Brownies
Plain Brownies- CONTAINS NO NUTS
$9.99
A delicious decadent chocolatey, fudgy brownie. These brownies are thick, very fudgy and one of the best you’ll try! 3 (2 oz.) brownies in a pack.
Walnut Brownies
9.99
A delicious decadent chocolatey, fudgy brownie with walnuts. These brownies are thick, very fudgy and one of the best you’ll try! 3 (2 oz.) brownies in a pack.
$Cookies
Butter Cookies (1/2 dozen)
$9.99
A delicious crisp buttery cookie. Butter cookies are a crisp and flaky cookie. You can truly taste the butter. Made fresh daily. Also known as "CPS lunchroom cookies" to many Chicagoans.
Chocolate Chip Cookies (1/2 dozen)
$9.99
A delicious soft and chewy chocolate chip cookie!
Chocolate Chip Oatmeal Cookies (1/2 dozen)
$9.99
A chewy oatmeal cookie with milk chocolate and semi-sweet chocolate chips. Chocolate Chip Oatmeal cookies are a chewy cookie. Made fresh daily.
Gluten Free Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookies (1/2 dozen)
$9.99
A soft and chewy chocolate chip cookie that taste just like a traditional chocolate chip cookie. No dairy or gluten. Most customers can’t differentiate the taste from our regular cookies, because they’re that good!
Oatmeal Rasin Cookies (1/2 dozen)
$9.99
A traditional chewy, oatmeal raisin cookie-- made fresh daily! Packed in a cellophane bag for freshness.
Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies (1/2 dozen)
$9.99
A soft and chewy peanut butter cookie, complete with chocolate chips.
Peanut Butter Cookies (1/2 dozen)
$9.99
A soft and chewy peanut butter cookie.
Snickerdoodle Cookies (1/2 dozen)
$9.99
A soft and chewy cookie with cinnamon, sugar + spice, and everything nice!
Turtle Cookies (1/2 dozen)
$9.99
A chocolate cookie with caramel, pecans, and chocolate chips. Turtles cookies are a soft and chewy cookie.
Keto ＆ Vegan Chocolate Chips Cookies (1/2 dozen)
9.99
These Chocolate Chip Cookies are Sugar-Free, Dairy Free ＆ Gluten Free, so you can enjoy a treat guilt-free! Many people can’t taste the difference. Contains almond products. May contain traces of dairy, wheat ＆ eggs.
$Pastries
Lemon Bars
$9.99
Lemon bars with pate sucre (sweet French pastry) crust. Each order contains 2 bars.
Roasted Pineapple Cupcake
$2.99
This roasted pineapple cupcake is topped with spiced rum buttercream frosting. Tropical and delicious. Each order contains 1 cupcake.
Carrot Cupcake
$2.99
A spiced carrot cake cupcake with cream cheese icing. Each order contains 1 cupcake. CONTAINS: milk, wheat, eggs, may contain traces of nuts.
Red Velvet Cupcake
$2.99
A rich red velvet cupcake with cream cheese icing. Each order contains 1 cupcake. CONTAINS: dairy, wheat, eggs, may contain traces of nuts.
Chocolate Cupcake w/ Buttercream Frosting
$2.99
A deliciously soft and moist chocolate cupcake. Buttercream frosting. Contains wheat, milk, and eggs.
Vegan Chocolate Cupcakes
$2.99
A deliciously soft and moist chocolate cupcake with no dairy or eggs. Chocolate frosting is made with vegan butter. Contains WHEAT.
Yellow Cupcake w/ Chocolate Frosting
$2.99
A deliciously soft and moist yellow cupcake with chocolate frosting. Contains: MILK, WHEAT, EGGS
Pound Cake (slice)
$2.99
A dense, fluffy slice of pound cake. Each order contains 1 slice. CONTAINS: dairy, wheat, eggs. May contain traces of nuts.
Pound Cake (loaf)
$19.99
A deliciously soft and moist yellow cupcake with chocolate frosting. Contains: MILK, WHEAT, EGGS
Mini Apple Pie
$9.99
Our perfectly baked apple pie includes juicy apples and a flaky buttery old fashioned crust. This delicate, golden brown crust and hearty sweet-tart apples combine to make a deliciously perfect pie.
Mini Cherry Pie
$9.99
Our perfectly baked cherry pie includes juicy tart cherries and a flaky buttery old fashioned crust. This delicate, golden brown crust and hearty sweet-tart cherries combine to make a deliciously perfect pie.
Mini Chocolate Chess Pie
$9.99
Our perfectly baked chocolate chess pie includes creamy chocolate and a flaky buttery old fashioned crust. This delicate, golden brown crust and rich chocolate combine to make a deliciously perfect pie.
Mini Blueberry Pie
$9.99
Our perfectly baked blueberry pie includes juicy sweet blueberries and a flaky buttery old fashioned crust. This delicate, golden brown crust and juicy blueberries combine to make a perfect pie. 6 inch in size (Mini-Pie). CONTAINS: MILK, WHEAT, EGGS. Made in a facility that also produces products with nuts.
Mini Sweet Potato Pie
$9.99
Our southern inspired sweet potato pie is on point! Our special family recipe is so irresistible. Fresh sweet potatoes with brown sugar ＆ spices, baked in a flaky crust. CONTAINS: MILK, WHEAT, EGGS. Made in a facility that also produces products with nuts.
Mini Pecan Pie
$9.99
Our perfectly baked pecan pie. Flaky, buttery, old fashioned crust with our homemade pecan filling. CONTAINS: MILK, WHEAT, EGGS, PECANS. Made in a facility that also products products with peanuts.
Mini Pumpkin Pie
$9.99
Our perfectly baked pumpkin pie. For many of us, homemade pumpkin pie is the classic dish that says “Thanksgiving,†pure and simple. Flaky, buttery, old fashioned crust with our homemade pumpkin filling. CONTAINS: MILK, WHEAT, EGGS. Made in a facility that also produces products with nuts.
Mini Peach Cobbler
$12.99
Our perfectly baked peach cobbler includes juicy peaches and a flaky buttery old fashioned crust. This delicate, golden brown crust and ripe peaches combine to make a deliciously perfect pie.
Yesterday’s Mini Peach Cobbler
$6.99
Our perfectly baked peach cobbler includes juicy peaches and a flaky buttery old fashioned crust. This delicate, golden brown crust and ripe peaches combine to make a deliciously perfect pie. "Yesterday’s Pies" are the same delicious pies only 3-5 days old. Many people can’t taste the difference. While the shelf life of our pies is 2 weeks, we pride ourselves on selling fresh cookies. So "Yesterday’s Pies" are discounted 50% off and only available when we don’t sell out.
German Chocolate Cupcakes
$2.99
A chocolate cupcake with coconut frosting. Each order contains 1 cupcake.
Hummingbird Cake
$5.99
This jumbo slice of Southern Hummingbird Cake is a deliciously moist cake filled with ripe banana, perfectly sweet pineapple and chopped pecans that’s topped with an irresistibly rich cream cheese frosting, pineapple and cherry.
Banana Cream Pie w/Chocolate Ganache (mini pie)
9.99
5 inch mini, This silky pie is made by layering chocolate ganache, fresh bananas and vanilla custard into a buttery pie crust with more ganache drizzled on top.
$Yesterday’s Cookies
Yesterday’s Butter Cookies (1/2 dozen)
$5.99
A delicious crisp buttery cookie. Butter cookies are a crisp and flaky cookie. Contains 5 cookies. "Yesterday’s Cookies" are the same delicious cookies only 3-5 days old. Many people can’t taste the difference. While the shelf life of our cookies is 3-4 weeks, we pride ourselves on selling fresh cookies. So "Yesterday’s Cookies" are discounted 50% off and only available when we don’t sell out.
Yesterday’s Chocolate Chip Cookies (1/2 dozen)
$5.99
A delicious soft and chewy chocolate chip cookie! Contains 5 cookies."Yesterday’s Cookies" are the same delicious cookies only 3-5 days old. Many people can’t taste the difference. While the shelf life of our cookies is 3-4 weeks, we pride ourselves on selling fresh cookies. So "Yesterday’s Cookies" are discounted 50% off and only available when we don’t sell out.
Yesterday’s Chocolate Chip Oatmeal Cookies (1/2 dozen)
$5.99
A chewy oatmeal cookie with milk chocolate and semi-sweet chocolate chips. Contains 5 cookies. & quot;Yesterday’ s Cookies & quot;are the same delicious cookies only 3 - 5 days old.Many people can’ t taste the difference.While the shelf life of our cookies is 3 - 4 weeks, we pride ourselves on selling fresh cookies.So & quot;Yesterday’ s Cookies & quot;are discounted 50 % off and only available when we don’ t sell out.
Yesterday’s Gluten Free Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookies (1/2 dozen)
$5.99
A soft and chewy chocolate chip cookie with no dairy or gluten. Contains 5 cookies. & quot;Yesterday’ s Cookies & quot;are the same delicious cookies only 3 - 5 days old.Many people can’ t taste the difference.While the shelf life of our cookies is 3 - 4 weeks, we pride ourselves on selling fresh cookies.So & quot;Yesterday’ s Cookies & quot;are discounted 50 % off and only available when we don’ t sell out.
Yesterday’s Oatmeal Rasin Cookies (1/2 dozen)
$5.99
A traditional chewy, oatmeal raisin cookie— made fresh daily! Contains 5 cookies. "Yesterday’s Cookies" are the same delicious cookies only 3-5 days old. Many people can’t taste the difference. While the shelf life of our cookies is 3-4 weeks, we pride ourselves on selling fresh cookies. So "Yesterday’s Cookies" are discounted 50% off and only available when we don’t sell out.
Yesterday’s Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies (1/2 dozen)
$5.99
A soft and chewy peanut butter cookie, complete with chocolate chips. "Yesterday’s Cookies" are the same delicious cookies only 3-5 days old. Many people can’t taste the difference. While the shelf life of our cookies is 3-4 weeks, we pride ourselves on selling fresh cookies. So "Yesterday’s Cookies" are discounted 50% off and only available when we don’t sell out.
Yesterday’s Snickerdoodle Cookies (1/2 dozen)
$5.99
A soft and chewy cookie with cinnamon, sugar + spice, and everything nice! "Yesterday’s Cookies" are the same delicious cookies only 3-5 days old. Many people can’t taste the difference. While the shelf life of our cookies is 3-4 weeks, we pride ourselves on selling fresh cookies. So "Yesterday’s Cookies" are discounted 50% off and only available when we don’t sell out.
Yesterday’s Turtle Cookies (1/2 dozen)
$5.99
A chocolate cookie with caramel, pecans, and chocolate chips. Contains 5 cookies. "Yesterday’s Cookies" are the same delicious cookies only 3-5 days old. Many people can’t taste the difference. While the shelf life of our cookies is 3-4 weeks, we pride ourselves on selling fresh cookies. So "Yesterday’s Cookies" are discounted 50% off and only available when we don’t sell out.
Yesterday’s Keto ＆ Vegan Chocolate Chips Cookies (1/2 dozen)
$5.99
These Chocolate Chip Cookies are Sugar-Free, Dairy Free ＆ Gluten Free, so you can enjoy a treat guilt-free! Many people can’t taste the difference. Contains almond products.May contain traces of dairy, wheat＆ eggs. & quot;Yesterday’ s Cookies & quot;are the same delicious cookies only 3 - 5 days old.Many people can’ t taste the difference.While the shelf life of our cookies is 3 - 4 weeks, we pride ourselves on selling fresh cookies.So & quot;Yesterday’ s Cookies & quot;are discounted and only available when we don’ t sell out.
Yesterday’s Surprise Bag
2.99
Yesterday’s" Surprise Bag products contain cookies from our menu which are 75% off and only available when we don’t sell out. Products are 3-5 days old and many people cannot taste the difference! While the shelf life of our products is 2-3 weeks, we pride ourselves on providing fresh products, hence “Yesterday’s Surprise Bagâ€. Yesterday’ s Surprise Bag contain miscellaneous flavors from our menu including: Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Chip Oatmeal, Peanut Butter, Butter, Oatmeal Raisin, Brownies(plain + walnut), Vegan / Gluten Free, Keto and many other flavors.Cookies are six of the same flavor in a bag and brownies are three in a bag. We cannot accept request for specific flavors when choosing.If you have allergen restrictions please order a specific item from our menu.
$Yesterday’s Brownies
Yesterday’s Plain Brownies- CONTAINS NO NUTS
$5.99
A delicious decadent chocolatey, fudgy brownie. These brownies are thick, very fudgy and one of the best you’ll try! 3 (2 oz.) brownies in a pack. "Yesterday’s" brownies are the same delicious treats only 3-5 days old. We pride ourselves on selling fresh treats, so these are discounted and only available when we don’t sell out. CONTAINS milk, wheat, eggs.
Yesterday’s Walnut Brownies
$5.99
A delicious decadent chocolatey, fudgy brownie with walnuts. These brownies are thick, very fudgy and one of the best you’ll try! 3 (2 oz.) brownies in a pack. "Yesterday’s" brownies are the same delicious treats only 3-5 days old. We pride ourselves on selling fresh treats, so these are discounted and only available when we don’t sell out. CONTAINS milk, wheat, eggs.
Menu for Not Just Cookies is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
