Breakfast
Plain Croissant
$3.25
Only available on Saturday and Sunday!
Chocolate Croissant
3.50
Only available on Saturday and Sunday!
$Gift Boxes
These make great gifts!Assorted Macaron Box (6 piece)
$15.00
Vanilla, Lemon, Pistachio, Chocolate, Espresso, Raspberry
Assorted Sweets Gift Box (11 pieces)
$26.00
Our favorites gift box includes a variety of festive chocolate covered Oreos, and macarons.
Chocolate Babka
$20.00
Decorated Cookies
$4.00
Pick a gingerbread person, or reindeer or a sugar cookie snowflake!
Chocolate Peppermint Bark
$15.00
8 ounces of chocolate peppermint bark, perfectly packaged as a gift for the holidays!
Breakfast Box
$48.00
A chocolate babka loaf, a cinnamon coffee cake loaf, a pack of six orange pecan shortbreads, and holiday tea.
Cozy Kit
$50.00
This kit includes: hot cocoa mix, marshmallows, Buttermilk Bakeshop mug, a pack of six orange pecan shortbreads, and 4 festive gingerbread cookies to decorate yourself. Includes sprinkle blend, vanilla frosting, and a piping bag.
Cocoa Bombs
$16.00
Pack of four cocoa bombs, 2 pink white chocolate with marshmallow and 2 dark chocolate. Put one cocoa bomb in four ounces of boiling milk for hot chocolate!
6 Pack Chocolate Covered Oreo
$12.00
6" Flourless Chocolate Cake
$25.00
A decadent dark chocolate flourless chocolate cake, covered in ganache!
4 piece box Bunny Cookies
$15.00
4 piece box, decorated pastel Bunny cookies! Great for a gift!
Banana Wafer Cake
$45.00
6-inch vanilla cake with vanilla pudding, fresh bananas, and wafers.
Floral Hexagon Sugar Cookie (box of 6)
15.00
Vanilla shortbread cookies with pastel pink royal icing, finished with lavender and rose petal
$Cupcakes
Oatmeal Cream Pie
Cinnamon cupcake with, whoopie pie frosting and oatmeal cookie on top.
Vanilla Cupcake
$3.25
Vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream.
4-Pack Cupcake
$13.00
Red Velvet Cupcake
$3.25
Red velvet cake with cream cheese frosting.
Dozen Cupcakes
$36.00
6-Pack Cupcake
$19.00
Chocolate Cupcake
$3.25
Served with chocolate buttercream.
Daily Cupcake
$3.25
Gluten Free Strawberry Almond
$3.00
GF almond cupcake with strawberry buttercream
GF Pumpkin Cupcake Cream Cheese
$2.75
Pumpkin cupcake with cream cheese frosting, and caramel
Cranberry Carrot
$3.25
Cranberry Cupcake with cream cheese frosting
Cookie Butter
$3.00
Chocolate Cupcake with cookie butter frosting
Chili Coconut Mango
$3.00
Coconut cupcake with Mango meringue buttercream, toasted coconut, and chili powder
Tutti Frutti Cupcake
$3.00
Funfetti cupcake with Orange-Blossom buttercream and white chocolate shavings
Boston Cream Pie Cupcake
$3.00
A vanilla cupcake topped with vanilla pudding and chocolate buttercream.
Root Beer Float Cupcake
$3.00
A chocolate cupcake with root bear float buttercream, topped with a maraschino cherry.
Smores Cupcake
$3.00
A chocolate cupcake with graham cracker buttercream topped with a chocolate fudge drip and our homemade marshmallow.
Mulled Cider
$3.00
Spiced Cake, citrus buttercream, candied ginger,
White Chocolate Peppermint
$3.00
White chocolate cake with peppermint swirl buttercream.
Cannoli Cupcake
$3.00
A vanilla cupcake with a cannoli buttercream, topped with chocolate chips and cannoli shell crumbles.
GF Pumpkin Cream Cheese
$3.25
A gluten free pumpkin cupcake with cream cheese frosting.
Red Velvet Whopper Cupcake
$3.00
Key Lime Cupcake
$3.00
Mango Coconut Cupcake
$3.00
Chocolate Apricot Almond
$3.00
Neapolitan Cupcake
$3.00
A chocolate cupcake with vanilla buttercream, strawberry buttercream, and a cherry on top.
Apple Pie Cupcake
$3.00
Dulce De Leche Cupcake
$3.00
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
$3.25
Chocolate chip cupcake with chocolate buttercream with a cookie dough center
Kit Kat Cupcake
$3.25
Kit Kat Cupcake
Spiced Hot Chocolate Cupcake
$3.25
Spiced Hot Chocolate Cupcake
Gluten Free Chocolate Peppermint Cupcake
$3.25
Gluten Free Chocolate Peppermint Cupcake
Spiced Gingerbread Cupcake
3.25
Spiced Gingerbread Cupcake
$Cookies
Triple Chocolate Chunk Cookie
$3.25
Filled with dark, milk, chunks.
Vegan Gingersnap Cookie
$3.25
Salted Nutella Cookie
$3.25
Rich chocolate cookie topped with Nutella and sea salt.
Chai Spice Pecan Snickerdoodle Cookie
$3.25
Chai spice sugar cookie topped with pecans and caramel.
Butterscotch Marshmallow Cookie
Peanut Butter Cookie
$3.25
Peanut butter chocolate chip cookie.
Black and White Cookie
Build Your Own 6-Pack Cookie
$19.00
Sprinkle Cookie
Sugar cookie with rainbow sprinkles.
Build Your Own 4-Pack Cookie
$13.00
Build Your Own 12-Pack Cookie
$36.00
Pumpkin Oat White Chocolate
Cookie of the Day
$3.25
Please call (347) 987-3941 for more information.
French Toast
$3.00
Chocolate Almond Oat
$3.25
French Toast
$3.00
The classic French Toast cookie is back!
Coconut Eggnog
$3.00
Eggnog cookie with shredded coconut and white chocolate
V/GF Chocolate Chunk
$3.25
Vegan and gluten free, contains almonds.
Pumpkin Praline Cookie
$3.00
Pumpkin cookie with candied pecans and maple glaze
M & M Cookie
$3.00
Cinnabon Cookie
$3.00
Coconut Eggnog
$3.00
Eggnog cookie with coconut and vanilla nutmeg glaze.
Red Velvet Crinkle
$3.00
A red velvet crinkle cookie topped with powder sugar.
Butterscotch Marshmallow
$3.00
French Toast Cookie
$3.00
Apple Cider Cookie
$3.00
Coconut Macaron
$3.00
A coconut macaroon with chocolate!
Pumpkin S'mores
$3.00
Pumpkin cookie with chocolate chips, topped with toasted marshmallow.
Butterscotch Marshmallow
$3.00
Take 5
$3.00
A chocolate cookie with butterscotch and peanut butter chunks, topped with pretzels.
Orange Poppy Shortbread
$3.00
with a vanilla glaze!
Apple Cider
$3.00
Your favorite fall drink, created into a cookie!
Cookies And Milk Cookie
$3.00
White Chocolate Peppermint
$3.00
Pumpkin Chocolate Chip
$3.25
Apple Cider
$3.25
Back every season! The popular apple cider cookie!
Creme Brulee Cookies
$3.25
Creme Brulee Cookies
Red Velvet Crinkle Cookies
3.25
Red Velvet Crinkle Cookies
$Bars
Lemon Bar
$3.50
Fudge Brownie Bar
$3.50
Studded with chocolate chips.
S'Mores Bar
$3.00
Graham cracker crust, chocolate ganache layered with bruleed marshmallows.
Raspberry Linzer
$3.50
A hazelnut cookie filled with raspberry jam and topped with powdered sugar.
Peanut Butter Bar
$3.50
GF and Vegan
Oatmeal Cream Pie
$3.25
Two Oatmeal cookies sandwiched between cannoli cream!
Bar of the Day
$3.50
Please call (347) 987-3941 for more information.
The "Brookie"
$3.50
Half brownie, half chocolate chunk cookie.
Vegan Brownie
$3.50
Vegan Brownie (no soy or nuts)
Cherry Pie Bar
$3.25
Cherry Pie with an almond crumble.
Caramel Apple Cheesecake
$3.25
Graham cracker crust, with an apple caramel swirl
Gingerbread Blondie
$3.25
Yum!
Oreo Blondie
$3.25
Red Velvet Cheesecake Bar
$3.25
Pina Colada Bar
$3.25
A coconut pineapple bar with a graham cracker crust!
Cookie Monster Bar
$3.25
A blue cheesecake bar with oreos and M&Ms!
Apple Pie Cheesecake
$3.25
Shortbread crust, apple filling layered in cheesecake batter, topped with brown sugar cookie crumble.
Whoopie Pies
$3.25
Apple Blondie
$3.25
caramel drizzle
Pumpkin Streusel
$3.25
Caramel Cornflake Brownie
3.50
$Cake in the jar for two!
Now get the cake in the jar you love in a jumbo size perfect for sharing!Banana Cake In A Jar
$16.00
Layers and layers of vanilla cake, fresh bananas, pudding, whipped cream and wafer cookies.
Chocolate Cake In A Jar
$16.00
Layers of chocolate cake, chocolate buttercream, crunchies and sprinkles!
Vanilla Cake in Jar
$16.00
Layers and layers of vanilla cake, buttercream, crunchies and sprinkles.
Tiramisu Jars
15.00
Espresso soaked lady fingers, cannoli filling, vanilla cake and vanilla buttercream
$Bake at Home Cookie Dough
Now you can bake our cookies in your home! Just scoop and bake at 350 degrees for 12 - 14 minutes.Sprinkle Cookie Dough
$15.00
Salted Nutella Cookie Dough
$15.00
Scoop and bake! Then drizzle with Nutella.
Chocolate Chunk Cookie Dough
$15.00
Gluten-Free / Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
$16.00
Contains Almond Flour , No Soy
Pumpkin Praline Cookie Dough
12.00
Bake at home for 10 to 12 minutes at 350F! Contains pecans.
$Other Desserts
Oatmeal Cream Pie
$3.00
Cake Pops
$2.00
Chocolate or Vanilla
Gluten Free Banana Bread Loaf
$22.00
Topped with walnuts.
Macarons
$2.00
Orange Pecan Shortbread Cookie
Vanilla Cake in Jar
$5.00
Layers of vanilla cake, buttercream and sprinkles! Great for gift giving!
Chocolate Cake in the Jar
$5.00
Layers of chocolate cake, chocolate buttercream and sprinkles! Great for gift giving!
Tiramisu
$5.75
Whipped mascarpone cream and espresso ladyfingers layered.
Homemade Milano
$3.00
Two buttery homemade Milano cookies with citrus ganache in-between
6 Pack Macarons
$15.00
A six pack of macarons with assorted flavors.
Fruit Tarts
$15.00
Three 4" fruit tarts filled with vanilla pastry cream topped with fresh fruit.
Apple Babka Loaf
$20.00
Apple Babka
$20.00
This apple cinnamon babka features sweet apples and a thick cinnamon filling twisted inside a rich and buttery yeasted dough. Finish the indulgent loaf with a buttery brown sugar cinnamon crumble topping and bake until golden brown.
Chocolate Whoopie Pie
$3.50
A chocolate whoopie pie with a cannoli and chocolate chip buttercream filling.
Cocoa Bombs
$16.00
Chocolate Covered Oreo
2.00
$Cakes and Party Packs
8" Black and White Cake
$56.00
Two layers vanilla cake, one layer of chocolate cake. Filled with vanilla and chocolate buttercream
Classic vanilla Cake
$45.00
6" (feeds 8-10). Served with vanilla frosting and raspberry jam between layers.
Chocolate Cake
$45.00
6" (feeds 8-10).
Daily Cake
$55.00
Please call (347) 987-3941 for more information. 6 & quot;Cake serving(8 to 10 guests)
Cake Slice of the Day
$4.50
A single slice of cake with buttercream.
6" Cookies & Cream
$45.00
Funfetti cake, Cookie and Cream frosting with dark chocolate drip.
Birthday Candles
$3.00
The Rocher
$47.00
Layers of chocolate cake, hazelnut buttercream, ganache dripped, topped with Rocher chocolates
Tiramisu Cake
$45.00
6" Marble cake soaked with espresso, mascarpone mousse and layered with lady fingers.
Classic Birthday Package
$57.00
Classic Birthday cake or Double Chocolate with Birthday message, handwritten card, and candles!
Vanilla Cake Push Up Pops
$4.00
Layers of vanilla cake, buttercream and sprinkles!
Chocolate Cake push-up pop
$4.00
chocolate cake layered with chocolate buttercream
6" Rainbow Cake
$51.00
A 6" vanilla cake with five layers, each the color of the rainbow, filled and topped with vanilla buttercream and rainbow sprinkles.
8" Flourless Chocolate Cake (GF)
$38.00
Matza Bark
$15.00
1/2 pound!
6" Strawberry Milkshake
51.00
6" Funfetti Cake with Strawberry Buttercream filling and malted ball filling with a white to pink ombre vanilla buttercream outside!
$Pies
All our yummy pies!Caramel Apple Walnut Pie
$42.00
Classic Apple pie layered with caramel and brown sugar crumb topping
Salted Nutella Pecan Pie
$38.00
Classic pecan pie with layers of salted nutella
Pumpkin Pie
$35.00
Buttermilk Pie
$36.00
Our signature pie! It is like a Creme Brule inside a pie!
Menu for Buttermilk is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
