Coney Island Cafe

Coney Island Cafe Menu

(845) 343-3714
10 Railroad Ave, Middletown, NY 10940

Breakfast Specials

Served all day, served with choice of coffee, tea or hot chocolate till 11am
English Breakfast
$6.10
Scrambled egg whites, ham, and American cheese on a toasted English muffin.
Pancakes
$7.99
French Toast
$8.15
Oatmeal
$3.99
2 Eggs with Homefries and Toast
$6.10
2 Eggs with Homefries and Toast with Ham
$8.49
2 Eggs with Homefries and Toast with Bacon
$8.49
2 Eggs with Homefries and Toast with Sausage
$8.49
2 Eggs with Toast
$4.99
No potatoes.
2 Eggs with Toast and Ham
$7.82
2 Eggs with Toast and Bacon
$7.82
2 Eggs with Toast and Sausage
$7.82
Ham and Cheese Omelette
$10.12
Western Omellete
$10.50
Made with ham, peppers and onions.
Huevos Rancheros
$10.15
Two 6" tortillas grilled with refried beans, cheddar cheese, and over-easy eggs topped with salsa & guacamole
Egg Quesadillas Special
10.99
Wheat tortilla stuffed with scrambled eggs with tomatoes, peppers, onions, and choice of bacon or sausage with melted jack cheese served with salsa and guacamole.

$Breakfast Breads and Desserts


Buttered Toast
$1.99
Assorted Muffins
$2.49
Croissant with Cream Cheese
$3.49
Toasted Bagel
$2.08
Toasted Bagel with Cream Cheese
$2.99
Buttered Roll
$1.59
English Muffin
$2.06
Crossaint
$2.18
Banana Bread
$2.49
Slice of banana bread
Chocolate Chip Cookie
$1.99
Tapioca Pudding
$2.99
Rice Pudding
2.99

$Breakfast Sandwiches

Comes with coffee before 11 am.
Fried Egg and Cheese
$3.25
Croissant Sausage Egg and Cheese Sandwich
$6.25
Western Egg and Cheese Sandwich
$6.49
Ultimate Egg Sandwich
$7.49
Fried egg, bacon, American cheese, home fries, and jalapenos on a brioche roll
Bacon, Tomato, Avocado Crossaint
7.62
Scrambled eggs, bacon, tomato, and avocado on a crossaint

$Breakfast Wraps and Sandwiches


Ultimate Wrap
$7.62
2 scrambled eggs, home fries, sausage, jalapenos and pepper jack cheese in a wheat wrap. Spicy.
Mediterranean Wrap
$7.49
3 egg whites, fresh mozzarella and tomato in a wheat wrap
Meat Lover's Egg Wrap
7.62
Bacon, sausage, onions, peppers, 2 scrambled eggs and Swiss cheese, in a wheat wrap.

$He-Man Breakfast


3 Meat Spicy Skillet
$10.87
Ham, bacon, and sausage topped with 2 scrambled eggs, pepper jack cheese over home fries and green peppers. Served with toast.
French Delight
$10.64
2 slices of french toast and 2 eggs served with bacon.
Mediterranean Skillet
$10.42
3 scrambled eggs over homefries, roasted red peppers, diced tomatoes, and spinach topped with feta cheese and served toast.
Grand Slam Breakfast
$11.10
2 eggs with ham, bacon, and sausage served with home fries and choice of pancakes or french toast.
Steak & Eggs Breakfast
11.62
5 oz. sirloin steak served with 2 eggs, home fries and toast.

$Signature Omelettes

Served with home fries and toast, unless otherwise stated.
Coney Island Omelette
$10.54
2 franks, cheese, onions and chili sauce.
Farmers Omelette
$10.54
Ham, onions, peppers, bacon, sausage and cheese.
Caprese Signature Omelette
$10.06
Sliced tomato, melted mozzarella, chopped basil and toast.
Gracian Omelette
$9.49
Spinach, feta cheese and tomatoes.
Western Omelette
$10.06
Made with ham, pepper and onions.
Chicken Fajita Signature Omelette
$10.86
Chicken, American and Monterey Jack cheese, onion and peppers served with salsa and guacamole.
Spicy Avocado Omelette
$10.54
Grilled onions, peppers, avocado and pepper jack cheese drizzled with chipotle sauce. Spicy.
Tex Mex Signature Omelette
10.54
Diced red and green peppers, sauteed onions and pepper jack cheese.

$Egg and Omelettes

Comes with home fries and toast.
1 Egg
$3.58
2 Egg
$4.08
1 Egg with Meat
$4.12
2 Eggs with Meat
$4.56
Mushroom Omelette
$8.57
Mushroom Omelette with Cheese
$8.99
Cheese Omelette
$8.12
Choice of American, Swiss or cheddar.
Ham Omelette
$8.90
Ham Omelette with Cheese
$9.30
Bacon Omelette
$8.90
Bacon Omelette with Cheese
$9.30
Sausage Omelette
$8.90
Sausage Omelette with Cheese
$9.30
Broccoli Omelette
$8.55
Broccoli Omelette with Cheese
8.99

$Say Hello to the Benedicts

All benedicts include a side of home fries.
Classic Benedict
$9.92
2 poached eggs on a grilled Canadian bacon on a toasted English muffin topped with hollandaise sauce.
Irish Benedict
$9.92
2 poached eggs, served over housemade corned beef hash and a toasted English muffin topped with hollandaise sauce.
Mexi Benedict
$9.92
2 poached eggs served with refried beans on a toasted English muffin topped with hollandaise sauce then drizzled with chipotle sauce. Spicy.
California Benedict
$9.92
2 poached eggs, over grilled tomato, fresh avocado on a toasted English muffin and finished with hollandaise.
Chipotle Bacon Benedict
10.26
2 poached eggs. Served with crisp bacon and guacamole on a toasted English muffin topped with hollandaise sauce, drizzled with chipotle sauce. Spicy.

$Pancakes and French Toast


Pancakes
$7.98
French Toast
$7.42
Blueberry Cakes
$8.37
Filled with blueberries.
Short Stack Pancakes
$5.25
Short Stack French Toast
$5.42
Chocolate Chips Pancakes
$7.42
Cinnastack Pancakes
$8.29
Pancakes layered with cinnamon spread and topped with cream cheese icing.
Strawberry Fields
$8.38
3 thick slices french toast topped with strawberry compote and whipped cream.
Banana Bread French Toast
8.48
Our delicious homemade banana bread topped with bananas, cinnamon and powdered sugar.

$Appetizers and Soups


OverLoaded Potato Skins
$7.98
Topped with cheddar jack cheese, bacon, diced onions, tomato, jalapeños, and black olives, served with sour cream on the side.
Sweet Potato Fries
$5.92
Sweet potato sliced and fried to perfection
Homemade Fried Green Beans
$7.98
Fresh green beans lightly battered & fried to perfection, served with ranch
French Fries
$6.49
With mozzarella cheese and gravy.
Bacon Cheese Fries
$7.57
French fries with melted cheese and crisp bacon with a side of ranch.
Chili Con Carne
$5.57
Chili Cheese Fries
$7.42
French fries topped with our signature chili sauce and shredded cheese.
Large Chicken Noodle Soup
4.45
Chicken,Carrots, celery ,Onions and egg noodles in seasoned broth

$Glorious Salads


California Supreme Salad
$10.96
Breast of chicken, grilled and sliced over fresh green salad with tomato, cucumbers, onions, shredded cheese, and choice of dressing.
Caesar Salad
$8.93
Crisp hearts of romaine lettuce tossed with our creamy caesar dressing with freshly grated Parmesan cheese and fresh croutons. Add grilled chicken for an additional charge.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Salad
$11.25
Grilled chicken over romaine, shredded cheddar jack, diced tomatoes, chopped bacon, and ranch.
Greacian Chicken Salad
$10.98
Grilled chicken, shredded romaine lettuce, peppers, onions, and diced tomatoes served with tzatziki sauce.
Pepper Jack Chicken Romaine Salad
$10.62
Crispy romaine lettuce topped with grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, pepper jack cheese, and chipotle ranch dressing.
Fajita Chicken Salad
$10.96
Cajun chicken, romaine, corn, black beans, tomato, and tortilla chips with chipotle ranch dressing. Spicy.
Chef's Salad
11.25
A bed of fresh lettuce topped with turkey, roast beef, ham, Swiss cheese, tomato, and cucumbers, and garnished with a hard boiled egg.

$Coney Island Combos


1. Coney Dog Combo
$8.12
Coney Island Chili Dog
$3.49
Coney island chili sauce, mustard and onions.
Plain Dog
$2.64
Plain Dog Combo
$6.99
Chicago Coney Dog
$3.49
Mustard, onions, relish, pickle, tomato, and jalapenos.
Manhattan Coney Dog
$3.49
Red onion sauce, mustard, and sauerkraut.
Philly Coney Dog
$3.49
Grilled onions and cheddar cheese.
Red Onion Sauce Coney Dog
$3.49
Southwestern Coney Dog
$3.49
Ketchup, cheese, jalapenos, and coney island chili sauce.
New Yorker Coney Dog
$3.49
Spicy mustard, grilled onions, and kraut.
Cheeseburger Sandwich
$5.49
Cheeseburger Sandwich Combo
$9.96
Double Cheeseburger Sandwich
$6.49
Double Cheeseburger Sandwich Combo
$10.27
Greek Gyro Sandwich
$8.49
Greek Gyro Sandwich Combo
$12.85
Coney Cheesesteak Sandwich
$8.49
Coney Cheesesteak Sandwich Combo
$12.87
Chicken Wings
$5.49-14.12
Chicken Tenders
$7.49
Chicken Tenders Combo
$11.75
Coney Island Combo
7.12-10.76
Chips not included in combos.

$Hard Pressed Burgers

Served with french fries, cole slaw, and pickle. Substitute sweet potatoes or onion rings for an additional charge.
Chipotle Bacon Burger
$8.45
With pepper jack cheese, bacon, red onions, and chipotle sauce wrapped in a whole wheat tortilla. Spicy.
Spicy Philly Burger
$8.45
Our hand-pressed burger topped with melted cheddar cheese, sautéed onions, jalapeños, and chipotle sauce on a hamburger bun. Spicy.
Swiss Melt Burger
$8.45
With fried onions, mushrooms, and melted Swiss on rye.
Cajun Bacon Jack Burger
8.45
Our hand pressed burger Cajun-seasoned, topped with melted pepper jack cheese and bacon on a hamburger bun.

$Paninis, Wraps and Melts

Served with potato chips, pickle, and cole slaw. Substitute fries, sub sweet potato fries or onion rings for an additional charge.
Turkey Melt
$8.95
Grilled American cheese with turkey, tomato, and Russian dressing on rye bread.
Philly Roast Beef Melt
$9.99
Homemade roast beef, thinly sliced and grilled topped with cheddar cheese, grilled onions and served with sourdough bread.
Tuscan Roast Beef Panini
$9.99
Roast beef sliced thin, grilled, topped with melted mozzarella cheese, sauteed spinach, and tomatoes on grilled rye.
Hickory Chicken Melt
$8.99
Grilled chicken breast topped with melted Swiss cheese, crispy bacon, and BBQ sauce on grilled rye bread.
Spicy Chicken BLT Wrap
$9.99
Grilled chicken breast topped with bacon, lettuce, tomato, melted cheddar and filled with chipotle sauce in a whole wheat tortilla. Spicy.
Pepperjack Pastrami Wrap
$9.99
Thinly sliced and grilled pastrami topped with pepperjack cheese, roasted red peppers, and mayo in a whole wheat tortilla.
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
$8.49
Crispy buffalo chicken, lettuce, tomato, and ranch dressing. Spicy.
Crispy Chicken Wrap
$10.35
Crispy fried chicken, bacon, shredded cheese, avocado, cucumber, lettuce, tomato, and honey mustard.
Chipotle Chicken Wrap
9.99
Grilled chicken topped with crispy bacon, shredded cheddar jack cheese, tomato, and chipotle sauce in a wheat tortilla. Spicy.

$Signature Sandwiches

All served with french fries, pickle, and cole slaw. Substitute sweet potato fries or onions rings for an additional charge.
French Dip Signature Sandwich
$11.15
Thin sliced roast beef and melted Swiss cheese on a baguette brushed with garlic butter with au jus on the side. Add onions and mushrooms for an additional charge.
Chicken Avocado Signature Sandwich
$9.99
Grilled chicken topped with Swiss cheese and avocado. Served with lettuce, tomato and mayo on a bun.
Grilled Reuben Signature Sandwich
$10.95
Lean corned beef and sauerkraut topped with melted Swiss cheese on rye bread with Russian dressing on the side.
Corned Beef Pastrami Combo Signature Sandwich
9.99
Grilled corned beef and pastrami on rye.

$Tasty Sandwiches

Served with chips, cole slaw and pickle.
Roast Beef Sandwich
$8.35
Served with lettuce.
Roast Turkey Sandwich
$8.35
Served with lettuce.
Virginia Ham Sandwich
$8.35
Served with lettuce.
Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato Sandwich
$6.45
Chicken Salad Sandwich
$7.99
Served with lettuce.
Egg Salad Sandwich
$6.87
Served with lettuce.
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
5.48

$Triple Decker's

Served with potato chips, pickle and cole slaw.
Sliced Turkey Triple Decker
$10.32
Served with turkey, lettuce, tomato and bacon.
Sliced Roast Beef Triple Decker
$10.32
Served with roast beef, lettuce, tomato, bacon and American cheese.
Sliced Ham Triple Decker
10.32
Served with ham, lettuce, tomato and Swiss cheese.

$Mexican Fiesta


Chicken and Black Bean Quesadilla
$10.30
Wheat tortilla stuffed with grilled chicken, shredded cheese, corn salsa and black beans. Served with salsa, sour cream and guacamole.
Burrito
$9.50
Wheat tortilla filled with seasoned beef, refried beans and shredded cheese. Topped with lettuce, tomato, salsa and sour cream.
Fajita Quesadillas
9.50
Wheat tortilla filled with grilled chicken and shredded cheese. Topped with lettuce and tomato. Served with salsa, sour cream and guacamole.

$Cincinatti Style Chili


3 Way Cincinatti Style Chili
$6.80
Spaghetti with chili sauce and shredded cheese.
4 Way Cincinatti Style Chili
$7.12
Spaghetti chili sauce, shredded cheese and onions.
5 Way Cincinatti Style Chili
7.75
Spaghetti chili sauce, shredded cheese, onions and kidney beans.

$Hot Entrees

Served with vegetables and mashed potatoes.
Hot Open Turkey
$10.99
Hot Open Virginia Style Ham
$10.99
Hot Open Sirloin of Beef
10.99

$Side Orders


Side of Bacon
$3.49
Side of Sausage
$3.49
Side of Ham
$3.49
Corned Beef Hash
$5.49
House made corned beef
Sirloin Steak
$5.99
Turkey Sausage
$3.99
Home Fries
$3.99
French Fries
$4.99
Onion Rings
$5.99
Sweet Potato Fries
$5.99
Fries with Mozzarella and Gravy
$6.49
Cole Slaw
$3.49
Mac and Cheese
3.99

$Shakes and Smoothies


Chocolate Milkshake
$4.50
Strawberry Milkshake
$4.50
Vanilla Milkshake
$4.50
Banana Smoothie
$4.99
Blueberry Smoothie
$4.99
Mango Smoothie
$4.99
Strawberry Smoothie
$4.99
Mixed Fruit Smoothie
4.99

$Beverages


Apple Juice 16oz
$2.99
Cranberry Juice 16oz
$2.99
Orange Juice 16oz
$2.99
Large Ice Coffee24 oz
$2.99
Small Ice Coffee16oz
$2.49
Sweet Ice Tea24 oz
$2.49

Menu for Coney Island Cafe is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

Check Other Restaurant Menu