Bake Me Happy

Bake Me Happy Menu

(614) 477-3642
116 East Moler Street, Columbus, OH 43207

Pies


Sugar Cream
$10.00
Pie Bites
$2.00
2. 5 in circles of crust filled with the following: lemon curd pumpkin butter (seasonal only) nutella.
Pecan
$12.00
Pumpkin
$10.00
Sweet Potato
$10.00
Sour Cream Apple
$12.00
Cherry
$12.00
Pie Crust
$3.50
Unbaked and frozen pie crust to take home and fill with your favorite recipe.
Chocolate Cream Pie
$14.00
Double Crusted Apple Pie
$12.00
Hand Pies
4.00
Half moons of crust filled with the following: apple tart cherry chocolate pecan other specialty flavors rotate seasonally.

$Cookies


Sweet and Salty Dark Chocolate Chippies
$3.00
Seriously big chocolate chunk cookies topped with crunchy maldon sea salt.
Quinoa Flake Monster Cookies
$3.50
Flourless peanut butter cookie with quinoa flakes, chocolate chips and mini mandms - monster in size.
Peanut Butter Burners
3.00
Slightly spicy peanut butter cookies dusted with turbinado sugar.

$Cakes And Cupcakes


Sprinkle Cake
$50.00
Layers of buttery yellow funfetti cake filled frosted with marshmallow w creme frosting and sprinkles on the sides.
Red Velvet Cake
$32.00
Two layers of decadent red velvet cake filled with our goat cheese-cream cheese filling and frosted with cream cheese frosting. Topped with toasted coconut or white chocolate shavings.
Cupcakes
$2.50
Cupcakes for all your party needs! all cupcakes come with sprinkles - please specify if you prefer no sprinkles. Available in yellow, funfetti or chocolate with vanilla bean or chocolate marshmallow w frosting.
Boston Cream Pie Cake
$24.00
Layers of buttery yellow cake filled with pastry cream and topped with dark chocolate ganache.
Carrot Cake
$26.00
Deliciously spiced carrot cake with a cream cheese frosting (naked cake style. ) (we do not put raisins or nuts in our carrot cake!) with or without nuts on top.
Whoopie Pie Cake
$22.00
Decadent chocolate cake filled with our delicious marshmallow w creme filling and topped with dark chocolate ganache.
Specialty Cupcakes
$3.50
Snoball Cake
$42.00
One large domed snoball, perfect for that special ones birthday! our delicious chocolate cake, baked in a dome, filled with a ton of our marshmallow w creme frosting and loaded with pink coconut on the outside.
Traditional Frosted Cake
25.00
Layers of your choice of chocolate, yellow or funfetti cake and frosted with chocolate or vanilla marshmallow w creme frosting with light sprinkles around the top and bottom of the cake.

$Scones


Scone
$18.00
Take and Bake Scones
10.00
5 unbaked frozen scones in a box ready to take home and bake yourself - fresh and delicious, almond, coconut and chocolate chip, ham, cheese and chives, maple cream, bacon and white cheddar, blueberry, goat cheese and basil.

$Nostalgic Treats


Brown Butter Rice Krispie Treat
$3.00
We brown the butter, add some flaky sea salt and vanilla bean and package them to keep them super fresh. So rich and so good.
Oatmeal Creme Clouds
$4.00
One of our top sellers! our take on the classic oatmeal creme pie: soft molasses cookies filled with marshmallow w creme frosting.
Zebra Cakes
$3.00
Buttery yellow cake, sliced horizontally and filled with marshmallow w creme filling, dipped in white chocolate and striped with dark chocolate.
Poptarts
$3.50
Rectangles of pie dough filled with nostalgic (and not-so-nostalgic) fillings. Flavors: strawberry cinnamon brown sugar cherry almond - other specialty flavors rotate seasonally.
Spongies
$2.50
Yellow buttery cake filled with marshmallow w creme. Better than you remembered!
Snoballs
$3.50
Super moist chocolate cake domes filled with marshmallow w creme, covered in marshmallow w fluff and rolled in pink coconut flakes.
Moon Pies
$3.50
Two soft maple molasses graham cookies sandwiched between house made marshmallow w fluff and dipped in dark chocolate. Big and decadent!
King Dongs
3.00
Super moist chocolate cake rounds filled with marshmallow w creme filling and dipped in dark chocolate.

$Specialty Items


Pumpkin Spice Spongies (Seasonal)
$3.50
Spiced pumpkin cake filled with cinnamon cream cheese filling.
Red Velvet Spongies
$3.50
Moist red velvet cake, filled with a goat cheese-cream cheese filling and lined with coconut.
Donut Muffins
$3.00
Baked nutmeg donut muffins rolled in cinnamon sugar.
Lemon Blueberry Mini Sour Cream Bundts
$4.50
Dense and moist individual sized sour cream pound cakes.
Cinnamon Coffee Cake Muffins
$4.00
Jumbo muffins with a layer of cinnamon streusel, dotted with cinnamon chips and topped with cinnamon crumb. Topped with cream cheese frosting lattice.
Double Chocolate Brownies
$3.50
A little cakey, a little fudgey - delicious brownies studded with chocolate chunks (dairy free).
Cream Cheese Cutouts
$3.00
Dense and lightly flavored with lemon, these cookies will be your new favorite. Frosted with cream cheese frosting. Ohio cutout with heart sprinkle.
Morning Glory Muffins
$4.00
Delicious muffin loaded with carrots, apples, coconut, golden raisins and spices. (dairy free).

Menu for Bake Me Happy is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

Check Other Restaurant Menu