Jars
Gimme S'more (seasonal May-Sept)
$5.95-8.95
Graham cracker crust, fudge center and toasted marshmallow.
Hot Fudge Toffee Crunch Jar
$8.95
Fudgey brownie, toffee and heath bar crunch. Contain nuts. Large, 11oz.
Monkey Madness Jar
$5.95-8.95
Banana cake, toffee, candied pecans with a shortbread crust. Contain nuts.
Apple Jar
$8.95
Classic apple crumb pie. 11oz
Lemon Lust Jar
$8.95
Shortbread crust, lemon filling, lemon poppy seed poundcake and glaze. Large, 11oz.
Peanut Butter Fudge Jar
$5.95-8.95
Fudgey brownie with peanut butter topping. Contain nuts.
Pecan Jar
$5.95-8.95
Shortbread crust with pecan pie filling. Contain nuts.
Funfetti Jar
$5.95-8.95
Vanilla cake, vanilla frosting and rainbow sprinkles.
Black and White Jar
$5.95-8.95
Devils food cake, fudge with vanilla frosting.
Fudgey Mint Chip Jar
$6.00
Fudgey brownie, white chocolate chips and fudge topping with white chocolate peppermint pieces. No nuts. 4oz.
Old Fashioned
$7.00
Just like the popular holiday drink! Shortbread crust, spiked toffee with bitters and lemon, whiskey cake topped with glaze.
Pecan
$8.95
Shortbread crust, gooey pecan pie. 11oz
Pumpkin Bourbon
$6.95
Shortbread crust, pumpkin pie, topped with Bourbon syrup. Alcohol is baked off.
Gift Pack
$29.95
Includes 6 small jars and cute gift box! 2 Hot Fudge, 2 Apple, 2 Peanut Butter Fudge OR in Notes please list up to six flavors you would like! Originally sold for $39.95, now on sale!
Peanut Fudge Jar Pie
$5.95-8.95
fudgey brownie topped with peanut butter and mini chocolate chips
Red Velvet Cake Jar
$5.95-8.95
Layers of red velvet cake and cream cheese frosting!
Strawberry Limeade
$5.95-8.95
Sugar cookie crust, tart strawberry limeade filling, topped with sprinkled sugar cookie.
Gimme S'more
$5.95-8.95
Graham cracker crust, fudge center, toasted Squish Smore's Marshmallow, baked in a jar!
Strawberry Poundcake
8.95
Layers of whip cream, poundcake and strawberry mousse!
$Main Menu
Corn Muffin
$3.00
Muffin
Contains wheat and dairy.
Cinnamon Bun
$4.50
Buttery dough swirled with cinnamon and sugar.
Cheesecake 6"
$27.00
Graham cracker crust, 4-6 servings.
Cupcakes
Contains dairy & wheat.
Mini Cupcakes
Contains dairy & wheat.
Banoffee
$5.00-6.00
8 oz. Layers of toffee, bananas, Nilla wafer crumb and whipped cream. Choose between regular or gluten free.
Tiramisu
$6.00
8 oz. Layers of custard and hand piped ladyfingers soaked in coffee liqueur topped with a dusting of cocoa powder.
Bread Pudding
$5.00
8 oz. Baked creamy custard with cinnamon buns. Best served warm.
Chocolate Covered Pretzels Gluten Free
$14.00
Fatty Sundays Brand, dark chocolate covered gluten free pretzels with sprinkles. 6oz resealable bag.
Coffee Cake
$2.75
Soft coffee cake perfect with our ice coffee!
Cookies + Cream
$4.00
Layers of Oreo cookies and whip cream, topped with a Fudge drizzle. 5 oz.
Mini Cheesecake
$3.00-3.00
Mini cheesecake with graham cracker crust. Choose from plain or Strawberry.
3'' Cheesecake
$6.00-6.00
Choose from Plain cheesecake with Graham Cracker crust or Strawberry with graham cracker crust and strawberries pureed on top. Choice of whip cream or plain.
TPIN Pie
$7.00
Certified Vegan, Gluten Free and Paleo, This Pie Is Nuts! Single serving little pies full of nothing but the good stuff. These pies are made with a nut crust, not advised for any nut allergy. TPIN does not add any sugar, only sweetened with a little maple syrup.
Banana Bread Pudding
$5.00
8oz of heaven! Banana Bread soaked in custard and baked with chocolate chips, drizzled with Nutella.
Cream Puffs
$1.00
Dough filled with pastry cream, fluffy and delicious!
Banana Cream Tart
$5.00
Graham cracker crust, caramelized bananas, pastry cream topped with fresh whip cream and salted caramel sauce! *Limited quantities
Tres Leches
$5.00
Vanilla cake soaked in sweetened milks and topped with whip cream! 8oz.
Peanut Butter Tart
5.00
Graham cracker crust, peanut butter mousse and fudge.
$Cookies
Eva Cookies
$0.95
Butter cookies sandwiched with buttercream and raspberry jam.
Mini Black and White Cookies
$1.00
Classic New York cookie.
Wedding Cookies
$0.95
Pecan shortbread cookies. Contains nuts, wheat and dairy.
Chocolate Chunk
$1.00
Classic chocolate chip (chewy).
Chocolate Chunk Sandwich
$3.00
Two cookies sandwiched with vanilla frosting.
Nutella Thumbprint Cookie
$0.95
Buttery cookie with dollop of Nutella baked inside.
Raspberry Thumbprint Cookie
$0.95
Buttery cookie with dollop of raspberry jam baked inside.
Gingerbread Cookie
Gingerbread Man decorated for the holidays
Chocolate Chunk S'mores
$2.00
Chocolate chunk cookie, dipped in chocolate, dipped in marshmallow then toasted.
Oatmeal Mix Up
$1.50
Oatmeal Raisin with pretzels, white chocolate chips and mini M&M's
Loaded Cookie
$1.00
Loaded with Oreos, Rainbow Sprinkles, White Chocolate Chips and Brownie bits!
Sprinkle Cookie
$0.95
Mini sugar cookie covered in sprinkles
Rainbow Cookies
$1.25-2.75
Layers of teal, white and pink almond cake with raspberry jam and topped with chocolate. Our take on an Italian cookie!
Chocolate Chocolate
$1.50
Chewy chocolate cookie loaded with gobs of chocolate chunks!
Red Velvet Cookie
$1.50
Soft Red Velvet cookie with white chocolate chips
Stuffed Cookie
$1.50
Stuffed chewy chocolate chip cookies! Stuffed with housemade fudge and Snickers.
Peanut Butter Cookie
$1.50
Peanut Butter cookie with peanut butter chips
Tiny Cookie Sandwich
1.75
Tiny Birthday sugar cookies sandwiched with vanilla frosting and sprinkles. One per order.
$Bars and Brownies
Pecan Bar
$4.00
Shortbread crust, gooey pecan filling baked on top. Nuts, wheat and dairy.
Lemon Bar
$2.50
Shortbread crust, tart lemon filling baked on top. No nuts. Contains wheat and dairy.
Brownie
$2.50
Rich and fudgey brownie.
Cheesecake Brownie
$2.50
Fudgey brownie with cheesecake swirl.
Key Lime Bar
$2.50
Tart key lime bar with buttery shortbread crust. Topped with toasted meringue.
Cheesecake Jam Swirl Brownie
$2.50
Fudgey Brownie swirled with cheesecake and raspberry jam
Peanut Butter Reeses Stuffed Brownie
$2.50
Name says it all! Rich brownie stuffed with gobs of peanut butter and Reese's Cups
S'mores Bar
$3.00
Graham cracker crust, fudge center, topped with toasted meringue
Dream Bar
$2.50
Graham cracker crust, toasted pecans, white and dark chocolate covered in sweet coconut!
Blondie
$3.50
Chewy blondie with chocolate chunks topped with Unicorn Sprinkles!
Red Velvet Bar
4.00
Chewy red velvet cookie crust, creamy cream cheese filling topped with whip cream, oreos and chocolate chips.
$Cakes
Carrot Cake Slice
$5.50
Slice of carrot cake with cream cheese frosting. No nuts.
Chocolate cake with Vanilla Frosting Slice
$5.00
Pink Velvet Slice
$5.00
Vanilla cake, with almond extract, with Vanilla Frosting
Tiny Cake
$5.75
3'' Whole Tiny Cake. Please call for flavor.
Vanilla Cake/Vanilla Frosting Slice
$5.00
Vanilla Cake with Vanilla Frosting
German Chocolate Cake Slice
5.50
Light Chocolate cake, filling made with coconut, pecans in a sticky caramel, chocolate frosting
$Beverage
Iced Coffee
$3.00-3.50
Iced Coffee, roasted locally in LIC by Demarco Coffee.
Water Bottle
$2.00
12oz Poland Spring
Iced Tea
$2.50-3.25
House brewed, unsweetened. Please specify if you would like sugar added. May select to have a half lemonade/half iced tea, please choose flavor.
Renegade Lemonade
$4.00-5.00
Award winning lemonades made by Renegade Lemonade. Choose between Strawberry Basil, Passion Fruit Hibiscus or Peach Mint!
Milk
$1.25
Sweets best friend. 16oz cup of ice cold whole milk.
Sparkling Water
3.00
San Pellegrino. 250mL
$Misc.
Birthday Candles
$2.00
1 pack of birthday candles.
Happy Birthday Candles
$4.00
Candles spelling out "Happy Birthday"
Cutlery Set
$2.00
Set of 24 forks, knives, spoons. Black plastic.
Plates
$5.00-3.00
Choice of pack of 24 teal dessert plates or 8 Confetti dessert plates. Both paper.
Menu for Abigail's Bakeshop is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
