Nicky's American

Nicky's Menu

(631) 206-3311
99 Maple Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Barges


Clam Barge
$14.50
Plate of fresh shucked fried hard shell clams
Clam Barge with French Fries or Cole Slaw
$16.50
Flounder Barge
$15.00
2 Fried filets
Flounder Barge with French Fries or Cole Slaw
$17.00
Scallop Barge
$17.00
Fried bay scallops
Scallop Barge with French Fries or Cole Slaw
$17.00
Oyster Barge
$15.00
Shucked fried oysters
Oyster Barge with French Fries or Cole Slaw
$17.00
Shrimp Barge
$17.00
4 Enormous fried shrimp
Shrimp Barge with French Fries or Cole Slaw
$19.00
Crab Cake Barge
$13.75
2 Fried maryland style crab cakes served over cole slaw
Crab Cake Barge with French Fries
15.75

$Super Starters


Clams on the 1/2 Shell
$7.50-13.00
Your choice of little necks, top necks or cherry stones
Freshly Shucked Oysters on the 1/2 Shell
$10.00-16.00
Cold Combo
$17.00
3 Little neck clams, 3 oysters and 3 jumbo shrimp cocktail
Clams Casino
$8.25-14.00
Baked whole little neck clams with bread crumbs and bacon
Steamed Little Neck Clams
$8.25-14.00
Steamed in white wine and garlic sauce.
Clams Oreganata
$8.25-14.00
Little neck clams baked with garlic bread crumbs
Baked Stuffed Clams (3)
$6.75
Crab Cakes
$13.75
2 Maryland style crab cakes served over a bed of cole slaw with texas petal sauce.
Fried Calamarl
$12.25
Lightly fried, served with lemon & marinara sauce
Fried Mozzarella Sticks (6)
$6.00
Served with marinara sauce
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail (4)
$16.00
Jumbo chilled shrimp served with cocktail sauce
Mussels
$15.00-10.50
Choice of white wine and garlic or marinara, served with fresh italian bread for dipping
Steamers
$19.75-12.75
Tastiest steamers on the island served with our famous broth and drawn butter
Specialty Platter for Two
$17.75
Clams, oysters and shrimp oreganata, chicken fingers, mozzarella sticks, calamari and chicken wings
Boneless Buffalo Chicken Tenders
$9.50
Served with bleu cheese, carrots and celery
Hot Wings (12 wings)
$8.75
Served with bleu cheese, carrots and celery
Chicken Fries
6.75
Chicken in the shape of french fries served with marinara sauce for dipping

$Salads

Homemade house dressings: bleu cheese, thousand island, creamy garlic, french onion, balsamic vinaigrette
Greek Salad
$8.00
Greek Salad with Chicken
$9.50
Greek Salad with Shrimp
$18.00
Caesar Salad
$8.00
Caesar Salad with Chicken
$10.50
Caesar Salad with Shrimp
$18.00
Tossed Garden Salad
5.00

$Cold Salads

Served open style with small side garden salad, with potato salad and cole slaw.
Shrimp Salad
$15.75
Crab Meat Salad
$15.75
Tuna Salad
$12.50
Combination Shrimp and Crab
$15.75
Chicken Salad
12.50

$Soups


Manhattan Clam Chowder
$5.00-6.00
Famous red clam chowder
Clam Bisque
$5.00-6.00
Creamy white style clam chowder
Corn Chowder
$5.00-6.00
Creamy corn and vegetable soup
Black Bean Soup
$5.00-6.00
Seafood Bisque Nicky's Ultimate
$6.75-7.75
Creamy pink seafood soup with lobster, shrimp and crabmeat
Soup of the Day
5.00-6.00

$Sandwiches

Served on white, whole wheat, rye, roll or wrap with potato salad and cole slaw
Shrimp Salad
$11.00
Crab Meat Salad
$11.50
Tuna Salad
$10.00
Chicken Salad
$9.00
Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato
$8.00
Turkey Club
$10.25
Turkey and Cheese
$8.50
Ham and Cheese
$8.50
Roast Beef and Cheese
8.50

$Seafood Sandwiches

Served open style with small side garden salad, with potato salad and cole slaw
Fried Shrimp (5)
$21.50
Fried Scallops
$17.50
Fried Flounder
$17.50
Fried Oysters
$18.50
Fried Hard Shell Clams
$18.50
Fresh shucked
Soft Shell Crabs (2)
18.00
Sauteed or fried

$Grilled Ones


Grilled Cheese Sandwich
$5.00
Grilled Ham and Cheese Sandwich
$5.50
Hot Dog
$3.00
Chicken Cuttlet
$8.50
Served grilled or fried with lettuce & tomato
Flounder On a Roll
$10.00
Served broiled or fried.
Solt Shell Crab
10.00
Fried or sauteed served on a toll

$Burgers Galore


Hamburger (4 Oz)
$5.25
Cheeseburger (4 Oz)
$5.75
Hamburger Deluxe
$9.00
Served with a side garden salad, french fries and cole slaw.
Cheeseburger Deluxe
$9.50
Served with a side garden salad, french fries and cole slaw.
Turkey Burger
$5.50
Served with lettuce and tomato
Turkey Cheeseburger
$6.00
Served with lettuce and tomato
Bison Burger
$5.50
Served with lettuce and tomato
Bison Cheeseburger
$6.00
Served with lettuce and tomato
BBQ 8 Oz Bacon Cheeseburger
7.25
With our hickory BBQ sauce served on a hard roll

$From the Broiler


Broiled Flounder
$24.00
Fresh and delicately broiled with light garlic and butter
Stuned Flounder
$25.00
Stuffed with snow crab meat stuffing
Stuned Shrimp
$30.00
(5) Enormous shrimp with snow crab meat stuffing
Shrimp Scampi
$30.00
(6) Enormous shrimp in a butter garlic wine sauce
Sauteed Scallops Oreganata
$23.00
Fresh bay scallops sauteed in garlic and wine sauce
Seafood Au Gratin
$26.00
Crab meat, lobster meat and (2) jumbo shrimp in a creamy white sauce with melted cheddar and monterey jack cheese
Fish of the Day
$26.00
Flounder Oreganata
24.50
Broiled with light garlic bread crumbs

$Fresh Fried Seafood Dinners


Fried Warm Shell Clams
$21.75
Freshly shucked and lightly breaded top neck clams
Fried Oysters
$23.00
Freshly shucked and breaded
Fried Scallops
$23.00
Fresh bay scallops lightly breaded
Fried or Sauteed Soft Shell Crabs (3)
$23.00
Frozen, only served when in season
Fried Flounder
$23.00
Golden filets of fresh flounder lightly breaded
Fried Combination Planer
$30.00
Scallops, oysters, clams, flounder and two jumbo fried shrimp
Coconut Fried Shrimp
$30.00
(5) Golden brown enormous battered coconut shrimp
Fried Shrimp
30.00
6 Enormous fried shrimp

$live from our Tank


Lobster Dinner
Steamed or broiled, stuffed $5.50 extra

Italian Seafood Dinners

Served with garden salad and garlic bread
Shrimp Parmigiana
$29.00
Werved with linguini
Flounder Parmigiana
$24.00
Served with linguini
Fried Calamari
$21.00
Served with linguini
Linguini with Red or White Clam Sauce
21.75
freshly shucked chopped clams over a pile of linguini, cooked to perfection

$Sides


Fresh Corn on the Cob
$3.50
Baked Potato
$3.50
Garlic Bread
$1.75-3.50
Cajun Fries
$4.50
Seasoned not spicy
Tossed Garden Salad
$5.25
Cole Slaw
$2.75
Potato Salad
$2.75
French Fries
$3.50
Onion Rings
$4.50
Fried Shrimp
$4.50
Sauteed Broccoli
$4.00
Sauteed Spinach
$4.00
Rice
3.50

$Lover's Specials

Served with garden salad, garlic bread and choice of one: baked potato, french fries, fresh corn on the cob, cajun french fries, spinach, broccoli or rice
Steak Dinner
$30.00
Marinated or plain giant aged shell steak grilled to your liking
BBQ Boneless Pork Chops
$18.50
Grilled with our hickory BBQ sauce topped with crispy onions
Roasted Half Chicken
$18.50
Roasted in garlic lemon and herbs or hickory BBQ style
Chicken Parmigiana
$19.50
Served with linguini or choice of one side dish listed above

Menu for Nicky's is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

Check Other Restaurant Menu

Fat Fish Bar & Bistro Food
Fat Fish Bar & Bistro

American, American (New)

Captain Bill's Food
Captain Bill's

American

Great American Cookies Food
Great American Cookies

American, Bakery & Pastries

Chowder Bar Food
Chowder Bar

American, Seafood

Cool Water Grill Food
Cool Water Grill

American, American (New)

South Philly Steak & Fries Food
South Philly Steak & Fries

American, Cheesesteaks

Wok 'n Roll Food
Wok 'n Roll

Chinese

Paul's Pizza Food
Paul's Pizza

Pizza

Baskin-Robbins Food
Baskin-Robbins

American, Ice Cream

Chubby's Delicatessen Food
Chubby's Delicatessen

American, Deli Food

El Buen Gusto Food
El Buen Gusto

Mexican

Golden Star Food
Golden Star

Chinese