Specials & Fan Favorites
Rotating specials for the weekDill Pickle Personal Pizza
$14.75
Available in Regular or Spicy, this delicious personal pizza comes with a ranch sauce base layered with a blend of mozzarella and cheddar and topped with our homemade pickles
Teriyaki Grilled Chicken Tacos
$14.95
Our always fresh grilled chicken a top homemade cabbage slaw, drizzled in our teriyaki glaze topped with cucumber, carrot and green onion.
Chipotle Grilled Chicken & Bacon
$16.50
Our marinated grilled chicken topped with a spicy Chipotle ranch sauce and crispy thick cut bacon - served with LTO and a side
Shrimp Scamp'aroni Sandwich
$16.95
Crispy shrimp tossed in garlic butter a top homemade Mac & Cheese, and baked with melted mozzarella, w/ a side of course
Curd is the Word Burger
$16.95
This double smash burger is stuffed with delicious cheese curds and topped with our house gravy - served with choice of side
Love me Tenders
$15.50
Our always fresh panko breaded chicken tenders fried golden brown and delicious finished with cheddar cheese and crispy bacon served with our house gravy for dipping and choice of side
General Tso's Fried Chicken Sandwich
$16.95
Your favorite Chinese takeout food in sandwich form, our delicious fried chicken drizzled in General Tso’s sauce atop slaw and green onion - served with your choice of side
Good for your Seoul Burger
$16.95
Inspired by Korean garlic bread that is stuffed with cream cheese, this double smash burger is topped with mozzarella, garlic butter and cream cheese, sounds crazy but it's absolutely delish
Bee Sting Personal Pizza
$15.95
This personal pizza is topped with mozzarella, pepperoni and drizzled with our hot honey sauce for a little sweet and heat finish
The Animal Smashburger
$16.95
This California inspired burger is cooked with onions and finished with a secret burger sauce that makes it “Animal Style†- served with LTO and a side
Crab Rangoon Personal 10" Pizza
$16.95
Sweet crab meat mixed with cream cheese and topped with mozzarella then baked and finished with crispy dumplings, green onion and sweet chili drizzle.
Kevin Bacon Double Smash
$17.50
We add bacon to our burger grind, then smash down 2 patties for that crispy sear with thinly sliced onions, your choice of cheese and mayo to finish it off. Served with your choice of side.
Po’ Boy Tacos
$14.95
Three crispy battered shrimp tacos topped with lettuce, tomato, diced pickles and finished with our Old Bay aioli drizzle.
Buffalo Shrimp Tacos
$14.95
Three crispy battered shrimp tacos drizzled in your choice of Buffalo sauce a top crisp cabbage and finished with a dollop of sour cream, green onion and bleu cheese crumbles.
KISS Fried Chicken Sandwich
$16.95
Our famous fried chicken topped with our new hot sauce(KISS), pepperjack cheese, and warm bacon slaw.Served with your choice of side. KISS is our latest sauce, a perfect blend of tart, sweet & amp;heat...its lip - smacking good.(Our new kiss sauce is available on any of our always fresh chicken options as well)
Bang Bang Shrimp Tacos
$14.95
Three tacos topped with homemade slaw, crispy shrimp, green onions and finished with a our spicy Thai Bang Bang sauce
Garlic Butter Burger
$16.95
Steaks are finished with butter why not our steak burger! Our grilled steak burger finished with garlic butter, onion and pickle and your choice of side.
Honey Butter Fried Chicken & Biscuits
$14.95
Two (2) sweet and crisp fried chicken & biscuits topped with our honey butter sauce and your choice of side
Yuengling Beer Battered Fish Fry
$16.95
Atlantic Haddock dredged in a Yuengling beer batter and fried, served with your choice of side, tartar, slaw and lemon wedge.
Honey Chipotle Bacon Grilled Chicken Tacos
$14.95
Three grilled chicken tacos made with cheddar cheese atop a crispy bacon slaw, avocado and drizzled with our smoky chipotle honey sauce
Et tu, Bacon? Caesar Salad
$16.95
Grilled romaine drizzled with our homemade Caesar dressing topped with crispy bacon bits and your choice of crispy shrimp or marinated grilled chicken
The Belgium Burger
$16.50
Did you know Belgium invented the french fry? Belgium’s interpretation of the American burger served open face with lettuce, and tomato - the burger is topped with crispy fries and drizzled in our delicious cheese sauce and a thousand island inspired sauce - this one is meant to be eaten with a knife and fork
Batman & Reuben Burger
$16.95
POW this Reuben inspired burger is topped with a crispy bacon slaw, swiss cheese and from Russia with Love dressing - served with your choice of side.
Everything Bagel Pizza
$15.95
This is what dreams are made of, a personal 10†pizza made with cream cheese, mozzarella and mouth watering pastrami then topped with everything bagel seasoning and baked to perfection
Disco Fries
$8.95
Jersey’s most popular late night snack food, these fries are topped with melted mozzarella and gravy
The Big Popper
$14.50
Combine Jalapeno poppers with fried chicken. Sounds strange, but it’s delicious! Our always fresh hand battered fried chicken topped with cream cheese, spicy jalapenos, pepperjack cheese and choice of side.
The Lobster Roll
$23.50
It's back!!! Our most popular special - our take on the classic Lobster Roll served with your choice of side
Big Bird and the Street Sauce
$14.50
This sandwich has some serious height...take two of our fried chicken cutlets, a crispy potato hashbrown in between with your choice of cheese, lettuce and mayo. Served with our new Street sauce, a tangy BBQ sauce with a dash of heat, and a side.
Just in Queso Pizza
$13.95
10†Personal pizza made with a cheesy queso base, cheddar cheese and finished with grilled chicken, avocado, green onion and chipotle honey drizzle.
T.T.T. Salad
$13.95
Tater Tot Taco salad! Crispy tots topped with your choice of spicy beef or grilled chicken, olives, jalapenos, cheddar cheese, lettuce, avocado, sour cream & served with chipotle ranch dressing.
Nashville Hot Wings
$14.95
Our delicious twice fried crispy wings finished with a complex undeniably spicy spice blend with a touch of sweet for that perfect balance of flavor.
Buffalo Chicken Bite Toutine
$14.50
This is a full meal! Crispy tots topped with melted cheese curds and our crispy panko chicken bites drizzled in your choice of Buffalo sauce, and finished with bleu cheese and green onion.
Panko Crusted Buffalo Bite Mac & Cheese
$13.75
Our creamy delicious homemade mac & cheese baked with a crispy panko topping and finished with our always fresh buffalo bites.
Tender KISS Tacos
$13.95
Three tacos made with our crispy jumbo chicken tenders, tossed in our sweet with a little bit of heat KISS sauce, a top warm bacon slaw, shredded cheddar cheese and green onion.
The Shrimp Scampi Burger
$16.95
This surf-n-turf burger starts withour grilled steak burger, topped with melted provolone and finished with garlic buttered crispy shrimp, Old Bay aioli and your choice of side.
Gluten Free Cauliflower Grilled Chicken Panini
$13.95
Always fresh grilled chicken, gluten free cauliflower Panini, topped with sharp cheddar, LTO and cranberry aioli. Served with your choice of side.
The Bills Burger
$15.75
Our 8 oz. steak burger, topped with your choice of cheese, and our fresh crispy fried chicken with your choice of buffalo sauce. Served with LTO and a side.
Garlic, Bacon & Crispy Shrimp Personal Pizza
$14.50
Buttery garlic white sauce topped with mozzarella, bacon, crispy fried shrimp, parmesan and green onion.
Teriyaki Burger
$14.95
Our 8 oz. steak burger topped with pepper jack cheese, slaw, and spicy pickles finished with a sweet and savory teriyaki sauce and your choice of side.
Blazing Honey Buffalo Wings
$14.95
Our latest sauce invention, we balance our delicious homemade hot Buffalo sauce with a touch of honey and a dash of a savory and sweet spice blend.
Crackn’ Crab Cake Sandwich
$14.95
6 oz crab cake filled with sweet, flaky, delicious crab meat, topped with lettuce, tomato and finished with our Old Bay aioli and your choice of side.
The Last Dance Burger
$17.95
Better be hungry, this is our biggest burger ever! First we take our half pound steak burger, top that with our cherrywood smoked thick cut bacon, then top that with your choice of red or white hot, and lastly finish it with a heaping serving of delicious meat hot (and your choice of side).
Super Smashburger Personal Pizza
$13.75
Our seared super smashburger baked with a blend of mozzarella and your choice of cheese, topped with bacon and caramelized onion.
The Lobster Roll
$23.50
Our most popular special of all time!
Crab Rangoon Personal Pizza
$15.95
Sweet crab meat mixed with cream cheese and topped with mozzarella then baked and finished with crisp pot stickers and a sweet and sour chilli drizzle.
Bacon Cheeseburger Tacos
$13.95
Three Stone Steakburger tacos topped with cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, crispy bacon bits, mayo and diced pickles.
Pigskin in a Blanket
$13.95
Football is back and so is this fan favorite special. Cheddar Cheese, Bacon, and your choice of dog (red or white) wrapped in our homemade pizza dough and baked to perfection. Served with cheese dipping sauce and your choice of side.
Chicken Bite Bowl
13.75
A bed of house-made mashed potatoes, cheese, corn, and our amazing fresh chicken bites with gravy. For a limited time only
$On the Side
Spicy Cheese Curds
$11.95
Breaded cheese curds with a hint of heat, fried golden brown served with a side of ranch for dipping
Soft Pretzel Sticks
$11.95
Served with our homemade cheese sauce, perfect for dipping
Mac & Cheese bites
$11.95
Crispy fried Mac & Cheese bites served with a side of our homemade Buffalo sauce
VooDoo Fries
$9.25
Bed of fries covered with cheese sauce, chipotle pepper powder, and chipotle ranch sauce
Fries
$6.50
Pub style and each fry uniquely cut
Onion Rings
$7.95
Breaded, thick-cut onion rings
Tots
$6.50
Cauliflower Bites
$13.95
Fresh cauliflower hand battered then fried and served with a side of any of our sauces
Loaded Tots
$12.50
Our crisp tots smothered in bacon, cheese, green onion and a side of sour cream
Sweet Potato Wedges
$6.95
Served alongside our homemade spicy maple dipping sauce
Pot Stickers
$9.95
Chicken teriyaki pot stickers served with house Korean BBQ sauce
Toutine
$12.95
Crispy tots smothered with melted cheese curds and a side of house gravy
Mozz Sticks
$9.95
Fried Mozzarella sticks with a side of marinara sauce
Cup of Chili
$5.95
Cup of our homemade Old Stone Chili
Garlic Cheddar Grilled Cheese Bites
11.95
Garlicky and cheesy what else could you want, served with a side of ranch for dipping
$Chicken
10 Stone Wings
$17.75
Ten extra crisp twice fried wings, tossed in your choice of sauce or rub
Wing Flight
$16.00
Twelve (12) wings, naked. Includes choice of 3 sauces.
Half Wing Flight
$8.00
Six (6) wings, naked. Includes choice of three sauces
Boneless Chicken Bites
$14.50
Homemade panko-floured fresh chicken bites served with a side of your choice of sauce
Jumbo Chicken Tenders
$14.95
Fresh jumbo panko hand-breaded tenders served with a side and your choice of sauce
IMPOSSIBLE Chicken Nugs (10)
11.95
Plant based chicken nuggets with a crispy breaded coating, taste like the real thing!
$Pizza
Pizza Slice
$3.95
One slice with choice of toppings
20" Full Pizza
$24.95
Large 20" pizza with choice of toppings
10" Personal Pizza
$14.50
Personal 10" pizza with choice of toppings
Personal 10" Gluten Free Pizza
14.95
10" pizza on a gluten-free crust with choice of toppings
$Tacos
Mix & Match Chicken Bite Tacos
$13.95
Choose any combination of 3 panko chicken bite tacos: Buffalo Mac & Cheese, Hot Honey, Bacon Ranch
Crispy Fish Tacos
$14.50
Three crispy fish tacos a top fresh slaw, and finished with avocado and red onion
Plate Tacos
13.95
A taco take on the Rochester classic with crispy tots, mac salad, meat hot mustard and onion
$Everyday Fish Fry
Our delicious local wild caught Perch Fish Fry, available every day!Fish Fry
$16.95
2 battered fresh water perch fillets served with choice of side, lemon, slaw and tartar sauce
Yuengling Beer Battered Fish Fry
16.95
Atlantic Haddock dredged in a Yuengling beer batter and fried, served with your choice of side, tartar, slaw and lemon wedge.
$Between the Buns
The Stone Steak Burger
$16.95
1/2 lb of our delicious blend of sirloin, short rib and brisket, grilled and served with choice of cheese, LTO and side
Super-Smash Burger
$16.95
The 1/2 lb steak burger smashed down into a huge 6" diameter and seared to perfection, served with double cheese, LTO and side
Fried Chicken Sandwich
$15.95
Southern style fried chicken finished with any of our home made sauces, fillers and bun. Served with choice of side
Hot Honey Fried Chicken Sandwich
$15.95
Crispy Southern fried chicken doused with our spicy sweet hot honey sauce, topped with mayo, diced pickles, lettuce and a side
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
$14.95
Grilled chicken breast finished with any of our homemade sauces, fillers and bun. Served with choice of side.
Veggie Beyond Burger
$15.95
1/4 lb juicy, delicious plant-based burger served with choice of cheese, LTO and side
Fish Sandwich
15.95
Crispy battered fish on fresh Italian bun, lettuce, tomato onion, our homemade tartar sauce and your choice of side
$Huge Plates
Our huge take on the Rochester classic, you better be hungry!Steak Burger Plate
$16.95
1/2 lb Stone Burger on top of mac salad and tots or fries, topped with your choices of meat sauce, chopped onion and mustard
Supersmash Burger Plate
$16.95
1/2 lb Supersmash Burger on top of mac salad and tots or fries, topped with your choices of meat sauce, chopped onion and mustard
One-Dog Plate
$13.50
One dog (red or white) on top of mac salad and tots or fries, topped with your choices of meat sauce, chopped onion and mustard
Two-Dog Plate
$14.50
Two dogs (red, white, or one of each) on top of mac salad and tots or fries, topped with your choices of mustard, onion, and meat sauce
Grilled Chicken Plate
$14.95
Grilled chicken on top of mac salad and tots or fries, topped with your choices of meat sauce, chopped onion and mustard
Dog and Steak Burger Plate
$17.95
1/2 lb Stone Burger and a dog (red or white) on top of mac salad and tots or fries, topped with your choices of meat sauce, chopped onion and mustard
Dog & Supersmash Burger Plate
$17.95
Veggie Burger Plate
$14.95
The Rochester classic topped with a 1/4 lb beyond burger
Beyond Plate
$15.95
1/4 lb Veggie Beyond Burger on top of mac salad and tots or fries, topped with your choices of meat sauce, chopped onion and mustard
Chicken Bite Plate
14.95
Hand breaded panko crusted chicken bites with your choice of sauce on top homemade mac salad, tots or fries and meat hot
$Dogs
The Stone Dog
$8.95
Jumbo Sahlens red hot or Zweigles white hot, grilled and cut on the spiral to give your choice of toppings a place to settle, served with a side
The Veggie Dog
8.95
A big carrot poached in our special marinade, grilled then finished with choice of toppings and a side
$Salads
Buffalo Salad
$15.75
Romaine salad with a grilled or fried chicken breast tossed in your choice of wing sauce. Served with choice of homemade dressing
Grilled Wedge Salad
$13.95
Lightly grilled heart of romaine drizzled in bleu cheese dressing, topped with thick cherry wood smoked bacon.
Grilled Chicken Avocado
15.95
Grilled romaine topped with grilled avocado, sliced chicken, tomatoes, cucumbers and diced red onion
$The Sweeter Side
Funnel Cake Fries
$9.50
Fried dough pieces in french fry shape and topped with powdered sugar. Optional dipping sauce available
Lava Cake
8.50
Delicious Lava Cake with a molten chocolate center
$Brunch (Sunday 12-3 PM)
Brunch (Sunday 12-3 PM)Freid Egg Sandwich
$10.00
Two eggs, bacon, choice of cheese on a Martusciello's roll with hash brown patty on side
BLT
$9.00
Bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo on a MArtusciello's hard roll. With a hash brown patty on the side. Add fried egg for $1 more.
Breakfast Dog
$9.00
Red or White dog, grilled, topped with scrambled eggs, bacon, and cheddar with hash brown patty on the side
Chicken and Waffles
$13.50
Southern Fried chicken bites between two buttermilk waffles with tots and a side of our spicy maple syrup
Breakfast Pizza
$13.50
10" personal pizza (regular or gluten-free(+$1)) with mozz, cheddar, potato, bacon, sausage, and 2 eggs your way
Honey Butter Chicken & Biscuits
$13.00
Two fried chicken biscuit sandwiches topped with honey-butter sauce with a side of tots
Breakfast Tacos
12.50
Three tacos with scrambled eggs, bacon, cheddar cheese, tots, and avocado
$Fountain Drinks
20-oz Fountain Drinks or 12-oz bottle of Saranac Root BeerCoke
$3.05
20-oz soda on ice in to-go cup
Diet Coke
$3.05
20-oz soda on ice in to-go cup
Sprite
$3.05
20-oz soda on ice in to-go cup
Unsweetened Iced Tea
$3.05
20-oz soda on ice in to-go cup
Ginger Ale
$3.05
20-oz soda on ice in to-go cup
Lemonade
3.05
20-oz soda on ice in to-go cup
$Bottled Drinks
Saranac Root Beer
3.05
12-oz bottle. Must be 21 to purchase.
$Beer, Seltzers & Hard Ciders
Beer, Seltzers & Hard CidersGenny
$4.00
Nutrl
$6.00
High Noon
$6.50
White Claw
$5.00
K2 Sour
$8.00
Hamburg Blueberry Peach Cider
$7.00
Blackbird Cider
$6.00
Rohrbach Scoth Ale
$7.00
Rohrbach Vanilla Porter
$7.00
Hamburg Tropical Delicious Sour
$8.00
Founders All Day IPA
$5.00
Brewdog Elvis Juice IPA
$6.00
Juice Bomb IPA
$6.00
Fiddlehead IPA
$8.00
Menu for The Old Stone Tavern is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
