Appetizers & Small Plates
Pulled Pork Nachos
$13.99
Slow smoked pork, poblano queso, fresh corn tortilla chips, black beans, avocado, tomato, fresh corn salsa, cilantro. Irish Curry Poutine.
Irish Curry Poutine
$14.99
Beer braised short rib, hand cut fries, curry gravy, Kerrygold aged cheese, sunny side up egg, fresh parsley.
Hand Crafted Charcuterie Plate
$16.99
An assortment of locally sourced meats and cheeses limited only by our imagination.
Rhode Island Calamari
$13.99
Lightly breaded & fried, pickled sweet & hot peppers, arugula, harissa tomato sauce.
House Made Spent Grain Pretzels
$7.99
Malty soft pretzels made from our own spent grain and served with roasted poblano queso.
Sweet Potato Gnocchi
$13.99
Guanciale, toasted pecans, baby spinach, Grana Padano, balsamic brown butter. Omit Guanciale for a vegetarian delight.
Buffalo Shrimp
$11.99
Gulf shrimp in buffalo sauce. Served with celery and blue cheese dressing.
Jumbo Chicken Wings
$9.99-15.99
Choose one of 4 sauces: Buffalo, O'Learys Hot, Korean BBQ, or Mango Habañero. Served with celery and blue cheese dressing.
Southwest Egg Rolls
9.99
Chicken, black beans, corn, pepper jack, avocado, southwest ranch.
$Soups and Salads
Old Man Tom's Gumbo
$6.99-8.99
Gulf shrimp, blue crab, clams, and house-made andouille.
Soup Special
$5.99-7.99
Scratch-made, creative interpretations of soups. Ask your server for today's variety!
Winter Kale Salad
$11.99
Baby kale, baby spinach, roasted apples, wheat berries, pickled butternut squash, spiced pecans, Ricotta Salata & cider vinaigrette.
Caesar Salad
$11.99
Romaine, mixed greens, grilled asparagus, shaved radish, cherry tomato, red onion, hardboiled egg, Grana Padano, herb polenta croutons.
Southwest Salad
$10.99
Mixed greens, romaine, fresh corn salsa, black beans, pickled red onion, cherry tomato, avocado, Chihuahua cheese, cilantro, tortilla strips, southwest ranch.
Thai Salad
11.99
Baby bok choy, Thai basil, rainbow carrots, scallions, red cabbage, red bell pepper, smoked cashew, crispy wonton & spicy yuzu vinaigrette.
$Burgers
Grass Fed
$11.99
½ lb hand-formed 90/10 from 7 Sons Family Farm in Roanoke, IN.
Venison
$15.99
Illinois ground venison, American and cheddar cheese, red onion, pickle chips, house aioli, buttered brioche bun.
Lamb
$14.99
Slagel Farms ground lamb, arugula, red onion, tomato jam, mint infused goat cheese.
House-made Veggie
$10.99
Cheddar cheese, harissa aioli, black beans, farro, brown rice, roasted mushrooms and pimento cheese.
Southwest Turkey
11.99
Pepperjack cheese, avocado, fried jalapeño, southwest ranch.
$Sandwiches
Lieutenant Dan
$13.99
Fried Gulf shrimp, cilantro, baby bok choy, Thai chili aioli, pickled carrots & daikon, toasted French bread.
Cuban
$12.99
Smoked pulled pork, Gruy?re, Dijon mustard, pickles, pimento cheese, house smoked bacon, green chilis, red onion.
Pulled Pork Sandwich
$11.99
A ½ lb of hand pulled pork on a brioche roll. Choice of sauces.
Fat Chef
$13.99
Pulled pork, house-made links, buttermilk slaw and a duo of sauces
Brisket Sandwich
$13.99
12-hour smoked beef brisket, horseradish aioli & fried onion strings on a biscuit bun.
Lamb Meatball Gyro
$12.99
Slagel Farms ground lamb, coconut tzatziki sauce, sweet vinegar cucumbers and red onion, parsley, pita.
Southern Chicken
$13.99
Breaded or grilled chicken breast, buttermilk slaw, sriracha bourbon maple, bread and butter pickles, toasted brioche biscuit bun.
Jerk Cauliflower Wrap
$11.99
Black eyed pea hummus, baby spinach, red onion, roasted sweet potato, Chihuahua cheese & tomato basil tortilla.
Stuffed Chinese Eggplant
11.99
Wheat berries, butternut squash, pickled red cabbage, baby bok choy & pumpkin seeds.
$BBQ
Pulled Pork
$14.99
½ lb dry-rubbed pork shoulder, smoked 12 hours, and hand pulled.
Ribs
$19.99-26.99
White Marble Farms baby backs. Dry rubbed and smoked 4 hours.
BBQ Chicken
$16.99
½ fresh brined chicken, dry rubbed, and smoked 4 hours.
Links
$14.99
House recipe pork sausage link smoked 2 hours and grilled.
Combination Platter
23.99
¼ lb pulled pork, ¼ chicken, links and ¼ rack of ribs.
$Entrees
Miso Honey Glazed Salmon
$22.99
Baby bok choy, oyster mushrooms, carrot ginger puree, yuzu butter.
The Butcher's Cut
$25.99
10 oz. hanger steak, poblano potato gratin, charred broccolini with Calabrian chili, chimichurri butter.
Sweet Tea Brined Pork Chops
$17.99
Apple spaetzle, bacon braised red cabbage, smoked apple puree.
Beef Short Rib
$20.99
Herbed mascarpone polenta roasted rainbow carrots, "Beer"-delaise sauce fried giardiniera.
Hoppin' "Johnny" Strozzapret
17.99
Priest Strangler pasta, black eyed peas, cherry tomato, poblano romesco, Calabrian chili, charred corn, Grana Padano.
$Sides
French Fries
$2.49
Sweet Potato Fries
$3.99
Corn Bread
$0.99
Baked Beans
$2.49
Buttermilk Slaw
$2.49
Mac & Cheese
$3.99
House Salad
$3.99
Sautéed Veggies
2.99
$Desserts
Triple Chocolate Flourless Cake
$6.99
Semisweet, milk, and bittersweet chocolate.
Charleston Coconut Cake
$7.99
Coconut simple syrup infused cake, coconut custard, butter cream frosting.
Whiskey Sweet Potato Pecan Pie
$6.99
Butter crust, vanilla infused pecans, caramel sauce & vanilla ice cream.
Mississippi Mud Brownie
$6.00
Marshmallow, pecans, chocolate ganache
Menu for Horse Thief Hollow is provided by findrestaurantmenu.com
DISCLAIMER: Information shown here may not reflect the latest changes. Check with the restaurant for current pricing and other menu information. A listing on findrestaurantmenu.com does not reflect any affiliation with or endorsement of the listed restaurant, or the listed restaurant's endorsement of findrestaurantmenu.com. Please inform us of any errors in the information. For more information, please read our Terms and Conditions.
Check Other Restaurant Menu
Pide ve Lahmacun
Turkish
The Dapper Doughnut
Bakery & Pastries
Vio Cafe & Grill
American, Mexican
Polk Street Pub
American, Bar Food
Margaritaville Bar & Grill
American, Bar Food
LB Bistro & Patisserie
American
Buen Apetito
Mexican
The Hot Dog Guy
Hot Dogs
Spicy Monkey Soup Company
Sandwiches, Soups
Le Cafe du Marche
Coffee & Tea, French
I-Cafe Sukur's Place
Turkish
Captain Hooks/Firehouse Steak & Lemonade (Roosevelt & Ashland)
Chicken, Mexican, Seafood, Wings