Appetizers
Steamed Littlenecks
$19.00
Lemon-butter broth
Peel n Eat Shrimp
$14.00
Hot or cold simple or seasoned with old bay
Fried Calamari
$15.00
Shishito pepper, sweet honey-chile sauce
Angry Mussels
$16.00
White wine, spicy garlic marinara
Crab Dip
$15.00
Mrs. holmes secret crab dip recipe, corn torilla chips
Guacamole
$12.00
Corn tortilla chips
Lobster Tater Tot Poutine
23.00
Tots, squeaky cheese, lobster meat, lobster gravy
$Salads
Additions to your salad: grilled chicken, shrimp, salmon or tuna $7.00 crab cake $9.00.Old Mill Salad
$12.00
Gathered greens, tomato, carrot, chayote, red onion, goat cheese, balsamic vinaigrette
Caesar
$11.00
Romaine, caesar dressing, shaved parmesan, crouton, anchovy
The Wedge
$11.00
Iceberg lettuce, blue cheese, bacon, tomato
Raw Beet Greek
12.00
Raw matchstick beet, granny smith apple, red onion, oregano, feta cheese, red wine vinaigrette
$Soups
Clam Chowder
$8.00
Chunky new england style
Lobster Bisque
8.00
Classic smooth & creamy
$Pasta
Mussels Arrabbiata
$18.00
Spaghetti & mussels in a spicy tomato sauce
Linguini & Clams
$23.00
Littlenecks, white wine & garlic
Penne a la Bia
19.00
Sweet summer corn, tomato confit, basil, mint, shaved parmesan
$Bakes Boils
Lowcountry Shrimp Boil
$28.00
Unpeeled shrimp, red potato, corn on the cob, smoked sausage
Long Island Clam Bake
48.00
12 littleneck clams, lobster tail, unpeeled shrimp, red potato, corn on the cob, andouille sausage. For two.
$Raw Bar
Oysters on the Half Shell
Champagne mignonette, cocktail sauce
Littlenecks on the Half Shell
Champagne mignonette, cocktail sauce
Tuna Beet Poke
14.00
Hawaiian style tuna tartar, roasted beet, sesame seed, soy-lime citronette
$Sandwiches
All sandwiches are served with friesOld Mill Burger
$15.00
10 oz, lettuce, tomato, onion pickle, blue duck bun choose: american, swiss, pepperjack, cheddar
Grilled Portobello Burger
$15.00
Grilled portobellos, mozzarella, guacamole, blue duck bun
Fried Fish Sandwich
$16.00
beer battered fish, pickles, tartar sauce, Blue Duck bun, slaw
Lobster Roll
Celery, black pepper mayo, lemon confit, blue duck pull-apart roll, slaw
Mains
Old mill rubs: kitty's tickle ancho rub $1.00, the caretaker's coffee rub $1.00, porcini rub $2.00.Fresh Fish Taco
$22.00
Grilled filet, or sauteed shrimp, ancho rub house-made mango pico de gallo, guacamole, cilantro, corn tortilla, siracha slaw
Pan Seared Pacific Salmon
$19.00
Crispy skin-on filet, simple, blackened or with a rub
Tuna Steak
$18.00
Sashimi grade tuna, simple, blackened or with a rub
Southern Sweet Tea Chicken
$18.00
Half chicken, roasted or fried, herb salsa verde
Butcher's Steak
21.00
10 oz. hanger steak, simple or with a rub House made steak sauce add fried farm egg $2.00
$Fisherman's Fry
Served with french fries, house slaw.Mixed Seafood Platter
$34.00
Crab cake, beer battered fish, fried shrimp, fried clams
Fish & Chips
$21.00
Beer battered fish
Crab Cakes
$28.00
Handmade lumpcakes
Fried Shrimp
$19.00
Fried Clams
18.00
$Sides
Broccoli
$6.00
Simply steamed
Farmstand Vegetable
$6.00
Olive oil & salt
Corn on the Cob
$4.00
Butter & salt
Smashed Reds
$7.00
Red potatoes smashed with butter & salt
House Slaw
$4.00
Creamy apple cider vinegar dressing
French Fries
$6.00
Simple or garlic provencal
Sweet Potato Fries
6.00
$Desserts
Chocolate Cake
$8.00
Key Lime Pie
$9.00
Creme Brulee Cheesecake
$10.00
Ice Cream
$7.00
Two scoops, vanilla or chocolate
Coffee - The Caretaker
$3.00
North fork coffee roasters
Menu for Old Mill Inn is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
