outdoor events, and do not require electricity. We do not cater events on Sundays.
Final menu and event adjustments, along with a final guaranteed guest count, are required 14 days prior to the event.
A 25% non-refundable deposit and signed contract are required when an order is placed and an event date is reserved. Unless previous payment arrangements have been made, the remaining balance is due 48 hours prior to event. We accept personal and corporate checks, Visa, Mastercard and Discover.

Salad Bar

Fresh vegetables, prepared salads, and regional specialties that are constantly refilled and refreshed. We support local growers and serve their fresh produce on our salad bar when possible – $11.99; with soup add $0.99. Salad Bar sharers will be charged full price

Soups & Salads

Salad dressings: We make Sweet & Sour, Thousand Island, French, Bleu Cheese, Ranch, and Poppy Seed. We also serve Honey Mustard, Fat-free Ranch, Italian, Vinegar & Oil, Fat-Free Raspberry Vinaigrette
Homemade Soup
$3-4
Vegetable beef, chicken noodle, broccoli cheese
Chef Salad
$12
Crisp lettuce, hardboiled egg, cheese, tomato, onion, croutons, and your choice of grilled or broasted chicken breast, ham, turkey, chicken tenders or roast beef
Strawberry Poppyseed Salad
13
Spinach and Romaine lettuce, marinated chargrilled chicken, and strawberries topped with feta cheese and honey roasted pecans. Served with poppyseed dressing

$Side Dishes

A la Carte – $3.59. No discount to omit sides

Hot


Mashed Potatoes & Gravy
Dressing & Gravy
Noodles
Creamed Corn
Green Beans
Vegetable Blend
French Fries
Mac & Cheese
Side of the Day
Baked Sweet Potato
add $0.50
Sweet Potato Fries
add $0.50
Onion Rings
add $0.50

Cold


Red Beets
Potato Salad
Coleslaw
Tossed Salad
Fresh Fruit
add $0.50

Favorites


Roast Beef Dinner
$15
Old-fashioned slow-roasted in its own juices and served with two sides
Roast Turkey Dinner
$14
Old-fashioned slow-roasted and served with two sides
Noodles Over Mashed
$10-9
Noodles ladled over made-from-scratch mashed potatoes
Manhattan
$12-11
Hot sandwich served with mashed potatoes and covered with gravy. Your choice of roast beef, turkey, pork, or meatloaf
Meatloaf Dinner
14
A traditional Amish-style recipe and served with two sides

$Sandwiches

Served on homemade breads and buns with one side. Add salad bar for $4.99. Add grilled mushrooms, onions or cheese for $0.79 each. Add bacon for $1.79
Dutchman Burger
$12
8oz Certified Angus Beef® chopped sirloin topped with Swiss cheese
Hamburger
$11
5oz Certified Angus Beef® patty
Charbroiled Chicken Breast
$11
Gerber's Amish Farm Chicken breast, marinated and chargrilled to perfection
Beef, Turkey or Pork Sandwich
$11
Slow-roasted in it's own juices. Try it with our own BBQ Sauce!
Bacon Lettuce & Tomato
$10
Seven pieces of bacon, crisp lettuce and tomato served on white or wheat toast
Grilled Cheese
$8
Famous & local Guggisberg Baby Swiss with thick slices of our homemade bread
Cod Filet Sandwich
$12
Hand-breaded and deep-fried
Trail Bologna & Swiss
$11
Famous Trail Bologna served hot or cold with Guggisberg Swiss; local specialty
Reuben or Rachel Sandwich
$12
Corned-beef or slow-roasted turkey with sauerkraut, swiss cheese and Thousand Island dressing on rye bread
Veggie Burger
11
Chargrilled all-vegetable patty with a hint of spice

$Barn Raising Buffet

Enjoy all-you-can-eat homestyle meats, dressing, real mashed potatoes, noodles, creamed corn, green beans, salad bar and more – $16.49. Save $1 on a slice of pie if you add it to your buffet dinner! Please Note: Buffet & Salad Bar sharers will be charged full price and no leftovers may be taken home. Thank you for your cooperation!

Dinners

Includes homemade white or wheat dinner rolls and choice of two side dishes listed below. To substitute salad bar for a side, add $1.99. Der Dutchman serves only Certified Angus Beef® and Gerber's All-Natural Chicken
Broasted Chicken
$14-12
Broasted chicken is marinated, breaded and broasted under pressure – crispy outside, juicy inside
Charbroiled Chicken
$13-14
Boneless marinated in our seasoning
Chicken Tenders
$13
4 pieces all white meat
Chopped Sirloin Steak
$14
8oz seasoned Certified Angus Beef® charbroiled
Liver & Onions
$13-14
Grilled beef liver topped with grilled onions
Grilled Ham
$14
Old-fashioned grilled ham
Roast Pork
$14
Old-fashioned slow-roasted in its own juices
Cod Filet
$15
8oz mild cod, hand breaded, deep-fried
Salmon
16
8oz filet lightly seasoned and grilled tender

$Sampler Plate

A traditional Amish or Mennonite potluck features a variety of meats and homecooked side dishes. Our "Sampler" serves up our most popular items – real mashed potatoes and gravy, dressing, green beans or creamed corn, tossed salad, and homemade dinner rolls
Choose 2 Meats – Chicken, Ham, Roast Beef, Pork or Turkey
17

$Beverages


Freshly Brewed Iced Tea
$2
Free refills. Sweet iced tea, unsweetened iced tea
Milk
$3
White or chocolate
Fresh Ground Coffee
$2
Free refills. Cup of Hope® regular or decaffeinated
French Vanilla Cappuccino
$3
Hot Tea
$2
Free refills. Ask your server for our selection
Hot Chocolate
3

$Cold Drinks

$2.99. Free refills
Pepsi
Diet Pepsi
Mountain Dew
Diet Mountain Dew
Dr. Pepper
Root Beer
Sierra Mist
Raspberry Iced Tea
Lemonade

Juice

$3.29
Orange
Apple
Grape
Cranberry

Breakfast Buffet

All-you-can-eat Amish Country favorites like fried mush, biscuits & gravy, scrambled eggs, bacon, sausage, potatoes, pancakes, french toast, grits, fruit slush, yogurt, fresh fruit, and fresh pastries. Buffet served Monday – Saturday until 11:00am | Adult – $11.29

Made to Order!

Available Monday-Friday until 11:00am Saturday until 10:45am
Emanuel's Favorite
$10
Buttermilk biscuit with sausage gravy, two eggs, hash browns, choice of meat and homemade toast
Farmstead Breakfast
$10
Two pancakes, 2 eggs, and choice of meat
Sugarcreek Breakfast
$9
2pc mush, 2 eggs, and choice of meat
Plain City Breakfast Stack
$9
Homemade toast piled high with scrambled eggs and hash browns, then smothered with sausage gravy
Bellville Barn-Raiser
$9
2 eggs, hash browns, choice of meat, and homemade toast
Walnut Creek Breakfast
$8
2 eggs, choice of meat, and homemade toast
Sarasota Sunrise
$8
2 eggs, cup of fresh fruit, and homemade toast
Egg & Cheese Sandwich
$5
On your choice of bread or English Muffin
Biscuits & Gravy
$6-4
Creamy, homemade sausage gravy ladled over fresh-baked buttermilk biscuits
Buttermilk Pancakes
$5-4
Chocolate Chip or Blueberry Pancakes
$6-5
French Toast
$6-4
Thick slices of texas toast and served with warm syrup and sprinkled with powdered sugar
Hot Oatmeal
$4-3
Cornmeal Mush
$5-3
Crispy golden slices of fried cornmeal mush served with warm syrup
Fresh Fruit Parfait
7
Fresh fruit layered with vanilla yogurt and our homemade granola. Served with your choice of bread

$Omelets

Served with toast and hash browns. Choose from four of the toppings listed below. Additional toppings, $0.89 each
Create Your Own 3-Egg Omelet
10

$Omelets - Toppings


Cheeses
Swiss, American, Cheddar, Pepper Jack, Feta
Veggies
Tomatoes, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Onions, Spinach
Meats
Turkey Sausage, Bacon, Ham, Sausage Links, Sausage Patties

Sides


Hashbrowns
$2
Sausage or Tomato Gravy
$3-2
One Egg, Any Style
$1
Ham
$3
Bacon
$3
Sausage Links
$3
Turkey Sausage
$3
Sausage Patties
$3
Homemade Granola
$3
Fresh Mixed Fruit
5-3

$Bakery


Homemade Toast
$1
White, Wheat, Rye, Sourdough
Biscuits
$1
Cinnamon Roll
$2
Pecan Roll
$3
Blueberry Muffin
$2
Donuts
$1
Cake or Glazed
Pastries
$1
Apple fritter, Long Johns or Twists
English Muffin
$1
Plain Bagel with Cream Cheese
$1

Main


Broasted Chicken
$12-187
Orders of 24 or more wings are included at no additional cost; Breasts only, add 40%; Legs and Breasts only, add 20%; Any orders with special requests must be placed 2 hours in advance
Chicken Wings
$9-27
20 pc and 30 pc orders must be placed 2 hours in advance; Add BBQ Sauce for $1.50 for every 10 wings
Soups
4-8
Vegetable Beef, Chili, Chicken Noodle

$Bulk Meats


Roast Beef
$13
Baked Ham
$11
Roast Pork
$11
Roast Turkey (Mix)
$11
Roast Turkey (White)
12

$Side Dishes

Pint (serves 2-3) $4.99; Quart (serves 4-6) $8.49; Gallon (serves 20-30) $28.99
Mashed Potatoes
Homemade Dressing
Green Beans
Noodles
Creamed Corn
Mac & Cheese
Potato Salad
Macaroni Salad
Coleslaw
Broccoli & Cauliflower Salad
Beets

Rolls & Desserts


White Rolls
$4
Wheat Rolls
$4
Fruit Pies
$12
Cream Pies
$11
Premium Pies
$13
Cookies
7

$Family Meals


Family Meal for Four
$28
Your choice of a meat, two sides and dinner rolls. Choice of Meat: Broasted Chicken (9 pc), Slow-Roasted Turkey or Pork. Choice of Sides: Mashed Potatoes & Gravy, Homemade Stuffing, Noodles, Mac & Cheese, Green Beans or Corn. Choose from: White or Wheat Dinner Rolls
'3 Course' Family Meal for Four
$36
Your choice of a meat, two sides, one side salad, dinner rolls and chocolate chip cookies. Choice of Meat: Broasted Chicken (9 pc), Slow-Roasted Turkey or Pork. Choice of Sides: Mashed Potatoes & Gravy, Homemade Stuffing, Noodles, Mac & Cheese, Green Beans, Corn, Potato Salad, Macaroni Salad, Coleslaw or Cauliflower Salad. Choose from: White or Wheat Dinner Rolls
Family Charbroiled Chicken Salad
$24
1 Gallon of fresh crisp salad tossed with garden vegetables and with shredded cheese. Topped with 1 pound of charbroiled chicken. Includes 1/2 dozen dinner rolls and your choice of 4 salad dressings
Sandwich Deal
$26
Choose from: 1 1/2 lbs of BBQ Beef or BBQ Pork. Comes with 6 sandwich buns and 1/2 dozen chocolate chip cookies. Choose 1 quart of: Potato Salad, Macaroni Salad or Coleslaw
Chicken Lover
$30
4 chicken tenders, 6 pc broasted chicken. 1 quart of Mashed Potatoes with gravy. 1 quart of Mac & Cheese (sides can be substituted). 1/2 dozen chocolate chip cookies

A la Carte


Meats
$12-1
Mixed bucket comes with Breast, Thigh, & leg. Must be ordered in increments of three assorted pieces. All breast meat, add 40%, leg & breast only, add 20%. Special requests require 2hr advance notice! Thanks!
Chicken Tenders
$9-33
Served with your choice of sauce
Roast Beef
$14
1 pound serves 2-3 people
Baked Ham
$12
1 pound serves 2-3 people
Roast Pork
$12
1 pound serves 2-3 people
Roast Turkey – Mix
$12
1 pound serves 2-3 people
Roast Turkey – White Meat
13
1 pound serves 2-3 people

$Soups


Soups
5-8
Vegetable Beef, Chicken Noodle

$Dinner Rolls


White Rolls
$4
Wheat Rolls
4

$Side Dishes

Pint – serves 2-3 $5.29, Quart – serves 4-6 $8.99, Gallon – serves 20-30 $29.99
Mashed Potatoes
Homemade Dressing
Green Beans
Old-Fashioned Noodles
Mac & Cheese
Creamed Corn
Coleslaw
Potato Salad
Broccoli & Cauliflower Salad
Macaroni Salad
Beets

Dessert


Fruit Pies
$13
Cream Pies
$12
Premium Pies
$14
Cookies (Doz)
8

$Family Meal


Family Meal for 4
$34
Includes one meat, two sides, and dinner rolls. Choice of meat – 9pc Broasted Chicken, Roast Turkey, Roast Pork or for Roast Beef – add $2. Choice of two Sides – Mashed Potatoes & Gravy, Dressing, Noodles, Mac & Cheese, Green Beans, Creamed Corn. Choose – White or Wheat Rolls
3-Course Family Meal for 4
$42
Includes one meat, two sides, tossed salad, chocolate chip cookies and dinner rolls. Choice of meat – 9pc Broasted Chicken, Roast Turkey, Roast Pork or for Roast Beef – add $2. Choice of two sides – Mashed Potatoes & Gravy, Dressing, Noodles, Mac & Cheese, Green Beans, Creamed Corn, Coleslaw, Potato Salad, Macaroni Salad, Cauliflower Salad. Choose – White or Wheat Rolls
Sandwiches for Six
$34
1.5 lb BBQ Beef or Pork. Includes 6 sandwich buns, 6 chocolate chip cookies
Charbroiled Chicken Salad for 4
$29
Fresh lettuce tossed with garden vegetables and shredded cheese and topped with 1lb charbroiled chicken. Choose – White or Wheat Rolls

Menu for Der Dutchman is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

Check Other Restaurant Menu

Longhorn Bar And Grill Food
Longhorn Bar And Grill

American, Barbecue

Subway Food
Subway

Sandwiches

Subway Food
Subway

Sandwiches

Dunkin' Food
Dunkin'

American, Bagels, Bakery & Pastries, Coffee & Tea, Diner