Year Round Ice Cream Flavors
All of our ice cream is homemade in small batches. We start with fresh cream and milk from Lancaster County cows, add locally grown fruits or goodies from our kitchen and spin them in our American made Emery Thompson batch freezer. The end result is the freshest and hopefully most delicious ice cream you’ll find anywhere.Absolutely Nuts
Praline flavored ice cream with pecans, almonds, walnuts, peanuts and a caramel swirl
Birthday Cake
Cake batter ice cream with buttercream swirl and rainbow sprinkles (gluten)
Black Raspberry
Homemade fresh black raspberry ice cream
Bourbon Caramel Crunch
A touch of Virginia Gentlemen Bourbon, Heath Bar pieces, and a caramel swirl
Butter Pecan
Homemade fresh butter pecan ice cream
Cake Batter
Yellow cake batter ice cream (gluten)
Cherries Jubilee
Brandy flavored ice cream with brandy soaked cherries
Cherry Vanilla
Our homemade vanilla ice cream swirled with black cherries
Chocolate
Homemade fresh chocolate ice cream
Coffee
Homemade fresh coffee ice cream
Cookie Dough
Vanilla ice cream loaded with homemade cookie dough pieces (gluten)
Oreo
America’s favorite cookie made into ice cream (contains gluten)
Cotton Candy Party
Homemade fresh cotton candy ice cream
Iced Nirvana
Espresso ice cream with chocolate chunks and fudge swirl
Java Jolt
Strong coffee ice cream with homemade brownie chunks and chocolate covered espresso beans (gluten)
Marsh Mud
Double strength chocolate ice cream
Mint Chip
Mint ice cream with chocolate chunks
Peanut Butter Cup
Peanut butter ice cream with peanut butter cups
Pony Tracks
Vanilla ice cream with homemade hot fudge, peanut butter cups and peanut butter swirl
Rum Raisin
Rum flavored ice cream with rum soaked raisins
Snickers Cheesecake
Cheesecake ice cream with caramel swirl and Snickers pieces
Strawberry
Homemade fresh strawberry ice cream made with local strawberries (in season)
Vanilla
Creamy vanilla ice cream made with Madagascar bourbon pure vanilla extract
No Sugar Added Vanilla
Made with Splenda
No Sugar Added Butter Pecan
Made with Splenda
Vegan Coconut
Made with coconut milk
Vegan Chocolate Mint Oreo
Made with coconut milk
Vegan Mocha
Made with coconut milk
Seasonal Ice Cream Flavors
All of our ice cream is homemade in small batches. We start with fresh cream and milk from Lancaster County cows, add locally grown fruits or goodies from our kitchen and spin them in our American made Emery Thompson batch freezer. The end result is the freshest and hopefully most delicious ice cream you’ll find anywhere.Almond Joy
Coconut ice cream with chocolate covered almonds and a fudge swirl
Apple Cobbler
Local apples from M&C Vessey Farm, homemade cobbler pieces (gluten)
Apple Cider Sorbet
Local fresh cider from M&C Vessey Farm, fat and lactose free, vegan
Banana Carumba
Banana ice cream with a caramel swirl and a hint or rum flavor
Blueberry
Fresh local blueberries
Blueberry or Strawberry Cheesecake
Cheesecake ice cream swirled with graham and strawberry or blueberry (gluten)
Butter Brittle
Buttery ice cream with butter brittle pieces
Cadbury Creme Egg
Sweet cream ice cream with Cadbury chocolate pieces and creme egg filling swirled in
Candied Sweet Potato
Local sweet potatoes with cinnamon and brown sugar, praline pecans and caramel swirl
Cannoli
Ricotta ice cream with chocolate covered waffle cone pieces and chocolate chips (gluten)
Cantaloupe
Made with fresh local cantaloupes
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Chocolate ice cream with peanut butter swirl
Cinnamon Bun
Cinnamon ice cream with cinnamon bun pieces and icing swirl (gluten)
Coconut
Homemade fresh coconut ice cream
Egg Nog
Egg nog ice cream with rum flavor
Ginger Snap
Ginger snap ice cream with pieces of homemade ginger snap cookies (gluten)
Limoncello
Lemon juice, zest and a touch of limoncello
Lucky Charms
Cereal flavored ice cream with Lucky Charms swirled in (gluten)
Mango Sorbet
Fresh mangos, fat and lactose free, vegan
Milky Way
Malt ice cream with Milky Way candy bar pieces swirled in
Muddy Butter
Marsh mud ice cream with peanut butter swirl and Nutter Butter cookie pieces (gluten)
Muddy Mint
A minty version of Marsh Mud ice cream
Orange Juice Sorbet
Fresh orange juice, fat and lactose free, vegan
Peach
Fresh local peaches
Peppermint
Mint ice cream with crushed peppermint candy
Pineapple Upside Down Cake
Cake batter ice cream with pineapple, swirled with caramel (gluten)
Pistachio
Imported Sicilian pistachio paste with California pistachios (no almonds here)
Pumpkin Pie
Pumpkin ice cream with a graham cracker swirl (gluten)
Raspberry Sorbet
Fresh raspberries, fat and lactose free, vegan
Red Velvet Cake
Cream cheese ice cream with red velvet pieces (gluten)
Ruby Red Grapefruit Sorbet
Fresh grapefruit, fat and lactose free, vegan
Rum Cake
Cake batter ice cream with rum flavor, caramel swirl and cake pieces (gluten)
Salty Caramel
House made caramel with a touch of sea salt
Sugar Cookie
Icing flavored ice cream with homemade sugar cookie pieces (gluten)
Strawberry Sorbet
Local strawberries, fat and lactose free, vegan
Thin Mint Cookie
Minty ice cream with pieces of Girl Scout thin mint cookie pieces (gluten)
Vanilla Butterscotch
Homemade fresh vanilla ice cream with a butterscotch swirl
Wallops Rocket Fuel
Homemade fresh chocolate ice cream mixed with cinnamon and chili pepper
Whiskey Brickle
Chocolate ice cream with toffee pieces and whiskey flavor
Homemade Ice Cream
Homemade Ice Cream Cones & Cups
Choose from: Our Homemade Waffle Cone, Sugar Cone, Plain Cone or Cup
Hand Dipped No Sugar Added Ice Cream
made with Splenda Choose from: Our Homemade Waffle Cone, Sugar Cone, Plain Cone or Cup
Hand Dipped Vegan Ice Cream
made with coconut milk Choose from: Our Homemade Waffle Cone, Sugar Cone, Plain Cone or Cup
Homemade Ice Cream Pints
Homemade Ice Cream Quarts
Waffle Cone Bag Pieces
Ice Cream Sundaes
Waffle Bowl Sundae
Choose Ice Cream (2 Scoops), Topping, Nuts Toppings: Hot Fudge, Caramel, Butterscotch, Peanut Butter, Marshmallow, Strawberry, Pineapple, Chocolate, Assorted Dry Toppings, Pecans, Peanuts, Almonds
2 Scoop Sundae with Nuts
Choose Ice Cream (2 Scoops), Topping, Nuts Toppings: Hot Fudge, Caramel, Butterscotch, Peanut Butter, Marshmallow, Strawberry, Pineapple, Chocolate, Assorted Dry Toppings, Pecans, Peanuts, Almonds
Round Up
Choose Ice Cream (5 Scoops), 3 Toppings, Nuts, Whipped Cream & a Cherry Toppings: Hot Fudge, Caramel, Butterscotch, Peanut Butter, Marshmallow, Strawberry, Pineapple, Chocolate, Assorted Dry Toppings, Pecans, Peanuts, Almonds
Ultimate Brownie
Homemade Brownie, Choice of 2 Scoops, Hot Fudge, Caramel, Pecans, Chocolate Chips & Toffee Pieces
Turtles
Choose Ice Cream (2 Scoops), Hot Fudge, Caramel, Pecans
Banana Splits
Homemade Ice Cream Cakes
Island Creamery ice cream cakes are perfect for any occasion. Our small round (8 inches) serves 8-10. Our large round (10 inches) serves 16-18. Listed below are the ice cream cakes we try to stock at all times. They can be purchased fully decorated at any time or personalized with advance notice. In most instances, custom cakes require 24 hour notice. Call us and we will be more than happy to answer any questions about cake orders.Chocolate and Vanilla Cake Crunch
Chocolate cake crunch filled with Chocolate and Vanilla ice cream
Oreo Delight
Crushed Oreo crust filled with Oreo ice cream
Chocolate Extreme
Chocolate cake crunch filled with Marsh Mud ice cream and frosted with fudge
Peanut Butter Cup
Chocolate cake crunch filled with Peanut Butter Cup ice cream
Ice Cream Cake Slice
Drinks
Milkshakes
Malts
Ice Cream Float
Can Soda
Bottled Water
Menu for Island Creamery is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
