Buffalo's Best Catering American

Buffalo's Best Catering Menu

(716) 481-1117
4510 Lake Ave, Lancaster, NY 14086
$$$$$

Specialty Salads

Add chicken to any salad - additional $2.00 per person. Add shrimp to any salad - additional $3.00 per person.
Signature Salad
$3.50
Mixed field greens, gorgonzola cheese, mandarin oranges, toasted almonds, grape tomatoes, accompanied by our famous salad dressing.
House Garden Salad
$3.50
Antipasto
$3.50
Caesar Salad
$3.50
Spring Salad
$3.50
Mixed greens, blueberries, strawberries, raspberries with pine nuts and goat cheese with balsamic .
Berry Salad
$3.50
Mixed greens, blueberries, strawberries, gorganzola with poppyseed dreesing.
Fresh Raspberry Salad
$3.50
Arugala with cranberries, pears, gorganzola and candied walnuts with raspberry vinegrette
Poached Pear Salad
$3.50
Mixed field greens, pears, candy walnuts, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers with balsamic dressing
Caprese Salad
$3.50
Mixed field greens, cherry tomatoes, red peppers, black olives topped with fresh mozzarella and romano cheese with basil vinaigrette dressing
Sunflower Salad
$3.50
Mixed field greens, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, goat cheese crusted in sunflower seeds with roasted tomato dressing
Greek Salad
$3.50
Crisp romaine, greek olives, pepperonchini and feta cheese
Pistachio Salad
$3.50
Spring mix, gorgonzola cheese, pistachios, craisens with raspberry vinaigrette or signature dressing
Arugula Salad
$3.50
Baby arugala with goat cheese, pine nuts, cherry tomatoes, sweet peppers with rosemary balsamic dressing
Maria's Cobb Salad
$3.50
Romaine lettuce with shredded eggs, tomatoes, crumbly bleu cheese, bacon and chicken with a savory vinaigrette dressing
Braised Asparagus Salad
3.50
Romaine, brased asparagus, red grapes, cucumbers, baby spinach, feta cheese with french dressing

$Breakfast

Entrees: Breakfast sandwiches, eggs benedict, breakfast pizza, breakfast burritos, scrambled eggs pancakes, french toast, chocolate chip pancakes, quiche, fritatta, oatmeal with brown sugar, french toast sandwich with egg, bacon or sausage and side of syrup. Sides: home fries, sausage, bacon, muffins, croissants, danish, yogurt, fruit, bagels, honey glazed yogurt with fruit and a granola drizzle
Starter Breakfast
$8.00
Includes 1 entree or 2 sides
Ultimate Breakfast
10.00
Includes 2 entrees and 3 sides

$Buffets

All buffets include: Choice of chef salad or caesar salad. Includes Serving utensils, wrapped silverware, plates and napkins. Upgrade salad to a specialty salad for additional $0.50 per person.
Bronze Buffet
$8.50
Includes: 1 Entrees, 1 side, salad and bread
Silver Buffet
$9.50
Includes: 2 Entrees, 2 side, salad and bread
Gold Buffet
$10.50
Includes: 3 entrees, 2 sides, salad and bread
Taco Bar
$10.50
Includes: Chicken and beef, taco shells, all taco toppings, mexican rice, homemade chips and queso dip.
Pasta Entrees Selection
Penne pasta, penne pasta with meatball or sausage, baked penne pasta with ricotta cheese, lasagna - meat & cheese or vegetable, pasta alfredo, pasta alfredo with chicken, pasta with alfredo with broccoli, pasta gorganzola with spinach, artichokes and sundried tomato, pasta with kalamative olivs, hot peppers, garlic and olive oil, pasta ala norma - with fresh sauteed eggplant, diced tomatoes, basil, shallots, roasted red peppers, garlic with light red sauce topped with parmesan cheesePasta verde ? Pasta with zucchini, snap peas, scallions, baby spinach in garlic alio sauce, portabella mushroom pasta with gorgonzola cream sauce, pasta primavera, caprese pasta, manicotti, stuffed shells, eggplant parm, cheese ravioli, cheese tortellini, smoked mozzarella pasta, veggie pasta con vodka, rotini pasta with roa
Meat Entrees Selection
Our famous amos chicken, chicken parmesan, beef or chicken marsala, chicken picata, chicken florentine, chicken cordon bleu, chicken parm florentina, fried chicken, bruchetta chicken, chicken con vodka, almond crusted chicken, chicken provencal, chicken or sausage cacciatore, roasted red pepper chicken, hawaiian chicken, chicken stir fry - over rice, balsamic chicken with portabella, mushrooms, grape tomatoes & spinach, roasted turkey, hawaiian pork, pulled pork, grilled pork with mango chutney, virginia baked ham, italian sausage with peppers & onions, BBQ hamburger, italian chicken, garlic BBQ chicken, tuscan chicken, greek chicken, monte cristo chicken, blooming onion chicken, oriental crunchy chicken, garlic parm crusted chicken, breaded chicken breast, smoke house chicken&co
Entrees Selection
Entrees with an additional $0.50 charge. Roast beef, beef souvlaki, beef stroganoff, sundried tomato ravioli, spinach gorgonzola ravioli, tortellini with roasted red pepper or sundried tomato cream sauce, caprese chicken, chicken broccoli cheddar - baked over rice, caprese pasta with chicken, chicken souvlaki, beef stir fry, beef burgundy, pablano chicken, chicken in the grass, portabella mushroom raviolis, manhattan chicken, shrimp stir fry, shrimp fra diavlo, caprese pasta with shrimp, southwestern shrimp, shrimp carbonara, lobster mac n cheese, shrimp scampi, dill crusted salmon, balsamic salmon salmon, lobster ristotto, black & blue salmon additional $3000 per person
Additional Sides
$1.75
Pasta with roasted red pepper sauce, pasta with spinach in cream sauce, vegetable supreme, loaded potatoes, twice baked mashed potatoes, grilled asparagus, mediterranean tortellini salad: tortellini with roasted red pepper, cucumber, feta, onion, black olives and greek dressing, asparagus risotto, roasted fresh eggplant, roasted asparagus with parmesan and lemon garlic, harvest mashed potatoes, spinach augratin mashed potatoes, truffle mashed potatoes, truffle oven roasted potatoes, butternut squash, brussel sprout slaw, spaghetti squash with veggies. Additional $1.00 per person
Sides Selection
Fresh cole slaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, pasta salad, pasta with red sauce, fiesta corn, country baked beans, buttered corn, stuffing, mexican rice, wild rice, mashed potatoes with gray, garlic mashed potatoes, cheddar mashed potatoes, oven roasted potatoes, au gratin potatoes, parsley boiled potatoes, oven roasted sweet potato casserole, fresh vegetables, green bean almondine, honey glazed carrots, green bean casserole, 3 cheese mac & cheese, hot pepper mac-n-cheese, cranberry sauce, garlic herb roasted baby reds, broccoli, greek potatoes, italian green beans, pepperjack mashed potatoes, roasted red potatoes with tomato, garlic, olives, herbs & onions, roasted cauliflower augratin, cucumbers with taziki sauce, honey roasted baby red potatoes, grilled garlic par

Just Trays - Pasta


Pasta Gorganzola
$98.75-59.25
Pasta with spinach, artichoke, mushroom and sundried tomatoes in gorganzola cream sauce
Meat & Cheese Lasagna
$98.75-59.25
Layers of lasagna noodles, meat, ricotta cheese and sauce
Veggie Lasagna
$98.75-59.25
Layers of lasagna noodles, veggies, ricotta cheese and white wine
Eggplant Parm
$98.75-59.25
Pasta with Meatball or Sausage
$98.75-59.25
Smoked Gouda Mac ?N' Cheese
$98.75-59.25
Pasta with smoked gouda cheese sauce
Buffalo Chicken Wing Mac ?N' Cheese
$98.75-59.25
Stuffed Shells
$98.75-59.25
Manicotti
$98.75-59.25
Crepe pasta filled with ricotta cheese and red sauce
Cheese Ravioli with Red Sauce
$98.75-59.25
Spinach Gorganzola Raviolis
$98.75-59.25
Gorganzola Mushroom Risotto
98.75-59.25

$Just Trays - Meats


Chicken Picatta
$98.75-59.25
Egg battered chicken breast with capers and white wine, lemon and butter. Full tray 50 2 oz. pcs serves 20-25, half tray 30 2 oz. pcs serves 10-15
Chicken Florentine
$98.75-59.25
Pan seared chicken breast with spinach, white wine and fontinella cheese. Full tray 50 2 oz. pcs serves 20-25, half tray 30 2 oz. pcs serves 10-15
Chicken Cordon Bleu
$98.75-59.25
Breaded chicken breast topped with smoked ham, swiss cheese and cream sauce. Full tray 50 2 oz. pcs serves 20-25, half tray 30 2 oz. pcs serves 10-15
Chicken Parm
$98.75-59.25
Breaded chicken breast topped with marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese. Full tray 50 2 oz. pcs serves 20-25, half tray 30 2 oz. pcs serves 10-15
Almond Crusted Chicken
$98.75-59.25
Chicken breaded with breadcrumbs and shaved almonds in a citrus herb honey glaze. Full tray 50 2 oz. pcs serves 20-25, half tray 30 2 oz. pcs serves 10-15
Chicken Provencal
$98.75-59.25
Grilled chicken with artichokes, kalamative olives, peppers and onions in a white wine sauce. Full tray 50 2 oz. pcs serves 20-25, half tray 30 2 oz. pcs serves 10-15
Balsamic Chicken
$98.75-59.25
Grilled chicken with portabella mushrooms, grape tomatoes, spinach, balsamic and garlic. Full tray 50 2 oz. pcs serves 20-25, half tray 30 2 oz. pcs serves 10-15
Blooming Onion Chicken
$98.75-59.25
Onion crusted chicken breast with blooming onion sauce. Full tray 50 2 oz. pcs serves 20-25, half tray 30 2 oz. pcs serves 10-15
Monte Cristo Chicken
$98.75-59.25
Egg battered chicken breast layered with slices of ham and turkey, swiss cheese and dijon cream sauce. Full tray 50 2 oz. pcs serves 20-25, half tray 30 2 oz. pcs serves 10-15
Roast Beef
$111.25-66.65
Carved roast beef in au jus served with a mix of dinner and kimmelweck rolls and horseradish
Pulled Pork
$98.75-59.25
Marinated in a bourbon BBQ sauce and served with small dinner rolls
Oven Roasted Turkey
$98.75-59.25
Turkey slices topped with turkey gravy
Virginia Baked Ham
$98.75-59.25
Famous Amos Chicken
$98.75-59.25
Bone in chicken pieces grilled and marinated for 24 hours and baked
Fried Chicken
98.75-59.25

$Sandwich Melts, Wraps & Paninis


Sandwich Melts
$8.00
On sour dough bread with bag of chips. ham, turkey, tuna, roast beef, turkey club
Gourmet Wraps
$8.00
Philly cheese steak or chicken, chicken souvlaki, famous amos chicken, caprese chicken, steak or chicken fajita, chicken caesar, roast beef, steak, turkey, chicken, ham, tuna, veggie
Gourmet Sandwiches
$8.00
On pretzel and hard rolls
Turkey Panini
$8.00
Chicken Panini
$8.00
Steak Panini
$8.00
Roast Beef Panini
$8.00
Marinated Eggplant Panini
$8.00
Cajun Black ?N' Blue Chicken Panini
$8.00
Caprese Chicken Panini
$8.00
Deli Sandwich Platter
$8.50
With fresh rolls
Ten Pac
$64.95
Serves ten. 6 cold subs and 1/2 party size antipasto
Twenty Pac
119.95
Serves Twenty. 12 cold subs and 1 party size antipasto

$Cold Sub Choices


Ham
Salami
Cappicola
Assorted
Turkey
Roast Beef

Box Lunches


Deli Sandwich or Wrap
$9.50
With lettuce, tomato and cheese, chips, choice of cookie or apple, condiments and bottle of water
Ham, Turkey, Roast Beef, Tuna, Cappicola or Salami Sandwich or Wrap
7.50
With chips and cookie

$Party Pac


Two Large or 1 Sheet Cheese Pizza
52.99
With 1 item and bucket of wings. Add $2.05 for BBQ wings

$This & That - Platter

Small platters serve 10-15 people, large platters serve 15-22 people.
Fruit
$32.95-42.95
Fruit & Cheese
$34.95-46.95
Cheese & Crackers
$32.95-42.95
Gourmet Flat Breads
$32.95-44.95
Fried Raviolis
$36.95-46.95
Sante Fe Rolls
$33.95-43.95
Buffalo Bites
$32.95-42.95
Honey Sesame Bites
$32.95-42.95
Honey Sesame Shrimp
$36.95-46.95
Portabella Mushrooms
$36.95-46.95
Stuffed with spinach and gorganzola cheese
Sweet & Tangy Meatballs
$36.95-46.95
Chicken Satay
$36.95-46.95
Mini Crab Cakes
$60.00-80.00
Shrimp Cocktail
60.00-80.00

$This & That - Dips with Homemade Chips

Small platters serve 10-15 people, large platters serve 15-22 people.
Hot Pepper Dip
$34.95-44.95
Buffalo Wing Dip
$34.95-44.95
Spinach & Artichoke Dip
$34.95-44.95
Con Queso Dip
$34.95-44.95
Olive Tampenade with Pita Chips
$34.95-44.95
Hummus and Pita Chips
34.95-44.95

$Sides

Full tray: serves 20-25, half tray: serves 10-15
Pasta with Red Sauce
$60.00-30.00
Fresh Veggies
$60.00-30.00
Parsley Butter Boiled Potatoes
$60.00-30.00
Mashed Potatoes with Gravy
$60.00-30.00
Cheddar or Garlic Mashed Potatoes
$60.00-30.00
Three Cheese Mac ?N' Cheese
$60.00-30.00
Steamed Broccoli
$60.00-30.00
Green Beans Almondine
$60.00-30.00
Hot Pepper Mac ?N' Cheese
$60.00-30.00
Grilled Asparagus
$75.00-45.00
Garlic Parm Zucchini
$60.00-75.00
Brussel Sprout Slaw
$90.00-60.00
Spaghetti Squash with Veggies
90.00-60.00

$This & That - Dessert


Gourmet Dessert
$31.95-41.95
Cookies
31.95-41.95

$This & That - Beverages


Two Liter Soda
$2.75
20 oz. Soda
$1.75

Menu for Buffalo's Best Catering is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

Check Other Restaurant Menu