Starters
LIMITED TIME: Duck Wings in Jameson Orange Whiskey Ginger Sauce
$15.00
A Culinary Delight, Duck Wing Drumettes Tossed with Real Jameson Orange Whiskey Ginger Sauce and Served with Bleu Cheese Dressing and Celery.
Starter Sampler
$14.00
2 Pieces of Fried Mozzarella, 2 Fried Pickles, 2 Jalapeno Poppers, 2 Mac 'n' Cheese Wedges and 2 Fried Green Tomatoes. (Kitchen may substitute items based on availability).
Fried Mozzarella
$9.00
Battered, thick mozzarella sticks served with red sauce.
Fried Pickles
$9.00
Breaded pickle spears, not chips, fried crisp and crunchy; served with ranch dressing.
Tavern Seasoned Potato Flats
$9.00
Not a fry and not a chip. It's a potato flat and seasoned with Mattingly's Tavern's own proprietary Tavern Seasoning.
Jalapeno Poppers
$9.00
Cheddar cheese wrapped in a crunchy jalepeno and rolled in a savory breading. Served with ranch dressing.
Mac ‘N’ Cheese Triangles
$9.00
Fun and tasty. Mac 'n' Cheese cut into triangles, dipped in batter, and deep-fried until perfectly crisp. Served with ranch dressing
Onion Rings
$9.00
Beer-battered, thick-onion rings.
Colossal Pretzel
$9.00
When we say colossal, we mean giant. You haven’t seen a pretzel this size. It’s a pretzel that King Kong couldn't finish. Served salted with a side of Beer Cheese.
Half-Order of Wings (6)
$9.00
Any of Mattingly's Tavern Party Wing Flavors Just to Whet Your Appetite.
Loaded Baked Potato Stix
$8.00
Bacon, Cheese, Chives, and Flavorful Idaho Potato, All in a Dipping Stick Making a Tasty Treat. Served With Creamy Ranch Dressing.
Toasted Ravioli
$8.00
Made popular on "The Hill" in St. Louis, Missouri where Yogi Berra and Joe Garagiola call their hometown, "T-Rav" is deep-fried cheese ravioli served with red sauce and sure to become a New York favorite.
Hand-Breaded Butterfly Shrimp
$8.00
Six pieces of golden brown, hand-breaded butterfly shrimp.
Stuffed Baked Potato Sticks
$8.00
Literally, sharp cheddar, bacon bits, buttery flavor, and potato - all contained in a crispy dippin' stick and served with ranch dressing.
Chili
$7.00
Seasoned Cross Cut Fries
$7.00
Sweet Potato Fries
$9.00
Breaded Mushrooms
$8.00
Seasoned Breading and Deep-Fried, These Mushrooms Will Blow Your Mind.
Sweet Potato Fries
$9.00
For a limited time, enjoy a generous helping of straight-cut, Tavern-Seasoned Sweet Potato Fries.
8" Tavern Pizza
$9.00
Hand-Tossed Tavern Pizza, The Perfect Appetizer.
Chicken Cordon Bleu Balls
11.00
Ham and Swiss Cheese wrapped in Chicken, Lightly Breaded, and Quick-Fried and Served with Ranch Dressing Sauce Creating a Unique Taste Sensation.
$Long Relief
LIMITED TIME: Wagyu Beef Sliders
$19.00
Three Delicious Wagyu Beef Sliders on Toasted Slider Pretzel Buns.
Steakburger w/Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
$15.00
This isn't just any burger. It's a half-pound of USDA 80-20 beef served on a salted pretzel bun with lettuce, tomato, and onion and includes a side of our famous Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats.
The Stand-Up Double Steakburger w/Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
$21.00
Two incredible, USDA, half-pound patties comprise this massive burger is a beef-lover's dream; served on a salted pretzel bun, lettuce, lettuce, tomato, onion, and Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
Buffalo Crispy Chicken Sandwich w/Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
$19.00
Lightly Seasoning-Breaded Crispy Chicken Breast Tossed In Buffalo Sauce on a Grilled Pretzel Roll and Served With Side of Blue Cheese Dressing and Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats.
Chicken Wings
$15.00
Twelve (12) or more party wings seasoned with your favorite flavor.
Tavern Battered Atlantic Cod w/Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
$15.00
Comes with Tavern seasoned potato flats. w/Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
Fillet of Fish w/Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
$15.00
Served on a pretzel bun with lettuce, tomato and onion with Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats.
Grilled Chicken Sandwich w/Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
$15.00
Comes on a pretzel bun with lettuce, tomato and onion with Tavern seasoned potato flats.
Stadium Dogs w/Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
$15.00
Two all beef hot served with tavern seasoned potato flats.
Chicken Tenders w/Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
$15.00
Breaded chicken white-meat and deep-fried to golden perfection and served with Matttingly's Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
Tavern Salad
$15.00
A bed of seasonal, locally grown and/or sourced greens topped with Gorgonzola, cranberries, onions, celery, and Warwick Valley apple slices.
Chicken Tenders w/Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
$15.00
Crispy Chicken Strips served with Tavern Seasoned Potato Flats
Gorgonzola Bacon Burger w/Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
$19.00
Add Thick-Cut, Applewood-Smoked Bacon and Gorgonzola Crumbles to our Signature, Half-Pound Steakburger and What You Have Is Something Extremely . . . YUMMY!
Bacon Egg & Cheese Steakburger w/Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
$19.00
Who ever said you can't have breakfast and lunch at the same time. Enjoy Mattingly's Tavern half-pound burger, cooked-to-order, with our maple-smoked, thick-cut back, American cheese, and an over-easy, farm fresh egg.
Beyond Burger w/Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
$19.00
Meatless. Served on a pretzel bun with lettuce, tomato and onion with Tavern seasoned potato flats.
Caramelized Onion Swiss Burger w/Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
$19.00
Enjoy Mattingly's Tavern's half-pound steakburger with caramelized onions and fresh Swiss cheese served with our fresh-cut Potato Flats.
Crispy Chicken Sandwich w/Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
$15.00
Lightly Seasoning-Breaded Crispy Chicken Breast Meat on a Grilled Pretzel Roll and Served With Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats.
Jack Daniels Honey Bourbon Four Cheese Bacon Burger
$21.00
You Read It Right. Mattingly's Tavern Half-Pound Steakburger Dressed with Real Jack Daniels Honey Bourbon Sauce, Cheddar, Gorgonzola, Swiss, and American Cheeses, and a Slice of Thick-Cut, Applewood-Smoked Bacon Served With Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
LIMITED TIME: Wild Boar Burger w/Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
$17.00
Real, Juicy, Ground Wild Boar On a Soft Pretzel Roll and Served With Mattingly's Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats. Don't Wait. This Is a Special, Limited Time Item.
New York Strip Steak
$26.00
A 12-ounce New York Strip steak, cooked to order, served with Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats.
Tavern Pizza
$15.00
The Mattingly's Tavern Pizza features only the finest, gourmet ingredients including fresh mozzarella and parmesan cheese, locally-sourced plum tomatoes, kosher salt, olive oil and crust-high flour.
LIMITED TIME: Corned-Beef & Cabbage with Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
$13.00
For the entire week beginning Sunday, March 14, 2021, enjoy traditional St. Patrick's Day fare, Corned-Beef & Cabbage with a Mattingly's Tavern twist. Our CB&C includes Mattingly's Tavern famous and fresh-cut daily Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats. Get 'em while the getting's good.
Thanksgiving Day Dinner
$22.00
For delivery on Thanksgiving Day - Thursday, 11/26/20 only, Mattingly's Tavern Thanksgiving Dinner includes Turkey, Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats, Cornbread Stuffing, Green Beans, Cranberry Sauce, and a Mattingly's Mason Jar Cocktail.
The Dinger Steakburger w/Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
$17.00
A half-pound of 100% USDA beef burger topped with bacon, Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats, Fried Mozzarella, and served on a salted pretzel roll. Of course, a side of more Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats complement this burger sensation.
Texas Toast Grilled Cheese Sandwich w/Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
$11.00
Comes on a pretzel bun with Tavern seasoned potato flats.
Corned Beef & Cabbage
$11.00
For a limited time. Slow-cooked corned beef with carrots, red potatoes, and green cabbage
Beer Brat on a Brioche Bun
$11.00
Served with Tavern seasoned potato flats.
Tavern Salad
$11.00
Green leaf lettuce, tomatoes, onions, celery, candied walnuts, dried cranberries with balsamic vinaigrette. Add proteins for an additional charge.
Barbecued Thunder Thighs
13.00
Bring your appetite. New to the menu at Mattingly's Tavern, brachiosaur-sized Barbecued Thunder Thighs. Our enormous, bone-in, skin-on chicken thighs slathered in our sweet and tangy barbecue sauce are served with Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats.
$Closers
Fried Oreos with Fluff Closer
$11.00
Ballpark Candy Closer
$3.00
Dutch Apple Pie - Thanksgiving Day Only
$5.00
Thanksgiving Day Only, just like home-made Dutch Apple Pie with a generous scoop of whipped cream.
Pumpkin Pie - Thanksgiving Day Only
5.00
Thanksgiving Day Only, just like home-made Pumpkin Pie with a generous scoop of whipped cream.
$Cocktails To-Go (Must be 21 to Purchase)
Growlers & Pints: Beer On-Tap To-Go (Must be 21 to Purchase)
Enjoy your favorite beer by the pint or by the half-gallon growler in a Mattingly's Mason Jar.Fat Tire On-Tap
$8.00
The New York State Liquor Authority “Restrictions Licensees in Response to the COVID-19 Outbreak,†Any on-premises licensee . . . may sell for off-premises consumption any alcoholic beverages that it is able to sell for on premises consumption . . . sold in any closed and sealed original container of any size. Provided that the sale of each container shall be accompanied by the purchase of food. Must‌ ‌be‌ ‌21‌ ‌to‌ ‌purchase.
Captain Lawrence 6th Borough Pilsner On-Tap
$7.00
The New York State Liquor Authority “Restrictions Licensees in Response to the COVID-19 Outbreak,†Any on-premises licensee . . . may sell for off-premises consumption any alcoholic beverages that it is able to sell for on premises consumption . . . sold in any closed and sealed original container of any size. Provided that the sale of each container shall be accompanied by the purchase of food. Must be 21 to purchase.
Doc's Cider On-Tap
$8.00
The New York State Liquor Authority “Restrictions Licensees in Response to the COVID-19 Outbreak,†Any on-premises licensee . . . may sell for off-premises consumption any alcoholic beverages that it is able to sell for on premises consumption . . . sold in any closed and sealed original container of any size. Provided that the sale of each container shall be accompanied by the purchase of food. Must‌ ‌be‌ ‌21‌ ‌to‌ ‌purchase.
Guinness On-Tap
$8.00
The New York State Liquor Authority “Restrictions Licensees in Response to the COVID-19 Outbreak,†Any on-premises licensee . . . may sell for off-premises consumption any alcoholic beverages that it is able to sell for on premises consumption . . . sold in any closed and sealed original container of any size. Provided that the sale of each container shall be accompanied by the purchase of food. Must‌ ‌be‌ ‌21‌ ‌to‌ ‌purchase.
Pabst Blue Ribbon On-Tap
$3.50
The New York State Liquor Authority “Restrictions Licensees in Response to the COVID-19 Outbreak,†Any on-premises licensee . . . may sell for off-premises consumption any alcoholic beverages that it is able to sell for on premises consumption . . . sold in any closed and sealed original container of any size. Provided that the sale of each container shall be accompanied by the purchase of food. Must‌ ‌be‌ ‌21‌ ‌to‌ ‌purchase.
Shock Top Belgian White On-Tap
$3.50
The New York State Liquor Authority “Restrictions Licensees in Response to the COVID-19 Outbreak,†Any on-premises licensee . . . may sell for off-premises consumption any alcoholic beverages that it is able to sell for on premises consumption . . . sold in any closed and sealed original container of any size. Provided that the sale of each container shall be accompanied by the purchase of food. Must‌ ‌be‌ ‌21‌ ‌to‌ ‌purchase.
Stella Artois On-Tap
$7.25
The New York State Liquor Authority “Restrictions Licensees in Response to the COVID-19 Outbreak,†Any on-premises licensee . . . may sell for off-premises consumption any alcoholic beverages that it is able to sell for on premises consumption . . . sold in any closed and sealed original container of any size. Provided that the sale of each container shall be accompanied by the purchase of food. Must be 21 to purchase.
Growler Fat Tire
$29.00
The New York State Liquor Authority “Restrictions Licensees in Response to the COVID-19 Outbreak,†Any on-premises licensee . . . may sell for off-premises consumption any alcoholic beverages that it is able to sell for on premises consumption . . . sold in any closed and sealed original container of any size. Provided that the sale of each container shall be accompanied by the purchase of food. Must‌ ‌be‌ ‌21‌ ‌to‌ ‌purchase.
Growler Glenmere Lucid Dragon On-Tap
$29.00
The New York State Liquor Authority “Restrictions Licensees in Response to the COVID-19 Outbreak,†Any on-premises licensee . . . may sell for off-premises consumption any alcoholic beverages that it is able to sell for on premises consumption . . . sold in any closed and sealed original container of any size. Provided that the sale of each container shall be accompanied by the purchase of food. Must‌ ‌be‌ ‌21‌ ‌to‌ ‌purchase.
Growler Guinness On-Tap
$29.00
The New York State Liquor Authority “Restrictions Licensees in Response to the COVID-19 Outbreak,†Any on-premises licensee . . . may sell for off-premises consumption any alcoholic beverages that it is able to sell for on premises consumption . . . sold in any closed and sealed original container of any size. Provided that the sale of each container shall be accompanied by the purchase of food. Must‌ ‌be‌ ‌21‌ ‌to‌ ‌purchase.
GROWLER City Roots Rose Cider On-Tap
$29.00
The New York State Liquor Authority “Restrictions Licensees in Response to the COVID-19 Outbreak,†Any on-premises licensee . . . may sell for off-premises consumption any alcoholic beverages that it is able to sell for on premises consumption . . . sold in any closed and sealed original container of any size. Provided that the sale of each container shall be accompanied by the purchase of food. Must‌ ‌be‌ ‌21‌ ‌to‌ ‌purchase.
Growler Pabst Blue Ribbon On-Tap
$13.00
The New York State Liquor Authority “Restrictions Licensees in Response to the COVID-19 Outbreak,†Any on-premises licensee . . . may sell for off-premises consumption any alcoholic beverages that it is able to sell for on premises consumption . . . sold in any closed and sealed original container of any size. Provided that the sale of each container shall be accompanied by the purchase of food. Must‌ ‌be‌ ‌21‌ ‌to‌ ‌purchase.
GROWLER Stella Artois On-Tap
$25.00
The New York State Liquor Authority “Restrictions Licensees in Response to the COVID-19 Outbreak,†Any on-premises licensee . . . may sell for off-premises consumption any alcoholic beverages that it is able to sell for on premises consumption . . . sold in any closed and sealed original container of any size. Provided that the sale of each container shall be accompanied by the purchase of food. Must‌ ‌be‌ ‌21‌ ‌to‌ ‌purchase.
Doc's Hard "Crisp Apple" Cider On-Tap
$8.00
Must‌ ‌be‌ ‌21‌ ‌to‌ ‌purchase.
Growler: Doc's Hard "Crisp Apple" Cider
29.00
Must‌ ‌be‌ ‌21‌ ‌to‌ ‌purchase.
$Bottled Beer - Domestic, Craft, IPA, & More (Must be 21 to Purchase)
The New York State Liquor Authority “Restrictions Licensees in Response to the COVID-19 Outbreak,†Any on-premises licensee . . . may sell for off-premises consumption any alcoholic beverages that it is able to sell for on premises consumption . . . sold in any closed and sealed original container of any size. Provided that the sale of each container shall be accompanied by the purchase of food. Must be 21-years old to purchase alcoholBall Park Beverages
Soda
$3.75
Juice
$3.75
Bottomless Coffee
$3.75
Tea
$3.75
Fresh Brewed Unsweetened Iced Tea
$3.75
Shirley Temple
$7.00
Real Sugar Coca-Cola Bottle
$5.00
Mexico.
Coca Cola
$3.50
Diet Coca Cola
$3.50
Sprite 20-Ounce Bottle
3.50
$Ball Park Beverages (Must be 21 to Purchase)
Package Liquor To-Go (Must be 21 to Purchase)
Gifts & Souvenirs
Enjoy Mattingly's Tavern "Really Good Bar Food" and Remember Your Visit With Some Great Souvenirs. Get Something for Yourself and Get Something as a Gift.Mattingly's Tavern T-Shirt
$25.00
Men's and Women's Cut T-Shirts, Second Edition. The Front Features Mattingly's Tavern "Hops" Logo. The Back Features the Phrase, "Quarantine Me at Mattingly's Tavern.
Mattingly's Tavern Koozie
$5.00
Keep Your Soft Drink, Beer, or Any Beverage With a Mattingly's Tavern Koozie
Mattingly's Tavern Magic Dust Seasoning
$15.00
Ever wonder about the secret ingredient that makes all of Mattingly's Tavern food so good? Well, it's Magic Dust and your can take some home for yourself.
Menu for Mattingly's Tavern is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
