It Started With A Cupcake

It Started With A Cupcake Menu

(201) 935-2100
242 Stuyvesant Ave, Lyndhurst, NJ 07071

Cupcakes


Baker’s Half Dozen Cupcake
$24.00
6 cupcakes. Assortment of daily flavors selected by the baker.
1 Dozen Cupcakes
$54.00
Assorted Cupcake box with daily seasonal flavors .
Key lime Pie Cupcake
$4.00
Best Seller! Graham Crust, Key lime cake, filled with key lime curd, cream cheese frosting, mini key lime pie slice on top
Lucky Charms
$4.00
Marshmallow Lucky Charms Cake, Filled with Marshmallow Fluff. Lucky Charms Buttercream, Lucky Charms Marshmallow Rice Krispies Square topper. Epically Delicious!
Red Velvet Cupcake
$4.00
A Southern Classic! Light Cocoa Flavored Buttermilk Cake, Topped with our Signature Vanilla Cream Cheese Frosting .
Midnight Cupcake
$4.00
Rich Dark Chocolate Cake, Chocolate Buttercream, chocolate drizzle and chocolate crumbles.
Vanilla Sprinkle Cupcake
$4.00
Classic Funfetti Vanilla Cake, Topped with Vanilla Sprinkle Buttercream.
Ube Coconut Flan
$4.50
Best Seller! Ube Coconut Cake, Filled with Pastry Cream, Ube Buttercream, Rolled in Coconut Flakes, Topped with a Caramel Coconut Leche Flan.
Honey Wildberry
$4.00
Vanilla Bean Cake , filled with house made Berry Jam. Topped with Berry Buttercream, Rolled in Vanilla Berry Crumble, Fresh Seasonal Berries, and Honey Drizzle! Delightful with Tea or Coffee.
Chocolate Caramel Churro Cupcake
$4.00
Our rich chocolate cake filled with dulce leche caramel. Caramel buttercream, topped with a mini churro and dulce leche drizzle.
Dulce Leche Oreo Cupcake
$4.00
Vanilla with oreo crumbs baked in, filled with dulce leche, caramel buttercream and more oreos crumbs and dulce leche drizzle
24 Karat
$4.00
Moist carrot cake topped our signature vanilla cream cheese frosting rolled in ginger crumbs and topped with caramel drizzle.
Pumpkin Spice Cupcake
$4.00
Pumpkin Spice Cake , with vanilla bean cream cheese frosting.
Salted Caramel Apple Pie Cupcake
$4.00
Vanilla Cinnamon Spice Cake, filled with apple pie filling, caramel spice buttercream, oat crumble, caramel drizzle.
Ferrero Roche
$4.00
Signature chocolate cake fille9d with nutella, topped with hazelnut Buttercream and a Ferrero Roche
Lemon coconut Cupcake
$4.00
Coconut cake stuffed with lemon curd topped with coconut Buttercream and toasted coconut
Sweet potato PECAN PIE Cupcake
$4.00
Moist sweet potato cake topped with cream cheese frosting, topped with pecan pie filling
Red velves Oreo Cupcake
$4.00
Cherry cheesecake cupcake
$4.00
Vanilla Cupcake filled withò cherry filling topped with cream cheese frosting and rolled in graham cracker
White chocolate raspberry
$4.00
Buttermilk white chocolate cake filled with raspberry preseve's topped with a raspberry Buttercream frosting
Strawberry crunch cupcake
$4.00
Strawberry vanilla cake topped with strawberry Buttercream rolled in strawberry crunch
Peanut butter chocolate Cupcake
$4.00
Chocolate cake peanut butter cream cheese frosting and peanut butter cup on top
Smore Cupcake
$4.00
Red velvet cookie dough
$4.00
Chocolate Pecan Pie
$4.00
Lemon meringue
$4.50
Turkey Cupcake
$4.00
Vanilla Cake with chocolate frosting and candy corns as feather decor
Ferrero Rocher
$4.00
Chocolate cake filled with hazelnut ganache and a Ferrero rocherry on top
Coquito
$4.00
Coconut cake, coconut pastry cream and shot of coquito
Gingerbread Man
$4.00
Gingerbread cake, cream cheese frosting and gingerbread cookie
Sugar cookie
$4.00
Sugar cookies cake, topped with sugar cookie
Chocolate Pecan Cupcake
$4.00
Matcha Strawberry
$4.00
The Bobby
$3.25
Vanilla Cake and chocolate fudge frosting
Sweet Potato Churro
$4.00
Sweet potato cake brown butter cream, cheese frosting topped with churro and caramel
Chocolate Caramel Brownie
$4.00
Love Bug Cupcake
$4.00
Strawberry Crunch
4.00

$Cookies & Macarons

French Macarons and Cookies
Macaron Box- 6 count
$14.00
Classic macaron pack. Assortment of 6 macaron flavors selected by baker.
Macaron Box - 12 Count
$28.00
Assortment of 12 macaron flavors selected by baker.
Nutella Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookie
$3.00
Best Seller! Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies, with Big Bittersweet Chocolate Chip. Nutella Stuffed, Sea Salt Sprinkle.
White Chocolate Sprinkle Stuffed Cookie
$3.00
Big NYC Style Cookie with white Chocolate Chips, Sprinkles and stuffed with Caramelized White Chocolate. AKA Birthday Cake Cookie. You won't want to share.
Oatmeal Cream Cookie Sandwhich
$3.95
Our signature artisan oatmeal cookies filled with Vanilla Buttercream. We set out to create a next level version of the classic Oatmeal Cookie Sandwich. Cookie Nostalgia Glow Up
Chocolate Chip cookie
$2.25
Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich
$4.00
Classic Alfajores
$4.00
Mini chocolate chip cookies
$3.50
Gingerbread cookie
$4.00
Gingerbread cookie with orange zest and warm spices, hand decorated
Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookie
$2.75
Red Velvet Cookie
3.25

$Coffee and Drinks

All syrups and caramels made from scratch in house, regular whole milk and almond milk, alternative milk options available.
Cappuccino
$3.75
12 oz.
Iced Caramel Latte
Iced Mocha Latte
Mocha Latte
Caramel Latte
Latte
Iced Latte
$4.25
16 oz.
Cortado
$3.50
8 oz.
Matcha Latte
Signature Chai Latte
Organic Cold Brew
Organic Hot Tea
$3.50
12 oz.
Organic Iced Tea
Americano
$3.50
12 oz.
Dalgona Iced Coffee
$5.00
Try the Coffee phenomenon that took the internet by Storm. Whipped Coffee on top of ice cold milk!
Hot Chocolate
$4.50
Ube Latte
House made Ube syrup . Steamed milk.
Red Rising
Red Velvet Latte made with house blend of cocoa powder beetroot powder and vanilla sugar. Steamed milk and shot of espresso
Double Espresso
$2.50
Organic Iced Tea
Pellegrino Soda
$1.50
Water Bottle
$1.25
Drip Coffee
House Cold Brew
Milk Chocolate, Toffee and dried fruit notes
Organic Hot Tea
Cocoa Surreal
Our Signature Rich Hot Chocolate made with Cocoa & 68% Dark Chocolate, sprinkle of salt
Daydream
Early Grey Tea, Steamed milk and House Lavender Syrup
Cinnamon Toast Crunch
Our House Cold Brew Coffee Maple Cinnamon Toast syrup over ice. Cinnamon toast crunch dust
It Started With a Kiss
Ceremonial Grade Matcha, Steamed Milk, Rose syrup, and rose petals
Passionfruit Lemonade
Lavender Lemonade
Classic Lemonade

Pies , Cakes, and Desserts

dessert cups, cake, Pies and more
Signature Banana Pudding
$6.50
Signature banana pudding, layers of creamy vanilla pudding, fresh sliced banana, nilla wafers, and toasted meringue.
Mini cheesecake sampler pack
$16.00
4 pack mini cheesecakes. 1 oreo, 1 vanilla bean, 1 guava, 1 s'mores
Edible Cookie Dough Cups
$3.75
Edible Cookie Dough Cups
Peanut Butter chocolate pie
$7.25
Chocolate cookie crumb crust , filled with peanut butter and chocolate mousse, salted caramel, crunchy peanuts dark chocolate ganache, snickers candy .
Signature Rice Pudding
$4.00
Vanilla Bean , Cinnamon, Cream and Coconut Milk Elevate this Classic to a creamy cool decadent dessert.
Tres Leches Cake
$5.50
Delicate Vanilla Sponge Cake, Soaked with out blend of Three Milks, Topped with Meringue. High quality Vanilla and a splash of rum take this classic to another level.
Oreo De Leche Tres Leches
$5.00
Delicate Vanilla Sponge Cake, Soaked with out blend of Three Milks, Topped with Dulce de leche, crushed Oreo Cookies and Meringue. A delicious twist on a Classic favorite
Key lime pie slice
$7.00
Red velvet cheesecake cake
$7.50
Best of both worlds, red velvet cake and cheesecake topped with cream cheese frosting rolled in white chocolate chips
Strawberry crunch cheesecake cake slice
$7.00
Best of both worlds, 1 layer of strawberry vanilla cake and 1 layer of cheesecake topped strawberry crunch and strawberry sauce
Ube cheesecake
$7.00
Oreo cheesecake
$8.00
Red Velvet Banana Pudding
$5.00
Caramel Apple Cobbler
$5.50
Pineapple upside down cheesecake
$8.00
Pineapple Upside down cheesecake
$8.50
Pineapple upside down cake with a layer or cheesecake pineapple caramel sauce
Peach Cobbler cheesecake
$8.50
Brownie cookie butter cheesecake slice
$8.00
Maple pumpkin cheesecake slice
$8.00
Pecan pie slice
$8.00
Mixed berry cheesecake slice
$8.00
Berry Tiramisu
$4.50
Pecan Cheesecake slice
$7.00
Vanilla Cheesecake Slice
$7.00
Peanut Butter Banana Toffee Cheesecake Slice
$7.50
Coconut Keylime Pie Slice
$7.50
Smore's Brownie Cheesecake Slice
7.00

$Mother’s Day Pre Order Menu

Mothers Day Menu 2020
Eton Mess Cheesecake
$46.00
The Classic Spring Dessert in Cheesecake Form. Sure to impress! 8 & #39; Vanilla Bean Cheesecake ( Serves 8-10) Topped with Fresh Berries, Tart Berry Sauce, Crisp Chewy Meringues, Whipped cream, edible flowers, Mother&# 39;s Day Plaque.
Mother’s Day Macaron Box-6 Count
$14.00
Our Best Selling French Macarons, Crispy Chewy and delightful. 12 Count or 6 Count Box with gift tag, in spring seasonal flavors.Mom Will Love them
Mother’s Day Macaron Box - 12 Count
$28.00
Our Best Selling French Macarons, Crispy Chewy and delightful. 12 Count or 6 Count Box with gift tag, in spring seasonal flavors.Mom Will Love them
Mother’s Day Mini Drip Cake
$40.00
Mini Mothers Day Cake (serves 4) Delicious cake topped with macarons, beautiful Fresh Flowers and Mothers Day Plaque. Vanilla and Berries Cake Chocolate Midnight Cake Red Velvet Cake
Buttercream Rose Cupcake
$8.50
Our Best Selling, Rose Buttercream Cupcake is back!Chocolate or Vanilla Cake topped with our realistic Buttercream Rose in a Clear Gift Box with Ribbon.Beautiful and delicious!Check ourates Instagram for photo
Mothers Day-Breakfast in Bed Box
$20.00
Stay in and Bring Mom a Breakfast in Bed Giftbox ! Savory Cheddar and Herb Scone Salted Caramel Banana Muffin Triple Chocolate Cookie 2 Macaron Cookies Buttermilk Vanilla Raspberry Panna Cotta Cup of Coffee / or Tea The perfect gift.
Ultimate Mother's Day Sweets and Blooms Box
48.50
The perfect gift you've been searching for is here! The Best of both world's. Beautiful flowers and delicious treats. Each Gift Box Comes with: 6 French macarons in seasonal flavors 9 Gourmet Belgian Chocolate Dipped Strawberries 4 premium Roses

$Thanksgiving Menu 2020


Thanksgiving Dessert Solo Party Box
$24.00
Each Box Contains 2 Slices of Pie, One mini caramel Banana Loaf, Mini Cheesecake, Buttermilk Biscuit with Honey Butter
Salted Caramel Apple Pie- Whole
$36.00
Buttery Crust, Granny Smith Apples with rich salted caramel and topped with buttery Crumbles. My Favorite Pie !
Bourbon Pecan Pie - Whole
$35.00
Our handmade Butter Pie Crust makes A rich and tender classic base. Packed full of Toasted pecans, vanilla extract and a dash of bourbon to make the custard extra amazing. Best enjoyed with a scoop of vanilla ice cream or fresh whipped cream. Store wrapped at room temperature.
Marshmallow Sweet Potato Pie
$36.00
Graham and gingersnap crust. Filled with roasted sweet potatoes blended with cream, butter, and our secret spice blend. Topped with Fluffy torched meringue. Amazing!
Brown Butter Maple Pumpkin Pie
$35.00
Classic Pumpkin pie made with nutty brown butter, house spice blend, With a dash of maple syrup to make it extra tasty, baked in our flaky butter crust. garnished with mini meringues and sugared cranberries
Tres Leches Cake - Family Size
$23.00
Delicate Vanilla Sponge Cake, Soaked with out blend of Three Milks, Topped with Meringue. High quality Vanilla and a splash of rum take this classic to another level.
Liquor Infused Thanksgiving Cupcake Box
$54.00
Our New Liquor infused Cupcake Box- Thanksgiving Edition 3 - Midnight - Dark Chocolate Liquor shot 3 - Winter Sangria - Sangria Shot 3 - Pumpkin Spice - Spiced White Chocolate Liquor shot 3 - Salted Caramel Apple - Spiked Cider Shot
Seasonal Loaf - 2 Small Loaf Pack
$16.00
Two of our best selling loaf bread, Rustic and delicious Salted Caramel Banana Bread made with brown butter a delicately spiced, with our house salted caramel drizzled on top. Pumpkin Spice Crumble Loaf, Moist and oh so tasty packed with spices and topped with generous handfuls of buttery crumbles. Perfect for thanksgiving breakfast or hostess gifts!
Thanksgiving Cupcake Box- Variety
Variety of best selling Cupcakes with Thanksgiving decorations. 2 - Vanilla Sprinkle 2 - Red Velvet 2 - Pumpkin Spice 2 - midnight 2 - Dulce De leche Oreo 2 - Salted Caramel Apple

Breakfast


Buttermilk Biscuit
$3.00
Classic Buttermilk Biscuit baked hot and fresh, brushed with Honey Butter
Orange Cranberry Scone
$3.50
Our Best Selling Orange Cranberry Scone is back. Fresh orange zest, tart and sweet cranberries in a flaky buttery scone. topped with fresh orange drizzle.
Salted Caramel Banana Bread Slice
$2.95
Moist and tasty banana bread slice topped with Salted caramel, brown sugar crunch
Pumpkin Crumble Mini Loaf
$3.50
Pumpkin spice loaf with buttery crumbles. great with coffee!
Wild Blueberry Scone
$3.50
Our Best Selling Scone. Wild Blueberries, folded into a sweet buttery scone and baked to perfection
Coconut tea cake
$6.00
Salted caramel snickerdoodle cruffin
$6.00
Our best selling Crisp buttery croissant muffin rolled in cinnamon sugar filled with Salted caramel and cool vanilla pastry cream.
Butterscotch scone
$3.50
Spiced custard and berries cruffin
5.50

$Brownies and Bars


Black Magic Brownies
$4.00
Dark Chocolate Brownies
Caramel Crunch Brownies
$4.50
Layer of Rich Chocolate Brownie and a layer of Caramel Cornflake Crunch. Delicious!
Lemon Bar
$3.25
Shortbread crust, tart lemon curd on top
White chocolate raspberry blondie
$4.50
White chocolate Raspberry Blondie
3.95
Brown Butter, White Chocolate and Raspberry Blondie Bar

$Holiday Menu


Hot Cocoa Bomb Gift Set
$28.00
Our Hot Cocoa bombs are back again this years! Try one or get them All! The box set comes with 4 delicious seasonal flavors, Handmade with love using Callebaut Chocolate, filled with signature cocoa mix and mini marshmallows. All in a beautiful decorative giftbox! Green - Classic Hot Chocolate Salted Caramel Hot Chocolate(made with our house made Salted caramel) Peppermint White Hot Chocolate Gingerbread Hot Chocolate - With handmade mini fondant Christmas tree!
Hot Cocoa Bomb-individual
$8.00
Our Hot Cocoa bombs are back again this years! Try one or get them All!. 4 delicious seasonal flavors, Handmade with love using Callebaut Chocolate, filled with signature cocoa mix and mini marshmallows. All in a beautiful decorative individual giftbox! Perfect stocking Stuffer! Green - Classic Hot Chocolate Salted Caramel Hot Chocolate(made with our house made Salted caramel) Peppermint White Hot Chocolate Gingerbread Hot Chocolate - With handmade mini fondant Christmas tree!
Holiday Layer Cake
$48.00
A 8” single Layer cake, filled and frosted with Vanilla Buttercream, With Macarons and gingerbread cookies on top. beautiful and perfect for a small gathering , or as a gift. Serves 8-10 Contains Nuts - (French Macarons)
Holiday Cupcakes Box
A Variety of Holiday Cupcakes- May contain nuts. please add allergy restriction in notes
Holiday Macarons Box
Our holiday macaron Collection is here! Celebrate with a box of tasty French Macarons. Macaron Flavors: . Gingerbread Caramel Madagascar Vanilla Dark Chocolate Eggnog White Chocolate Peppermint Sugar Cookie
Hot chocolate bombs
$8.00
(
Christmas sugar cookie
$5.50
Masked gingerbread man cookie
4.00

$Vday Menu


Red Velvet Cocoa Bombs
$6.00
Chocolate Cocoa Bomb
$6.00
Breakable Heart & Berries
$45.00
breakable chocolate heart filled with sweet treats and 6 chocolate covered strawberries. Best of both worlds!!!
Frog Prince Macaron
$2.00
Box Chocolate Cover Strawberries
$25.00
8 chocolate covered strawberries

Menu for It Started With A Cupcake is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com

DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.

Check Other Restaurant Menu