Sandwiches
Our sandwiches are served fried or grilled on our fresh locally baked buns. Your choice of fixins of tartar sauce, lettuce, onion, tomato, and bread and butter pickles. Combos are served with choice of side.Caplinger Special Sandwich
$7.99
Basa (mild, flaky whitefish) fillet served fried or grilled on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.
Caplinger Special Sandwich Combo
$9.99
Basa (mild, flaky whitefish) fillet served fried or grilled on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins and a side.
Smoked Tuna Salad Sandwich
$8.99
Our "almost famous" homemade smoked tuna salad served on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.
Smoked Tuna Salad Sandwich Combo
$10.99
Our "almost famous" homemade smoked tuna salad served on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins and a side.
Catfish Fillet Sandwich
$7.99
Our USA raised catfish fillet served fried or grilled on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.
Catfish Fillet Sandwich Combo
$9.99
Our USA raised catfish fillet served fried or grilled on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins and a side.
Salmon Fillet Sandwich
$11.99
Salmon fillet served grilled (or fried!) on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.
Salmon Fillet Sandwich Combo
$13.99
Salmon fillet served grilled (or fried!) on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins and a side.
Cod Loin Sandwich
$7.99
We use the loin cut of the cod making for a tasty, flaky marvel of the seafood world served fried or grilled on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.
Cod Loin Sandwich Combo
$9.99
We use the loin cut of the cod making for a tasty, flaky marvel of the seafood world served fried or grilled on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins and a side.
Calamari Steak Sandwich
$7.99
Not your typical Midwesterner's sandwich. Very mild flavor and great texture make for a unique addition to the menu. Calamari Steak served fried or grilled on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.
Calamari Steak Sandwich Combo
$9.99
Not your typical Midwesterner's sandwich. Very mild flavor and great texture make for a unique addition to the menu. Calamari Steak served fried or grilled on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins and a side.
Chicken Breast Sandwich
$7.99
You don't have to feel guilty about getting a chicken sandwich at a fish joint. We use a marinated breast, which keeps it very juicy and flavorful. Tastes great fried or grilled and is served on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.
Chicken Breast Sandwich Combo
$9.99
You don't have to feel guilty about getting a chicken sandwich at a fish joint. We use a marinated breast, which keeps it very juicy and flavorful. Tastes great fried or grilled and is served on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins and a side.
Lobsta Roll
$16.99
Our secret recipe lobster salad made with claw & knuckle meat is served on a bed of crisp lettuce tucked inside a freshly toasted hoagie roll.
Lobsta Roll Combo
$18.99
Our secret recipe lobster salad made with claw & knuckle meat is served on a bed of crisp lettuce tucked inside a freshly toasted hoagie roll with a side of your choice.
Shrimp Po Boy
$8.99
A quarter pound of shrimp fried or grilled and tucked inside a fresh toasted hoagie roll with your choice of fixins... The usual is lettuce, onion, pickle, tomato, and remoulade sauce.
Shrimp Po Boy Combo
$10.99
A quarter pound of shrimp fried or grilled and tucked inside a fresh toasted hoagie roll with your choice of fixins...the usual is lettuce, onion, pickle, tomato, and remoulade sauce...and a side of your choice.
Oyster Po Boy
$10.99
A quarter pound of oysters fried up and tucked inside a fresh toasted hoagie roll with your choice of fixins...the usual is lettuce, onion, pickle, tomato, and remoulade sauce.
Oyster Po Boy Combo
$12.99
A quarter pound of oysters fried up and tucked inside a fresh toasted hoagie roll with your choice of fixins...the usual is lettuce, onion, pickle, tomato, and remoulade sauce...and a side of your choice.
Soft Shell Crab Sandwich
$10.99
A pair of Soft Shell Crabs fried up and served on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.
Soft Shell Crab Sandwich Combo
$12.99
A pair of Soft Shell Crabs fried up and served on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins and a side.
Blue Crab Melt
$16.99
The ultimate indulgence, blue crab meat smothered under a blanket of melted mozzarella & provolone cheese with mayo and served on an open-faced hoagie roll.
Blue Crab Melt Combo
$18.99
The ultimate indulgence, blue crab meat smothered under a blanket of melted mozzarella & provolone cheese with mayo and served on an open-faced hoagie roll with a side of your choice.
Pork Tenderloin Sandwich
$8.99
An Indiana favorite, freshly cut pork tenderloin served fried (or grilled if you must) on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins.
Pork Tenderloin Sandwich Combo
10.99
An Indiana favorite, freshly cut pork tenderloin served fried (or grilled if you must) on a fresh toasted bun with your choice of fixins with a side of your choice.
$Dinners
Our dinners can be fried or grilled to perfection.Caplinger's Special Dinner
$11.99
Our #1 seller! This dinner is served with two planks of basa (a mild, flaky whitefish), two sides of your choice, a pair of hushpuppies, and a sauce.
Catfish Fillet Dinner
$11.99
Two catfish fillets fried or grilled to perfection and served with two sides, a pair of hush puppies, and a sauce of your choice.
Chicken Breast Dinner
$10.99
Two chicken breasts fried or grilled to perfection and served with two sides, a pair of hush puppies, and a sauce of your choice.
Alligator Tail Dinner
$17.99
"It tastes like chicken." Really, it does. A half pound of gator tail meat fried or grilled to perfection and served with two sides, a pair of hush puppies, and a sauce of your choice.
Calamari Steak Dinner
$11.99
Two tender calamari steaks fried or grilled to perfection and served with two sides, a pair of hush puppies, and a sauce of your choice.
Fish and Chicken
$11.99
A basa fillet paired with a chicken breast fried or grilled to perfection and served with two sides, a pair of hush puppies, and a sauce of your choice.
Fish and Shrimp
$11.99
A basa fillet paired with a quarter pound of shrimp fried or grilled to perfection and served with two sides, a pair of hush puppies, and a sauce of your choice.
Salmon Fillet Dinner
$14.99
A fresh salmon fillet grilled (or fried if you like) to flaky perfection and served with two sides, a pair of hush puppies, and a sauce of your choice.
Cod Loin Dinner
$11.99
Two cod loin fillets fried or grilled to perfection and served with two sides, a pair of hush puppies, and a sauce of your choice.
Shrimp Dinner
$14.99
A half pound of shrimp (14/16 pieces) fried or grilled to perfection and served with two sides, a pair of hush puppies, and a sauce of your choice.
Crab Cake Dinner
$19.99
Two tender house-made crab cakes baked to perfection and served with two sides, a pair of hush puppies, and a sauce of your choice.
Lobsta Roll Dinner
$18.99
Our secret recipe lobster salad made with claw & knuckle meat is served on a bed of crisp lettuce tucked inside our fresh toasted hoagie roll and served with two sides & a pair of hush puppies.
Fried Oyster Dinner
$18.99
A half pound of oysters fried to perfection and served with two sides, a pair of hush puppies, and a sauce of your choice.
Buffalo Clam Strips Dinner
$13.99
A half pound of clams fried to golden perfection and served with two sides, a pair of hush puppies, and a sauce of your choice.
The Platter
$17.99
A basa fillet and ¼lb shrimp fried or grilled along with ¼lb fried clams and served with two sides, a pair of hush puppies, and two sauces of your choice.
Soft Shell Crab Dinner
$18.99
Four soft shell crabs breaded and fried to perfection and served with two sides, a pair of hush puppies, and a sauce of your choice.
Tilapia Fillet Dinner
$11.99
Two tilapia fillets fried or grilled to perfection and served with two sides, a pair of hush puppies, and a sauce of your choice.
Whiting Fillet Dinner
$10.99
Whiting fillets fried to perfection and served with two sides, a pair of hush puppies, and your choice of sauce.
Ocean Perch Dinner
$13.99
Ocean Perch fillets fried to perfection and served with two sides, a pair of hush puppies, and your choice of sauce.
Frog Legs Dinner
21.99
A half pound of frog legs fried or grilled to perfection and served with two sides, a pair of hush puppies, and a sauce of your choice.
$Additions
Try any of these great options as your meal or an addition to something else.Clam Chowda
$6.99
This is our homemade rich and creamy New England style clam "chowda" with lots of clams.
Crab Cakes
$7.99
Our house-made crab cakes are crafted with lump crab meat and just a few other fresh and simple ingredients and served with our homemade remoulade sauce.
1/4 lb. Shrimp
$5.49
A quarter pound (6/8 pieces) of shrimp fried or grilled and served with choice of sauce.
1/4 lb. Fried Clam Strips
$5.99
These are a thicker cut clam strip and it is served with your choice of sauce.
1/4 lb. Fried Oysters
$6.99
A quarter pound of fresh oysters breaded, fried, and served with choice of sauce.
Gator Bites
$11.99
Half a pound of Alligator tail meat fried or grilled and served with choice of sauce.
Basa Fillet
$4.00
Single basa fillet.
Catfish Fillet
$4.00
Single catfish fillet.
Chicken Breast
$3.00
Single chicken breast.
Calamari Steak
$4.00
Single calamari steak.
Ocean Perch Fillet
$2.00
2 ocean perch fillets.
Salmon Fillet
$7.50
Single salmon fillet.
Whiting Fillet
$1.50
Single whiting fillet.
Cod Fillet
$4.00
Single cod fillet.
Soft Shell Crab
$4.75
Single soft shell crab.
Frog Legs
16.00
1 lb. frog legs.
$Sides
Waffle Fries
$2.49-3.99
Our fries are waffle cut and have a seasoned coating that goes perfectly with all dinners.
Fried Okra
$2.49-3.99
A southern favorite. Lightly breaded and fried.
Hushpuppies
$2.49-3.99
These tasty little morsels are a staple with any fried fish meal. Regular order comes with 6 and a large order has 12.
Collard Greens
$2.49-3.99
The best you will ever eat. Seasoned with smoked turkey.
Red Beans and Rice
$2.49-3.99
A southern favorite. Our red beans and rice are paired with andouille sausage, giving it a nice kick.
Mac and Cheese
$2.49-3.99
We make our mac and cheese with a nice blend of cheeses and finish it off in the oven.
Baked Beans
$2.49-3.99
Our baked beans are sweet and tangy.
Green Beans
$2.49-3.99
We cook our green beans in beef broth giving them a great flavor.
Candied Yams
$2.49-3.99
We bake our yams in a sweet brown sugar and cinnamon mix.
Sweet Corn with Old Bay Seasoning
$2.49-3.99
This is an East Coast style corn on the cob. The Old Bay adds a great kick.
Sweet Corn (Plain)
$2.49
Chipotle Slaw
2.49-3.99
With just a hint of spice and the smokiness of the chipotle, this is not your typical slaw.
$Kids Meal
Kids Meal
7.99
Choose between a basa fillet or chicken breast cut into bites or a quarter pound of shrimp plus your choice of one side, a sauce, a pair of hush puppies, and a drink.
$Desserts
Finish your meal with a sweet treat. When you pick up your meals you will pick out your piece next to the front register.Key Lime Lie
$3.99
Our smooth & tangy Homemade Key Lime Pie is crafted with Nellie & Joe's Key West Lime Juice.
Pineapple Bread Pudding
$4.99
This rich & sticky homemade Pineapple Bread Pudding is drizzled with our velvety vanilla cream sauce to warm your belly. Enough to share...or not!
Menu for Caplingers Fresh Catch is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
