Breakfast Sandwiches
Egg Sandwich
$5.50
2 scrambled eggs sandwich.
Egg and Cheese Sandwich
$6.00
2 scrambled eggs sandwich with cheese.
Bacon and Egg Sandwich
$6.00
2 scrambled eggs and bacon sandwich.
Sausage and Egg Sandwich
$6.00
2 scrambled eggs with sausage sandwich.
Bacon, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich
$7.00
2 scrambled eggs with bacon and cheese sandwich.
Ham and Egg Sandwich
$6.00
2 scrambled eggs with Forest Pork Store cooked ham sandwich.
Grilled Ham and Cheese Sandwich
$6.00
Grilled Forest Pork Store cooked ham and cheese sandwich.
Ham, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich
$7.00
2 scrambled eggs with Forest Pork Store cooked ham and cheese sandwich.
Sausage, Egg and Cheese
$7.00
2 scrambled eggs, sausage, and cheese sandwich.
Jersey Pork Roll, Egg and Cheese Sandwich
$8.50
2 scrambled eggs, Taylor ham, and cheese sandwich.
Scrapple, Egg and Cheddar Sandwich
$9.50
2 over easy eggs, scrapple, cheddar with real NYS maple syrup on an onion roll.
Cream Cheese and Bacon Sandwich
$6.00
Grilled Cheese Sandwich on Plain Rye
5.50
$Salad Sandwiches
Smoked Whitefish Salad Sandwich
$13.00
Shelsky's of Brooklyn famous whitefish salad made with Door County, Wisconsin smoked whitefish, cucumbers, and celery sandwich.
Baked Salmon Salad Sandwich
$13.00
Shelsky's of Brooklyn rich and smooth baked salmon salad.
Seriously Great Tuna Salad Sandwich
$11.50
Shelsky's of Brooklyn seriously great tuna salad sandwich.
Chopped Herring Sandwich
$10.50
Shelsky's of Brooklyn chopped pickled herring.
Chopped Liver Sandwich
$13.00
Shelsky's of Brooklyn homemade chopped chicken liver mixed with fried onions, hard-boiled eggs and luscious amounts of schmaltz.
Egg Salad Sandwich
$9.50
Shelsky's of Brooklyn egg salad with cornichons (French gherkin pickles).
Chicken Salad Sandwich
11.00
Shelsky's of Brooklyn chicken salad with Giannone chickens with pecans, grapes, and celery sandwich.
$Schmear Sandwiches
Plain Cream Cheese Sandwich
$5.00
Scallion Cream Cheese Sandwich
$5.50
Lox Cream Cheese Sandwich
$7.00
Cream cheese mixed with ground Nova smoked salmon.
Vegetable Cream Cheese Sandwich
$7.00
Cream cheese mixed with bell peppers, scallions, and garlic.
Jalapeno Cream Cheese Sandwich
$5.50
Cream cheese mixed with spicy jalapenos.
Sichuan Spicy Chili Crisp Cream Cheese Sandwich
$6.00
Cream cheese mixed with spicy chili crisp (ground dried chilies, soy nuts, fried onions, Sichuan peppercorns, MSG).
Goat Cream Cheese Sandwich
$7.50
Tofu Cream Cheese Sandwich
$6.00
Ben's Cheese Planet tofu cream cheese.
Tofu Scallion Cream Cheese Sandwich
$6.50
Ben's Cheese Planet tofu cream cheese with scallions.
Ben's Cream Cheese Sandwich
$7.00
Ben's cheese planet all-natural plain cream cheese sandwich.
Butter Sandwich
$3.00
Butter and Jelly Sandwich
$3.50
Butter and choice of raspberry or apricot fruit preserves on choice of bread.
Cream Cheese and Jelly Sandwich
5.50
Cream cheese and choice of raspberry or apricot fruit preserves on bread.
$Smoked Fish Sandwiches
Member Of The Tribe Sandwich
$13.50
Hand-sliced Nova smoked salmon with cream cheese sandwich (aka bagel with lox).
Brooklyn Native Sandwich
$15.50
Our famous whitefish salad made with Door County, Wisconsin whitefish, hand-sliced Nova smoked salmon, chopped herring salad, and sour pickles sandwich.
The Great Gatsby Sandwich
$15.50
Hand-sliced pastrami-smoked salmon, horseradish cream cheese, honey mustard, and sliced red onions on caraway-seeded rye.
The Newhouse Sandwich
$15.50
Hand-sliced wild Alaskan sable, scallion cream cheese, and tomato on a toasted onion bialy.
The Turboff Sandwich
$16.00
Baked salmon salad with hand-sliced Nova smoked salmon, horseradish cream cheese, tomatoes, red onions, capers and lemon juice on a toasted onion bialy.
The Clementine Sandwich
15.00
House-cured gravlax with butter, red onion, tomato, capers and lemon juice on a toasted bialy.
$Lunch Sandwiches Your Way
Roast Beef Sandwich
$11.50
Roast Turkey Sandwich
$11.50
Homemade roasted Dipaola Farm turkey sandwich.
Cooked Ham Sandwich
$8.00
Black Forest Ham Sandwich
$9.00
Virginia Ham Sandwich
$9.00
Sliced Liverwurst Sandwich
$7.00
Bologna Sandwich
$7.00
Genoa Salami
$9.00
Roast Turkey
$8.00
Salsalito Turkey
8.00
$Lunch Sandwiches Our Way
Chopped Cheese Sandwich
$9.00
Chopped up hamburgers with melted American cheese, grilled onions, raw onions, tomatoes, lettuce, mayo, and ketchup pressed on a seeded hero.
Roast Beef on an Onion Roll Sandwich
$16.00
Homemade roast beef, butter, Dijon mustard, and crispy fried onions on an onion roll.
Shelsky's Roast Turkey Sandwich
$16.50
Homemade roasted Dipaola turkey farm turkey, coleslaw, Swiss, and Russian dressing on rye or pumpernickel.
Shelsky's Hot Pastrami Sandwich
$21.00
Shelsky's of Brooklyn delicatessen hot pastrami, sliced thin, with deli mustard on rye.
Shelsky's Corned Beef Sandwich
$22.00
Shelsky's of Brooklyn delicatessen hot corned beef with deli mustard on rye.
Shelsky's Reuben Sandwich
$23.00
Shelsky's of Brooklyn delicatessen hot corned beef, Riesling-braised sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing pressed on plain rye.
Lewis' Knish Bomb Sandwich
$19.00
Shelsky's of Brooklyn delicatessen hot pastramI, Riesling-braised sauerkraut, and deli mustard served on a fried Coney Island-style knish.
Shelsky's Hot Pastrami Sandwich
23.00
Shelsky's Of Brooklyn Delicatessen hot pastrami, sliced thinly with deli mustard on Orwasher's rye
$Bagels, Bialys, and Bread
Plain Bagel
$1.60-20.00
3-day fermented, sourdough plain bagels, dense, chewy, just the right size.
Sesame Bagels
$1.60-20.00
Our plain bagels coated with all natural sesame seeds and a hint of pretzel salt.
Poppy Bagel
$1.60-20.00
Our plain bagels coated with poppy seeds.
Onion Bagel
$1.60-20.00
Our plain bagels coated with dried onions.
Garlic Bagel
$1.60-20.00
Our plain bagels coated with crunchy garlic.
Cracked Pepper and Salt Bagel
$1.60-20.00
A bagel au poivre.
Sichuan Peppercorn Black Sesame Bagel
$1.60-20.00
Our plain bagels with the numbing zing of imported single plantation Sichuan peppercorns.
Salt Bagel
$1.60-20.00
Our plain bagels with pretzel salt.
Everything Bagel
$1.60-20.00
Our plain bagels coated with sesame, poppy, onion, garlic, and pretzel salt.
Whole Wheat Bagels
$1.60-20.00
A whole wheat bagel made whole wheat flour and a mash of rolled and steel cut oats, hemp seed, flax seed and wheat germ topped with a germ mixture.
Whole Wheat Everything Bagel
$1.60-20.00
Our stunning whole wheat bagels topped with our everything topping.
Pumpernickel Bagel
$1.60-20.00
A complex chewy bagel with rye flour, coffee, and cocoa powder.
Egg Bagel
$1.60-20.00
Not your average egg bagel? made with egg yolks, turmeric, annatto, and Indian sulfur salt.
Cinnamon Raisin Bagel
$1.60-20.00
Not as sweet as is often the case, our cinnamon raisin bagels are pretty perfect.
Onion Bialy
$1.60-19.00
The lighter Polish-Jewish, not boiled cousin of the bagel with slow-cooked onion jam.
Garlic Bialy
$1.60-19.00
The lighter Polish-Jewish, not boiled cousin of the bagel with roasted garlic confit, poppy seeds, and pretzel salt.
Mixed Dozen
$20.00
Choice of any mixture of bagels and/or bialys. If you would like multiples of a certain flavor and/or combination, please indicate the quantity of each in the Special Instructions.
Gluten Free Plain Bagel
$12.00
The great knead gluten free bagels, pack of 4, comes frozen.
4 Pack Gluten Free Everything Bagels
$12.00
The great knead gluten free bagels, pack of 4, comes frozen.
Onion Roll
$1.60
Orwasher's bakery famous onion pockets with onion inside and out, a NYC classic.
Kaiser Roll
$1.60
Mazzola bakery kaiser rolls, simple, classic.
Seeded Hero Roll
$2.50
Classic seeded hero roll from Mazzola bakery.
Lard Bread
7.00
Mazzola bakery lard bread, a hero loaf with salamI, cheese, and lots of black pepper? a Carroll Gardens Italian classic.
$1/2 lb. Deli Meats
1/2 lb. Bologna
$7.00
Forest Pork Store bologna is mild and silky.
1/2 lb. Cooked Ham
$7.00
Forest Pork Store ham is cooked and has a clean ham flavor.
1/2 lb. Black Forest Ham
$8.00
Forest Pork Store black forest ham is a little dryer, firmer, and smokier than the cooked ham.
1/2 lb. Westphalian Ham
$8.00
Forest Pork Store Westphalian ham is their smokiest. It is really terrific served with butter.
1/2 lb. Braunschweiger
$7.00
Forest Pork Store's Braunschweiger liverwurst is a tender, sliceable liverwurst? it's a personal favorite of ours.
1/2 lb. Cervelatwurst
$8.00
Forest Pork Store cervelat is a hard salami that is perfect served on a roll with some butter.
1/2 lb. Roast Beef
$14.50
We roast our beef in-house at Shelsky's of Brooklyn on Court Street. It is rare to medium rare and perfectly brined.
1/2 lb. Turkey
$14.50
We brine Dipaola Turkey Farm breasts and thighs for 3 days, tie them into roasts and roast them slowly. No emulsified turkey product here!
1/2 lb. Corned Beef
$16.00
Our corned beef is cured for more than a week with a balanced blend of spices for that classic Brooklyn flavor. We then steam it until tender it's super tender.
1/2 lb. Pastrami
16.00
Our pastrami is cut from the navel, making it super moist. Cured for more than a week, then rubbed and smoked, we steam it until it is super tender!
$1/2 lb. Schmears
1/2 lb. Plain Cream Cheese
$5.50
Double-whipped plain cream cheese.
1/2 lb. Scallion Cream Cheese
$6.00
Double-whipped cream cheese with scallions.
1/2 lb. Lox Cream Cheese
$9.25
Double-whipped cream cheese mixed with ground Nova smoked salmon.
1/2 lb. Vegetable Cream Cheese
$8.50
Double-whipped cream cheese with bell peppers, scallions, and garlic.
1/2 lb. Horseradish Cream Cheese
$8.50
Double-whipped cream cheese with freshly grated horseradish root.
1/2 lb. Jalapeno Cream Cheese
$6.00
Double-whipped cream cheese with spicy jalapenos. (It is actually spicy.)
1/2 lb. Sichuan Chili Crisp Cream Cheese
$7.00
Double-whipped cream cheese with spicy chilI crisp (Ground dried chilies, soy nuts, fried onions, Sichuan peppercorns, and MSG).
1/2 lb. Ben's All Natural Cream Cheese
$6.50
Ben's Cheese Planet all-natural plain cream cheese is extra creamy and luxurious.
1/2 lb. Goat Cream Cheese
$9.00
Creamy goat cream cheese with assertive goaty-ness.
1/2 lb. Tofu Cream Cheese
$8.00
Ben's Cheese Planet's tofu cream cheese.
1/2 lb. Tofu Scallion Cream Cheese
8.50
Ben's Cheese Planet's tofuc ream cheese with scallions mixed in.
$1/2 lb. Salads
Beverages
16 oz. Cup Cold Brew Ashlawn Farm Coffee
$4.50
12 oz. Fresh Squeezed Juice
$4.00
16.9 oz. Poland Spring Water
$1.50
Canada Dry Seltzer
$1.50
Canned Soda
$1.50
Dr. Browns Canned Soda
$1.75
Yoo-Hoo Can
$1.75
Harmless Harvest Coconut Water
$5.00-6.50
Tropicana Orange Juice 14 oz. Carton
$3.25
Hint Water
$3.25
Spindrift Sparkling Water 16 oz. Can
3.50
$Coffee and Tea
Drip Coffee
$2.50-3.50
Ashlawn Farm's Deterra Villa Borghese coffee rich and bold.
Darjeeling Tea
$2.50-3.50
Palais des Thes Margaret's Hope Darjeeling is a classic morning black tea.
Earl Grey Tea
$2.50-3.50
Palais des Thes Margaret's Blue of London has floral notes and citrusy bergamot.
Mint Green Tea
$2.50-3.50
Palais des Thes green tea with mint is mild and soul-affirming.
Genmaicha Green Tea
$2.50-3.50
Palais des Thes Genmaicha is a mild Japanese green tea with toasted rice.
Rooibos
$2.50-3.50
Palais des Thes Rooibos red tea has no caffeine and has notes of sweet tobacco and vanilla.
Menu for Shelsky's Brooklyn Bagels is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
